Before I begin discussing these two topics, we must fully understand what they mean. The definition in the dictionary states that, multiculturalism consists of, relates to, or is designed for the cultures of several different races. Whereas the word melting pot is not a term used in the dictionary. For the purpose of this assignment I will make up my own definition for both these terms.
Multiculturalism to me is defined as abundant amounts of cultures in one area. Or it is simply a society where many different types of people with diverse cultural backgrounds, religion, and traditional values and beliefs cohabit peacefully with one another. It is the unification of diverse cultures, multilingual talents, and the ability to accept one another. (Although this may not actually happen)
Others see it as the union of all creeds, colors, religion that is free from prejudice, an open minded group of people who are able to step beyond themselves and explore each others interests while keeping their own interests and lastly allowing oneself and others the flexibility to be able to express one's thoughts and definition of culture that is free from ridicule.
The term multiculturalism is usually used in reference to Canada more than it is to the U.S. However if we take a closer look, America is also multicultural, but they believe in the melting pot idea.
Multiculturalism does not mean the same thing to everyone. Before we can address the advantages or disadvantages of a multicultural society, we need to understand these differing viewpoints.
Melting pot: The word melt can mean to be dissolved. The image that I get when I think about this term, is a group of many different; diverse people that are being assimilated or dissolved into one people, the American people. It is where newcomers melt into the American way of life. Basically it is viewing yourself as an American first, and then your ethnic background second. This is the exact opposite idea from that of multiculturalism. However some multiculturalists consider the "melting pot" a metaphor for oppressive assimilation. To them, the only way you can melt in the pot is by assimilating--becoming similar to--the dominant or "hegemonic" white culture.
Strengths and Weaknesses:
Multiculturalism:
First we must understand that no nation is born multicultural. It is the people and way of life that determine this factor.
Multiculturalism was set up as a national symbol for Canadians and fulfilled the need for a distinctive Canadian identity.
As a political tool multiculturalism has several uses. The meeting of different life views, cultures, beliefs, religions, ethnic habits, etc.
Diversity is about accepting the whole person including the culture he or she brings - the customs, gestures, dress, voice quality, patterns of speech, hairstyles etc. Differences are okay to have.
Multicultural diversity is what results of centuries of immigration. All Canadians, including the Native People, can trace their origins to an immigrant past. Only about 16% of today's Canadian citizens were born outside of Canada. By recognizing multiculturalism as a fundamental characteristic of Canadian identity and national heritage, Canadians of all cultural origins have the opportunity to contribute to the common goals of equality, sharing, social justice and economic prosperity.
It also maintains ancestral ethnic and cultural ties while simultaneously feeling a part of Canada.
Culture helps people understand life; from the different types of background and races is how we educate ourselves and look at things from a different perspective.
Given these strengths and advantages, it does not indicate that there are no flaws in this system. The following reasons are a perfect example of this.
In the unpleasant world of practical politics, multiculturalism encourages quotas over competition. That is the problem: On the one hand, they want all heritages and groups to be equal. On the other hand, they want some to be more equal than others.
Canada is a multicultural nation, but unfortunately both racism and prejudice still exist.
When looked at, you are viewed in terms of some group category: race, ethnicity, class, gender, nationality, etc
One cannot take up multiculturalism and expect students to see each other as individual human beings.
Historically, diversity has torn nations apart.
Finally a successful multicultural society is one that learns to appreciate the needs of others and not just their own cultural needs.
Melting Pot:
The idea of a 'Melting Pot' is to provide an environment where new ideas can be advised and advanced, where people can invite others to share their influential thinking, where people can discover others working in similar areas and with whom they may wish to begin teamwork, where public and private exchanges can occur as we all try to move forward in our thinking and experience.
With this idea we are more patriotic to the Country that we live in, like in America people consider themselves American above all.
It is a way of understanding American identity.
Puts everyone as an equal person by bringing them together as one culture, because they are know as an American.
Causes America to put up a flag of all the cultures represented.
America is a melting pot because all different cultures are represented here. Immigrants from all over the world gather together in the "land of opportunity" to share their ideals, however this is not always good and it has flaws just like the multicultural system.
We are all different, inside and outside, to be melted away means to take away something.
By being in a melting pot system we don't have the chance to educate ourselves and our children about history, and the different cultures, which they should obviously know about.
Although the immigrants are considered as an American in this system, they know that when asked who they are, they should respond with the answer: "I am American." However inside they realize that their background is not really an American, because they were not born in America. I think that some Americans (those born in America, feel challenged by the other people.)
We often forget about who we are, because in this system it is considered second.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
P1 – Explain the Range of Meanings Attached to Citizenship, Diversity and the Associated Terminology
Multiculturalism is the doctrine that several different cultures (rather than one national culture) can coexist peacefully and equitably in a single country. An example of multiculturalism in the public services was recorded in the results of the Citizenship Survey where respondents were asked whether they felt they would be treated better or worse than those of other races by 15 public services. Those that felt they would be treated…
- 1303 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Multiculturalism- This is the presence and acceptance of a variety of different religious cultures within a community or society. The idea of Multiculturalism is that all cultures are treated fairly and…
- 1188 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Multiculturalism- the concept that different cultural groups exist side by side within the same culture and the belief that the heritage of each should be understood and respected.…
- 431 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
|Melting pot |Diverse racial or ethnic groups or both, forming a new creation, a new cultural entity. |…
- 525 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
What does Diversity and Multiculturalism mean to me? I believe that diversity has become so much more than just the basic qualities of race or gender. It now includes all qualities that make everyone unique, as individuals or as part of a larger group. It is also the acceptance, respect, and understanding of these unique qualities that makes diversity work in a given society. Multiculturalism is the system that is centered around the respect for and the promotion of ethnic and or gender diversity in the society. Multiculturalism is the status of several different ethnic, racial, religious or cultural groups co-existing in the same society. Today, in the U.S. we already live in a diverse, multicultural world, where popular culture has introduced us to others’ foods, music, histories, customs, and more. Moreover, the predictions that a multiplicity of infusions from culture to culture will continue unabated – and that we must develop a respect for others if we are to be active, engaged participants in the new world order (Green, 1998).…
- 1374 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Multiculturalism is the appreciation, acceptance or promotion of multiple cultures. Multiculralists believe that in a multi-ethnic society, culture difference should be preserved and celebrated because such a vision sees diversity as a positive force, increasing richness of communities and actually encouraging tolerance.…
- 410 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
|Melting pot |The diverse racial or ethnic or both , forming a new creation and a new cultural entity. |…
- 1022 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The focus on multiculturalism started in the 1960s as minority issues became more prevalent in society, especially in the Anglo dominated countries such as North America. Multicultural was primarily defined in association to race or ethnicity. The focus has broadened to include age, gender, religion, sexual preferences, and social class. Much of the focus on multicultural issues was directed toward issues in society regarding equality; many were caused and generated by political biases, programs, and policies. Nagayama Hall (2010) stated, “Multicultural psychology is the study of the influences of multiple cultures in a single social context on human behavior” (p. 8).…
- 1170 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Multiculturalism is defined as a government policy recognizing and promoting the various cultural groups that live in Canada. Most of Canada's multiculturalism is due to the amount and…
- 535 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Often, I have heard the United States referred to as the “melting pot” due to its…
- 926 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
A melting pot refers to the idea that there are multiple races in America. Some people argue that there is or may not be a melting pot in America due to the perception of American actions. After reading and listening to both sides of the argument and explanations as to if America is or is not a melting pot, I’ve came to the conclusion that America is not a melting pot. Instead we are more of a of salad. Heres why!…
- 513 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
First things first, what is multiculturalism? Multiculturalism is diversity of two or more culture in some region or country. Canada was the first country to declare multiculturalism as official approach. It is a procedure for engaging diversity as different yet equivalent. Multiculturalism guarantees that all citizens can keep their identities, can take pride in their ancestry and have a sense of belonging. Acceptance gives people a feeling of security and assurance which will be making them more open to and tolerating of diverse cultures. All Canadians are guaranteed equality under the eye of the law and equality of opportunity no matter of their origins. Canada’s laws and policies perceive Canada’s diversity by race, cultural legacy,…
- 486 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
To begin with, the term multiculturalism has different meanings and associations. Multiculturalism can mean an ideal of cultural variety, and it can describe the…
- 874 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
American was dominated by the image of the melting pot that “melts up” all race differences and cultures to become on American culture. The ideas of multiculturalism started at the end of the nineteenth century and turned into the concept of cultural pluralism that defined the nation as a mixture of diverse ethnicities with different cultural backgrounds, all co-existing and contributing to the new nation.…
- 4293 Words
- 18 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Define the following terms. You may use definitions from the class readings, or from outside sources. If your definitions are from outside sources, cite the source(s) using APA style with in-text citations and a reference list.…
- 394 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays