Preview

Miss

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
927 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Miss
Topic: ‘You, and only you, Madame, are answerable for the dishonour which has befallen me.’ To what extent is Bertrande to blame for the situation confronting the Guerre family?

The wife of Martine Guerre by Janet Lewis is a 16thcentury love store set in the bleak and harsh society of medieval France. The main protagonist in the novel, Betrande De Roles is faced with an unusual and appalling situation when an imposter poses as her husband Martin, who has been absent for 8 years. Despite the belief of her husband, Bertrand is not to blame for the awful situation, but instead it is the family and those surrounding Betrande who are to blame for her acceptance of the imposter, ArnaueDeTil. Her husband’s sisters, Martins Uncle, the priest , her son Sanxi, Martin and even the imposter, ArnauDeTil, himself are all equally, if not more to blame for the situation that confronts the Guerre family.

Bertrand lives the life that many women with well-off families lead in medieval France; she is married at the age of 11 and goes to live with the family of her betrothed husband at the age of 14. Although Bertrande and Martin initially do not care for one another (on their wedding night Martin hits Betrande, and when they are forced to share a bed, she is fearful of him), after a period of living together, Betrande and Martin find themselves attached to one another, and they share a special bond within the household “they were a camp within a camp”. Shortly after Betrande gives birth to a son, Sanxi and the household flourishes and prospers. When Martin decides to leave, due to fear of punishment from his father after stealing grain to plant his field, the peace and happiness within the household that Betrande and the family have so become accustom to, is disrupted. The untimely death of Martins Mother is an indication of how unstable the household becomes “she was not an old woman and it may have been possible, as her daughters believed that the illness which she

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    During the sixteenth century, the role of men and women within society were distinctly determined and demonstrated in France. When it came to marriage, men had to remain faithful to his wife, while women also had to remain faithful to her husband. It was the man’s job to take care of his family and wife by being the provider. It was the woman’s job to keep honor to the family by being loyal wives and attentive mothers. Both the husband and wife were responsible to uphold these roles because divorce was not an option through the eyes of the church. In the sixteenth century, marriages were usually arranged at a very young age for both men and women in order to gain prosperity and property. In the novel The Return of Martin Guerre, Natalie Zemon Davis uses characters such as Bertrande and Martin/Arnaud to represent gender and marriage roles that were common during the sixteenth century in rural…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The Return of Martin Guerre” by Natalie Zemon Davis provides the read with an interesting case of a present, Arnaud du Tihl, stealing Martin Guerre identity and almost getting away with it. The story create two campus of thought on Bertrande’s motive. One side being defended by Davis, and arguing she masterminded the whole plan. While Robert Finlay arguing she was innocent. Davis argument is the most believable with too many questions and too many assumption, and to neatly package together that points to Bertrande being guilty of helping Amaund du Tihl stealing Guerre identity.…

    • 1484 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The thesis or themes that Natalie Zemon Davis discusses throughout the book have to deal mostly with Bertrande and the impersonation of Martin Guerre. Why did Bertrande go along with “Martin’s” lies? Was she lonely? Or does Bertrande take advantage of the opportunity to have a better husband and lover than she did before? At one point, Zemon Davis seems to hypothesize that Bertrande is in a conspiracy to coordinate her stories with Martin, even though she knows he is an impostor. Is this to say that she was willing to risk her life to keep their marriage and her love for “Martin”, Armand du Tilh alive? How is it that “Martin” kept the stories of the real Martin’s life in order? Zemon Davis discusses the fact that it was easy for the Deguerres to change their identities to the Guerres when they moved to Artigat, so maybe the changing of Armand du Tilh to “Martin” wasn’t as hard as it would seem. The fact that most peasants were illiterate and didn’t have…

    • 1621 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    I don't think that Arnaud du Tilh, Bertrand de Rols, and Martin Guerre knew each other before the trial. Arnaud and Martin may have met somewhere out on the battlefields across Europe. Arnaud went across Europe and was later told by some people that he looked like Martin so that's when he probably inquired about his life so he could "return" to his home and take over his life. He always asked questions about Martin's life and began to gain knowledge about his life and everything that happened in his life. When he had enough information to take over his life, he went to his house and proclaimed that he was Martin. When in actuality the old Martin wasn't literate and he was much nicer to Bertrand, he wanted to have much more sex with her too. They eventually produced a child together and everyone seemed to agree that they liked the new martin better. It seemed as though everything was going great until Martin wanted to collect on the profits he missed out during the 8 years he was missing. After doing so, his uncle didn't like the idea and considered him an imposter and then threatened legal action. Bertrand knew always that it was not the real Martin but she played a long anyway. I believe she did so because she likes this Martin…

    • 644 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The return of Martin Guerre is a story of a peasant who left his wife, Bertrande and his son. After several years, a man called Arnaud du Tilh impersonated Martin Guerre, stole his identity and lived under Martin’s name for three years until he became accused of this act. He almost convinced the court that he was Martin Guerre until the real Martin walked into the curt. Davis, the author of the book illustrates why Martin Guerre left his family and inheritance, how the imposter came into Bertrande’s life , and how economic and religion were playing a role in the sixteenth century society.…

    • 1592 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Martin Guerre's Return

    • 1327 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Those who testified claimed that Pansette was not an imposter, until a man walks in claiming to be the real Martin Guerre. Martin’s family, including Bertrande, admits that this man is, in fact, the real Martin. Pansette finally confesses that he is not Martin and learned everything he knew about him through Martin himself. Although Pansette is found guilty, the court frees Bertrande from prosecution as a collaborator. This is because the court holds the real Martin Guerre to be partially responsible for not acting as a true husband. This issue is considered so serious because it is an issue of property. By pretending to be another man, Pansette is taking another man’s wife and stealing his wealth. During the 16th century, crimes against property, such as theft and arson, were punishable by execution (Wahl, “Counter Reformation”…

    • 1327 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The notion of Bertrande de Rols in The Wife of Martin Guerre as having good intentions suggests not only that she was mindful of her own feelings in her pursuit of the truth, but also of the feelings of others. However, Bertrande's intentions were to cleanse her soul and absolve herself from sin by indicting the impostor, Arnaud du Tilh. Yet, she undertakes this task considering the despair it would inflict upon the mesnie. These actions also are detrimental to Bertrande in causing her perhaps the most anguish and grief of all. Bertrande intends to uphold the status quo, yet she has due knowledge that pathway to the greater good will be harmful to her and the Mesnie.…

    • 676 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    But even more than simply outlining the facts of the story, Davis also uses her research to enlighten us on the roles of different family members in 16th Century rural French life, the politics of family life and peasant life in general, and the role of the growing shift from Catholicism to Protestantism among the elite as well as the peasant classes. In relation to family and marriage life, Davis uses Bertrande de Rols, Martin Guerre's wife, as an example of a strong, virtuous woman with familial duty and an obstinate nature. Davis uses this characterization to explain how de Rols was not a weak-minded woman who was so easily duped by her missing husband's impostor, but was rather a woman who was in love and used her strength in order to facilitate her new relationship with Arnaud du Tilh. "Either by explicit or tacit agreement, she helped him become her husband." Bertrande de Rols, according to Davis, is an example of the more broad-minded and less misogynist peasant society of the village of Artigat in 16th Century France. Through Bertrande de Rols, we learn about how surprisingly fair the law was towards women: The testaments in the area around Artigat rarely benefit one child but instead provide dowries for the daughters.... (If there are only daughters, the property is divided equally among them). (11) Another aspect of the book is, it is also a deeper historical chronicle of changes in the shift from French Catholicism to the "new religion" of Protestantism. She uses the new Martin Guerre and Bertrande de Rols entire relationship to characterize the relaxing religious laws that were seeping into courtrooms and the higher classes as well as the fields and the peasant classes. Davis argues that the new religion might have been of interest to the new Martin Guerre and Bertrande de Rols because it supported their illicit relationship…

    • 1456 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bertrande's Transformation

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The novel The Wife of Martin Guerre by Janet Lewis tell the story of Bertrande’s life as a woman in France in the 16th century. Bertrande de Rols was married at age eleven to Martin Guerre through an arrange marriage in hopes of fixing the a feud between the two peasant families in Artigues. Bertrande goes from being a scared child to a strong women trying to defend her family only to be condemned for her actions in the end.…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The engrossing novella entitled ‘The wife of Martin Guerre' remarks on the inadequacies of Artigues' justice system in dealing with moral dilemmas in the rural village. Lewis' interpretation of a true historical incident that occurred in 1539, questions what human values and qualities their legal and social system suppresses when formulated on behalf of the community. Characters in ‘The wife of Martin Guerre' exist without questioning the mandates of social structure, and consequently these customs that guarantee the community's protection, concomitantly damage and restrictively inhibit individuals. Lewis induces readers ultimately to query the existence of a legal which is reliant on narrowness and rigidity, when its objective is to satisfy the needs of elaborate and intricate individuals. Evidently, the legal…

    • 1469 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lais of Marie de France

    • 1041 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Marie begins her collection of lais with the story of Guigemar, a noble knight who is cursed with the task of finding true love to heal a physical injury. This lay introduces two types of love: selfish and selfless. Selfish love is not courtly love. It lacks devotion and true loyalty. It lacks suffering and self-denial. Marie de France portrays this kind of love in the old husband of the woman whom Guigemar loves. The man locks his wife away in an enclosure guarded by a castrated man. By doing this, the husband shows a mean, limited devotion to his wife; perhaps even worse, he limits her ability to experience true love. This kind of love does not last; in fact, the husband is cuckolded when his wife has a year-long affair with Guigemar. He is made a fool, the dupe of love.…

    • 1041 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Miss

    • 2737 Words
    • 11 Pages

    1.1 Outline how risks to health safety and security can be minimised in an organisation or service.…

    • 2737 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Honor In Old Regime

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages

    This excerpt highlights how aristocratic privilege trumped concepts of ‘honor’ in Old Regime France and exasperated class tensions over aristocratic privilege. According to Loyseau, in early modern France, the social hierarchy of the three Estates was “. . . willingly observed through honor, and certainly they are more honorable when they come from a voluntary respect . . .” (Loyseau 17). Without the observance of honor and rank, Loyseau claimed “there would only be confusion among us.” (Loyseau 17). Consequently, the chevalier in the case, a noble, should never have pursued Noailles, the daughter of a merchant. Although Noailles resisted the chevalier’s advances because of the difference in their ranks, the chevalier continued to pursue her, leading to her kidnapping and, to protect her honor in the aftermath of the kidnapping, their…

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Manon Lescaut, an 18th century French novel by Abbé Prévost, originally titled “The Story of the Chevalier des Grieux and Manon Lescaut” is an erotic picaresque, a moral tale, and a biographical narration all at once. It relates the story of a couple of young lovers, who struggle to overcome numerous obstacles, while they are being pursued by forces stronger than them. The author structures his narrative so that the reader has full access into the hero’s mind, while we only see the heroine through the eyes of others, mainly des Grieux’s. De Grieux introduces himself as a man of noble upbringing and even nobler disposition, gentle, dignified, and with a tendency toward a virtuous conduct. Fate has it that he meets Manon by chance and he is instantly captivated by her charms.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Simple Heart

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages

    At Madame Aubain’s, Felicite enters a routine which makes her life seem orderly. By conscientious work, she makes herself necessary to the family. Most important to her happiness is her increased freedom to love.…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics