Resource Based Theory
The Financial Review 38 (2003) 213--234
Evidence on Value Creation in the Financial
Services Industries through the Use of Joint
Ventures and Strategic Alliances
Kimberly C. Gleason
Bentley College
Ike Mathur∗
Southern Illinois University
Roy A. Wiggins, III
Bentley College
Abstract
While an extensive body of literature has examined merger, acquisition, and consolidation activity in commercial banks and other financial services firms, little attention has been paid to examining how these institutions use the cooperative activities of joint ventures and strategic alliances to accomplish their growth objectives. We analyze the effects of the use of joint ventures and strategic alliances by a sample of firms in the banking, investment services, and insurance industries. Our results show that commercial banks, investment services firms, and insurance companies experience significant abnormal returns of 0.66% on average when they announce their participation in a joint venture or strategic alliance. These abnormal returns are significantly positive across the four strategic motives of domestic, international, horizontal, and diversifying cooperative activities. Using a matched sample, we also show that our sample firms enjoy significant, positive, abnormal returns for holding periods of six, 12, and 18 months after the announcement of the cooperative activity.
∗ Corresponding author: Department of Finance, Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, IL 62901-4626.
Phone: 618-453-1421; Fax: 618-453-5626; E-mail: imathur@cba.siu.edu
The authors thank two anonymous referees, Stephen P. Ferris (the editor), and participants at the 2000
Financial Management Association meeting for helpful comments on earlier drafts of the paper.
213
214
K. C. Gleason et al./The Financial Review 38 (2003) 213–234
Keywords: joint ventures, strategic alliances, long-horizon performance
JEL Classifications: G21/G29/G14
1. Introduction
Financial
Evidence on Value Creation in the Financial
Services Industries through the Use of Joint
Ventures and Strategic Alliances
Kimberly C. Gleason
Bentley College
Ike Mathur∗
Southern Illinois University
Roy A. Wiggins, III
Bentley College
Abstract
While an extensive body of literature has examined merger, acquisition, and consolidation activity in commercial banks and other financial services firms, little attention has been paid to examining how these institutions use the cooperative activities of joint ventures and strategic alliances to accomplish their growth objectives. We analyze the effects of the use of joint ventures and strategic alliances by a sample of firms in the banking, investment services, and insurance industries. Our results show that commercial banks, investment services firms, and insurance companies experience significant abnormal returns of 0.66% on average when they announce their participation in a joint venture or strategic alliance. These abnormal returns are significantly positive across the four strategic motives of domestic, international, horizontal, and diversifying cooperative activities. Using a matched sample, we also show that our sample firms enjoy significant, positive, abnormal returns for holding periods of six, 12, and 18 months after the announcement of the cooperative activity.
∗ Corresponding author: Department of Finance, Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, IL 62901-4626.
Phone: 618-453-1421; Fax: 618-453-5626; E-mail: imathur@cba.siu.edu
The authors thank two anonymous referees, Stephen P. Ferris (the editor), and participants at the 2000
Financial Management Association meeting for helpful comments on earlier drafts of the paper.
213
214
K. C. Gleason et al./The Financial Review 38 (2003) 213–234
Keywords: joint ventures, strategic alliances, long-horizon performance
JEL Classifications: G21/G29/G14
1. Introduction
Financial
References: Bank for International Settlements, 2001. Group of Ten Report on Consolidation in the Financial Sector. Baradwaj, B., D. Dubofsky, and D. Fraser, 1991. Bidder returns in interstate and intrastate bank acquisitions, Journal of Financial Services Research 5, 261–273. Baradwaj, B., D. Fraser, and E. Furtado, 1990. Hostile bank takeover offers: Analysis and implications, Journal of Banking and Finance 14, 1229–1242. Barber, B. and J. Lyon, 1997. Detecting long-run abnormal returns: The empirical power and specification of test statistics, Journal of Financial Economics 43, 341–372. Berger, A., R. Demsetz, and P. Strahan, 1999. The consolidation of the financial services industry: Causes, consequences, and implications for the future, Journal of Banking and Finance 23, 135–194. Bodnar, G., C. Tang, and J. Weintrop, 2001. Both sides of corporate diversification: The value impacts of corporate geographic and industrial diversification Boehmer, E., J. Musumeci, and A.B. Poulsen, 1991. Event-study methodology under conditions of eventinduced variance, Journal of Financial Economics 30, 253–272. Chan, S., J. Kensinger, A. Keown, and J. Martin, 1997. Do strategic alliances create value? Journal of Financial Economics 46, 199–221. Conrad, J. and G. Kaul, 1993. Long-term market overreaction or biases in computed returns? Journal of Finance 48, 39–63. Contractor, F., 1990. Contractual and cooperative forms of international business: Towards a unified theory of modal choice, Management International Review 30, 31–54. Cornett, M. and H. Tehranian, 1992. Changes in corporate performance associated with bank acquisitions, Journal of Financial Economics 31, 211–234. Cummins, J., S. Tennyson, and M. Weiss, 1999. Consolidation and efficiency in the U.S. life insurance industry, Journal of Banking and Finance 23, 325–357. Edmonson, G., and A. Robinson, 1999. Bank invaders scales the Pyrenees, Business Week, November 29, 62. Fried, H., K. Lovell, and S. Yaisawarng, 1999. The impact of mergers on credit union service provision, Journal of Banking and Finance 23, 367–386. Gupta, A., R. LeCompte, and L. Misra, 1997. Acquisitions of solvent thrifts: Wealth effects and managerial motivations, Journal of Banking and Finance 21, 1431–1450. Harrigan, K., 1985. Strategies for Joint Ventures (Lexington Books, Lexington, MA). Hughes, J., W. Lang, L. Mester, and C. Moon, 1999. The dollars and sense of bank consolidation, Journal of Banking and Finance 23, 291–324. Jacobsen, S. and A. Tshoegl, 1999. The Norwegian banks in the Nordic consortia: A case of international strategic alliances in banking, Industrial and Corporate Change 8, 137–145. Kogut, B., 1988. Joint ventures: Theoretical and empirical perspectives, Strategic Management Journal 9, 319–332. Kvint, V., 1998. Nature of international joint ventures and their role in global business, in International M and A, Joint Ventures and Beyond, ed Lorange, P. and J. Roos, 1992. Strategic Alliances: Formation, Implementation, and Evolution (Blackwell, Oxford). Madura, J. and K. Wiant, 1994. Long-term valuation effects of bank acquisitions, Journal of Banking and Finance 18, 1135–1154. McConnell, J.,and T. Nantell, 1985. Common stock returns and corporate combinations: The case for joint ventures, Journal of Finance 40, 519–536. Milbourn, T., A. Boot, and A. Thakor, 1999, Megamergers and expanded scope: Theories in bank size and activity diversity, Journal of Banking and Finance 23, 195–214. Newman, L. and G. diCiccio, 1998. Strategic Choices, in International M and A, Joint Ventures and Beyond, ed Palia, D., 1994. Recent evidence on bank mergers, Financial Markets, Institutions, and Instruments 3, 36–59. Rhoades, S., 1998. The efficiency effects of bank mergers: An overview of case studies of nine mergers, Journal of Banking and Finance 22, 273–291. Sushka, M., and Y. Bendeck, 1988. Bank acquisitions and shareholder wealth, Journal of Banking and Finance 12, 551–562. Williamson, O., 1975. Market and hierarchies: Analysis and antitrust implications (Basic Books, New York). Williamson, O., 1985. The Economic Institutions of Capitalism (Free Press, New York). Zhang, H., 1995. Wealth effects of U.S. bank takeovers, Applied Financial Economics 5, 329–336.