Preview

"Othello" Discussion Paper: In What Way did Desdemona's Mistakes Contribute to Her Death?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
428 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
"Othello" Discussion Paper: In What Way did Desdemona's Mistakes Contribute to Her Death?
In the play "Othello", Desdemona fell deeply in love with Othello. She was extremely loyal and faithful to the heretical general. Desdemona died at the end of the play as a result of many mistakes she made upon handling her relationship with Othello. Arguably, the first mistake that she ever made was marrying Othello, a heathen who did not match her complexion; it was a marriage that was not permitted by the society at the time. Othello's gain of Desdemona aroused the jealousy of Iago, who believed that Othello was not a proper spouse for Desdemona and wanted Desdemona himself. This first mistake Desdemona made was the fundamental cause that motivated Iago to form his conspiracy.

After the devised downfall of Cassio, Desdemona dedicated herself to speak on Cassio's behalf to reinstate him. It was not a mistake, but when Othello was persuaded by Iago's slander and questioned her about the disappearance of the handkerchief, she should have stopped her attempt on reinstating Cassio and thought about her own situation. She simply concluded that Othello's questioning of the handkerchief was a trick to stop her from her petition by "This is a trick to put me from my suit" (3.4.101). What she should have done was to solve the misapprehension between her and Othello that was built by Iago instead of presenting her petition blindly by "I pray, talk me of Cassio", and then turning Othello away through "(I' faith,) you are to blame" (3.4.114).

Shortly after Othello walked out, Desdemona queried if the reason why Othello had behaved in this manner was some bad news from Venice. "Something, sure, of state, / Either from Venice, or some unhatched practice" (3.4.161, 162). She did not think about other possible reasons why Othello was angry because she believed that the bond between her and Othello is unbreakable and cannot be affected by such slander.

She made the fatal mistake when Othello was about to strangle her, she did not try to escape or yell out for help. At that

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Who Is Roderigo In Act 1

    • 1835 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Othello argues that he did not force Desdemona into marriage but rather married her out of their shared love. The Duke sends for Desdemona to confirm his account, while Othello says she fell in love with him after hearing his life story – a story filled with redemption, adventure, and danger. The Duke sides with Othello, especially after hearing Desdemona confirm Othello’s claims and say she owes the loyalty of marriage to him. Desdemona’s father accepts. The Duke decides to send Othello to Cyprus in light of the impending attack, because of his knowledge of the area.…

    • 1835 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why did Othello decide to kill Desdemona? In the play, Othello by William Shakespeare, Othello, the noble Moor, is married to Desdemona, a daughter of Brabantio. Iago, an antagonist, didn’t have the promotion as a lieutenant, which made him hate Cassio, the Lieutenant, and Othello. He plots his plan to take down Cassio and Othello. Throughout the play, Othello is manipulated by Iago and decides to kill Desdemona for cheating on him with Cassio. After Othello killed Desdemona, Iago’s plan gets exposed, and Othello commits suicide. Othello is most responsible for Desdemona’s death because he falls for Iago’s lies instead of believing Desdemona, never confronts Cassio about the situation, and is the one who actually killed Desdemona.…

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Othello, Iago is able to convince Roderigo that Cassio will ruin their plans to have Desdemona, causing Cassio to be the first victim of murder. Iago prompts the second death by persuading Othello that his wife is a cheater. Iago has Desdemona's handkerchief copied by a prostitute named Bianca. Desdemona tells Othello that she hasn't cheated on him, but Othello doesn't believe her. Already going mad, He recalls the evidence of the handkerchief, and chokes Desdemona to death.…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He is insecure of his job, his life, and feels like an outsider from not being a Venetian like some of the other characters in this play. Ironically, Desdemona’s and Othello are -or they were- fairly good friends and Othello was invited into their home multiple times. When Brabantio finds out about his daughters marriage, of course he is hurt, but he feels betrayed by Othello. He assumes that his daughter must have been drugged to make her fall in love with him and Brabantio calls for the couple to explain. Keep in mind that Othello and Desdemona are deeply in love and they just got married. Both Othello and Desdemona know that her father didn’t want the marriage and he wanted to prove his worthiness by respectfully standing up to Brabantio, but he called for his wife so she could convince him that their marriage is, in fact, real. In this time period, it was considered reckless to marry for love, so the parents- in this case, Brabantio alone- tended to choose the spouse for their child. Of course Desdemona doesn’t want this, so when she says “But here’s my…

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ironically, it is primarily how Desdemona behave towards Othello that makes him doubt her. After Cassio lost his position as lieutenant, Desdemona accepted the task of trying to convince Othello to forgive Cassio. The start of her obsession of getting Cassio’s job back is when Desdemona says herself that “My lord shall never rest,/I’ll watch him tame and talk him out of patience”…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Shakespeare ’s play Othello, Iago’s words and actions cause Othello to change and to stop loving Desdemona; as a result, Othello and the people around him plunge into chaos. After much manipulation from Iago, Othello, like a coin, flips sides and hates Desdemona. When Desdemona leaves with Emilia, Othello says that “when I love thee [Desdemona] not, / Chaos is come again” (3.3.91-92). This clearly shows that Othello is in love with Desdemona and has no doubt in her faithfulness. Little does Othello…

    • 562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Desdemona had plenty of evidence that she was chaste and loved Othello, he was just too mad to see it. Their marriage was unfortunate to be doubted from the start which added extra pressure but if Othello truly loved his wife, they could have worked through it all. Iago really played the villain here as he sought revenge Othello and drove him crazy. Othello soon realizes how ignorant he was to have accused his beautiful bride of adultery when he had already smothered her to death and decided to take his own life as…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although Iago was the true liar in the play, Othello's inability to confront Desdemona of his suspicions contributed to his downfall. As Iago fed more and more nonsense to Othello, the more he had believed that she was unfaithful. After Iago leaves, Othello mutters to himself, "If she be false, heaven mocks itself! I'll not believe't." But when Desdemona asks, "How now, my dear Othello?" he could not confront her, only saying, "I have a pain upon my forehead, here" (III.iii.320-326). He could have easily just asked her where the handkerchief was, or as easily faced Cassio or Desdemona to tell them what was on his mind. Instead, he keeps quiet and just assumes everything Iago says is true. By keeping to himself, Othello is…

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Othello Act 1 Summary

    • 3451 Words
    • 14 Pages

    He praises her for being the gatekeeper to Hell, and tells her that she'd do best to keep the events of this night to herself. Othello then exits making quite an unsettling expression of himself. Emilia questions Desdemona worriedly about Othello's behavior, wondering what's happened to her husband’s mind. She then declares that she has no lord, nor does she have tears to cry, and no answer is appropriate about what is going on with Othello except an answer that could be told in tears. Desdemona bids Emilia to lay her wedding sheets on the quarreling lovers' bed tonight, and asks to have Iago come and talk to her. Alone, she resents bearing all this abuse, mostly because she's done nothing wrong. Emilia returns with Iago, and Desdemona says she can't even begin to convey what Othello called her. Emilia does this for her. She then lists off that Othello called Desdemona a whore and all sorts of other cruel names. She also reminds Desdemona that she turned down all sorts of nice, rich Venetian boys, even her father, and her friends, and her country… all to marry Othello. She also suggests that it could only be some really vile person, seeking his own self-interest that plied Othello with lies about Desdemona's faithfulness in order to make him jealous. She talks on this matter for a while, and Iago tells her to speak quietly, but Emilia notes that it was a very similar scheme, lies from a…

    • 3451 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this passage, the Duke of Venice asked Othello why he loves Desdemona, he tells him that his love has grown as Desdemona would listen to his stories about war and pity them. By Othello saying this it provides evidence that there is no fundamental foundation binding this relationship together. Othello is basing his love on pity instead of the strong affection and feelings that is necessary to hold or keep a relationship together. This clearly lays out that the relationship between the two is not really based on much. Albert Gerard discusses how Othello 's lack in self- knowledge contributes to his poor judgments.…

    • 858 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Alternatively Desdemona is revealed to be the ideal woman, Cassio even admits“She is indeed perfection.” Othello often makes remarks on her beauty and her wit. Even when he thinks she has betrayed him, he cannot help himself from looking upon her fondly even stating that she is “so delicate with her needle: an admirable musician: O! she will sing the savageness out of a bear: of so high and plenteous wit and invention:—“ despite Desdemona’s perfection Othello lets himself be manipulated into thinking she is unfaithful to him, and he kills her. Emilia, while not as perfect as Desdemona appears to be an obedient wife to Iago. She even gives him Desdemona’s handkerchief without knowing the reason he wants it, when stealing the handkerchief she says “what he will do with it Heaven knows, not I; I nothing but to please his fantasy.” In the end of the play however, she chooses to honour Desdemona and she exposes her husband's treachery as opposed to supporting it. Iago kills her due to this one moment of disobedience. Through the killing of Emilia and Desdemona at the hands of their husbands and the fact that Bianca lives, Shakespeare reveals what he thinks of the relationships husbands have with their wives. He is exhibiting how women are never good enough for their husbands. Desdemona and Emilia are honest women, but in Desdemona’s case Othello believes she is having an affair and to him this is inexcusable. Emilia is killed because Iago sees it as a fit punishment for her disobedience and her lack of support of his dishonesty. Bianca on the other hand has no husband and thus she appears to follow no rules but her own and suffers no dire consequences because she has no one ruling over her. Shakespeare is showcasing the oppression that husbands had over their wives. On top of that Shakespeare is suggesting…

    • 1710 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Desdemona is responsible for her own death, because she was cuckolding her husband, who found out and killed her. If Desdemona was loyal to her husband and was not seeing another man when Othello’s back was turned, he would have never killed her. She provoked and disrespected her husband who would bend over backwards for her. Desdemona’s death was justified one hundred percent in the play “Othello” by William…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Desdemona is probably the strongest willed character in the play, although she is a woman. Shakespeare takes no shame in making her this, considering the time this was written in. We first see her, defending her recent marriage surrounded by powerful men, whom of which include the duke, her husband, and her father, but shes is not ashamed to assert her belief in the validity of her desires and actions. Desdemona's forthrightness is her demise, because the brilliant Iago recognizes this and uses it against her. Using Cassio who becomes demoted in the play, Iago exploits her willingness to demand and justice, to make him her cause and simultaneously, Othello's enemy. As Iago's plan goes as planned, Desdemona asks Othello to forgive Cassio adding to Othello's suspicions created by his deceitful friend. She keeps pushing him in spite of her husbands growing rage until he declares, The handkerchief that Othello gave his wife at the beginning of the play, is stolen. Her courage is apparent in her refusal to search for it in Act III, scene iv; her willingness to have a voice and shout back at Othello as he abuses her in Act IV, scene i; and defending her innocence when accused Act V, scene ii. Since men have the ultimate power of women. Othello does not believe in, what he takes to be 'shameless lies'. Her courage convinces him all the more that she is remorseless in what he thinks to be her wrongdoing.…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Othello and Desdemona’s manifestly love-filled relationship was somewhat shielded by society’s views of the age, social position and race differences, that would evidently cause implications. In the late sixteenth century, the time in which Othello is based, it was disreputable to do anything that was thought of as abnormal, for example, marrying below your class. Othello and Desdemona’s relationship was quickly looked down upon, simply due to the fact that it was seen as unconventional at the time. The implications that were apparent in the relationship were; the fact that Desdemona was considerably younger then Othello, the difference in social position of the two, and of course the obvious reason, being that Othello was dark skinned and Desdemona fair skinned. Beneath these implications, the two shared a deep, meaningful and adoring relationship, for the start of the play, that is.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Othello’s notable tragic flaw is, as Iago states himself, “The Moor is of a free and open nature”, meaning that he takes people and things at face value, not expecting any hidden vendetta or betrayal. This can be emphasized since Othello was interpreted by Shakespeare as being a soldier since he was seven years old. This would mean that he would expect to recognize his enemy simply by looking at his face, and not expect any attack from his supposed allies. This is where the audience gets the impression that Othello is hopelessly naïve, which can be seen at how he describes the man who hates him the most, “my ancient: A man he is of honesty and trust.” In the following quotation Othello asks Iago to look after his most prized possession: his wife, Desdemona. This moment can be considered significant as it could symbolize Othello placing Desdemona’s and his own life in Iago ’s hands. “Honest Iago, My Desdemona must I leave to thee.” One example of Othello’s tragic flaw leading to his downfall is when he mishears the conversation between Cassio and Iago, and by his own thinking, contemplates murder. “How shall I murder him, Iago?” Although Iago does succeed in convincing Othello to kill Desdemona, there is no quotation before Act 4 Scene 1…

    • 1326 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays