Rural Credit
Rural Credit in 20th Century India
An Overview of History and Perspectives
Mihir Shah, Rangu Rao and P.S. Vijay Shankar
This brief overview of rural credit in 20th century India finds a remarkable continuity in the problems faced by the poor throughout this period. These include dependence on usurious moneylenders and the operation of a deeply exploitative grid of interlocked, imperfect markets. We articulate the theoretical and historical case for nationalisation of banks and provide evidence of its positive impact on rural credit and development. Certain excesses led to reforms unleashed in the 1990s. This did increase bank profitability but at the cost of the poor and of backward regions. While the MFI model of microfinance is unsustainable, the
SHG-Bank Linkage approach can make a positive impact on security and empowerment of the disadvantaged. Much more than microfinance is needed to overcome the problems that have persisted over the last 100 years.
Introduction
This brief overview of rural credit in India begins in the 19th and ends in the 21st century but it is primarily concerned with the major episodes of the 20th century. The historical narrative pays close attention in each case to the perspectives that informed changes in policy and also documents the impact of these changes. We begin with a description of rural credit in the late-colonial period. The problems faced by India 's villages display a remarkable continuity from this situation throughout the period being studied.
Dependence on usurious moneylenders and the operation of a deeply exploitative grid of interlocked, imperfect markets afflicts the rural poor. After a review of the weak performance of cooperative credit institutions in India, we articulate the theoretical case for nationalisation of banks in 1969 and document its positive impact on rural credit and economic development. However, we also suggest that certain excesses in the two decades
following
An Overview of History and Perspectives
Mihir Shah, Rangu Rao and P.S. Vijay Shankar
This brief overview of rural credit in 20th century India finds a remarkable continuity in the problems faced by the poor throughout this period. These include dependence on usurious moneylenders and the operation of a deeply exploitative grid of interlocked, imperfect markets. We articulate the theoretical and historical case for nationalisation of banks and provide evidence of its positive impact on rural credit and development. Certain excesses led to reforms unleashed in the 1990s. This did increase bank profitability but at the cost of the poor and of backward regions. While the MFI model of microfinance is unsustainable, the
SHG-Bank Linkage approach can make a positive impact on security and empowerment of the disadvantaged. Much more than microfinance is needed to overcome the problems that have persisted over the last 100 years.
Introduction
This brief overview of rural credit in India begins in the 19th and ends in the 21st century but it is primarily concerned with the major episodes of the 20th century. The historical narrative pays close attention in each case to the perspectives that informed changes in policy and also documents the impact of these changes. We begin with a description of rural credit in the late-colonial period. The problems faced by India 's villages display a remarkable continuity from this situation throughout the period being studied.
Dependence on usurious moneylenders and the operation of a deeply exploitative grid of interlocked, imperfect markets afflicts the rural poor. After a review of the weak performance of cooperative credit institutions in India, we articulate the theoretical case for nationalisation of banks in 1969 and document its positive impact on rural credit and economic development. However, we also suggest that certain excesses in the two decades
following
References: Banerjee, A. (2001): Contracting Constraints, Credit Markets and Economic Development, Working Paper 02-17, Department of Economics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Basu, P. and P. Srivastava (2005): 'Exploring Possibilities: Microfinance and Rural Credit Access for the Poor in India ', Economic and Political Weekly, April 23 Besley, T. (1995) “Saving, Credit and Insurance,” in Behrman, J. and T.N. Srinivasan (ed) Handbook of Development Economics, Vol Bhaduri, A. (2006): ‘Provision of Rural Financial Services’, in Employment and Development: Essays from an Unorthodox Perspective, Oxford University Press Binswanger, H.P., S.R. Khandker and M.R. Rosenzweig (1993) "How Infrastructure and Financial Institutions Affect Agricultural Output and Investment in India", Journal of Burgess, R. and R. Pande (2002): Do Rural Banks Matter? Evidence from the Indian Social Banking Experiment Catanach, I.J. (1970); Rural Credit in Western India, 1875-1930, Berkeley CGAP (2004): Interest Rate Ceilings and Microfinance: The Story So Far, Occasional Paper, Chandrashekhar, C.P. and S.K. Ray (2005): 'Financial Sector Reform and the Transformation of Banking ', in Ramachandran, V.K Chavan, P. (2005): ‘How ‘Inclusive’ Are Banks under Financial Liberlisation?’, Economic and Political Weekly, 22 October Chavan, P. (2005): 'Banking Sector Liberalisation and the Growth and Distribution of Regional Banking ', in Ramachandran, V.K Chavan, P. and R. Ramakumar (2005): 'Interest Rates on Micro-Credit ', in Ramachandran, V.K Ciravegna, D. (2005): The Role of Microcredit in Modern Economy: The Case of Italy, www.flacso.or.cr/fileadmin/documentos/FLACSO/auCiravegna2.DOC Dandekar, V.M. and F.K. Wadia (1989): ‘Development of Institutional Finance for Agriculture in India’, Journal of Indian School of Political Economy, I, 2. Darling, M. L. (1925): The Punjab Peasant in Prosperity and Debt, Oxford University Press Diamond, D Dichter, T. (2004): Remarks to the Microfinance Club of New York Drechsler, W EPW Research Foundation (2007): 'Need for Calibrated Policy in Interest Rates and Credit ', Economic and Political Weekly, February 24 Fernandez, A.P. (2007): 'Sanghamithra – An MFI with a Difference: Are SHGs Only Financial Intermediaries? ', Economic and Political Weekly, Vol Fisher, T. and M.S. Sriram (2002): Beyond Micro-Credit: Putting Development Back into MicroFinance, Vistaar, New Delhi Ghate, P Ghate, P. (2007): 'Consumer Protection in Indian Microfinance: Lessons from Andhra Pradesh and the Microfinance Bill ', Economic and Political Weekly, Vol Goetz, A.M. and R.S. Gupta (1996): 'Who Takes the Credit? Gender, Power, and Control over Loan Use in Rural Credit Programmes in Bangladesh ', World Development, Vol 24, No1 Government of India (1942): Report on the Marketing of Rice in India and Burma Government of India (2005): Report of the Task Force on Revival of Cooperative Credit Institutions, Ministry of Finance Government of India (2006): From Hariyali to Neeranchal: Report of the Technical Committee on Watershed Programmes in India, Ministry of Rural Development Government of India (2007): Report of the Working Group on Rainfed Areas for the 11th Five Year Haque, T. and S. Verma (1988): ‘Regional and Class Disparities in the Flow of Agricultural Credit in India’, Indian Journal of Agricultural Economics, XVIII, 3 Harper, M., E. Esipisu, A.K. Mohanty and D.S. Rao (1998): The New Middlewomen – Profitable Banking Through On-Lending Groups, Oxford & IBH Hashemi, S.M., S.R. Schuler and A.P. Riley (1996): 'Rural Credit Programmes and Women 's Empowerment in Bangladesh ', World Development, Vol.24, No.4 Hermes, N. and R. Lensink (2007): 'Impact of Microfinance: A Critical Survey ', Economic and Political Weekly, Vo.XLII, No.6, February 10 Kabeer, N. (2005): ‘Is Microfinance a ‘Magic Bullet’ for Women 's Empowerment?’, Economic and Political Weekly, 29 October Kalecki, M. (1954): Theory of Economic Dynamics Kannabiran, V Keynes, J.M. (1935): The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money Keynes, J.M Khandker, S.R. (2005): 'Microfinance and Poverty: Evidence using Panel Data from Bangaladesh ', The World Bank Economic Review, Vol.19, No.2 Krishnaswamy, K.S., K. Krishnamurthy and P.D. Sharma (1987): Improving Domestic Resource Mobilisation through Financial Development: India, Asian Development Bank, Manila Kumar, D. (1965): Land and Caste in South India Kumar, D Mahajan, V. (2005): ‘From Microcredit to Livelihood Finance’, Economic and Political Weekly, 8 October Marr, A. (2004): 'A Challenge to the Orthodoxy Concerning Microfinance and Poverty