Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Psych Research Paper on Article

Good Essays
1422 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Psych Research Paper on Article
Paper on article
Done for Intro to Psychology

IQ And Mathematical Learning
In the article Motivation, Not IQ, Matters Most for Learning New Math Skills, psychologists study math abilities and habits of thirty-five hundred German students from the fifth to tenth grade. Students’ mathematical abilities were evaluated each year using standardized testing. In addition to this students were given an IQ test and surveys that questioned about their attitudes toward math. As the title of this report suggests they found that IQ was not the main determining factor in how well the student’s math abilities grew. Instead IQ was found to be a predictor of initial math skill and studying and motivation where found to be predictors of growth in mathematical abilities. These findings came as a surprise to the researchers who predicted that intelligence measured by IQ would be a strong predictor of mathematical abilities. This article encompasses the main findings of the researchers into a summarization of their findings. This research in this study is credible and believable but the article leaves out some essential information about the findings that could strengthen or weaken the researcher’s argument and allow the reader to develop their own opinion.
In this study the independent variable is the student’s IQ and the dependent variable is the student’s mathematical scores/abilities. IQ tests have long been used as a system to measure the intelligence of the testee. Standardized mathematical testing is an accurate method of measuring mathematical abilities because it objectively scores each student’s mathematical knowledge in the same way. Due to the standardized nature of the IQ and math tests the student’s scores can be used to compare each other with without causing error. In order to solidify these findings and rule out possible sources of error researchers interviewed students to determine their attitudes and behaviors about math. Specifically they asked to see if the students had a genuine interest in math and what strategies they used to learn to improve their mathematical abilities. This strengthens the researcher’s findings because it helps them rule out outside factors affecting the standardized findings. It would make sense that students with a genuine interest in math would score better than students who did not like math. Depending on these correlations this could help explain or disprove the theory that IQ is not related to math scores.
The sampling size of thirty-five hundred is large enough where sampling error can be ruled out as a potential source of error. A larger sampling size is always better and would minimize any sampling error further, however the current sampling size is sufficient. One problem with the sample though is that it is entirely taken from students from Germany. This weakens the findings because cultural differences cannot be ruled out as a potential source of error. These findings also may be a reflection on the schooling systems in Germany. In order to overcome these shortcomings a larger sample of students could be used that sourced its participants from countries across the world. In order to fully understand these relationships a complete listing of all of the study’s data and findings would need to be provided. This article requires the reader to accept the judgment of the writer, Laura Blue, as fact. At the very least tables and graphs could have been provided in order to help the reader make a personal conclusion about the validity of this research. Independent review, which was not mentioned in this article, could also have helped strengthen the claims of the researchers and the validity of the author’s summarization. This article does not relate itself to any prior psychological theories within its writings. Despite this, this article relates back to theories of intelligence. It could be argued from these findings that theories of multiple intelligences have more merit than theories of one intelligence. This can be argued because it was found that the IQ test scores were not a good predictor of the ability to learn mathematical skills. Behaviorist could argue that this study reinforces that operant conditioning works. This viewpoint would look at working hard as a behavior that is positively reinforced with good grades. A cognitive psychologist can argue that the reward of getting a good grade can serve as an intrinsic or extrinsic motivator for doing well on the tests. A student who genuinely is interested in learning math would be intrinsically motivated and a student who works hard for the grade would be extrinsically motivated. The researchers were able to determine which students where extrinsically and intrinsically motivated based on the questions they answered in the survey.
Psychologists would also argue that these findings reinforce theories of multiple intelligences. This can be argued because IQ was found to not be a predictor of mathematical learning. If there was only one form of intelligence than the IQ test should predict success in all types of skills. This helps to prove that there must be multiple types of intelligence by showing that there is more to learning math than general intelligence.
This also helps to invalidate the IQ test as an accurate method of determining someone’s intelligence. Someone may have a high IQ but be less smart than someone of equal age because the lower IQ person was more motivated and thus tried harder to learn. Robert Sternberg would argue the students good at math have high analytic intelligence and Howard Gardner would argue they have high logical-mathematical intelligence. These findings would also debunk Sir Francis Galton’s belief that intelligence is strictly determined by biological capacity.
The researchers in this study hypothesized that IQ would be a good predictor of people’s abilities to learn and grow. Instead the findings went against this and suggested that hard work and effort had more to do with the growth of mathematical abilities than IQ. This raises questions about the validity of the IQ test as a test of intelligence. The IQ test is not completely invalidated by this research as it was found that IQ was a good determinant of the starting point of student’s mathematical abilities. The findings of this study reinforce the truth in the old saying that, “there is no substitution for hard work”. Because the IQ test was not able to measure all intelligences into one test, this supports that there are other factors that affect people’s abilities to learn and grow. This article was published online by TIME; TIME is widely considered to be a reputable source of news information. The article itself falls short on fully covering the findings of the research. Instead the article gives just enough information to let the reader know what the main findings of the study are. This is fine unless someone wants to look into the article in depth and analyze the data. For example someone wanting to know how student’s interest in math affected the outcomes of the student’s mathematical tests would not be able to determine this from the article. This article does not let the reader form their own opinions instead TIME’s Laura Blue tells you what happened and expects you to take her words as fact. This article is believable in that hard work would help a student learn math more than having a higher IQ. This finding reinforces the nurture viewpoint in the nature vs. nurture argument. Despite having the general findings in the article, the claims cannot fully be evaluated without providing more information. There are too many external variables that could have affected the outcome of this study. For example students who grow up in abusive environments may have a hard time completing school work and thus the abusive environment could be causing error in the findings. This example is an extreme, but in order to be one-hundred percent certain that the study’s findings are true complete data must be provided to account for every variable. Because gathering all of this data to such extreme detail would be very difficult, the research should be deemed sufficient and accurate. Motivation, Not IQ, Matters Most for Learning New Math Skills makes a compelling case that it is truly motivation that effects students study behaviors and thus leads to long term improvement in mathematical abilities. The standardized testing and surveys are good measures of student performance and reasoning. They help the researchers draw strong accurate conclusions about what affects the student’s ability to learn. The article may fall short on providing details of the data but it still presents a strong argument backed with solid data.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Psychology Question Paper

    • 1267 Words
    • 16 Pages

     Do all rough work in this book. Cross through any work you do not want…

    • 1267 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Since the development of the intelligence quotient, schools in every part of the world have been using the IQ test to categorize millions of students into three groups. These three groups, which are the gifted, the average, and the retarded, are falsifications that perpetuate in our world culture and cause many gifted students to be deemed retarded and vice a versa. Why then is the IQ test so heavily relied on in our school systems? For schools the answer is simple, an I.Q. test is a reliable predictor of a students later performance in academics. This answer is relatively true, but where the I.Q. test falls extremely short is with testing the multiple intelligences of the human brain. The intelligence quotient test, developed by Alfred Binet, was created to evaluate ones intelligence with a test that would yield a numerical value that could be compared with a collective average to determine ones level of intelligence. However, the questions of an I.Q. test, or even the SAT 's for that matter, are testing only the verbal-mathematical forms of intelligence. The human brain is extremely complicated and advanced, and to assume that the indicators of intelligence are only found in logical and linguistic intelligences is a poor assumption at best. A more comprehensive test, which can test all seven types of intelligence, should be implemented into the educational system to ensure every student an education tailored to their strongest abilities.…

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Psych 341 Research Paper

    • 2509 Words
    • 9 Pages

    References: Babbage, D. R., & Ronan, K. R. (2000). Philosophical worldview and personality factors in traditional and social scientists: Studying the world in our own image. Personality and Individual Differences. doi:10.1016/S0191-8869(99)00117-8…

    • 2509 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Intellectual Power Paper

    • 1123 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “Intelligence includes the ability to reason abstractly, the ability to profit from experience, and the ability to adapt to varying environmental contexts” (Bee & Boyd, 2012, p. 167). Tests to measure intelligence were first developed in 1905 by Frenchmen, Alfred Binet and Theodore Simon. The purpose of the tests was to measure these abilities to help children who difficulties in school. At that time, the French government began requiring all children to attend school, they wanted to be able to identify those with difficulties. The tests were made to measure skills that children would use in school “including measures of vocabulary, comprehension of facts and relationships, and mathematical and verbal reasoning” (Bee & Boyd, 2012, p. 167). The original tests developed by Binet and Simon were revised in 1916 and 1937 by Lewis Terman while at Stanford University. He wanted to revise the tests for children in the United States, and they were termed the Stanford-Binet tests. There were six different tests for different ages. When taking the test, the child would take the individual tests designed by age until he reached a test that he could not complete. A formula was used to determine the Intelligence Quotient (as known as IQ) of the child based on their scores. Binet and Simon compared the children’s actual chronological age to their “mental age” defined as “the age level of IQ test terms a child could successfully answer” (Bee & Boyd, 2012, p. 168). There have been revisions over the years in how IQ scores are calculated and today they are calculated by comparing a child’s score with that of children of the same age. There has been a need for changes in computing IQ scores because IQ scores have increased gradually over the last five decades. If a child today were to take the tests given in the early 1930s, he would score higher than the average of 100.…

    • 1123 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Best Essays

    It is crucial to develop in children the ability to tackle problems with initiative and confidence…mathematics has changed from careful rehearsal of standard procedures to a focus on mathematical thinking and communication to prepare them for the world of tomorrow (Anghileri, 2006, p.2).…

    • 1585 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Developing mathematical thinking from an early age is extremely important in establishing students understanding of number concepts. Clements (2001, p271) concludes that children “are self-motivated to investigate patterns, shapes, measurement, the meaning of numbers, and how numbers work, but they need assistance to bring these ideas to an explicit level of awareness.” Children learn mathematical ways of thinking, such as counting, subitising and patterning from a young age. The absence of mathematical understanding and ways of thinking, restricts children from grasping the concepts and processes they are learning. Booker et al. (2010) says children who lack early mathematical thinking are unable to link ideas and instead are provided with the skills of obtaining answers in unrelated ways. Developing mathematical thinking from a young age provides a meaningful basis for children to make connections between the full range of mathematical concepts (Booker et al., 2010).…

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The treatment method used will depend on the individual situation of the adolescent. Whereas one treatment may be effective for one child, it may not be effective, at all, for another. There are behavioral treatments, family interventions and even medications. There should be an extensive interview with a qualified substance abuse professional to determine which treatment would best fulfill the child’s needs.…

    • 1090 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    For this assignment I will describe two theories of mathematical development. I will discuss Jean Piaget’s and Tina Bruce’s theories about how children’s understandings of mathematical develop.…

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    General Psychology

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages

    An intelligence test is a test designed to determine the relative mental capacity of a person, standardized tests are used to establish an intelligence level rating by measuring a student’s ability to form concepts, solve problems, acquire information, reason, and perform other intellectual operations. “Although intelligence, like thinking, cannot be directly seen or touched, psychologists tie the concept to achievements such as school performance and occupational status” (Rathus, 174).…

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    WHAT IS RESEARCH AT LEAST 4 PEER REVIEW JOURNALS. {text:list-item} {text:list-item} {text:list-item} {text:list-item} {text:list-item} {text:list-item} {text:list-item} {text:list-item} Write about ANGER Do not put a www. Or going to a government website to get statistics. It must be peer reviewed. WHY NOT??? The case of Cheryl and the Internet PEER REVIEWED JOURNALS No pictures, a lot of statistics. Formal in format Sources are cited with footnotes or bibliography at the end of the article. Authors are scholars and researchers in the field and are identified as such. Purpose of the article is to publish the results of research. TABS CHOOSE ACADEMICS CHOOSE LIBRARY EBSCOHOST {text:list-item} CLICK ON EBSCOHOST GOOD RESEARCH IS ABOUT 2 YEARS OLD AND SHOULD BE FAIRLY CURRENT ONCE INTO EBSCO HOST SELECT NEW SERVICE EBSCOHOST PERIODICAL DATABASES CHECK PSYCHOLOGY AND BEHAVIORAL SCIENCE COLLECTION NO OTHER CHECKS Refine your search SCHOLARLY (PEER REVIEWED) JOURNALS!!! Write your paper in APA format. Research 1 Running Head: Research Paper Research Papers: How to Turvive the Torture Joseph Curiel Antelope Valley College Research 2 Abstract The abstract should be a single paragraph in block format (no paragraph indentations). It should not exceed 120 words. The abstract is simply a summary of the paper. One trick to writing an abstract is to write one summary sentence for each major part of the paper. Research 3 Research Papers: How to Survive the Torture APA STYLE WRITING WHAT IS A GOOD PAPER? Stories about Aunt Mildred… Sentences that start with “I’ ..Slang language Opinions… ETC! Have a lot of parenthetical citations. (Cite where you obtained the information) in parenthesis… (Vangilder,…

    • 284 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cross cultural psychology has advanced in the past years. Cross-cultural psychology is the scientific study of human behavior and mental process including both their variability and invariance, under diverse cultural conditions. The research article that I have chosen to review is Breugelmans, S.M., Chasiotis, A., Vijver, F. (2011). Fundamental Questions in Cross-cultural Psychology. Cambridge University Press.…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Hong, E. & Aqui, Y. Cognitive and Motivational Characteristics of Adolescents Gifted in Mathematics: Comparisons Among Students with Different Types of Giftedness The Gifted Child Quarterly Vol. 48, No. 3, 2004, pp. 191…

    • 2047 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    SELF ESTIMATED IQ

    • 3112 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Byrd, M. & Stacey, B. (1993) 'Bias in IQ perception '. The Psychologist, 6, pp. 16.…

    • 3112 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In fact, research suggests that this public perception does not reflect reality. Most individuals with psychiatric disorders…

    • 2493 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lovely Iq

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Solving many of the IQ Test's problems required the ability to add, subtract, multiply, and divide numbers mentally. Many mental tasks require arithmetical operations even though numbers may not be involved, and thus number manipulation abilities can strongly indicate general intelligence.…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays