Nov.10, 2012
Dr. Boria
Philsophy 306
Moral Theory: Abortion
After hearing a criticism of abortion by Don Marquis, and a defense of it by Judith Thomson I still haven’t changed my opinion on how I feel about it. I did enjoy the insight brought forward by both Marquis and Thomson, and the analogies, but the fact is I am prochoice with abortion, and that is where I stand with the issue. I am prochoice partially because I am not very religious and I don’t allow that to sway my decision. Not to mention the fact you brought up in class how a lot of very conservative Christians tend to neglect what the Bible says about it in the 21st chapter of Exodus, “the Law of Israel commands a penalty of death for murder but only a fine for causing a pregnant woman to have a miscarriage.” Besides the fact that I don’t allow religion to play a role in abortion, I personally don’t think men have any say so on the issue at all. After all they don’t have to deal with any part of a pregnancy other than for moral support, and of course if they want to keep the child or not. As far as abortion involving rape I think it is strictly up to the woman whether or not they would like to keep it, but I would assume in most cases considering it is unplanned I would doubt the likelihood of a mother wanting to keep the child of a rapist. As far as late abortions it really starts becoming a bit of a complicated issue, but it sounds like there are already a lot of state laws regarding up to when a woman can have one. I think the average is up to 25 weeks depending on the state. In conclusion I am prochoice, because why should anyone decide whether or not they want to keep the child besides the mother, and father? This isn’t up to some politician or a conservative religious person it should be up to whoever’s body it is.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The debate over whether abortion should be legal and to what point in the pregnancy it should be allowed has polarized many societies. Many religious preach that at the moment of conception, the new life is human and possesses a soul. Therefore, abortion is murder. Other, less extreme views, suggest the life is not human until there is a recognizable "completion of form." A third view proposes we have an obligation to create a good life for all children already born before we bring more unwanted children into the world.…
- 726 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
There has been an ongoing controversy surrounding the moral and legal status of abortion. The two main groups involved are the pro-choice movement (the right of women to choose whether to keep the fetus) and the pro-life movement (the right of the unborn child to be born).…
- 689 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The issue of abortion and how it relates to moral principles is an ethical issue as it is an interference with the natural, causing many disagreements with views on the rights of those involved including both parents and the unborn child; as well as moral principles and religious views. Ethical, meaning relating to a moral principles. Therefore abortion being an ethical issue due to the various viewpoints around the issue causing great disagreements. The main viewpoint I will be analysing is that of the Catholic Church. The church’s view, different views within the church and views from outside the church.…
- 1335 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
: Two arguments that goes against late-term abortion being immoral is subjectivism and utilitarianism. Subjectivism portrays that everyone has his or her own set of morals and that there is no one right way. A subjectivist’s opinion on the subject would argue that a person's view and choice in terms of late abortion is personal to their specific position.…
- 555 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
This paper explores the two contrasting views on abortion by giving arguments against and for abortion. These views are broken up into both pro-choice or pro-life activists and their beliefs on abortion. Pro-choice activist believe that a woman should ultimately make their own decision to their bodies. In contrast, pro-life activist believe that all life should be preserved. This paper examines the ceaseless debate from both parties and the different pressures in life that can influence a woman to have an abortion.…
- 846 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The debate over the choice to have an abortion and the timeline used to say when an abortion should be allowed is one that has caused much divide in society and in the courtroom. There are varying views and opinions from the moment of conception being a soul and when a fetus is considered human. There are also those who suggest that babies are not actually human until they are completely formed. A third group and the one that I choose to side with is that a woman has the right to their body and that they should have the ability to have an abortion in cases where they see fit or when it is deemed medically necessary. I believe that abortion should be up to each individual woman to decide if it best suits their individual needs when the possibility of life and death is at stake. The problem with abortion is there are many that hold the opinion that abortion is never justified and in my opinion that is absurd. I believe that every woman should have the ability or at the least the possibility of her choice in aborting an unwanted child as long as it is justifiable; since she will be the one responsible for this creation not the law or even those in society that feel abortion is wrong. Therefore, she herself should dictate her choices and not others. This responsibility is not something that should be taken lightly as there are many needs of not only the mother but the fetus itself once it is born. The parent must be able to care nurture and provide for this individual for a very long time and the mother should be…
- 2864 Words
- 12 Pages
Good Essays -
Death is morally wrong according to American ethics and values so is the killing of unborn fetuses morally wrong as well? A fetus is considered a human life because life begins at the moment of conception. Abortions are painful, inhumane, and dangerous for the child, the mother, and the mother 's health. Women should not have an abortion because it is an act of taking human life, can result in medical complications later in life, and to complete the process the mother and her baby must go through horrific procedures.…
- 2388 Words
- 10 Pages
Better Essays -
Ever since the idea/decision of abortion there has been arguments if it is moral are not. Very many people are strongly against it and state very good information on why but I'm pro abortion. I'm pro abortion because first of all it should really be up to women if its legal or not because its their bodies that have to go through the process of fetal extraction. There are some circumstances in which an abortion is needed. Lets say a high school couple happens to get pregnant they're not very capable to take care of a baby and be parents. A baby would compound the already existing problems a teen already has like school, sports, getting ready for college. Thats not life for a baby especially an unwanted one, what kind of quality of life is that for the baby or parents. What if the expectant parents of that baby aren't fit to be parents having problems with drugs and alcohol no one should grow up around that. If the baby did it could possibly follow in the corrupt footsteps of its failing parents and end up doing the same things. If women are forced to carry unwanted pregnancies to term the result is unwanted children which then when they grow up are at a disadvantage, and sometimes inclined toward brutal behavior to others. Now even God forbid let's say some woman had been raped and she has gotten pregnant because of that, she is probably going to want an abortion. This may sound vulgar and mean but what women would want to keep that baby and look at him or her and every day and be reminded of that time where she was highly helpless and being taken advantage of. No one should have to keep reliving that moment over and over again that would be very traumatic. Now the big problems why abortion should be legal came out in the 1973 case of Roe vs Wade. This case came along after women started having behind the scenes abortions where women had it done by coat hangers and dirty instruments to perform these highly dangerous procedures usually done on…
- 934 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Amelia is a 23 year old Hispanic woman who has a variety of issues that range from her drug addiction which has caused her 4 children to be removed from her home, to a current unwanted pregnancy.…
- 814 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
For assignment number two I chose an article from The New York Times on abortion. The article is titled: When Abortion becomes birth: A Dilemma of Medical Ethics Shaken by New Advances (New York Times). The main ethical question following this article is: when if ever is an abortion ethical according to deontology? Abortion by dictionary definition is “the deliberate termination of a human pregnancy, most often performed during the first 28 weeks of pregnancy” (“Abortion.” Merriam-Webster). Abortion is one of the most controversial ethical issues because it concerns the taking of a human life. Anti-abortion regulations first began to appear in the United States during the 1820s. Although the most influential case was the Roe Vs…
- 658 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“However, we might oppose it, Abortion is a sad feature of modern life” (Casey). A mother's womb should be a safe place for a child, it shouldn't be an alternative. It should be illegal because abortion is the murder of a child, federal law has already been passed to protect the unborn, and they have an adoption center for a reason.…
- 597 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
One of the western world's most controversial ethical issues in today's society is the act of abortion and its legislation. Abortion is the process in which a baby is killed whilst still in the mother's womb. This is performed for a variety of reasons. Due to the severity of the consequences of an abortion and the moral and religious elements involved, this is an ethical controversy and has divided people for decades.…
- 1936 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
Pretend for a moment you are a woman or young girl, and try to place yourself in their place in the following scenarios. Case #1: A 13-year-old girl crying confused and frightened watches her boyfriend walk out of her life after she tells him she is pregnant. She thought he loved her. Case #2: A woman finds out she is pregnant with her sixth child. Her husband is out of work and the five children they already have must go to bed hungry most nights. She asks herself, how can I feed another one? Case #3: A career minded young woman having just earned her nursing degree finds out she is pregnant. Her husband, a doctor, is already putting in loads of overtime at the hospital. When would they have time for a baby? Case #4: A woman is about to go home after shopping all day, and on the way to her car she is forced into an alley at gun point, and brutally raped. Case #5: A super model finds out she has gotten pregnant after an affair with her photographer. Of course she can 't have a baby, having a baby would end her modeling career. Case #6: A woman while pregnant contracts a disease which in nine out of ten cases causes birth defects, and therefore her doctor advises an…
- 1769 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
"Abortion Facts - Students for Life: Pro Life Youth, Anti-Abortion Facts, and Pro-Life Training." Students for Life. Alan Guttmacher Institute, n.d. Web. 11 Nov. 2012. <http://studentsforlife.org/prolifefacts/abortion-facts/>.…
- 917 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Abortion is a very touchy subject with very little middle ground. Every year around one-million developing fetuses are aborted for various reasons, usually financial problems. While technological advancements in medical science have made abortion a simple step to avoid unwanted pregnancies there are still negative repercussions. Abortion, specifically late stage abortion, should not be accepted by our society because the fetus can feel pain at 20 weeks, abortions are thinning the population of minority groups, and the child is never given a chance.…
- 597 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays