Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Nestle Water Scandal

Good Essays
931 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Nestle Water Scandal
Nestle is no stranger to boycott. Beginning in the 1970’s the corporation which brought consumers trusted brands such as Ovaltine and Nestle Tollhouse chips suffered backlash from their aggressive marketing of infant formula in underdeveloped countries, which was leading to sickness and death among infants. Consumers across the United States not only boycotted Nestle brands and products but petitioned and picketed to gain support against the corporation. Ethical business practices along with the exploiting of natural resources have taken their toll on Nestle, but not just the company’s bottom line has seen effects. Stakeholders such as small rural communities in the Great Lakes region, the East Coast, even in Western areas such as the Arkansas River in Utah, as well as third world countries including Nigeria, Ethiopia and Pakistan have dealt with the production and sale of Nestle bottled water.
As soon as Nestle began extracting and bottling the water from natural sources throughout the United States municipalities and citizens took notice. Nestle is the largest extractor of water in the city of Detroit and state of Michigan. Although other bottlers such as Coca-Cola and PepsiCo also extract water, Nestle has been credited with doing the great amount of environmental damage. “Opponents say Nestle's pumping is lowering water levels in local creeks and lakes -- systems that feed the Great Lakes. In Ontario, a hydrologist hired by a group opposing the Nestle plant reported that the company was using 7 percent of the local water supply and depleting the flow of a creek,” Kari Lydersen of the Washington Post in her article, Bottled Water at Issue in Great Lakes reported. Citizens, lawmakers and environmentalists have made many attempts to force Nestle out of the Great Lakes Region, or to at least impose a tax on the corporation to increase revenue for governments at the state and local level. With the growth in consumption of bottled water every year the demand is making it even more important for stakeholders such as local governments and environmental groups to stop or slow the depletion of the natural resources. Many environmental groups have formed out of support to stop Nestle. One group, led by Swiss journalist Res Gehringer and producer Urs Schnell recently released a documentary entitled The Bottled Life to gain support against Nestle by presenting information about the cost of the water on consumers, the environment, governments and third world countries.
Government has also reacted to claims made by environmental activist groups regarding Nestle’s use of fresh water. Terry Swier, president of Michigan Citizens for Water Conservation, has stated she does not believe Nestle should pay a higher price for water than residents of the state do, "With the financial situation Michigan is in, we would just open up the state to any water bottler," she said. "We have to preserve and protect the waters for future generations" (Lydersen). Other states and municipalities such as the city of Fryburg, Maine whose residents greatly oppose the extraction of water by Nestle see benefits in the bottling of their water as well. Fryeburg residents obtained over 100,000 signatures in protest of a contract between the city and Nestle, which would allow the corporation to extract water at a low tax rate while paying the city $144,000 annually, following a more predictable cash flow. Bruce Taylor, a Fryeburg, Maine taxpayer and an intervener of the case against Nestle was quoted the following, They’re buying a commodity at a cheap regulated rate from a monopoly they own and are reselling it for a high profit in the form of bottled water you find in your local 7-11” (Varela). The government disregarded the petition even though many residents claimed the contract displayed be ‘conflicted interests’ between the government officials and Nestle (Varela).
In addition to the water that is being extracted from North America, many activist groups are also petitioning to keep Nestle out of countries such as Pakistan. The group SumOfUs.org has sponsored a petition that has gained over a 215,000 online signatures to stop Nestle from extracting water in the Pakistani village of Bhati Dilwan where the water table has significantly sunk and the villagers are being negatively affected. Many residents of Bhati Dilwan are becoming ill or dying from the lack of water available to them or the sludge that is polluting their natural resources, a majority of these cases happen to be found in children. This same situation has taken place in many third world countries because of Nestle. Because Nestle has extracted the water to profit from, the only way the locals in these undeveloped, impoverished nations can obtain healthy drinking water is to buy it back in the form of expensive, bottled water. In most cases the villagers are living on a very fixed income, often only a few dollars a week, drinking water is not something they can afford. Many oppositions to Nestle have accused the corporation of privatizing water to the point that the only people that can afford it will be able to drink water, which they feel is a basic human right. Nestle on the other hand, with the help of the United Nations ruled that water is a human need, not a right and offering it to undeveloped countries at a cost is legal.

Varela, J. (2013, October 16). Maine commissioner recuses himself from Nestle water case. In Aljazeera America. Retrieved November 18, 2013, from http://america.aljazeera.com/watch/shows/the-stream/the-latest/2013/10/16/stream-update-mainecommissionerrecuseshimselffromnestlewatercase.html
Lydersen, K. (2008, September 29). Bottled Water at Issue in Great Lakes. In The Washington Post. Retrieved November 14, 2013, from http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/09/28/AR2008092802997.html

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Drinking water habit

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Arnold, E 2006, ‘Bottled water drains natural resources’, Earth Policy Institute, 1 April , viewed 22 October 2013, < http://www.watershedsentinel.ca/content/bottled-water-drains-natural-resources>.…

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    * Nestlé (2002), The Nestlé Sustainability Review. Nestlé S.A. Retrieved 18 May 2012. Available at http://www.nestle.com/asset-library/Documents/Reports/CSV%20reports/Environmental%20sustainability/Sustainability_review_English.pdf…

    • 3243 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Nestle in Michigan” is a video clip on YouTube about the Nestle corporations bottled water plants with a primary focus being on the plant located in Stanwood, Michigan (Menzies, 2010). Nestle has a 99 year lease on property that only cost them $63,000, “they received $10 million in tax abatements”, and they are pumping water at a rate of 218 gallons per minute (down from the original 450 gallons per minute) (Menzies, 2010). In other words, Nestle is pumping dangerously large amounts of water that is free to them as property owners, selling it for a profit, and not being subjected to the same tax as other land owners.…

    • 692 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Business Research Ethics

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This paper will take a look at the corporate giant Nestle and some questionable behavior that goes back to the 1960’s. I will take a look at the behavior that took place with Nestle that originally started out as a dispute over the way that infant formula was made by several companies but then the focus went directly to Nestle, which lead to a boycott of the infant formula make and how this scandal changed the course of this company.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Utilitarian

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Many people believe that water is just nothing, which in a way they are somewhat correct. Have you ever looked at the label on bottled water? What do you see or better yet what don't you see. You don't see numbers on the nutritional facts of bottled water because water is just that nothing, or is it? Water makes up about 70 percent of the Earth's surface is, and the oceans hold about 96.5 percent of all Earth's water. The water bottling industry is worth over $65.9 billion dollars. Nestlé Company’s Ice Mountain bottled water plant is one of the newest companies to embark on the billion dollar industry. Nestle’ Ice Mountain company has invested $100 million to build a new 410,000-square-foot bottling plant in Mecosta County, Michigan. There is some controversy about how much is to be pumped out of the springs. Locals are staying that 262 million gallons a year is too much. Who is right? In this paper I am going to explore this case from three different perspectives utilitarian approach, the libertarian alternative, and the Rawlsian theories of justice. Then I will choose which approach I found the most helpful.…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The global consumption of bottled water was 154 billion liters in 2004, up 57 percent from the 98 billion liters consumed in 1999. Even though most of the time bottled water is no healthier than tap water, it can cost up to 10,000 times more, as much as $2.50 per liter or $10 per gallon in some areas. This is almost the price of a gallon of gas. Bottled water is consumed by half of all Americans. One in six Americans drink only bottled water. The United States consumes more bottled water than any other country on earth. In 2004, the US consumed 26 billion liters, equivalent to one 8 ounce glass per person each day (Arnold and Larsen, 2006). San Francisco, Los Angeles, Phoenix, Chicago, St. Louis, and other major cities have recently jumped on the “ban bottle water” bandwagon which makes it illegal to spend the taxpayer’s city…

    • 1784 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Tapped Documetarty Paper

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The documentary “Tapped” presents the argument of how the production of bottled water has negative effects the environment. Representatives from several different soft drink and bottled water companies then defend their company and facts about how harmful bottled water is to the environment are presented. An interview of what customers think about the product is shown, and the scene ends. This is repeated throughout the film many times. At the end of the film, the audience is supposed to be convinced not to purchase bottled water because it is slowly destroying the Earth.…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tom Standageaug also reports one fourth of the bottled water in Cleveland contained more chemicals than tap water. Almost every city regulates its tap water to make sure it is not polluted. If someone lives in the country with well water all they have to do is check it regularly. In addition, several bottled water enthusiast claim recycling solves the environmental problem. The Water Project states only one fifth of water bottles recycled. This is nothing and does not help the environment. Bottled water is worse than tap water unless there are specific circumstances.…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In this article “The Case Against Bottled Water”, Petty and Trudeau (2008) claim that people should stop drinking bottled water. The first reasons consist that tap water has more quality control than bottled water. Also, dangerous substances are found in plastic water bottles. The second reasons is about the grave environmental consequences on the consumption bottled water. Statistics about energy consumption to produce bottle water, show that it is necessary a large quantity of freshwater. In addition, high energy consumptions is required to process a bottled of water for the consumer. Moreover, the environment and the food chain are vulnerable by the number of empty bottles that are thrown in inappropriate places. The last reasons is involving…

    • 248 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    During the year 2000, Ice Mountain, a Nestle water bottling company, moved into Mecosta County, Michigan. Many Mecosta residents were thrilled to learn that Nestle decided to build their water bottling plant in their county. The plant employs about a hundred people and pays hundreds of thousands of dollars in local taxes, much to the delight of some residents and local government. They also built a 12-mile pipeline between their plant and 850 acres of private property for the purpose of pumping and selling up to 262 million gallons of water per year, much to the displeasure of the MCWC. The MCWC filed suit against Nestle alleging that the company had gone beyond reasonable use and is endangering the surrounding environment and future uses of the water. Scientists reported an adverse environmental impact, including a lowered water table and northern pike spawning difficulties. Nestle and local government officials, however, contend that the water bottling plant provides economic benefits to the community that far outweigh the small amount of water that is pumped which was reported at less than 1% of the annual recharge rate (Shaw & Barry, 2010). Is it fair to the owners of this private property to restrict the use of its water? Alternatively, does the community have a…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the biggest concerns is the loss of jobs of those that produce and ship bottled water. According to bottledwater.org, the production of bottled water “directly or indirectly employed approximately 471,700 Americans in 2013”. By getting rid of the bottled water industry, it’s getting rid of a large mass of jobs. Furthermore many have concerns about the safety of tap water. Often times people will describe their tap water as smelling strange, tasting strange, or tasting strange. In a risk perception study done at Purdue University, “Many interviewees considered health risks from sources of water when choosing what to drink” (Saylor, et al. 598). Many were concerned about the potential risks of bacteria, “I always think about the bacteria that can be floating in it…” (Saylor, et al.…

    • 1401 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “In Canada, bottled water consumption was estimated at 24.4 litres per person in 1999. By 2005, that had increased to about 60 litres per person, with sales worth $652.7 million” (CBC News, 2008). This dramatic increase in bottled water consumption does not come without severe repercussions and has caused a chain reaction of unfortunate events. Although easily available and terribly convenient, bottled water negatively effects the environment, is extremely costly, and is composed of contaminants that are unhealthy to consume. The importance of discussing this issue is advantageous because the public is unaware that tap water is more favourable than bottled water. Choosing tap water over bottled water is beneficial because it preserves the environment, is cheaper to consume, and, in most cases, is a healthier choice.…

    • 1548 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nestle operates in the U.S under multiple names such as Poland Spring, Arrowhead, and Pure Life. Executive Director, Food and Water Watch, Wenonah Hauter said, "Nestle is one of the largest profiteer from bottle water, they basically come into rural towns and do water mining." (4:20) The author explains where the water corporation goes to specific rural towns where water is not controlled by the government. What is smart about the water corporation is that they went to this small town in Maine, where in Maine there is a law that says "He who has the biggest pump will control water" (6:09).…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One problem has to do with what's in the bottles themselves. The Earth Policy Institute reports that 1.5 million barrels of oil per year, which is enough to fuel 100,000 cars for that same year, are required to satisfy Americans' demand for bottled water. That's because PET, or polyethylene terephthalate, the plastic used in water bottles, is derived from crude oil. And, according to the Earth Policy Institute article "Bottled Water: Pouring Resources Down the Drain," by Emily Arnold and Janet Larsen, this oil is being used to make some 2.7 million tons of plastic each year for bottling water around the globe.…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tapped was a documentary that discussed the harmful effects that the bottled water industry has environmentally, biologically, and socially. There are a few topics that relate to the topic outline. The first is the second topic outline: “Global Economics”, more specifically “Tragedy of the Commons.” In the film, it seemed like big corporations such as Nestle went into small towns and counties, such as the Chaffee county, and abused the commons: water, in this case. They bought property with water and drained it dry without any notice to the locals.…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays