Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

The relationship between the US Federal Government and state governments from 1781 to present

Good Essays
1111 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The relationship between the US Federal Government and state governments from 1781 to present
The government of the United States is constantly changing. From the moment the country was born until today, there have been many eras and concepts that have transpired over the years. The United States federal government and state and local governments have gone through periods for transition from 1781 to the present day in which their relationships where continuously changing.

In order to understand the different eras of U.S. governmental history, one must first understand the history of the relationships between the federal government and state and local governments. The Constitution of the U.S. establishes a direct link between state governments and Congress. It gives Congress specific powers like declaring war and creating armies. The U.S. Constitution also bars states from performing acts that would undermine the federal government; some of those acts include making treaties, coining money, and making war. State governments can also create/destroy local governments. Federal, state, and local governments all interact with one another.

As each level of government interacts with the other(s), there are clear distinctions in the levels of interaction that take place. The different levels of government in the United States have something called formal interaction. There are four types of formal interaction: national to state, state to national, nation equals state (concurrent powers), and state to local.

The first form of interaction is national to state. National to state interaction gives the federal government most of the power over the land. The federal government has the power to have an army. It ensures a republican form of government; this means that when a state is admitted to the union, the federal government controls how the state is created (in the form of laws). This form of interaction also has something known as the Supremacy Clause; this makes the Constitution the supreme law of the land. The power of laws from highest to lowest is as follows: U.S. Constitution, federal law, state constitutions, state laws, and local ordinances.

On the reverse side of national to state interaction is state to national interaction. In this form of interaction, the states determine elections and procedures. States are represented in the national government in the Senate; they are also represented in the Electoral College. States must approve changes that are made to the U.S. Constitution.

The national government and state governments do not always battle for power in national to state and state to national interaction. When the national government and state governments share power, it is know as concurrent powers. Both the federal and state governments have the power to tax, borrow money, establish courts, make/enforce laws, and the power of eminent domain.

A step down from national and state interaction is state to local interaction. State and local interaction is not as complex as national and state interaction. This type of interaction involves funding. States have the ability to create and destroy local governments if they so choose. When a state creates or destroys a local government it also approves or removes power from that local government.

The interaction process of the different levels of government is based on the idea of federalism. Federalism comes from the idea that there are two levels of government that coexist within a nation. The United States has gone through various eras of federalism, which include dual federalism, cooperative federalism, picket-fence federalism, and conflicted federalism. Each level has distinctive features and can be seen in different time frames of United States history.

The earliest system of federalism that can be seen in U.S. history is the concept of dual federalism. Dual federalism can be seen from about 1789 to 1932 in U.S. history. Under this concept, the state governments have the most power, while the federal government has a limited to small amount of power. State governments have exclusive rights to "police powers" in policy areas. Even though it has a small to limited amount of power under this system, the national government is said to have grown; examples of this can be seen as the Civil War progresses and Civil War amendments are passed. The national government also moves from a passive to positive regulator of the economy. The amount of federal grants-in-aid also grows during this time period.

As dual federalism made its way out in 1932, the cooperative era of federalism crept in. This era was created in response to the Great Depression with Frank D. Roosevelt's New Deal. The national government used "interstate commerce" to put federal controls on the states and the economy. The economy is controlled by the federal government through the Commerce Clause and the federal budget. Intergovernmental grants-in-aid are also developed during this time period. These types of grants-in-aid allow the federal government to disperse federal money to the states for specific programs, and some strings are attached to the money states receive; this was used to regulate the states by saying that if they did not follow the guideline the federal government had given with the money, then the money could be taken away from the states.

The cooperative era runs until 1960, when picket-fence federalism replaces it. Picket-fence federalism brings about the idea of categorical grants-in-aid. Powers are balanced between federal, state, and local governments; each level of government pulls an equal amount of weight on programs. Cross-cutting sanctions also emerge in this era. The sanctions said that failure to comply in one program would result in the cut in funding of another program. The federal bureaucracy grows again with Lyndon B. Johnson's "Great Society". Local governments are able to now bypass the states and receive funding directly from the federal government. The Supreme Court expands national government's power over the states.

The federal government continued to expand with cooperative federalism until 1981 when President Reagan took office. Reagan gave birth to the era of federalism called conflicted federalism. This era continues up to present day. Reagan began to attack the federal government; he says that the government is the problem and many people distrust it. Reagan wanted to undo what FDR and LBJ had done in previous years. He also called for block grants and "regulatory relief". He wanted the strings that came with grants-in-aid to be cut.

As its government progressed through many changes over the course of history, the government of the United States is remains based on a federal system in which power is divided among national, state, and local governments. The federal system acknowledges that the U.S. is a large and diverse nation, and by having state and local governments that diversity can be represented. The government of the United States will always be changing; and as it does change the manner in which it is governed will vary slightly with the birth of new ideas.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    It had been the main source of conflict between the colonies and Great Britain and it continued during the formation of the Constitution. Madison attempt to answer the question of how could both the national and state government be sovereign and where did ultimate sovereignty fall. He concluded it came from the bottom, the people, and flowed up. The Constitution distributed powers between the national and state governments. The federal government had the power to tax, regulate commerce, and pass laws that were necessary and proper. States no longer retained every power, however the Constitution recognized their separated existence and allowed them to pass their own laws. (American History,…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    U.S. Government

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Our government is passed on federalism. Which means a government that shared its power between national, state and local governments. Our founding fathers wanted nothing to do with a centralized government and created the exact opposite, the federal government.…

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The federal government has powers that are more general and apply to the country as a whole, while the state government has powers specific to their area. According to Madison in Federalist Paper #51 written in 1788, federalism guards against tyranny because, “The different governments will control each other, at the same time that each will be controlled by itself.” (Document A) They are able to control their separate areas of government while still controlling the power of the other, ensuring that the other does not accumulate too much power and turn the country into a…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The national government is very strong level of government based on Bowman & Kearneys explanation of the commerce clause. The Commerce Clause, Article I Section 8 Clause 3 of the Constitution of the United States, grants Congress the power “To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes” The commerce power is an enumerated power of Congress and the Supreme Court has interpreted it as an articulate grant of authority to Congress and an assenting limitation on the rights of the states to regulate commerce within their own borders.…

    • 279 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Federalism is the type of government where there is segment of different powers between a state government and the central government. The United States is a federalist government where the states have their own individual powers and authority that they are able to exercise and the federal government has its own circle of authority that it tends to exercise.…

    • 828 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Between the levels of government there exist different structures, the federal government is a body is the government body of individuals at the federal level that sets and administers public policies, in US the federal government is established by the US constitution guides and it helps to maintain the use of power within the federation. In the US the federal government has three branches with which it operates and share sovereignty over the United States with the individual government of the states of US.…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Government can be a complicated system to understand, but one thing I have come to notice is it either you are for something or you are against something. One that is known to many is either the Federalist or the Anti-Federalist. To be considered a Federalist, they want a strong national government and were all for the approval of the Constitution to aid the debt and tensions. To be consider an Anti- Federalist, they were people who opposed a strong federal government and were for the Article of Confederation instead. They preferred for the power to remain in the state and local governments. Some major points of disagreement between the Federalist and Antifederalist visions of the United States were central government and important documents.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A system of dividing up power between a central national government and a local state governments that are connected to one another by the national government defines a federal government. While some areas are under control by the national government, the same boundaries are placed with the state or local governments that are set by the constitution. The questions that should be asked are what powers are granted, what powers are denied, and what powers are shared to both types of government.…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The United States constitution created a new type of government called federalism, which divided power between the states and the national government. But the proper balance of federalism has been debated throughout the history of the United States, Federalism, which signifies members of a group that are bond together with a governing representative head. Two time periods that there has been a debate on federalism was the Supreme Court under John Marshall in (1801- 1835) and the extension of slavery in (1820-1860).…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Let our government be like that of the solar system. Let the general government be like the sun and the states the planets, repelled yet attracted, and the whole moving regularly and harmoniously in several orbits.” said John Dickinson, a Delaware Delegate in 1787 (constitutionfacts.com). The United States has a government that, for the most part, flows smoothly. However, our governing documents have not always been so harmonious. The Articles of Confederation, created and ratified in 1781 during the Revolutionary War, was the first basis for the United States of America’s central government. This was a shaky set of laws, yet it evolved into The Constitution of the United States of America. Though The Constitution was created from the Articles of Confederation, there were many differences. Three of these are differences in powers, in purposes, and in effects.…

    • 716 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Federalism involves the sharing of powers between different levels of government. In the United States this relates to the government at national level (the federal government) and those at the level of the state. The United Kingdom is not a federal state instead it is a unitary state where power is held in one place (parliament). Federalism is the process of sharing power between a central government, in America’s case Washington, and the States. The US Constitution dictates what areas the Federal Government have control of and the areas that the States have control of. Amendment 10 of the Bill of Rights dictates that any area that is not a power of Congress, President or Supreme Court it is up to the States to decide. Dissimilarly to the UK, Britain has adopted the unitary system which means that there is just one main body of government as opposed to powers being distributed across the nation. Over time, federalism has adapted and changed and the theory of New Federalism was introduced after Nixon’s and Reagan’s administration and was further mentioned under George W. Bush’s presidency.…

    • 1456 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Federalism has been put in place to allow two or more entities to share control over one area. In the United States, power is separated between the national government and state government, which prohibits one area of government gaining too much control. This is called cooperative federalism, which is where national, state, and local government work together to solve common problems. The other type of federalism is called dual federalism. Dual federalism is like a layered cake because the state and national government each have specific powers, unlike cooperative federalism.…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are two parts of government in the fact of federal government and state government. These two sections are found within the two Houses of Congress, The House of Representatives and the Senate. Within these two houses they deal with separate issues, one with the problems that are on a state-to-state level, the other on matters that hold the whole country’s best interest, so definitely on more of a national scale.…

    • 652 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The first type of government in America was based primarily on state government. Following the Revolutionary War, the thirteen colonies, although they had formed a league of friendship under the Articles of Confederation, basically governed themselves. They feared a strong central government like the one they lived with under England 's rule. However, it was soon discovered that this weak form of state government could not survive and so the Constitution was drafted. This time, it was decided that a government system based on federalism would be established. In other words, power is shared between the national and state governments (“National versus State Government.” n.p.). Sharing power between the national government and state governments allows American citizens to enjoy the benefits of diversity and unity. On the other hand, issues such as the death penalty have been left up to the individual states. The decision whether or not to have a death penalty depends on that state 's history, needs, and philosophies (“National versus State Government” n.p.). In addition to the death penalty laws in many states, the federal government has also employed capital punishment for certain federal offenses, such as terrorism, murder of a government official, kidnapping resulting in death, running a large-scale drug enterprise, and treason (“The…

    • 1148 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    2. Describe how these three branches are supposed to interact. The three forms of government, the Legislative, the Executive, and the Judicial branches interact with each other through the system called, check and balance. Check and balance allow the feral branches to check on one another to ensure that each branch has equal power over their citizens’ rights.…

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays