Preview

Quebec: Distinct Society

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1483 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Quebec: Distinct Society
Quebec: A Distinct Society (?)

The concept of recognizing Quebec as a distinct society is an idea that has been kicking around for some time, but just what does it mean and what are its broader implications? This paper will examine the origins of the term, what it means, and its historical context. It will then examine rival interpretations of federalism. The essay will conclude with an in-depth examination of the concept's involvement with the failed constitutional accords and the failed Quebec succession attempts.

The term "distinct society" was a political notion used during constitutional debates during the Meech Lake accord and the Charlottetown accord. Its meaning is somewhat vague and controversial. In essence, it refers to the uniqueness of Quebec, in particular the uniqueness of Quebec's language, laws and culture. Given Quebec's language, laws and culture, it's difficult to argue that Quebec isn't a unique province within Canada, but by making a constitutional amendment to recognize Quebec as such, the dynamics of federalism would be dramatically different. Canada would become an asymmetrical Federation.

History
The origin of Quebec's distinct laws goes back to the conquest of 1760. Following the victory of the British, Common law was established under the Royal Proclamation of 1763. Special provisions were granted to Quebec. The Quebec Act of 1774 allowed Quebec the free exercise of the Roman Catholic religion, including the right of the Church to collect tithes; recognized the seigneurial system; and established that civil suits would be tried under French civil law and criminal cases would be tried under British common law. In Addition the act provided for an appointed legislative council that would include both French- and English-speaking members. Over time, however, tensions built up between the French and the English in the colony. The British attempted to reduce tensions by dividing Quebec into the provinces of Upper and Lower Canada



Bibliography: Tremblay, Reeta C., Andre Lecourse, Csaba Nikolenyi, Bassel Salloukh, and Francesca Scala. Mapping the Political Landscape. Toronto: Thomas Nelson, 2004. 284-285. "Separation Anxiety: The 1995 Quebec Referendum". The CBC Digital Archives Website. Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. Last updated: 20 March 2006. . [Accessed 20 June 2006.]

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Libs 7002

    • 9345 Words
    • 38 Pages

    Figure 5 : Average debt of students in the last year of an undergraduate degree (dollars)…

    • 9345 Words
    • 38 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As a part of Quebec’s youth and up and coming younger generation I have witnessed the conflicts between the French- English divide since I could remember and it is important that the needs of both sides are full filled or at least compensated for, future generations need to focus on other issues and need to resolve the French-English divide in a fashionable matter so that both sides can work together and benefit from each other such as the increase of speaking French in schools and businesses. Cleavages are defined as “a politically significant distinction among identifiable groups in a given population” (L7, S5). Language is an important cleavage in Canadian society (L7, S6), Canada is known to being a diverse country the population consists of many different types of people, cultural backgrounds and value systems each of which should be respected and tolerated by every citizen of this country. The English-French divide has persisted over time as a result of events and decisions by governing bodies that have continued to fuel the divide (L7, S7). There are different solutions to the language issue among French and English speakers but it takes time and although the divide has changed a lot, the past 20 years we aren’t where we want to be just yet and it is up to future generations to solve this problem. Further issues such as the compact vs contract theory will be discussed and also in recent news the dispute over the Charter of values the Pauline Marois government seek to put in effect that has sprung up a dispute other issues that will be discussed are Bill 101 and the disputes over the equalization of payments that has become a major topic for discussion and a large part of the French-English division if future generations were to resolve these topics they would be one…

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Brian Mulroney

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Cited: Blake, Raymond Benjamin. Transforming the nation: Canada and Brian Mulroney. Montreal: McGill-Queen 's University Press, 2007.…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Best Essays

    Canadian History Essay

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Today’s relationship between Quebec and the rest of Canada has been relatively steady. Over the years, Québec has certainly developed separately but in association with the rest of Canada. However, without influence from the past, their relationships would not be what it is today. The development of the French and English relationship follows a long and complicated history. Throughout history, tensions between French and English Canada have been evident. Looking back at World War I and II, one of the key issues that divided English and French Canada was conscription. Quebec was against conscription, while English-Canada supported it. However, this is not the only issue that influenced the relationship between Quebec and the rest of Canada. Throughout history, there have been many defining moments which have influenced this relationship. This essay will outline three defining moments. The first one is ‘the October crisis’, which caused a national sense of crisis when a French separatist group kidnapped 2 government officials. Then, the passing of Bill 101 which brought a controversy both inside and outside of Quebec. And thirdly, ‘The Constitution of 1982’ which changed the contract that linked Quebec to the rest of Canada. These three defining moments have greatly helped to establish the character of the relationship between Quebec and the rest of Canada.…

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Van, Die Marguerite. Religion and Public Life in Canada: Historical and Comparative Perspectives. Toronto: University of Toronto, 2001. Print.…

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sst 1 Task 1 Wgu

    • 2714 Words
    • 11 Pages

    While there are many nation-states in the world there are also nations which are not states. One of these nations would be Quebec. While they are actually part of Canada they are now officially recognized as a nation. The House of Commons in Canada passed the motion to recognize Quebec as a nation inside of Canada in 2006. Quebec has a different culture than the rest of Canada. They are predominately a French speaking people and have various views that differ from the rest of Canada. It is this different type of common culture inside of the Quebec region that has caused Canada to recognize them as a nation inside of their country. (House passes motion recognizing Québécois as nation, 2006)…

    • 2714 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The issue of what form this self-government should take still remains. In line with the relationship established by the Royal Proclamation, Aboriginal self-government should reflect the national characteristic of the Aboriginal peoples. A dual system of federalism, where there are two sets of Confederations (a British North American Confederation and a Treaty federalism), both existing within the same territory is the best solution for self-government in this context. “… [A] ‘treaty’ relationship … means that … relations among sovereign nations are based on diplomatic agreements … not on majority decisions… There is no central government but only negotiated and contractual agreement among governments.” (Abele and Prince 2006, 682) Dual Federalism recognizes the equality between Canada and the…

    • 1638 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Meech Lake accord and Charlottetown Accord can be defined as attempts of Canadian government to make Quebec rejoin the Canadian Constitutional family. P.M Brian Mulrooney wanted that Quebec should symbolically rejoin the Canadian Constitutional family. Therefore, the new premier of Quebec, Robert Bourassa, was asked to outline conditions for such reunion. Mulrooney and premiers met at Meech Lake in April 1987 and agreed on a document that addressed Quebec’s demand and was known as Meech Lake Accord. Prior to this accord government of Quebec “opted out” of the new Charter Of Rights to maximum extend possible under sec. 33 by introducing a “notwithstanding clause” into each of its existing statutes and into every newly acted statues. In addition, the government also refused to participate in new constitutional amendments. Quebec’s this behavior was the result of curbing of its powers by Charter of Rights. Quebec government announced five conditions, these were: (i) Constitutional recognition of Quebec as a “distinct society”. (ii) A veto on constitutional amendments. (iii) Increased jurisdiction over immigration. (iv) participation in Supreme Court appointments. (v) Financial compensation when Quebec opted out of national programs set by Ottawa within provincial jurisdiction. In 1991 a new set of ambitious negotiations began and it was believed that these negotiations would cure everybody’s constitutional discontent as well as Quebec’s. In 1992 the eleven first ministers reached an agreement at Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island. The Charlottetown Accord included all the elements of Meech LakeAccord, and much else besides. For example, regarding the division of legislative powers, it provided for exclusive provincial jurisdiction over forestry, mining and some other areas. It had four main parts : Canada Clause, a Triple-E senate, Aboriginal self-government, and changes to division of powers. The "Canada Clause" set out the values that define the…

    • 2004 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Meech Lake Accord

    • 3685 Words
    • 15 Pages

    To understand why the Meech Lake Accord failed, one must examine the evolution of the Accord as a constitutional amendment and why its creation was necessary in the first place. The necessity of a constitutional amendment was guaranteed in April 1982, when Queen Elizabeth II signed into law the Constitution Act, 1982. The new Canadian Constitution, which ended Canada’s colonial status with Britain[2], was seen as a great achievement for both the country and its Prime Minister, Pierre Trudeau. However, it was destined to create conflict and division within Canada, as it had been signed despite the strenuous opposition of the government of Quebec. The Parti Quebecois, in power in Quebec during the constitutional negotiations of the early 1980s, possessed a mandate of bringing sovereignty to the province. Failing that, the goal of the PQ was to define the province of Quebec as “distinct” from the rest of Canada. As such, signing legislation which would not only strengthen ties with Canada but make Quebec equal to every other Canadian province was simply out of the question. Prime Minister Trudeau, a fervent believer in provincial equality for the sake of a united nation, pushed ahead with the…

    • 3685 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    There was also a void in Nova Scotia in the context of nationalist identity. Nova Scotians did not real feel a sense of nationalism, in the sense that they wanted to stand up for “their rights.” More than anything else, they wanted to stay out of international…

    • 2296 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Stamp Act Apush

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Roman Catholic religion that was granted toleration in the trans-Allegheny West by the Quebec Act, arousing deep colonial hostility…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Prime Minister Mulroney had the Father of Confederations words, "Whatever you do, adhere to the Union. We are a great country, and shall become one of the greatest in the universe if we preserve it; we shall sink into insignificance and adversity if we suffer it to be broken”,[1] in mind when he proposed the accords to reconcile with Quebec after Quebec was stabbed in the back during the "Night of the Long Knives", where Quebec was left out of the discussion where other provinces reached an agreement on a process for patriating and amending the constitution.(2:)…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On The Flq Crisis

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Thesis: The October crisis was a significant event in Canadian history that depicted the conflict between Quebec and Canada, and the different views that Quebecers and English Canada had. This crisis dep…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    How did the Francophones get their rights? It all started in 1608 when Samuel de Champlain founded the city of Quebec; one hundred and sixty-six years later Britain passed the Quebec Act. Lord Guy Carleton was largely responsible for the Quebec Act. The Quebec Act did many things for Francophones in Quebec, it enlarged the boundaries of the province of Quebec to include Labrador, Mississippi and Ohio rivers on the west and the Aboriginal territory south of the Great Lakes. The Quebec Act also helped preserve French law and culture through religious freedom for the Roman Catholic majority and through restoring French civil law and British criminal law. Restoring those laws enabled the continued use of the seigneurial system which was used as…

    • 196 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    woman

    • 3293 Words
    • 14 Pages

    "Women & Canadian Elections." Women & Canadian Elections. Simon Fraser University, 2011. Web. 03 Feb. 2014.…

    • 3293 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics