Preview

School Consolidation Debate

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2430 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
School Consolidation Debate
School Consolidation Debate 1731
In recent years, municipal governments across America have found themselves searching for ways to trim costs by consolidating services with other municipal governments in the counties they’re in. They have consolidated law enforcement agencies, sanitation, health departments, municipal courts, etc. But in many of those counties, school systems have been left out of the discussion. In 2010, the Memphis City School (MSC) system made a failed attempt to merge with the Shelby County School (SCS) system through a referendum vote. Later that year, the MCS school board voted to surrender their charter thus legally forcing a merger of the two systems. This paper will attempt to weigh the pros and cons of operating a school system of more than 100,000 students from funding, quality of education, to the effects charter schools will have on the system and community. Good start, add you major arguments here in summary form. One of the first issues that may surface when two school systems consolidate will be funding. Many states use different formulas for calculating the disbursement of their educational funds SCS and MCS funding relied on funding from similar and separate sources. SCS received their funding from the state of Tennessee and Shelby County. After the surrender of the MCS charter by the MCS Board of Commissioners, MCS ceased to exist in a legal state. MCS relied on three sources which were the state of Tennessee, Shelby County, and the city of Memphis. Due to the fact that MCS has been absorbed by SCS, the city of Memphis is no longer obligated to be a source of financial support for the new unified school district under state law. That essentially removes roughly 80 million dollars a year from the school budget. Shelby county and the state of Tennessee are now responsible for 100% school funding in Shelby County. This seems a bit unfair.But on the other hand, MCS bring with it a host of urban education initiative grants



References: Manhattan Institute for Policy Research. (2009). Does Charter School Competition Improve Traditional Public Schools? Retrieved from http://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/cr_10.htm

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    First of all, there is the question of who gives a better education. There has not been much difference between the two. In a study done by the Center for Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO), mixed results were found. For example, charter students in New York only 25% percent of students were proficient or above in English. That percent is less that in public schools. There is also a similar story in math. Public schools had 35% proficiency, while charters only had 30%. Though this may be true in New York, it is not in Chicago. CREDO found that in Chicago, public and charter schools scored almost the same as each other. All of this data shows that charter schools aren't better, or worse, in their education, but it still causes conflict and tension between the…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Introduction: When it is time to attend school, how will you choose between public and private schools? While you will be attending yourself or sending your children to school your ultimate goal is to find a school that will meet you or your child’s needs. Having had first-hand experience with both schools, it allowed me to compare differences of each school system.…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Phi 105 Persuasive Essay

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages

    You may be wondering what a charter schools is. According to The National Alliance for Public Charter Schools, charter schools are public schools that are independently operated and are given the ability to use innovative teaching in exchange for assured improved student achievement. A charter is formed by the work of a group of educators, parents, educational leaders, and others that come together and develop the school 's mission statement, guiding principles, governing body, and the measure for accountability. They then submit the proposal to the state for approval. If the charter is granted then there is an agreement made between the state and the school, and because of the charters autonomy there is a higher level of expectation imposed. Not only by the state, but also by themselves, and ultimately by the people as enrollment is based on their choice.…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Wronkovich, M. (2000). Will charter schools lead to a systemic reform of public education? American Secondary Education 28 (4), 3-8. Retrieved March 24, 2011, from H.W. Wilson database (Education Full Text).…

    • 3723 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Inner City School Systems

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The school system in America has long been an issue of discussion and debate amongst people everywhere. The discussions and debates often stem from evaluating the current educational system in order to determine if significant social issues, including increasing regional poverty and declining literacy rates in specific urban regions are related to economic differentiations in the educational system. Many policy analysts have considered the issue of educational funding allotments in order to determine a system that provides greater equity between socio-economically disadvantaged inner-city schools and wealthier suburban, middle class schools (Kozol 83). The foundation for the necessary funding changes have stemmed from the recognition that school funding differences relate directly to sociological issues, including the creation of a cycle of poverty and illiteracy in under funded urban settings.…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Edu 601 Final Paper

    • 2276 Words
    • 10 Pages

    In this class, we have struggled to evaluate the current educational system in order to determine if significant social issues, including increasing regional poverty, and declining literacy rates in specific urban regions are related to economic differentiations in the education system. Because of recent studies, some have considered the issue of educational funding allotments in order to determine a system that provides greater equity between socioeconomically disadvantaged inner-city schools and wealthier suburban, middle class schools. This funding issue has been addressed a number of times. It has been recognized that the foundation for the necessary funding changes have stemmed from the recognition that school funding differences relate directly to sociological issues, including the creation of a cycle of poverty and illiteracy in under funded urban settings.…

    • 2276 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    State and Federal Aid

    • 1192 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There are many past and rising issues involving public school finance. The public schools system is funded through federal, state and local taxes. Each state has different formulas to distribute funding from state and local taxes. Federal funding does contribute to the rising cost of education for each state. State and local taxes is allocated to cover the majority of educational costs. Student achievement depends upon the available funding allotted to each district. This author will attempt to discuss equalization of federal, state and local funding. Also, this author will attempt to describe fair, equitable and adequate tax systems.…

    • 1192 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    My topic of research is high school consolidation. There is a lot of pressure on small schools, from governmental bodies and other influences, to consolidate into larger schools. In my paper I discuss the downfalls of consolidation, and talk about many benefits that small schools offer. Small schools average better test scores, a lower dropout rate, and a higher rate of extra-curricular activity participation. Studies also show that students who participate in extra-curricular activities become more successful academically and socially. Also, it’s been reported that large schools have a higher rate of violence and crime, and many studies propose that the ideal school size is under 400 students. Another downfall of high school consolidation is the fact that when high schools consolidate communities that no longer have schools tend to die off. Some large school advocates claim that small schools should consolidate for monetary reasons, but due to all the benefits that small schools offer, I disagree. There are many areas of the U.S. government spending that could easily be cut to make room for an increase in education spending. Military and defense spending is particularly high, and could easily spare some cuts. Another claim made by consolidation advocates is that a small drop in test scores is not enough incentive to pay for small schools to continue. To the possible surprise of such advocates, the United States is ranked between 14th and 25th worldwide in education , and cannot afford any more declines in its education system. Lastly, it’s clear to even those who pressure for consolidation that small schools offer better learning environments. While pushing for consolidation, the Illinois state government also helps fund a project to break up large inner-city schools in order to increase learning. It’s clear to all involved that small schools are more…

    • 3187 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Segregation on America

    • 2830 Words
    • 12 Pages

    Levy, T.. (2010). Charter Schools Legislation and the Element of Race. Western Journal of Black Studies, 34(1), 43-52. Retrieved July 18, 2010, from Research Library. (Document ID: 1989943651).…

    • 2830 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Pulic School Funding

    • 2077 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Unequal funding through out the country demonstrates the unfairness some school districts face. According to "School Funding," an article by PBS, the facts and figures of government spending on public schools is very imbalanced. In order to understand the problems of education in America, it is necessary to look at the way public schools are financed. As the article notes, "expenditures are not equal from state to state because of the different costs of education and inputs and real estate and teacher salaries"(1). An example is New Jersey spending twice as much as Utah per student. It is more striking to see how a district within a state varies tremendously as well. The example it used to compare the disparity is how district spending in San Antonio, Texas ranged from $2,112 to $19,333. (2) Because of that disproportion, low income schools have the short end of the stick.…

    • 2077 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Recently, attention has been given to plans for improving the public schools by allowing parents to choose where their children attend school through a school voucher system. The education voucher system exists when a government provides payment to families that allow their children to attend a private or public school of their choice. The payment is in the form of a voucher that can be given directly to the parents of the child, or indirectly to the school of choice. The purpose of the voucher systems is “to increase parental choice, promote competition and allow lower income families access to private education” (West 1997, p.83). The implementation of the voucher system would force poorly run schools and inadequate teachers to improve their…

    • 994 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Charter School Analysis

    • 1706 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Charter schools are generally attributed to an idea by Ray Budde in the 1970’s when he wrote a paper entitled “Education by Charter.” His suggestions centered around reorganizing the traditional schools in such a way that a group of teachers would receive educational “charters” directly from the district’s school board. At the time, his ideas seemed too cumbersome to address an issue many thought was minor. People were more inclined to tweak or update the existing system than try to begin something new from the ground up. In the 1980’s, the “Nation At Risk” report was released, changing the perception of our existing public educational model and creating an environment where people were more open to changes and alternatives to the existing educational model.…

    • 1706 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    Zelman V. Simmons-Harris

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages

    At this time in the United States there was a national movement for allowing school choice and a push for the availability of vouchers. The many who supported this movement were both conservative and mainstream politicians, independent school administrations, religious leaders, and African American who live in urban areas. Those who opposed school choice included: teachers unions, public school administration, and white suburban citizens who were happy with their public schools. It was also during this time that a push for additional options be available within the public schools. These options included advanced classes and charter schools. (Peterson, 2003)…

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Chicago Closing School

    • 1555 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Imagine going to a school your whole life. A school you enjoyed with your friends and were excited to go to every morning. Now, imagine being told that school was being shut down and you had to go to a different school with different people. This is the reality thousands of kids in Chicago are facing today. The Chicago Public School system (CPS) has announced the closing of numerous inefficient elementary schools and even a high school in the Chicago area. This has lead to one of the biggest controversies going on in the country today. Many parents are worried that their children will not benefit from the closings on an academic level, and will surely face more violence and gang related incidences. The CPS promises that with the closings of…

    • 1555 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The main issue with using this as an argument is, if you break down what a charter school is: a publicly funded, privately run school, is it doesn’t actually fit the description of what a neo-liberal program would be, specifically, the publicly funded part. Charter schools, as far as their present status is concerned, are an abomination that takes two separate ideologies and mixes them to form some sort of weird strawman to attack the new trend of neo-liberalization. Charter schools should not be considered neo-liberal the same way private schools are as a result of their inherent nature, and if someone were to seriously argue against neo-liberalization, they should argue against “absolute” private schools, as that has all the accoutrements of being neoliberal. Instead charter schools were chosen as a strawman to attack, when charter schools should not even be considered neo-liberal at…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays