Preview

Mesopotamia and Egypt Comparative Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
879 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Mesopotamia and Egypt Comparative Essay
Matthew B
Owens
World History AP-3
21 September 2011
Mesopotamia and Egypt Comparative Essay
While both the Egyptian and Mesopotamian civilizations share similar political, social and economic qualities, the details of these broad spectrums branch off in opposite directions. For example, both Mesopotamia and Egypt were ruled by kings, but in Egypt, their kings were called pharaohs and they had significantly more power than the Mesopotamian kings of the city-states. Both civilizations also had social classes in which a person fit into, but in Mesopotamia, many more rules and restrictions were forced onto women, especially young girls, than Mesopotamian boys or Egyptian boys or girls. Both Mesopotamia and Egypt traded with each other, but the goods they traded were completely dependent of their civilization’s special needs.
Pharaohs played a powerful role in the Egyptian society, more so than the kings did in the Mesopotamian civilization. Although both rulers had great responsibilities such as leading their armies, managing their civilizations, and ruling over the people in their jurisdiction, the Egyptian pharaohs ruled over much more land and people than the Mesopotamian kings did. This is because Mesopotamia was divided into small city-states in which one king was assigned to, but in Egypt the pharaoh ruled over the entire civilization and was expected to bring them wealth and prosperity. The pharaohs were even thought to have godly powers and used them to communicate with other gods to protect the Egyptians from the flooding of the Nile and other disasters.
Socially, Mesopotamia and Egypt are very similar in such ways like they both have social classes. Both Mesopotamian and Egyptian social classes strongly reflect one another with the priests and kings at the top, followed by the wealthy people, then the common people, then the slaves, however in Egypt, slaves could climb up the social ladder by marrying someone in another class. In Mesopotamia, slaves

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Egypt developed around the Nile River, while Mesopotamia developed between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers. Egypt and Mesopotamia grew into complex civilizations. Politically, both Egypt and Mesopotamia had a government with one main ruler, but Egypt had a centralized government with a pharaoh, while Mesopotamia had a decentralized government with a king. Socially, both civilizations were patriarchal, but Egypt was more lenient towards women while Mesopotamia was stricter. The political and social structures of Egypt and Mesopotamia both similarities and differences.…

    • 897 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mesopotamia and Egypt are similar in a variety of ways, especially considering that Mesopotamia pre-dates Egypt, so it is easy to see the connections between the two. One of the major difference between the two societies was how their systems of class worked, Mesopotamia was more fair towards all people rather than Egypt which was extremely bias and segregated. Furthermore, they varied in the ways they punished convicts, but shared similarities in punishments for capital crimes. Lastly, there were many similarities between the women in both societies, which relates back to Egypt being a later version of Mesopotamia essentially.…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the ancient world, Egypt and Mesopotamia coexisted between 3000 and 2000 B.C.E. Throughout this essay, I will be comparing and contrasting these two prominent ancient civilizations. Both had many cultural and political differences between them. Although ancient Egypt and ancient Mesopotamia shared similarities in beliefs and agriculture, they differed greatly in afterlife and documentation.…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The root of the differences between the Mesopotamian cultures lies within the politics. The two cultures operated very differently as Mesopotamia was ruled regionally while Egypt used a more centralized government. Kings in the Mesopotamian region formed city states ruled by leaders of their armies while they just oversaw what was going on via these mediums. On the other hand, Egyptian culture featured “god-kings” or pharaohs that controlled much larger expanses of land than Mesopotamian leaders did. Logically, it makes sense that this would occur because of the differences in influence for these two regions. For example, unification of Egypt was inspired by Sudan’s use of small kingdoms that governed the agriculture of the rulers. The Egyptians then faced competition which caused their small kingdoms to conquer neighboring kingdoms to the point where they controlled much larger territories. The notion of kings and pharaohs leads into another difference. Mesopotamian societies featured monarchies as they were led by kings while Egyptians had a theocracy as pharaohs were divine rulers. In Mesopotamia it is figured that their monarchs evolved from men making decisions on behalf of their whole…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Egypt vs Mesopotamia

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The social structure of both civilization were different. The Egyptian upper class were mainly pharaohs (the supreme central ruler). Under the Pharaohs, there were the peasants, who supplied all the labor for agriculture. The Egyptian social classes were not like the classes of the Mesopotamian civilization. The Mesopotamian classes were more defined classes. The Mesopotamian upper class was based on, elected leaders and military powers. Under that were the religious class, then the free commoners, and finally the peasant class. The Egyptian civilization not only had less defined classes, but also their pharaohs, which weren’t genetically selected, had a chance of serving some high political offices, like tax collectors.…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although both Mesopotamia and Egypt developed along major river valleys, each have established different political, economical, social and even religious customs. Their differing geographic makeups have shaped each civilizations existence. The root of the difference is caused by the fact that Mesopotamia was unguarded, the crossroads of civilizations, while Egypt was highly protected on many sides by natural barriers. From a political view, Mesopotamia and Egypt are fairly similar, with certain opposing features. Mesopotamia was led by a monarchy with one ruler holding the power.…

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Known as one of the earliest civilizations, Mesopotamia and Egypt both share set amounts of similarities along with a share of striking distinctions. Environmentally, these two civilizations were formed in similar surroundings, yet their weather patterns show distinctions. Politically, both governments derived from a monarch, yet their laws and punishments distinguished the two’s court systems. Economically, they both shared prosperous success in similar manners. Socially, although the two lands followed a hierarchy, the value of women contrasted. Culturally, they both believed in a higher order of creation; however, their views of them were polar opposites. Intellectually, these two societies developed skilled abilities and creations that changed history forever.…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mesopotamian society and Ancient Egypt have many similarities and differences when comparing them to each other. For example, they are both located near rivers, as water provided an area to hunt and fish and if the river flooded, the land would become fertile. Each society has their unique way of doing things, but they also have similarities in their ways.…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia have many similarities, but also many differences. They had similarities in social values, religious views and economic surplus, and differences in social values, political values, writing, religious views and economic surplus; they had more differences than similarities.…

    • 358 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mesopotamia and Egypt are the two of the several remarkable civilizations that have had a vast impact on our present day society. Both were similar socially as they had comparable social class systems, agricultural societies, and woman’s roles. However, both differ in view of after life, the status of a king or ruler, as well as the process of death. The main reasons to why these two civilizations were so successful were due to the fact of their incredibly similar social characteristics.…

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Between 3500-500 BCE, Mesopotamia and Egypt were both seen as major civilization. Although they are both ancient river civilizations and have many similarities, there are multiple differences between their religion, social structure, and political systems. Three similarities between Mesopotamia, and Egypt is that they were both patriarchal societies, both had written languages, and had education. They are both patriarchal societies as evidenced by Egypt having Pharaohs and Mesopotamia having Kings. They both had written languages as evidenced by multiple findings of slabs of clay with symbols, also known as cuneiform writing, in Mesopotamia and hieroglyphic writing on sheets of papyrus in Egypt. They both had an education system as evidenced by the Mesopotamian study of astronomy and mathematics and the Egyptian finding of “The Satire of the Trades.” Patriarchal societies are a similarity between Egypt and Mesopotamia because Egypt was primarily ruled by a pharaoh which was always a male figure. Also, Egypt had built such a strong patriarchal society that they had given men authority over public and private affairs. The women had routinely performed the domestic work in upper elites and in wealthy households. Mesopotamia, much like Egypt, also had a patriarchal society where the men had authority over both public and private affairs. Within their households the men decided the work that family members would perform and made marriage arrangements for their children as well as any others who came under their authority. Men also ruled as kings and made the decisions about policies and public affairs. The men even had power to sell their wives and children into slavery to satisfy their debts. Although women had made their influence felt in Mesopotamian society. Women sometimes advised kings and their governments. A few women wielded great power as high priestesses who managed the enormous estates belonging to their temples. Women also pursued careers as midwives,…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mesopotamia and Egypt

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Mesopotamian (in modern day Iraq) and Egyptian (in modern day Egypt) civilizations flourished around 3500 BCE. They were River Valley civilizations that thrived on agriculture. During their reign, they were very prosperous and shared similarities and differences. Differences between them were that Mesopotamia’s environment hindered their civilization in warfare and agriculture while Egypt’s environment strengthened it and in their patriarchy society, women were treated more as equals to men in Egypt than in Mesopotamia. They were similar in ways such as, they both incorporated and influenced the culture of neighboring peoples. The environment in Egypt has special features that the Mesopotamia lacked that ensured a prosperous civilization. Women were entitled to rights in Egypt that only men were allowed to have in Mesopotamia. However, they both gained new cultures and tools by traveling peoples and left their marks on other civilizations.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Compare Contrast

    • 1533 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Ancient Egypt, known as “The Gift of the Nile,” and ancient Mesopotamia, known as the land “Between the Rivers,” were the first two civilizations developed by mankind. Not only this is a double-negative that you do not need.] These were they the first civilizations to form, andbut they were also the first river-valley civilizations using the nearby river(s) [redundant – if they are the first river valley civilizations, then aren’t they near a river?] for their benefit. Ancient Egypt was birthed around 3100 B.C., and was based in the northern part of Africa. Ancient Mesopotamia came into existence around 3000 B.C. in the region now known as Iraq. Although the ancient civilizations of Egypt and Mesopotamia were developed independently, they also exhibited similarities in their governments, religions, geographies, and economies. [Good, thesis statement is clear]…

    • 1533 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When beginning a study in history one must approach it in a broader view. It is simply insufficient to look at one aspect of a society and claim that the society is now understood. Instead an in depth approach must be taken to determine not only the cultural pieces that identify a society but also the environmental impacts that molded the society into what we know it as today. In the following paragraphs I will be explaining how the different environments of Mesopotamia and Egypt shaped their cultural traits.…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The political and cultural ways of life were completely different for these two civilizations. Egypt was not in total isolation, but was as self-contained as possible. Unlike Egypt, Mesopotamia was more focused on expanding as far as they could. Egyptian leaders liked to think of their civilization as their own world. Emperors of Mesopotamia focused on expanding their territory toward the Middle East. Egypt had a few interactions here and there along the Nile, but other than that, they preferred to stay within its borders. They traded on the southern part of the Nile, which influenced the Kush and Ethiopian people. Other than interactions such as these, Egypt felt no pressure to broaden its horizons. On the other hand, Mesopotamian traders traveled outward, and made deals with merchants eastward or went on trips into the Mediterranean and farther. They even made it as far as India. As you can see, expansion was the main goal of the civilization of Mesopotamia. As well as political indifference, the two also had cultural differences. Mesopotamia was very advanced in science and an elaborate alphabet. The Sumerians had developed a good idea of the movement of the sun and stars and ultimately invented the science of astronomy. Astronomy was the basis for the calendar that was used in politics and even their religion. Egypt had a better mathematical standpoint. The idea of a twenty-four idea hour day was introduced by Egypt, and later spread to other cultures. Although Egypt and Mesopotamia differed in so many aspects of life, they had…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays