Preview

Seamus Heaney- The turnip snedder

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1762 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Seamus Heaney- The turnip snedder
The Turnip-snedder
The poem “The Turnip-Snedder” by Seamus Heaney is about an archaic machine that was used in traditional farming, to cut the heads off turnips. The turnip-snedder is personified and portrayed in multiple ways. It is personified in a monstrous way but also in a very god like and powerful manner. The turnip snedder is also used to reflect the idea how some people refuse change even though it is inevitable. The poet’s attitude is nostalgic with a sinister undertone of violence and terrorism.
The poem is written in couplets and contains two sentences. The couplets mimic the sound and feel of turning the turnip-snedder, making it seem like a cycle. The first sentence introduces the turnip snedder as an archaic machine that refuses to adapt to change, with a slight undertone of violence. In the second sentence, the snedder is personified and portrayed as God like with a sinister tone. The overall rhythm of the poem is irregular and this reflects the struggle of manual labor and tough work, creating a sense of disharmony. The irregular rhythm reflects how things always change and that change is inevitable.
The title “The Turnip-Snedder” has a very ominous tone but it also sounds powerful, personifying the turnip-snedder. The word “sned” is derived from old English meaning “to cut” and “to kill by cutting”. By using old English, Heaney extends on the idea that the turnip-snedder is archaic and no longer used. It also hints at the violence that the turnip snedder is capable of and links to the victims of terrorism and massacre on a metaphorical level. Heaney dedicated this poem to Hughie O’ Donoghue as he is the photographer of the picture that inspired Heaney to write this poem. This shows how Heaney is always trying to find inspiration in traditional Irish things as a process of being able to relate and find his identity.
In the opening lines, Heaney introduces the setting and by using the word “age” it creates a sense of a period of time that has

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The first section, when the female is 62, seems like the beginning stages of Alzheimer’s. At first, the reader may think this lady is just old and can’t remember a simple song. The setting in this first section…

    • 3430 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The language used throughout the poem “Nettles” consists of military language, and a fair few metaphors, used to describe the pain and imagery for the nettles. “Bed seemed a curious name for those green spears,” the term “green spears” is a metaphor…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This poem starts off in a mellow way: “...his parents boarded him at school in town, slaving to free him from the stony fields”. The main character, Warren Pryor, is graduating and on his way to a flourishing life as a result of his parents many sacrifices. By the last stanza, the innocent tone turns into a belligerent voice: “...his axe-hewn hands upon the paper bills aching with empty strength and throttled rage.” This ultimately expresses Pryor’s point of view. Though he achieves the first steps of the American Dream and completes his parent’s wishes, he is ungratified, ironically. Instead, Pryor prefers to be at the farm he grew up in and working alongside his parents. This shows how the American Dream does not suit everyone, especially Pryor, but he continues on the path of working for the American Dream in fear of disheartening his…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ka Ching Tone Assignment

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages

    With use of proper connotative diction the author allows us to understand the terrible conditions in Ireland and reveals the dominant tone.…

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    When looking at the figurative level, there are multiple lines that indicate the poet’s fear of the ‘saw.’ For instance, in the lines “I had a scar to remind me not to go near the circular saw” (9-11) it shows that he has experienced something before that tells him not to go close to them. The poet leads this recurring topic into the theme. At the beginning it is atrocious and apprehensive, but there is a change in the last stanza, when he realizes that he has become an individual that will pass on the pain he has received. This is shown in lines, “the worst thing is that under the masks I wear and without intending to be I am a circular saw.” (22-26) The regretful tone comes into play when he comes to the understanding that he is the ‘circular saw’ that will give others sorrow intentionally or unintentionally. An eye opening truth is revealed that leaves the audience to give sympathy to the poet. When analyzing the poem carefully, slight appearance of embarrassment can be noticed through the line “under the masks” (23) as he transforms into the thing he is distressed by. Throughout the poem, it can be understood that the ‘circular saw’ is used as a metaphor…

    • 673 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The first line contains an image of a “bronze butterfly” sleeping on a trunk. This stagnant description of such a beautiful creature demonstrates a slowly moving life, one of which hasn’t achieved much. The trunk that the butterfly is sleeping on is colored black, representing the man’s missed opportunities to leave the farm. The next line portrays a leaf blowing down a ravine found behind an empty house. Obviously the empty house and the later heard cowbells in the distance (implying that the cows are leaving the farm) are clear images of the man’s loneliness. The speaker moves on to spot some horse manure. This dung, after being left for over a year, has dried and is turning into stones. The changing of this manure symbolizes the man’s changing into an old, lifeless man. Just as the manure does, the longer the man sits there and waits for something, the more prone he is to dry up and waste his life. Before the last line of the poem, the speaker mentions the setting sun and the evening that approaches as he lays back in his hammock. A chicken hawk, a well-known hunter, flies by the man and looks for his home, just as the man is looking for his home — or the place where he belongs. As the evening envelops the man, all of these apparently “beautiful” images (yet symbolically depressing messages) pushes the man to realize that his life has become…

    • 382 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The poem is told from the narrator’s perspective. It begins with the narrator building a house, but nothing was aligned, as it should be. The wood even began to rot and maggots infest his hard work. He claimed that unlike Christ, he is no carpenter, but went on to build his dream home with only his needs in mind. At times, he hammered his own thumb and cursed while he worked; but in the end, he celebrated his own hard work with his favorite whiskey. For a short time, the house was strong and all that it should have been, but then it “screamed,” settled and was anything but what he had…

    • 1780 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Heaney’s ‘At a Potato Digging’ the language sets up the close relationship between man and the earth and the cruel treatment man receives by the earth. The labourers are shown to work hard; the verb ‘swarm’ in the first stanza is used to show the frantic and busy nature of their work. This is followed by ‘ fingers go dead in the cold.’ This metaphor for the workers illustrates how cruel the labour and working conditions were. The simile used in the second stanza compares the labourers to ‘crows’ that are entrapped by the land- unable to escape; they must scavenge, like crows, for survival.…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay 1

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages

    While different ages are momentous in the United States, when a person turns twenty-one it seems as if the person is definitely ready to enter the real world. A twenty-one year old step’s into the real world of grownups, accounting, and a legal drinking limit. A twenty first birthday is very special, as is someone’s sixteenth and eighteenth birthday. Both poems by Samuel Johnson and A.E. Housman demonstrate a person turning twenty-one, but both poems demonstrate different views on how the speaker and the audience feel. “To Sir John Lade, on His Coming of Age” is about the speaker telling his audience on how he feels about finally turning twenty-one. “When I Was One-and-Twenty” describes a young adult listening to an elder or someone they look up too about their new age. Both of these poems have a condescending or rude tone while they either talk or listen to the advice that they are given.…

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Once the reader can passes up the surface meaning of the poem Blackberry-Picking, by Seamus Heaney, past the emotional switch from sheer joy to utter disappointment, past the childhood memories, the underlying meaning can be quite disturbing. Hidden deep within the happy-go-lucky rifts of childhood is a disturbing tale of greed and murder. Seamus Heaney, through clever diction, ghastly imagery, misguided metaphors and abruptly changing forms, ingeniously tells the tale that is understood and rarely spoken aloud.…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "Dolor"

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Noticeably the poem is made up of only two complete sentences, where periods are replaced with commas. The use of asyndeton in both sentences creates a feel of a never-ending list of sadness and misery. Roethke chose to prolong the sentence in order for the reader to feel as though they are deprived of a break because like society in the poem they are trapped as the list goes on and on. Asyndeton is partnered with personification in sentence one to create the gloomy and somber tone. By personifying everyday inanimate objects with feelings such as the “Inexorable sadness of pencils… Misery of manila folders…” (lines 1 & 3), Roethke brings these everyday objects to life in order for them to serve as symbols of how the tasks performed everyday are simply rituals done with no true passion. They simply create boring and diluted individuals that become ultimately the same, photocopied, image.…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The writer uses an alliteration to emphasise how gruesome the things are that the persona has witnessed. The expression “spools of suffering” has a literal and figurative meaning which is effective in encouraging the reader to feel sympathetic. The literal meaning of this expression is that the “spools” have undeveloped images of people suffering and simply states what is on the film whereas the figurative meaning plants an image in the mind of the reader that it is a spiral of suffering and it is never ending. The poet also uses word choice to encourage the reader to feel sympathy for the persona. In stanza two the writer remarks that the war photographer is “ordinary pain which weather can dispel”. This use of the word “ordinary” emphasises the extremity of the suffering witnessed by the war photographer by downplaying what we perceive as “suffering”. The writer uses word choice and imagery to portray and emphasise the extremity of misery and suffering the persona has witnessed which effectively encourages the reader to feel sympathy towards the war photographer because he has to witness…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The ploughman and the speaker talk about a “fallen elm” (3) destroyed by “the blizzard” (13). They then go on to talk about one of the ploughman’s mates, who was killed in France “the very night of the blizzard” (28). This sets up an equivalency between the fallen elm and the fallen man, and also between the blizzard and the war. The speaker sits “among the boughs of the fallen elm” (3), by “a woodpecker’s round hole” (14), and talks about how he could spare an arm in the war but would not like to lose a leg or his head. This equates the ploughman’s dead mate to the fallen tree – his arms are like the boughs of the elm, his body the roots, and the woodpecker’s hole the bullet wound that killed him. This equivalency also links the blizzard and the war. The blizzard that felled this tree, and undoubtedly many others, is equivalent to the war, which had felled many men. These equivalencies show that even though these living things were vastly different in their life, they are ultimately the same in…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Circular saws response

    • 404 Words
    • 1 Page

    The poem starts off in a sort of sad,deep, insightful mood/atmosphere. The fact that “circular…

    • 404 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Highwayman

    • 297 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The figurative language in this poem has a huge impact on the poem. This poem uses very realistic and graphic mental imagery. The poems repeating phrases make you think of a man horseback riding through a dark, dismal place, trying to get to his lover. It also creates a sense of King George's soldiers progressing down that road the horseman was on hunting him down. The language helps enhance the setting of the story. The story takes place in a dark spooky town, with an aged inn on a stormy night. What keeps the reader focused on the story is the intensity of the spookiness on that black, alarming night.…

    • 297 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics