Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Outline the Concepts Made by Clarke and Critcher (1995) of ‘Material and Cultural' (Clarke, J. and Critcher, C. ‘Leisure and Inequality' in C. Critcher Et.Al., 1995, Sociology of Leisure: a Reader. London: E+Fn Spon, P247) Constraints to Leisure

Powerful Essays
1380 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Outline the Concepts Made by Clarke and Critcher (1995) of ‘Material and Cultural' (Clarke, J. and Critcher, C. ‘Leisure and Inequality' in C. Critcher Et.Al., 1995, Sociology of Leisure: a Reader. London: E+Fn Spon, P247) Constraints to Leisure
This essay will have three sections. The first section will briefly outline the concepts made by Clarke and Critcher (1995) of ‘material and cultural ' (Clarke, J. and Critcher, C. ‘Leisure and Inequality ' in C. Critcher et.al.,1995, Sociology of Leisure: A Reader. London: E+FN Spon, p247) constraints to leisure. The concepts shall be detailed, and briefly explained and elaborated. The second section will illustrate these concepts by relating them to a article by Green, E., Hebron, S. and Woodwood, D (1990). This article recognises that gender is a key dimension in both the public and private spheres of leisure. This shall be further supplemented with other sources that also highlight gender differences, and supports Clarke and Critcher 's (1995) concepts. The final section will reflect upon factors that have enabled or constrained my own leisure experiences.

John Clarke and Chas Critcher (1995) argue that there is an ‘inequality of leisure opportunity ' (ibid., p247), and that this is made up of two aspects they term ‘material and cultural '(ibid., p247). They describe the material aspect as being the ‘access to key resources ' (ibid., p248), these include time and money. This material aspect can be described as a constraint to leisure, because simply if you do not process the time you cannot have or gain the leisure, it is a constraint preventing your leisure from occurring. Clarke and Critcher (1995) argue that the cultural aspect of the inequality of leisure is the perception of what is ‘appropriate leisure behaviour ' (ibid., p248) for a member of a particular social group. These perceptions are socially constructed, and may be based on a number of factors, gender stereotype for example. They are crucially held by people in a position to enforce these expectations. This cultural constraint can be described as a constraint through leisure as it is reflecting and perpetuating the inequalities present in society, and acts as a further agent for social division. Therefore leisure could be seen as a mirror, echoing societies inequalities. However, Clarke and Critcher (1995) also note, that leisure does more than reflect social divisions, it realises them, so that leisure becomes one of the means by which social divisions receive expression and validation.

There are many factors that influence leisure, and these all lead to further ‘inequality of leisure opportunity ' (ibid., p247) as Clarke and Critcher (1995) described. These factors may be class, race and gender among others. They often appear together and intersect, as there is no one primary influence on leisure. For this argument, gender is a key dimension in understanding the form and inequalities in leisure, it can also be used to illustrate Clarke and Critcher 's (1995) material and cultural constraints. But first it is crucial to describe what is gender?
Gender is defined as the cultural and social aspect of sexuality. Gender differences are important at the level of personal identity, and more broadly as a base of social classification and differentiation, so it is not surprisingly it affects leisure as well.
(Harris, D., 2005, Key Concepts in Leisure Studies, Sage: London, p125)
As Harris (2005) describes gender is seen as being socially constructed and can play a crucial role in shaping leisure inequalities, as it does social inequalities. Again we see leisure as a mirror for society. So with gender defined we can move on to the Green, E., Hebron, S. and Woodwood, D 's (1990) article. In this article there are numerous examples of where Clarke and Critcher 's (1995) concepts are illustrated and supported. In their article Green, E., Hebron, S. and Woodwood, D (1990) interviewed wives and mothers, a key finding from the respondents was that they ‘never had sufficient time to clean and polish. ' (Green, E. et.al., 1990, Women 's Leisure, What Leisure?, London: MacMillan, p117) If they had insufficient time to clean and tidy how would it be possible to participant in leisure activities, this is a clear example of a material constraint to leisure, lack of time. This was found to be true of most wives and mothers. This is not only an example of a material constraint, if explored further a cultural constraint becomes evident. ‘Tiredness associated with the burden of unpaid domestic work which they are expected to assume. ' (ibid., p117) The cultural constraint that is illustrated here is that society expects the ‘wife ' to take on and complete the domestic work. This has arisen from gender stereotypes that were created centuries ago, where men were seen as the ‘bread winners ', going out to paid work, the ‘hunters ', in contrast the women stayed at home and ‘cooked ' and acted as a ‘good wife '. The article shows that these stereotypes are very evident today. The article goes on to discuss the link between gender and drinking, and in particular the limits of ‘decent ' behaviour.
‘Traditionally female activities that accord with ideologies of femininity (such as aerobics, keep fit, flower arranging and coffee mornings) are approved and deemed acceptable, others, such as a night out on the town visiting pubs or discos unaccompanied by male partners, are not '. (ibid., p121)
This quote again demonstrates a cultural constraint for women 's leisure, because activities that correspondent and agree with the concepts of femininity are acceptable, those that do not are frowned upon. There are a seemingly endless number of examples of material and cultural constraints to leisure surrounding the concept of gender. Ranging from the material, lack of funds, to the cultural, women ‘worried about being alone after dark ' (Green, E., Hebron, S. and Woodward, D. ‘Women 's Leisure Today ' in C. Critcher et.al.,1995, Sociology of Leisure: A Reader. London: E+FN Spon, p135) there is such an array of factors contributing to the ‘inequality of leisure opportunity '. (ibid., p247)

I myself have experienced both directly and indirectly material and cultural constraints to leisure. During my A-levels, my peers and I would find time to play five-aside football at the local sports arena at the weekend. It may have only been an hour but it was welcome relief from the pressures of school. However it was not cheap, and as students some of us struggled to afford it, this material constraint lead to some weeks not having enough to play, so we all missed out. Time became a second material constraint as A-level examinations loomed, and the revision timetable seemed to engulf our lives. Through five-aside football I also was indirectly exposed to cultural constraints of leisure; ‘racism came in the form of chanting, banana throwing, monkey chanting and songs.` (Cyrille Regis, 1998 quoted in Garland, G. and Rowe, M., 2001, Racism and Anti-Racism in Football, Hampshire: Palgrave, p5) One of my black friends suffered racial abuse when we played, from a small number of spectators. On one occasion it became so severer he walked of the pitch. This cultural constraint should not have prevented him from participating. I witnessed a second example of a cultural constraint again whilst playing football. A female friend expressed her desire to play, however it was laughed of by my male peers ‘a girl cannot play footy '. Of course there was no reason why she could not join in, she was just as skilful, even more so than many of the males, admittedly she may not have been as strong but there was no real reason. Except perhaps male pride, a girl could not be seen to be better at football, a sport that encapsulates all that is masculine. It also highlights the male dominance of the sport, and also of the public sphere. This was another example where a woman was forced to take the back seat.
Word Count 898 – minus quotations and referencing
BIBLIOGRAPHY
PRIMARY SOURCES:
Clarke, J. and Critcher, C. ‘Leisure and Inequality ' in Critcher, C., Bramham, P. and Tomilinson, A., 1995, Sociology of Leisure: A Reader. London: E+FN Spon

Green, E., Hebron, S. and Woodward, D. ‘Women 's Leisure Today ' in Critcher, C., Bramham, P. and Tomilinson, A., 1995, Sociology of Leisure: A Reader. London: E+FN Spon
Green, E., Hebron, S. and Woodward, D. 1990, Women 's Leisure, What Leisure?, London: MacMillan
Harris, D., 2005, Key Concepts in Leisure Studies, London: Sage
Garland, G. and Rowe, M., 2001, Racism and Anti-Racism in Football, Hampshire: Palgrave

Bibliography: PRIMARY SOURCES: Clarke, J. and Critcher, C. ‘Leisure and Inequality ' in Critcher, C., Bramham, P. and Tomilinson, A., 1995, Sociology of Leisure: A Reader. London: E+FN Spon Green, E., Hebron, S. and Woodward, D. ‘Women 's Leisure Today ' in Critcher, C., Bramham, P. and Tomilinson, A., 1995, Sociology of Leisure: A Reader. London: E+FN Spon Green, E., Hebron, S. and Woodward, D. 1990, Women 's Leisure, What Leisure?, London: MacMillan Harris, D., 2005, Key Concepts in Leisure Studies, London: Sage Garland, G. and Rowe, M., 2001, Racism and Anti-Racism in Football, Hampshire: Palgrave

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Throughout the history of Western civilization, evolution of leisure has been linked to societal and political changes as well as to technological advancements. Aristotle defines leisure as “a state of being in which activity is performed for its own sake or as its own end” (Grazia p.13). The Greeks came up with the concept of leisure. They believed that a state could not flourish without leisure. Aristotle says, “The life of leisure was the only life fit for a Greek”(pg.19). The Greeks found leisure in ways such as music and contemplation. They believed that music gave way to other activities such as poetry, dance, and gymnastics.…

    • 3286 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cheap Amusements

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “Among working women, leisure came to be seen as a separate sphere of life to be consciously protected” (40). Kathy Peiss’s book, Cheap Amusements, was about women’s roles at the turn of the century in New York. Her main idea was that working women at the turn of the century were trying to create more leisure time and autonomy despite the stereotypes that came with some of this newfound independence. The “Old World” role of women was changing because of economic pressures from industrialization. Commercialization of amusement helped create more opportunities for women’s leisure. Some of the key themes in her book are autonomy, oppression and dependence, and sexuality.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    ways that leisure time is spent by women has indeed benefited them in both the workplace and at home. This position requires a closer look at specific leisure activities; where and with whom they are spent, and the ultimate effect that these activities had on society and gender roles. More significantly however, is how the establishment of leisure activities for women came about, rather than the simple change in availability of such activities. First let s look at Peiss s position on the matter of how cheap amusements challenged gender traditions in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.…

    • 1836 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The meaning of leisure is widely investigated by both Chinese and Westerners. Since culture between Chinese and Western are different, the ideas towards the meaning of leisure are diverse.…

    • 416 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Leisure Essay

    • 2460 Words
    • 10 Pages

    References: Aguiar, M. (2006). Measuring trends in leisure: The allocation of time over five decades. Cambridge, Massachusetts: National Bureau of Economic Research. http://www.nber.org.ezproxy.library.yorku.ca/papers/w12082…

    • 2460 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    AHSC 20Assignment

    • 5029 Words
    • 20 Pages

    Bibliography: Hopp, Robert. "Recreation and Leisure in Canada." eConcordia. 2009. Concordia University, Web. 10 Nov 2009.…

    • 5029 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Recreation, from an individual perspective, involves as an example, watching television, attending an opera, base jumping, mowing the lawn, taking your children to the zoo, playing checkers, downloading music, writing a book, an evening on the town, going to the mall, or whatever one chooses to make it. Theorists even struggle to agree on what to call these types of experiences. Is it recreation, leisure, free time, available time, creativity, selfishness, or hedonism? One’s own perceptions are important in the defining of leisure and recreation that researchers continue to argue its meaning to society, individuals, and culture. According to “The Mall as Disneyland” article it states that “More than twenty years ago, when Edward Tauber insightfully stated that “not all shopping motives, by any means, are even related to the product, he introduced the concept of “sociorecreational shopping.” Several very revealing articles over the last dozen of more years have shown that shopping centers are important places of social interaction where people may wind up meeting future spouses and friends; where families go simply to stroll, to see people and to be seen by them; where young people go to “hang out” and socialize”…

    • 1527 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    My main reference point while gathering background information was, naturally, Thorstein Veblen’s book "The Theory of the Leisure Class". Written in 1899, “Theory” is a socio-economic work that discusses a so-called “Leisure class”, and its relation to the working class and social stratification. According to this sociological theory, Veblen believes there is a separate working and leisure…

    • 2780 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Cantelon, H., Hollands, R., Metcalfe, A., Tomlinson, A. 1988. Leisure, Sport and Working Class Cultures. Garamond Press. Toronto, Ontario.…

    • 2658 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Leisure is a complex subject, which is part of our day-to-day life. The word ‘leisure’ comes from the Latin word ‘licere’, which means ‘to be free’. Along time, specialists tried to find a suitable definition, but they faced several difficulties because ‘one person’s ‘leisure’ may be another person’s ‘work’!’ (Haworth, 1997, p. 1). According to Webster’s Revised Unabridged Dictionary, leisure is ‘freedom from…

    • 2284 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    A women in the Victorian age who does not have to work is a status symbol for husband and family. The more well-off a family and the greater its economic success are deciding factors in how much leisure…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nowadays, gambling industry is already become a huge global industry. Due to the rapid development of technology, people can place the bet in another country simply by using internet without travel, which make much easier for gambler. According to Roberts (2004, p168), gambling also become one of the leisure industries, such as visit a casino can be seen as a leisure activity. Also is different personal perspective with no doubt. Devereaux (1968) defined that ‘gambling is a form of activity in which the parties involved, who are known as bettors or players, voluntarily engage to make the transfer of money, or something else of value among themselves’. Since colonization in 1788, the culture of gambling includes legal and illegal has prospered in Australia (Rowe & Lawrence 1998 p40). O’Hara (1988) has examined a wild range history of gambling in Australia and well documented the growth of gambling into a major national industry. Based on freedom of choice, must be enjoyable and intrinsically motivating, leisure should be always positive as a main premise. Besides, good leisure should be socially acceptable which is good for personal and does not have negative impact on other people. But in reality, there are many forms of ‘deviant leisure’ exist, such as gambling has certainly been in people shadier uses of leisure. In finding Rojek (1999) there usually are 3 forms of the dark side of leisure, self-indulgent, self-destructive and exploitive. Therefore, gambling is not a good leisure but an acceptable form of leisure unless it is illegal. However, there is no distinct evidence shows that gambling has brought up the life quality of people as a leisure activity. So, a question raised here whether gambling is an acceptable form of leisure or not, it is always been arguable. This essay will focus on whether gambling is an acceptable form of leisure, here are two sides which gambling is more affected by the strength of…

    • 1986 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Leisure Activities

    • 1513 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Brajsa-Zganec, A, Merkas, M, Sverko, I 2010, ‘Quality of Life and Leisure Activities: How do leisure Activities Contribute to subjective WELL-Being’, Social Indicators Research, vol.102, no.1, pp.81-91, viewed 13 December 2011, Springer database, DOI 10.1007/s11205-010-9724-2.…

    • 1513 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The purpose of this paper is to identify, explain and appraise Thorstein Veblen theses in “The Theory of the Leisure Class” (henceforth, referred to as TLC). Furthermore, this paper will discuss wether leisure class being too conservative and hinder the development of the society. To begin with, in order to identify TLC, it is essential to define what Veblen means of “leisure class” in the book. As Veblen said in TCL, “The leisure class as a whole comprises the noble and the priestly classes, together with much of their retinue.” Leisure classes can be defined by occupations and they all share the same economic feature of not being industrial (Veblen 1899). On the other word, this group of leisure class people usually would not produce tangible goods or any other goods, which have intrinsic worth. (The intrinsic worth in this content refers to produce a tangible unit by themselves) This group of people can be a ruler, warrior, priest or wealthy entrepreneur nowadays. One interesting characteristics of this leisure class is it exists when the society accumulates sufficient or excess amount of goods to support a group of “non-productive” people, which in this case, the leisure class. In the history of evolution, human race is the only living creature in the earth that does not required to compete with other species to struggle for a room to live. However, this does not mean we do not need to face any competition throughout our life. Everyone in the society or within their community needs to face the competition with their peers. On the other word, people are competing with each other in the society. But how does this related to the leisure class?…

    • 2294 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    * Akrofi, J. 2006, Recreation and Tourism: Impacts of Tourism: Socio cultural aspects: Ethical Issues, retrieved on May 04, 2011 accessed [02/05/2011]…

    • 3328 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics