Preview

O Brien's Guilt Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
637 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
O Brien's Guilt Analysis
According to the interview, O'Brien's continuing guilt over his military service in a war he opposed and his anger about government deceit. He said: "I didn't go to war as an innocent. I went to war knowing, at least convinced, that the Vietnam War was ill-conceived and morally wrong. That was my conviction. I didn't go to war an innocent. I went to war a "guilt," that is to say "guilt" being a sort of weird noun. I was not an innocent, I was a "guilt." I knew that the war was wrong. I wasn't a Henry Fleming. I wasn't a Caputo or a Kovic. I wasn't a Paul Baumer. My situation was different, and it separates me from a lot of veterans to this day. It doesn't make me better or worse, but different, in the sense that I believed that the war was wrong and I went to it anyway. I didn't go to the war with a sense that I was going to prove my own courage, for reasons of glory, for reasons of adventure, for patriotic reasons--a lot of the variables that send men off to war that are so conspicuous in most literature about Vietnam and other wars. In …show more content…
He calls this feeling "a kind of schizophrenia". It is a "moral split" for him. "I feared the war, yes." "but I also feared exile. I was afraid of walking away from my own life, my friends and my family, my whole history, everything that mattered to me. I feared losing the respect of my parents. I feared the law. I feared ridicule and censure" . It is also one of the reasons why O'Brien quitted from his job at a meat packing plant and leave his family and hometown. He fleeing to northern Minnesota with the intention to cross into Canada. “I did not want people to think badly of me”: "My conscience told me to run," but, he also confesses, "I was ashamed of my conscience, ashamed to be doing the right thing." He said, "I was a coward. I went to Vietnam" in the New York Times Magazine memoir, therefore each thing he did in Vietnam "was an act of the purest self-hatred and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Dunny's Guilt Analysis

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The third mention of guilt does not have to do with Dunny. Near the end of the novel, Dunny has Boy and Paul, who is now Magnus, over to where he lives. They are admiring the hominess of where Dunny lives. They remark about an odd paperweight that Dunny owns. When Boy asks where he got it, Dunny seems surprised that Boy does not remember it. The rock on Dunny’s desk is the same one that Boy put in the snowball he threw, which hit Mary Dempster when they were kids. Boy seems to have forgotten about this incident, claiming that he does not remember doing it and has completely forgotten everything about his childhood as it will do him no good now. While Boy and Dunny are talking, Dunny asks if Boy remembers anything, he replies by saying “’No.…

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He pictures his victim’s whole life, and imagines he was a young student that had just entered the university in Saigon in 1964, avoided politics, didn’t like to fight, and just hoped the Americans would go away. Though out the whole story, O’Brien both, consolidates and tortures himself, by picturing the life of this young dead soldier. He imagines it in such a way, that the Vietnamese soldier ends up being very similar to himself, and by relating to his victim this way, O’Brien grapples with and tries to understand the unpredictability of his own mortality, and is better aware of the horrible nature of the killing. He contemplates the fact of life and death. How the death of this poor soldier will not change one thing and life will go on, leaving him in the past, making his death look irrelevant and…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tim O'Brien

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages

    When he first received the notice O’Brien contemplated the idea of abandoning his duty to serve in the war and defecting to Canada. However, “the prospect of rejection: by my family my country my friends, my hometown” convinced O’Brien that he had to say and fight the war…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The war officially began in 1939. Americans were not searching out to become involved in the war, but were brought into it by the attacks of other countries. Perhaps men were more honored to die for their country because they were defending it, and they were trying to avenge the lives of the people who were killed in the Pearl Harbor bombing. They had a deep rooted, intrinsic motivation to fight for the country. Their country and their people were wronged, and so the soldiers who went to fight were determined to make it right for their fellow countrymen and women. Now, in the Vietnam War, O’Brien writes that “The war, I thought, was wrongly conceived and poorly justified” (18). In the case of the Vietnam war, no one had that intrinsic motivation. They were not defending their country, they were attacking another one. People were more motivated by fear than honor. Erik, a friend of O’Brien says early in the memoir, “All this not because of conviction, not for ideology; rather it’s from fear of our society’s censure […] Fear of weakness. Fear that to avoid war is to avoid manhood” (38). For O’Brien and many other men, this war was a pressure, not an…

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the novel The Things They Carried the young soldiers are afraid of seeming weak. O’ Brien didn’t want to go to war. He was even considering fleeing to Canada. O’ Brien eventually decided to go because he was afraid of seeming like a coward to his family and town. He went to war out of fear of appearing weak to his peers. He believed it would be shameful if he didn’t go to the war. The soldiers in the novel were cautious to show any sign of fear. They were in an unpredictable and strange environment for an unknown cause, for most of them. They were young and proud and the last thing the tough, ammunition charged soldiers, wanted is to show how afraid they were.…

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He feels guilt because of the way the man dies. As he stares at the man, O’Brien thinks about the man’s life before any of the war happened. “It was entirely automatic. I did not hate the young man; I did not see him as the enemy; I did not ponder issues of morality or politics or military duty.”(126). O’Brien didn’t think about anything in that moment. He knew that he had to do his duty, but felt as if he had no control whatsoever. “At night, lying on his mat, he could not picture himself doing the brave things his father had done, or his uncles… He hoped the Americans would go away.”(119) O’Brien shows the man’s perspective of his life. Though he didn’t know who the man was or his life story, he showed the readers his interpretation of his life. It shows that everyone in the war had a life before the war. Everyone has a different way of understanding the war and the way they deal with it after is based on them as well. Though he never met the man, he feels remorse for killing him the way he…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In If I Die in a Combat Zone, the end is O’Brien going home from Vietnam. He says that there is no joy in leaving Vietnam. He says that he thought of the friends he gained and the friends he lost. He reminisced what he learned, and realized that he did not learn a lot.…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The chapter begins to state that us humans are bounded by guilt. Guilt robs us of certain satisfactions. Viorst says that we develop a superego around age five and by then we only want want we want. To solve this we develop a conscience that limits and restrains us. Our parents are the symbols for our conscience in our minds. Socially our conscience is modified for what we value and what we forbid. Our conscience is based on emotions and it evolves over time. Our conscience address concerns, feelings, and conflicts. Our conscience is also the our moral restraints, ideals, and our inner submission to human law. If we breach with those moral restraints and leave those ideals behind then we will observe, reproach, and condemn. Guilt can be illogical and can cause a person to lose the ability to discriminate between bad deeds and bad thoughts.…

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is in this chapter that O'Brien reveals that the only aspect of the novel thus far that hasn't been fabricated is the fact that he did walk through Quang Ngai Province as a foot soldier. "Almost everything else is invented" (179). However, it must be understood that he is simply bending the truth in order to convey the most feeling and emotion. "I want you to feel what I felt" (178), O'Brien explains. Evidently, there are times when invented war stories communicate his feelings more clearly than anything actual could. For example, "The Man I Killed" is about a VC soldier killed with a grenade by O'Brien. He is overcome by guilt and regret, but later in the book he reveals that he did not kill the man at all. He was simply present at the time of the young man's death. "But my presence was guilt enough…I remember feeling the burden of responsibility and grief. I blamed myself" (178). He remembers feeling responsible and blaming himself, so he writes himself in as the one physically responsible for the death. It is much more powerful to tell the story this way; readers experience the guilt he felt even though he wasn't actually responsible. This is the sole purpose of O'Brien's style—to communicate feelings in the most effective and powerful way possible, without regard for…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “No amount of guilt can change the past and no amount of worrying can change the future”- Umar Ibn Khattab…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A guilt ad, according to Jack Solomon, is the manifestation of the American consumer’s weakness to general social stigma. Solomon illustrates this with examples of advertisements that reveal the American consumer’s “need” to stave off social rejection, to insure their own health, and to be competitive. Via guilt-trip tactics, advertisers manipulate the American consumer with guilt ads to make them think they need the advertised product so they can conform to the status quo. These guilt ads essentially help reinforce the American consumer-based society.…

    • 315 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Tim O’Brien’s novel, “The Things They Carried”, fear and shame in the characters lead to several actions. For example, both fear and shame were motivating factors in the war. Some of the characters had a fear of being shamed by others, so they joined the war. O’Brien describes a personal experience he had involving fear and shame. After receiving his draft notice, O’Brien debates running away to Canada or staying to fight in the war. He ends up deciding to fight in the war because he fears being thought of as a coward by everyone else and the shame he would feel if he ran away. Additionally, fear and shame affected the relationships that the men had with one another. None of them wanted to look bad in front of each other so they engaged…

    • 192 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    How to Tell a True War Story

    • 2535 Words
    • 11 Pages

    O’Brien tells his story when he was in the Vietnam War though books that he has written. For example in “The Things They Carried” there is a character named Tim. One of the interviews from Library of Congress Tim O’Brien states that “he goes back and forth about Vietnam and also about his first girlfriend.” He was in 4th grade when he was in love and that using his girlfriend as an example that Vietnam was not that easy like losing his girlfriend at nine years old. In the story Bob Kiley was known as Rat. O’ Brien points out that Rat that had a good friend with him in the Vietnam War. They both were good soldiers and when Lemon would volunteer Rat would volunteer as well. He lets people know that his friend and he were goofing around like always. Lemon showed Rat that the war can be fun but also very serious. There will be times to goof around and there will be times to be services during the war. He tells people that when they were goofing around they felt like kids again. Lemon and Rat “were giggling and calling each other motherfucker”. They would go a nature hike in the woods and started messing around. They heard a noise and next thing a bomb killed his friend. Rat had taken his friend back with the other soldiers. Hs friend named was Curt Lemon. He told Sander and the other soldiers what happen to Lemon.…

    • 2535 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Marxist Literary Analysis

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Through writing about his experiences in Vietnam, O 'Brien 's character is able to find a medium in which he can sort through his emotions, since "by telling stories, you objectify your own experience. You separate it from yourself. You pin down certain truths" (158). He does not look upon his stories as therapy--he recounts his stories since they are a part of his past, and who he is now is the direct result of them:…

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “First Confession” by Frank O’Connor, Mrs. Ryan’s method of teaching the negatives instead of the positives, is basically her using reverse psychology. Being taught more about hell is a way of saying if you do not do something you will be punished. The ultimate punishment of your sins is being demised to going to hell and not being forgiven by Jesus or God himself. If you were to leave out any particular sin in a confession, the Holy himself will know. Mrs. Ryan explains this by telling a story of a man who was killed in a priest house and left behind burn marks, because he was condoned as a demon. Instead of sprouting wings, the man was taken to Hell. I believe that Mrs. Ryan’s method of reverse psychology is way of getting the students…

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays