Preview

Rap and Moral character

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1407 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Rap and Moral character
In the article Rap and Moral Character by Susan Dwyer, the subject of concern is the consequences of listening to rap music and the effect it has on moral character. The author argues that rap music contribute to the corruption of moral character, it is misogynistic, promotes violence and street crime. In this paper I will examine the author’s claims, use of key concepts, and her reasoning. By doing so, I will be able to demonstrate that Dwyer’s thesis is unjust and unsupported. In what follows, I will analyze the claims to show that the author’s arguments are irrelevant and lack sufficient evidence to support her thesis. Secondly, I will examine the author’s reasoning to point out fallacious reasoning and lastly I will evaluate her use of key concepts. There are about 7 claims in the article. However, many of them were only used to demonstrate and explain issues regarding rap and moral behaviour. The author begins the argument by claiming rap music is both a sign of and contributes to a form of corruption of moral character. This particular claim is empirical because the author did not offer her reader any type of verification or facts to prove her point. Dwyer failed to demonstrate how people’s moral character is corrupted by listening to rap music. Many people enjoy listening to different types of music for different reasons. Rap music does not determine the person’s character or behaviours. Rap music does not contribute to a form of corruption of moral character. Rap music has come a long way and has been shaped by different skills of various rappers who reflect a blend of elements into fascinating wordplay. It has become very popular among young people; they listen to it as a form of entertainment and rap songs have helped many people through tough times the same way Johnny Cash and country music helps people. Music is music everyone has their own preference. Rap music can help people build a positive character; for instance, a rap song

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Rap music has been around since the 1970’s. People have questioned why it has only recently gotten such bad publicity. Denise Herd did a study on rap and hip hop music to determine if the lyrics in rap music have increasingly gotten worse in promoting sexism and violence. In her study she “examined 130 platinum (rap) albums with 430 songs released from 1992 to 2002 using Anderson’s conceptualization of ‘the street code’ and found that violence was the central theme of the lyrics along with wealth, violent retaliation, nihilism, and objectification of women.” (Herd p395) She also took songs from the 1970’s and discovered “that despite the stereotypes, violence is not the central focus of rap” (Herd p396). Between 1979 and 1984 only 24 per cent of rap songs mentioned violence, between 1985 and 1989 it rose to 32 per cent and between 1994 and 1997 it rose to 60 per cent. Herd’s studies made it evident that rap music has increasingly gotten worse. Nathan McCall who served nearly three years in jail for armed Robbery and now works for The Washington Post stated “We're going to take away the market value of these attacks on our person. Anyone black or white who makes money calling our women bitches or our people niggers will have to face our indignation” (Suggs p3). It’s an indignity that people are making money for putting such negative media out by which today’s youth is being influenced.…

    • 2202 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some of the most famous rappers have songs named, “F**k The Police”, “Crooked A** N***a”, and “Cop Killer.” (“Negative Influences Gangster Rap What Can Be Done About It”). These songs, like so many others, also talk about murder and disrespect of women. Lives have been lost and people have suffered, yet the gangster rap industry is still flourishing. Society has noticed the negative influence this music has had, yet they still continue to make it succeed through a number of record sales. Even though there is no way to solve this problem it’s still a benefit that parents do not let their children listen to the music and have them grow up hearing these types of…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I was just like you when I first started listening to rap. I found that the negatives of rap outweighed the positives. Therefore, I looked for rap that I could relate to and I found that not all rap artist are in pursuit of profit. Their are artist out there that rap for a cause. The reason rap has become immoral is that money is involved just like everything else involving profit.…

    • 76 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout its brief history rap has been criticized for its violent misogyny and whether rap music is portrayed with “music violence”, “lethal lyrics”, “violent pornography”, and “aural violence” that has been expressed against rap because it provided a “gangsta ideology”, a shameless acceptance of violence and misogyny (Armstrong 184). In the article “Hip Hop Culture Mirrors the Negative Effects in Society?” By Leigh Haugh, she questions if hip-hop has become a negative influence on not only ourselves as individuals, but for everyone in our society. Hip-hop was also being recognized by the lifestyles of many individuals, and it also has created its own path on how life should be, especially in the black communities. For example, In the The Pew Research Team’s article “King’s Dream Remains an Elusive Goal”, statistics show that Blacks have mainly got some racial equality (39%) toward Martin Luther King’s I have a Dream speech of racial equality and 79% show what needs to be accomplished in order to achieve racial equality (Pew Research Team 628). Mainly 57% of blacks say they have gotten along with whites and it has decreased by 13% when blacks get along with Hispanics 44% of the time (Pew Research Team 629). Rap expresses how the younger people react to hip-hop and it’s culture by speaking and dressing differently. It shows how rap music and its artists like to express…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rap and Moral Character

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages

    man in front of a moving bus with the intent of killing him is judged…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The moral focus on music should be about respect. Even tough some individuals doesn't have a problem with not respecting themselves by exploiting their personal lives but, exploiting the individuals that lives in the similar situations is completely wrong. This writer had experienced many biases and ideas from white people that were totally wrong. They believed since the writer is black, he has experiences violence which is depicted in highly publicizes hip hop music. People from other culture listen to hip hop music and has formulated thoughts from the language and actions of the music. At times, many individuals who are black understands that people from other cultures believes that they all from broken homes and know somebody that sells narcotics. Now the black culture is misrepresented and has trouble erasing that…

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Rap Bad Influence

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Rap music isn't music,some will say and have been saying for years hip hop and rap aren't good for you.It's just propaganda to promote violence,drugs,alcohol(etc…). According to Davey D, his article “Is Rap Actually Music or is it a Bad Influence” he states that “88% percent of the rap music that is currently on the top lists around the world contains violence. They glorify the acts of beating up another person, or even worse shooting them. Looking like someone who just got released from prison in their eyes is a good thing. Not to mention that half of the time they are yelling their lyrics in such a loud and annoying way you may not be able to really understand what they are saying”. With that being said hiphop/rap music is very influential but in all of the wrong ways because its corrupting young kids minds making it seem that life is suppose to be like a rap music video , that isnt art its corruption. Portraying gang violence such as wearing colors of said gang,having pants below waist,using gang related words that isn't art it an outbreak of intolerance.…

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Scott's article, "Rap Music and its Violent Progency: America's Culture of Violence in Context” approaches the issue of "rap music as a creative expression and metorphorical offspring of America's well-established culture of violence. Richardson and Scott's point of this article was to answer the question to what the role of rap music is and how it contributes to voilence in society. Richardon and Scott pulled different statistics and data from violence within movies, video games, and music. This artical states, "Violence in music is not by any means limited to rap or gangsta rap. Folk and country music have contained references to murder, killing of police, and domestic violence for decades" (181). The method of the authors was to place rap music in a context that was unusual to the audience, the authors grabbed several different ideas about rap music such as; capitalism and rap, political and judicial scrutiny of rap, rap in the scholorly literature, rap within cultural capital and social reproduction, violence in rap music and overal rap musics effects on the culture. The authors did not exaclty answer their research question, they merely just implemented different ideas about violence and rap in order to increase the audiences knowledge on the given subject. The authors arrived to the conclusion that "[r]ap music has drawn attention to the subjugated life and senseless violence the mainstream culture attempts to…

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Rap Music Controversy

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This article elaborates on the negative effects of Rap Music on the minds of young people. In a specific example, Too Short, a rapper well-known for his degrading music, is chastised for promoting sexual assault to woman among middle school aged boys. He profusely apologizes for his behaviour and uses…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gun Laws Must Be Enforced

    • 1811 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Herd, D. (2009, Spring). Changing images of Violence in Rap music. Journal of Public Health, 30(4), 395-406 12p. EBSCOhost.…

    • 1811 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hip Hop Satire

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Hip hop serves as a form of unity and a crutch for some. Kids tend to always be looking for an adult figure in their life. Some have many others have none, but just about all look up to those in media. Rappers are a part of a multi-billion dollar industry their reach stretches from clothing to cars. Rappers tend to be that adult figure in most urban communities. These kids look up to see their favourite music stars are like themselves. Popular rap star Kendrick Lamar grew up in Compton, one of Americas worst hoods. Now he is a huge star and has fame and fortune. The youth in situations like this see him as a form of inspiration. They aspire to be great like their favourite hip hop stars; they want to pull themselves out of the ghetto. This impact on youth is a great positive for the genre, and a great story for it to. For some the music that they can identify with the most is a way for other to connect. Much like people connect through sports or other interests, hip hop serves as the same tool. Friendships form through these social bonds provided by the music of this genre. With the formation of these friendships they often lead to positive results. For example Taylor and Taylor note that “Early hip hop has often been credited with helping to reduce inner-city gang violence by replacing physical violence with dance and artwork battles.”(qtd About Hip Hop Youth Subculture, 1) These outlets and groups help in reducing violence and instead promote creativity. Music of any genre is a form on entertainment. Rap is no different; these kids are escaping into the world of music. With these kids staying away from gangs and violence they are more likely to grow up to be functioning members of society. While the rap stars are not the sole reason for this they are definitely a part of the solution as opposed to the problem. There are many examples of rap artists helping the youth in a community whether its “Drake and P Reign playing…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Violence In Rap Music

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The association of violence with alcohol also increased, but the relationship was not as pronounced as that with drugs, Explanations for the rise of gangster rap and violence in rap music have tended to focus on two basic themes. Representatives from the music and other media industries have argued that media violence is a reflection of actual social trends. Echoing this perspective, some scholars have focused on the structural conditions – oppressive economic and social conditions, the crack cocaine drug trade and ensuing drug war, and high levels of police brutality – within urban ghettos that promote violent themes in rap music. Within this framework, other writers have focused on the violent lifestyles of major rap artists as an explanation for the rising tide of violence in the…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Music Lyrics being NON-VIOLENT Rap music can be considered a style of art, and a way for the artists to express feelings through their words on paper. However, there are quite a few rap artists that get criticized for their lyrics. In my essay, I want to discuss why rappers use certain lyrics in their music and why people shouldn’t believe that it causes violence among the younger generations. People shouldn’t censor the music just because of violent, vulgar and abusive messages it promotes to the world. I believe in my own mind, that there is a reason for these types of lyrics that rap artists use and I will simply explain those reasons in this essay. Rap has been called one of the most important music forces to emerge in two decades. It’s pounding beats and staccato rhymes exploded on the streets of the urban America in the early 1980s and since have become the theme music and lyrical heart of the vibrant youth culture called hip-hop ( SIRS 1993). There are many different types of rap artist. There are some that talk about money, some talk about righteousness, and the list goes on and on. Every rap artist had their own way of expressing themselves. There are those that talk about sex, drugs, and violence who receive the negative attention( SIRS 1993). People, think this so- called gangster rap is a bad influence on children in the world and that it promotes violence and that it also is abusive to women. Delores Tucker, head of national congress of black women has been among those pressuring different record companies to stop distributing gangster rap music. There were other significant names that participated in this action. Names like Senate Majority leader Bob dole, and former education Secretary William J. Bennett(Surveys, pg. 1). There are some rap artists that have been openly criticized for their lyrics. Rappers like Lil Kim, Too Short, Snoop Doggy Dogg, and a member from “Too Live Crew,” named Luke Skywalker. These rap artists in the past have been…

    • 1708 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gangster Rap And Crime

    • 126 Words
    • 1 Page

    One of the biggest debates is over the relationship between gangster rap and crime. Many believe that gangster rap glorifies and encourages criminal behavior, but those that are in support of the music, argue that the problem of crime has nothing to do with gangster music, that it is the result of poverty, and the lack of opportunity. It is also believed that blaming rap music is only a way to stir up unwarranted moral panic, causing people to look at the music through a racially charged lens. Creating stereotypes of young black males as being criminals and dangerous Stereotypes and assumptions are bad enough when they lead to moral panics over rap music, but they could also lead to the death of young black…

    • 126 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Alisa Valdes Rodriguez, a writer for the Los Angeles Times, appeals to her reader’s emotions in a manipulative way, resulting in a convincing argument about holding the music industry responsible for violence against women. She wrote an article titled “Is Music Issuing a Call to Violence?”. According to Ms. Rodriguez, misogynistic music in pop culture is considered one of the major culprits in glorifying abuse and violence towards women. She highlights examples such as the sexual assaults that happened in Central Park and her own personal experience when a young man acted aggressive towards her on the subway reciting rap lyrics. Racial stereotypes are brought up to explain why sexism is being shrugged off and not take seriously with her saying “I also honestly believe lots of people in the U.S. still believe black and brown men are somehow innately more barbaric than other men, and so excuse these lyrics as artistic expression of creatures from another universe”. She cites other examples and details as well which leads to her to put the blame on the music industry.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays