Preview

Out Of Our Past Carl Degler Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
614 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Out Of Our Past Carl Degler Analysis
“Was the American Revolution Largely a Product of Market-Driven Forces?” The English suffered from frequent and constant European wars, constant religious strife. Some of the people in England were suffering from harsh economic changes, and lack of land due to wool trading. The English saw America as land which was scarce in their homeland and as an economic reprieve. Colonies were built, mercantilism was established. – Page 11. A British Empire was being built. However, England was in enormous debt due to the many years of fighting wars and in desperate need of revenue. England was cash poor and decided it needed to capitalize off and increase its administrative capacities in America. Tax Acts were imposed and some repealed. However, some colony leaders had …show more content…
Carl Degler does not dispute that the American Revolution was a Product of Market-Driven Forces as he writes, “Within a century after the revolution, France, Spain, and Portugal lost portions or all of their New World empires through colonial rebellion.” – Page 213. Although, rebellion started with boycotting imports, this was not the sole reason of the American Revolution. Carl Degler’s articles gives other avenues to consider. He explains the causes and consequences that lead up to the American Revolution. The shattering victory of the Anglo-American forces over the French suddenly revealed how wide the gulf between colonist and England had become. As stated by the previous author, England lost a lot of money in the war; they needed revenue. Carl Degler wrote, “The new imperial polices of the British government caught the Americans off guard. It was not injustice or the economic incidence of the taxes which prompted the colonial protests; it was rather the novelty of the British demands.” – Page

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    As soon as the Americas were discovered, tens of thousands of people wanted to migrate across the sea. The fastest the voyage could be made was approximately one or two months. Communication between the colonies and England was extremely difficult. The regulation of religion was basically impossible. Without the government to intervene, colonists were free to grow whatever they wished and do what they wished with their money. Also, it is exceedingly difficult to govern a colony from thousands of miles away, so the colonies needed to develop their own system of governing. Britain at this pointed adopted a policy of salutary neglect. Salutary neglect allowed the North American society to develop and change into something completely different from what it originally was in England.…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Legislation imposed by Britain was unavoidable for the colonists in early eighteenth century colonial America; however, to what extent would Britain take advantage of their power over the colonies? In the late 1600’s and early part of the 1700’s, salutary neglect was in great use. Some British leaders strongly believed that these newer colonies would not excel on their own if trade laws (ie. The Navigation Acts) were not strictly enforced. With the better part of the eighteenth century proceeding without strict trade laws, the inevitable litigious aspect of Britain’s relationship with colonial America was in its early stages of kicking in. The first real attempt by Britain of regaining their financial status in the mid eighteenth century was the placement of the Sugar Act (which taxed molasses, rum, and other simple products). The Sugar Act would partially imitate a system similar to one that existed already in Britain, in attempt to reduce debt accrued during the Seven Years’ War. Shortly after the Sugar Act took effect, the Stamp Act was placed, adding more tax stress to the average eighteenth century colonist over something that we see today as virtually disposable- paper. As if these two pieces of legislation were not enough force on the colonists from British parliament, the Townshend Acts followed shortly thereafter the Stamp Act. This series of legislation would include the addition of tea being taxed, which would soon lead to a monumental “party”, that wasn’t so celebratory in the eyes of Britain- the Boston Tea Party. The punishment was the…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The English strategy for colonies was to create a very tight knit group of people to survive in a place where it would take years for any help to come. They didn't even have anything to get back to England. They all voluntarily came there. They were supposed to treat each other with "kindness and patience" make America seem amazing in every way. Like it just made people nice and productive. That was supposed to make other people want to come there. That strategy was also supposed to make people want to be like the city on the hill. In other words they wanted people to be like the best city. That was just little bit so that the people sending the colonists would make money but it was also to make sure the colonies survived and were easy…

    • 332 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The English colonists of the 17th century came to the American colonies for many different reasons. The one that motivated them the most was their pursuit of wealth because, despite the early colonists saying that it was their mission as children of God to go to the new world and spread Christianity to more people, the whole idea of going to the new world was to make a profit for England and themselves. This colonization affected many people and eventually led to a war between two very powerful countries.…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Main reason for Britain to colonize America was for resources. It provided crops and raw materials which meant that England did not have to import these items. The English wanted raw materials in America now, and before they bought them from European countries for a high price (in gold and money). By colonizing America Britain wanted to solve economic problems. It wanted to do business with American colonies to keep its powerful “merchant marine” and it had to replace some of its assets and materials, by exporting its cargo and merchandise. Great Britain wanted to run its colonies based on the trade “mercantile” system – gold, silver and money is the main thing from which a nation gets its power. In 1650, the British government made a law “mercantilism” in international trade. Americans gave raw goods to England to produce goods and sell them in European market and then back to colonies. To improve merchant marine and the economy, between the years 1651 and 1673 the English parliament passed four Navigation Acts to ensure mercantilist trade balance. - "that all trade between France and English colonies, Europe and English colonies, and the colonies with themselves must be conducted on an English ship". For the benefit of England the Navigation Act forbid trade between colonies, that is why some colonies started to smuggle. Mercantilism was a triangular trade, with trade routes to American colonies, Africa,…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Early Us History

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The economy plays an important role in colonial America. The leaders on the New England colonies prided themselves on the idea that religion was the primary motivation for emigration, but economic motives were hardly unimportant. The American colonial economy was export-driven, although by far the largest share of output was consumed internally. Joint stock companies financed the initial conquest of New England and the Chesapeake colonies. Investors were expecting profits from the riches of the New World but would end up basically paying the colonists' bills. After several years of trial and error, the colonists discovered that agricultural goods such as corn, wheat, tobacco, rice, indigo, and naval stores were in great demand in England and Europe. By the mid-seventeenth century, trade under England's support was mutually beneficial. The English navy protected colonial commerce, and colonists gained a guaranteed market in England and access to English and Scottish credit and manufactured goods. The English gained markets for manufactured goods, profits from the sale of colonial staples on the Continent, and interest payments on the credit they extended.…

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The American Revolution paved the way for democratic rule in nations and ignited the spreading thereof throughout the whole world. Yet events that led up the start of the revolution have been mixed in their significance by historians. Both historians, Carl Degler and T.H. Breen agree that the British mercantile system had benefited the colonists, allowing them to have comfortable lifestyles. Madaras L, SoRelle J (2011)…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There were acres of fertile land to be stolen from the Indians, a large surplus population in Europe eager to come and farm it, plenty of capital available from British investors, and a steadily growing industrial population in Western Europe, and subsequently in the eastern half of the USA needing cheap food. The Protestant promotion of Bible reading led to a literate and therefore more productive working class. Unskilled labour was cheaply available by import from Africa for the first half of the 1800s, after which it could be replaced by mass immigration from the poorer countries of Europe such as Ireland, Italy and Russia. And during all these years Britain was a superpower strong enough to impose world peace, so that the progress of the USA was not limited by the inconveniences of warfare between 1812 and its self-imposed mayhem of 1861-65.The thirteen colonies that became the USA were originally colonies of Great Britain. By the time the American Revolution took place, the citizens of these colonies were beginning to get tired of the British rule. Rebellion and discontent were rampant. For those people who see the change in the American government and society a real Revolution, the Revolution is essentially an economic one. The main reason the colonies started rebelling against 'mother England' was the taxation issue. The colonies debated England's legal power to tax them and, furthermore, did not wish to be taxed without representation. This was one of the main causes of the Revolutionary War. The Revenue Act of 1764 made the constitutional issue of whether or not the King had the right to tax the thirteen colonies an issue, and this eventually "became an entering wedge in the great dispute that was finally to wrest the American colonies from England" (Olsen, 6). It was the phrase 'taxation without representation' "that was to draw many to…

    • 308 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Another key reason in why people decided to settling in the American Colonies was the English Civil War. The parliament held resentment towards the king’s mission to raise revenues for his government. Not only was the parliament outraged but also many other people of this region. England became a republic under the dictatorship. The disruption in the government left many of the people confused, and sent many into war. This was the final factors in these people hoping for a new start and a new…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Revolution Dbq

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Like other European nations, England revolved around mercantilism which was the idea of being a self-sufficient nation by exporting more goods than importing. Between 1651 and 1673, the Parliament Navigation Acts were instilled which set forth three essentials of the mercantilist theory which included that only English and colonial merchants could trade in the colonies legally, certain American products were only to be sold to England or other English colonies and lastly, foriegns foods sold to the British colonies were to be imported first through England (Pg. 76). With these new laws in place, colonial America became even more heavily dependent on England for expansion and economic growth since the colonies could only trade with them. In addition, the concept of mercantilism revolves around the idea there is a limited amount of affluence, therefore if one nation gains, another must lose. During this time, England had full control over the colonies, making them the superior nation. Because of the power England had, the colonies were unable to export goods that would compete with English goods. With England at the center of trade, the circumstances they created made it nearly impossible for colonial America to flourish financially. Colonial America’s only hope for a successful economy lied on the…

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    It can be assumed, that the American Revolution was caused more by political factors because the British government wanted to change the way the colonies were ran. Factors such as deprivation of trial by jury and the right to assemble, grieve, and petition the king (Document E). Another political factor was the colonies’ natural and legal rights were constantly being annexed by the Parliament (Document H).…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    England was governed by strict laws and regulations created by the King, who didn’t allow the citizens much freedom. The Englishmen weren’t allowed to practice religious freedom without being prosecuted nor were they able to give input into their government. They also grew tired of the warfare in England and wanted to seek a new start and thought that America was the perfect suit for them. The King initially rejected the voyage, but eventually expected the idea of mercantilism and saw the potential economic opportunities that it presented. Mercantilism is the concept of exporting more goods and services than importing to increase the nation’s wealth, and in this particular case it was Britain. This provided groups such as the Puritans, Pilgrims,…

    • 1798 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Revolution, started from New England to the South, culminated with the Declaration of Independence. Both spiritual and economic factors exerted crucial influences on this monumental event. American Revolution was doomed to be launched. Economically, benefits of both upper-classes and lower-classes were offended respectively by Great Britain dominators and English businessmen.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The thirteen Colonies

    • 375 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The thirteen colonies that joined together to become the United States of America were but a part of the first British Empire. They were the product of a broad and dramatic expansion of England that began with the establishment of “plantations” in Ireland during the reign of Queen Elizabeth I and reached a peak with the conquest of Canada and the extension of British influence over India during the 1760s. In the New World alone at the time of the American Revolution Britain had close to two dozen colonies, most in the Caribbean, apart from the thirteen rebellious ones. As was the case for other colonizing nations, this expansion was driven by a variety of factors, including religion, nationalism, and economics—often categorized as God, Glory, and Gold. Specific colonies typically combined more than one of these objectives. The Roanoke colony of 1585, for example, was intended to serve as a privateer base that would undermine Spain’s Catholic empire in America, advance the interests of England, and enrich those who would actually capture Spanish possessions.…

    • 375 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The American Revolution embarked the beginning of the United States of America. A war that lasted eight years, 1775-1783, was able to grant the thirteen colonies the independence they deserved by breaking free of British rule. The war was an effect of the previous French and Indian War, which forced England to tax the American colonist, compelling them to rebel against parliament. From the 1760’s to 1775, many factors lead up to the American Revolution such as the various acts the British Parliament passed to pay the war debt, no representation in parliament, and the American people wanting to gain their independence. “No Taxation without Representation”, a slogan used by the American colonist, was the most important cause of the colonists declaring war for their independence on the British government.…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays