Preview

Rogerian Argument: Male Sports Dominate Female Sports

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
707 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Rogerian Argument: Male Sports Dominate Female Sports
Ashley Suter
Coffey
WR-122
Rogerian Argument
Male Sports Dominate Female Sports

An issue that I have always been concerned with is how much attention male sports get, while female sports get pushed aside. Males and females put forth the same amount of effort and the same amount of hard work towards the sports they play, and in return males dominate the limelight. Arguments opposing this show that males are obviously better athletes than females. According to Mariah Burton Nelson, controversial activist and author, football, baseball and other manly sports in the United States are not games, but a culture which offer a pre-civil rights world where white men, as owners, coaches and umpires, still rule. In the manly sports, men learn to think about and talk about women in contempt. It is common practice for boys to be belittled as "wusses" or worse if they are not tough or brutal enough or willing to deny their own pain or the pain of others.
Any time a male environment is steeped in sexism, those attitudes eventually hurt women, whether verbally or physically. Sports have been defined as male, like physics and math and Congress. Any time women have entered a field previously dominated by men, it threatens men's self-confidence. If women can do it, what does this
…show more content…
Because of all the attention male sports get and all of the notoriety male professional athletes are awarded, it is clear to me that male sports have casted a shadow over female sports allowing the public to overlook its excitement and potential. Baseball is everywhere. The mainstream media is packed full of merchandising opportunities that every talented athlete only dreams of. The media gives a massive a mount of attention to male sports, allowing female sports to appear not as necessary or worth wild. It is unfair, when each athlete, whether it is baseball or

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the article titled”Face off on the Playfield”, by Judith B. Stamper explores the issues of female athletes competing on traditional boy’s sport team. First, Stamper explain how opponent agree that girl are not aggressive enough. But supporters argue that girl don’t have good equipment like boy. The author also report that some male athletes get uncomfortable having physical contact with girls. Second, girl are too weak to compete. In Addition she emphasised that supporters say Title IX has benefitted girl’s health and how society view girls. Now, more girl are playing sports. Finally Stamper concludes that as the debate over ow Title IX continue, boy are now asking to compete on girl’s team.…

    • 119 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Research Paper Final Draft

    • 1562 Words
    • 3 Pages

    held against them ("Masculinity and Gender Roles in Sports"). As the role of women has progressed, a…

    • 1562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the key points to evaluate here is the argument that males biologically have an advantage in the majority of sports. In the vast number of cases this is true, however this should not be a reason why females are either discriminated against or feel pressurised to not participate in a sport. In a study done by McArdle, Katch & Katch in 1981, it was shown that among Western adults, men are around 50 percent stronger than women1. One thing that is important to point out here is that the average female has not been encouraged to participate in activities that would develop the growth and potential of muscles in the same way men have been encouraged to do. The stereotype that women should be slender and with little muscle does not aid this particular viewpoint on women’s sport. This leads on to the point of the history of female sport and the view on women’s roles in society. The earlier you go back in history, the more the viewpoint has existed that women are there to aid the husband in the house and bring up the children whilst he is out earning the money. This was very much the case and still is in some cultures, which inhibited and inhibits women from participating in sport because they simply do not have the time for it. As Spears (1978) said in his study, “Only the exceptional woman was involved in sport”2. I think it is fair to say however, that this viewpoint is quite clearly changing because participation in female sport is at an all time high at the moment. According to…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Sport is not traditionally seen as feminine. Ex-professional women’s basketball player, Mariah Burton Nelson begs the question then- “How can you win if you’re female? Can you just do it? No. You have to play the femininity game. Femininity by definition is not large, not imposing, not competitive. Feminine women are not ruthless, not aggressive, not victorious. Femininity is about appearing beautiful and vulnerable and small. It’s about winning male approval (Burton 1998).” Gender roles play a large part in the media’s representation of female athletes. In a historically sexist world where ruthlessness, aggression, and victory are associated as male characteristics, female athletes are viewed as masculine and undesirable. In order to be socially…

    • 169 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Title IX

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Throughout history, people generally associated women with domestic and subservient activities. Women were not encouraged to play outdoors or get dirty because such actions did not embody a proper lady’s behavior. Because of society’s deeply ingrained ideas of traditional gender roles, women would not have been able to fully participate in the sports culture without a catalyst such as Title IX. Although some argue that Title IX causes America’s overall competitiveness in sports to decrease and men’s sports to suffer, statistics show that men still have a dominant representation in college athletics. Because sports represents a major aspect of American culture and should fully encourage the participation of both genders and since enough opportunities for male athletes can be provided while still proportionally representing Title IX mandates, the benefits of Title IX providing opportunities for women outweigh the potentially negative effects on men’s sports.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unequal Pay in Sport

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Sports have become arguably the single most important institution in our nation. They have overcome issues of race, colour, and class. However, one area that faces continual struggling is that of gender equality. More especially, areas of concern include male and female athlete pay. I strongly disagree with the contention that pay in sport should always be equitable between genders. In fact I believe (sorry ladies) men deserve to be paid more.…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Furthermore, if no one supports women playing sports, it is pointless for them to do so. "There are fewer women involved in college athletics because women in General have historically been discouraged from participating in sports," (Source B). Government programs like Title IX are ineffective in changing our "legacy of sexism," (Source C). Instead, we rely on the work of a dedicated few such as the famous female tennis player, Billie Jean King (Source E). Motivated individuals and organizations are frequently found to be more effective than government programs. For example, Martin Luther King Jr. and the efforts of community organizations accomplished more in the fight for civil rights than any government program. There is no way that an impersonal bureaucracy can possibly, "produce positive social change," (Source B). The gender stereotypes of today are deeply rooted, but will hopefully fade as women continue to prove…

    • 512 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The sports community defends the men ability more than they do with the females, and women should receive the same opportunities as the men. There has been a lot of high school, and colleges that have dealt with discrimination of gender in…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    As a fan of soccer I enjoy watching soccer games with my dad; it doesn’t matter if it's Futbol Liga Mexicana or UEFA EURO, we love watching soccer. We both find it exciting when we see the women’s soccer games as much as the men’s soccer games. Several of the US women’s soccer players have sued the US Soccer Federation for equal pay. I have been seeing the difference in how the women are being rewarded for their effort and winning great titles compared to the men who hasn’t been showing much effort but yet still get more paid than the women. Women involved in sports has changed a lot in the community of sports and made gender roles more into equality. Women should get the same treatment men such as more promotion, salary, sponsorships, and recognition to feel more equal. Many people thought the equality problem had been solved with the establishment of the Title IX and the Equality Act but not everyone seems to follow the rules and gender equality is still a problem present day.…

    • 1752 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Importance Of Title IX

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Sports are very crucial and take part of a vast roll in people’s life. To some it is a stress reliever, fun game, or their entire life but sometimes there are situations that make you step back to evaluate what is actually going on. In a female athlete’s opinion male sports get more than what their sport or any other female sport would get but in a male competitor’s assumption is that they are both given the opportunity to do the same things especially with the Title IX that was put in place in 1972 stating that, “no matter what the sex is of someone, they can not be excluded from, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discriminate participating in any educational program or activity. Each physical activity is given money from the school, fundraises, and has a set fee at the start of each season…

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Memoir

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Those who are opposed to the idea of men and women playing baseball together, often defend their argument with the belief that women are not physical capable of participating in sports. In addition they often entice the belief that women are more susceptible to injury than men. This is not a valid reason to exclude women and there is an abidance of research that refutes this claim. In addition to excluding women based on their sex, the sport of baseball is connected to racial segregation. It was believed that baseball was a white man's sport and only men who were white possessed the ability to play the sport. This ideology has filtered into present society, resulting in a few number of African Americans or people of color who participate in the sport. With that being said race is absolutely a factor in whether or not women can play baseball with men. Women who are not white are seen as inferior and they are not expected to be successful in playing baseball. There are great deal of stereotypes that surround race and a person's athletic ability. These stereotypes have been around since the "Americanization" of baseball and traces of them are still evident today. Physical size and strength, the possibility of injuries, and the color of one's skin have been used as strong reasons to prohibit women and girls from entering the world of baseball, all of these claims are absurd and false, these issues should not just be associated women due to their biological sex. Women regardless of race are just as capable as men to participate in the sport of baseball. We can alleviate and erase these myths surrounding the inferiority of women and the superiority of men in the arena of sports. To solve this problem we must start early, we must preparing girls early to have the ability and skill to play baseball amongst their male counterparts.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gender In Sports

    • 688 Words
    • 3 Pages

    However the popularity of woman's in “men's” sports has risen, and in the majority of our society many girls are pushed to join sports, as much as boys are, such as soccer or basketball, and are placed into leagues where they gain experience for when/if they decide to join their school leagues. As time progresses, I do believe that sports will be seen as vital socialization for men and women, if not in the generation of my generations, children, then in their children. Those of my generation where sports have been a big part of their life, will wish to share that with their children. The joys of being on a team, learning how to cooperate and work with others, no matter how different is vital to human beings regardless of gender. The norm of sports being for 'men' seems to be shifting as more professional athletes are coming out with their sexual orientation. Gay men are often ridiculed and regarded as weak, or 'not real men' the players coming out or demonstrating, “I'm gay, yet I had a successful athletic career in spite of/regardless of my…

    • 688 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the article Women, Sports and Science, Sandra Hanson states, “Sports are a social institution constructed by men that reflects traditional male stereotypes of dominance and aggression.” This suggests that some people usually view sports as a man’s activity. Hanson then goes on to say, “Women are typically considered ill-equipped to participate in sports, and their participation is viewed as unfeminine and thus undesirable.” In the article, Advantage Men: The Sex Pay Gap, Collin Flake suggests that sports are considered a masculine pastime, so that is where the mindset comes from. He states, “Much of the literature on gender inequality in sport is devoted to media bias and conceptualizations of masculinity and femininity.”…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Masculinity In Sports

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There are many aspects why female and male athletes should not compete together. Although one reason may be because of physiological differences, societal barriers also prevent female athletes from competing with males. What it means to be male or female is one of the hardest things to decipher. This is one of the more bigger struggles between masculinity and femininity. One institution that specifically targets this idea of gender differences is professional sports. Women are challenged because of these gender differences to be accepted into a male dominated institution. Female athletes are encouraged and in many cases forced to under appreciate themselves by the media because of sports. Our society tends to under appreciate women who play…

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the media today, we are constantly being pounded and pushed with the thought of whether gender stereotyping, but is it ok. It is clear that it is everywhere, from the Internet to television to newspapers. Television both shapes and reflects the attitudes of our society (Wilson, 2014). A Google search, of sport, was recently done, and the images that came up were almost all of male athletes. But why is this the case? Why are woman’s sports not being shown or advertised as much as men’s?…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics