Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Outline and assess feminist explanations for the relationship between gender and victimisation.

Better Essays
1223 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Outline and assess feminist explanations for the relationship between gender and victimisation.
Outline and assess feminist explanations for the relationship between gender and victimisation.

Official crime statistics show that males are four times more likely to commit crimes than females. Victim surveys show women to be more likely to be victims of sexual and violent assaults than males. It has also been suggested there are gender differences in punishments.

Radical feminists such as Heidensohn claim that women’s lower crime rates can be explained in terms of patriarchy. She claims that both in the private sphere (family) and public sphere (work and leisure) men exert power and social control over women. Heidensohn describes domesticity as ‘a form of detention’; the endless hours spent on housework and the constant monitoring of young children in the family leave little time for illegal activities. Women who challenge the traditional roles of women within the family run the risk of having them imposed by force. In public, women are controlled by the male use of force and violence, by the idea of holding on to a ‘good’ reputation, and by the ‘ideology of separate spheres’. Women often choose not to go out into public places because of the fear of being attacked or raped. Heidensohn argues that the consequence of this control is that women have fewer opportunities to commit crime and acts of deviance whereas men have more opportunity.

However, many of Heidensohn’s arguments are based upon generalisations, some of which don’t apply to all women. She doesn’t always support her claims with strong empirical evidence. Furthermore, she admits that many of the empirical tests of control theory have been carried out on juvenile offenders rather than adults, and that control theory does sometimes portray women as being passive victims. Yet, Heidensohn does present a plausible explanation of why such a gap remains between men’s and women’s crime rates. In doing so she highlights some of the inequalities that remain between men and women. Also, Dobash and Dobash support the view that domestic violence is a product of patriarchal control, as they found that domestic violence was often triggered off by husbands’ perception that his wife was not always carrying out her ‘duties’ thus suggesting women are victims of this violence because of patriarchy thereby giving validity to radical feminist ideas. However, Panorama’s research into violent women would suggest that violent crime is in fact a significant and growing problem amongst females (e.g. girl gangs and female domestic abusers) thus suggesting the validity of radical feminist theories must be questioned. Furthermore, Postmodern feminists would suggest the ideas are dated and don’t take into account the significant changes which have occurred in women’s lives – for example women’s greater access to paid employment – thus suggesting that radical feminist ideas only offer a partial view of gender differences in patterns of offending, victimisation and punishment in contemporary society.

Furthermore, Interactionist feminists reject official crime statistics, seeing them as little more than a social construction. They point out that females are under represented in the statistics and therefore the statistics don’t present an accurate picture of the social distribution of criminality. These feminists share Becker’s idea that the social distribution of crime and deviance is dependant on processes of social interaction between the deviant and powerful agencies of social control. They suggest that females are less likely to be policed and labelled as deviant than males, which is perhaps because of sexism and chivalry within the police. This also has the effect that women are given less severe punishments than males. Chivalry asserts that women are stereotyped as fickle and childlike, and therefore not fully responsible for their criminal behaviour.

Undeniably, interactionist feminist theories have gained support. Campbell found that females were more likely to receive cautions from police than males (who would receive more severe punishments) and Hedderman and Hough claim that female offenders are far less likely than male offenders to receive a custodial sentence for nearly all serious offences. A study by Allen, based upon an examination of crime statistics, found evidence that women sometimes escape prison in very serious cases, where a male may have been expected to receive a prison term. These studies thus give validity to interactionist feminist ideas. On the other hand, however, Box reviewed the data from self-report studies in Britain and the USA and found that, although a few of these studies indicated some leniency towards females, the majority did not thus casting doubt on the chivalry thesis. Also, Marxist feminists would criticise interactionist feminists for ignoring social class. They would point out that selective law is not only tied to gender but also to social class thus suggesting that interactionist feminist theory only offers a partial view of gender differences in patterns of offending, victimisation and punishments.

Otto Pollak agrees that statistics underestimate the extent of female criminality. From an examination of official figures in a number of different countries, he claimed to have identified many findings. First, he assumed that nearly all offences of shoplifting and all criminal abortions were carried out by women, and then asserted that such crimes were likely to come to the attention of the authorities. He also argued that many unreported crimes were committed by female domestic servants. He then went on to say that women’s domestic roles gave them the opportunity to hide crimes such as poisoning relatives and sexually abusing their children. An important factor for why there is an under-recording of female crime, according to Pollack, is that women are particularly adept at hiding their crimes; he attributed this to female biology. Women have become accustomed to deceiving men because traditional taboos prevent women from revealing pain and discomfort resulting from menstruation. Furthermore, women also learn to mislead men during sex; men can’t disguise sexual arousal when they get an erection, whereas women cab take part in sexual intercourse while faking interest and pleasure.

However, Stephen Jones points out that Pollack gave no real evidence that female domestic servants commit many crimes against their employers or that women are better at concealing crimes than men. Jones says: ‘Pollack’s methodology nowadays appears hardly satisfactory: for example, he failed to take account of changes in the law against abortion in several of the countries he studied’. Heidensohn also criticises Pollack, noting that later research indicates that much shoplifting is committed by men. She also comments that ‘concealment of menstruation is by no means universal and changed sexual mores have long since made nonsense of his view as passive, receptive females brooding vengeance’. Heidensohn regards Pollack’s work as being based upon an unsubstantiated stereotypical image of women, and notes his unwillingness to attribute male crime to a biological predisposition to aggression and violence.

In conclusion, it seems that there are many different views of gender differences in patterns of offending, punishment and victimisation. At one end theories accept the crime statistics and offer explanations as to why males are more criminally inclined; however, theorists reject the statistics and give explanations as to why female criminality is under-represented. Yet, it may be all of theories are becoming out-dated, as the equality between men and women has been rising rapidly in recent years and so it may be that the gender differences in rates of offending, punishment and victimisation are becoming diminished.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    It is no secret that gender differences in crime exist; however even with all the theories there is no set reason as to why this is. Kevin Beaver said “In virtually every study ever conducted, males are much more likely than females to engage in violence, aggression, and serious crimes”. There has always been a gap in the amount of crime that men commit compared to women. All crime, aside shoplifting and prostitution, males commit significantly more. With population between the genders being almost exactly 50/50, with females making up 51%, why is there such a clear difference? These are a few theories criminologists came up with to try and explain this phenomenon.…

    • 1291 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Feminist Theory Of Crime

    • 1669 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Previous to the emergence of feminist theories in the 1960’s and 70’s the criminal justice system and studies surrounding it were developed under the assumption that males were the predominate perpetrators and victims of crime- particularly in cases regarding interpersonal violence. Whilst this was and still is true, the number of women being involved in interpersonal crimes is increasing, causing a new wave of interest as to what circumstances a woman finds herself involved in a criminal situation; hence the emergence of feminist theory. Whilst this theory does not aim to dismiss the majority (males) in this form of crime, it acts to elevate the minority (females) so as they can be recognised by the criminal justice system and have their cases…

    • 1669 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    For my research essay, I would like to discuss the violence that North American women often go through at least once in their lifetime. Oftentimes they go without reporting because they feel like no one will listen to them, or reach out to help them. Some victims choose to reach out for help, but are often silenced. This leads to repercussions which affect the victims the most in the end. Throughout, I will be outlining a possible plan of action on how we can stop this from happening, or at least minimize the occurrence of violence. These women need more support than is being given to them and I believe with feminism that we can make a difference. With everyone’s help, we can give these women a reason to fight for control in their lives and their freedom.…

    • 1640 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gendered Intersections

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Both in the past and present, for many different reasons violence towards women has been a concerning issue for the safety of females in private and public life. Although my grandmother never experienced this type of male domination, she agrees that violence has always been apparent in the lives of females and its effects on the female both physically and mentally are detrimental. Joanna Harris writes in one of her sections of “Gendered Intersections: An Introduction to Women’s and Gender Studies” about violence against women. She writes, “It is seen as ‘essential to the struggle to restore dignity to disempowered women’ and ‘necessary conditions to self-empowerment in a socio-economic and cultural context where access to and mobility within public space is still largely controlled by men and where women’s roles and opportunity are frequently defined against their own interests’” (Harris 465). Violence towards women stems from many different areas of society and for many different reasons. Violence towards women in the past was never as much of an issue as it seems to be today and that is reflective on some of the rights women have gained in society that men do not necessarily agree with, an example of this is violence towards women in the…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Males are most likely to be involved in violent offending and victimization. Males commit about 9 out of 10 homicides in the United States and account for about 3 in every 4 of it’s victims. Most homicides are male-on-male, which makes them the predominant gender in homicide patterns. About 2 in every 3 homicides involve a male offender and a male victim. Men are also more likely to killed by an intimate partner or in a sex-related offense. But, 82% male juvenile offenders are likely to commit homicides(Humphrey & Schmalleger,2012).…

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Within the feminist theories we have victimization, differences in crimes, Gender Differences, Masculinity. A great deal of focus is spotlighted on masculinity of crimes. Researchers argue that in order to reduce crime men must be socialized more and male dominance must be illuminated. It was noted in Chapter 3 that we already do a good job of raising our girls not to be criminals, however how can we implement this into the masculine side of things. Masculinity and crime is the significant focus of the work of gender-ratio issues. The problem according to sociologists is that crime is essentially a male issue and we need to figure out how we get to it being much less of an issue. Most crimes against women are either produced as a crime against a weaker person or a crime because the criminal is the dominant one. It seems to be a double edge…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    In attempting to answer the question how has feminist thought influenced the discipline of criminology? This essay will briefly discuss the development of feminist thought within the discipline. This essay will then discuss the female emancipation leads to crime debate which was the focus of liberal feminists, like Adler and Simon, before focusing on the radical feminist notion of patriarchy. This essay will then discuss how feminist thought has challenged and invalidated the leniency hypothesis and then the development of a gender based theory of female criminality that focused on social control systems. Finally this essay will discuss the raising to greater prominence of the female victim and feminist victimology.…

    • 2275 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    The second study was by Simon and Sharma. This study employed Prosecutor Management Information Systems data to explore women 's involvement in a variety of crimes, including burglary. Conclusion 's from the study support that women do not commit crimes under the control of men, and 70% of female arrests where by females acting alone. An ethnographic study by Cromwell, Olsen, and Avary was also mentioned. But, due to sample size limits it was seen as conclusive.…

    • 1599 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Feminists such as Serena Parekh argue that there is a clear separation between the public and private realms in human rights laws, as the private realm (places such as the home) are assumed to be power-neutral and are shielded from Government interference. Furthermore, the power of law enforcement is only exercised in the public realm. Because of this, it is argued that the division between the public and private is creating permissive laws where instances of marital rape and domestic violence, for example, can be ‘ignored’. As cases of marital rape and domestic violence are often instigated by men against women, it can then be argued that the division of the public and private is working against recognising and enforcing women’s human rights.…

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Today the violence against women has taken a new dimension as it was in the earlier years, in which it relates to a variety of behaviours that go further than the simple physical violence. They include emotional, sexual, and physical assault, verbal abuse, humiliation, stalking, and sexual harassment by former and current intimate partners. According to the National Violence against Women Survey that was conducted by the National Institute of Justice indicated that violence between the intimate has risen in the United States. In their survey, they found that approximately 1.5 million women as well as 830,000 men are victims of intimate violence abuse each year (Continuing Psychology Education 2005). According to Tjaden and Thoennes (2000) an estimated 1.5% of women who were surveyed in the study, reported incidences of physical violence as well as rape by their current or former intimate partner within their lifetimes. The report also indicated that 8% of women were also attacked during their lifetimes. Despite the fact that such studies regarding women have not bore fruit regarding the clear solutions to do away with the vice, nonetheless, such research has facilitated the development of theoretical explanations as well as causes that are aimed at prevention and intervention programs. Among the theoretical explanations, include the…

    • 1536 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Women & Crime

    • 2116 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Amongst criminologists and social scientists, there are generally two perceptions as to why women commit crime. The first and most obviously known cause is that females generally maintain lower incarceration rates than males do. In every category, except embezzlement, prostitution and runaways, men tend to commit crimes at higher rates (Simon, &…

    • 2116 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Kimerling, R., Rellini, A., Kelly, V., Judson, P. L., & Learman, L. A. (2002). Gender differences in victim and crime characteristics of sexual assaults. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 17(5), 526.…

    • 4866 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Female Offenders

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages

    There are many social and environmental explanations that might increase the likelihood of female offending. Some feminists claimed that the likelihood of female offending was linked to the changing roles of women. According to Steffensmeier, the new female criminal is more a social invention rather than empirical reality. As women gain more liberal and equality through the impact of women’s liberation…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Although victimization differs from offenders, there are certain things that typically go along with women who commit murder/manslaughter. Victims of this type of crime are typically male, the ages of these victims are unknown but among the victims that are known, many were under the age of 16. The age difference differs by victim gender. Victim-offender relationship differ substantially from male offender and female offenders. According to Table 9 of SONY DOCS page 10, victims tend to be children of the offender or someone who is well known to the offender and is living with them. In the 1986 research, 35% of homicide victims were either married or living with the offender.…

    • 208 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Crime Vs Female Crime

    • 329 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The study period say that males were seen to be more likely than females to commit crime. In 2005, males were actually 10 times more likely than females to commit murder. A breakdown of the murders into gender and circumstance and gender and weapon gives further insight into male offender violence compared to female offender violence “(Prinz, 2012)”. Males were more likely than females to commit homicide during arguments, using a gun and commit felony murder and to be a multiple offender. These statistics become particularly more violent when compared to females.…

    • 329 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays