Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Lord of the Flies: Can Someone Be Innately Evil or Innately Good?

Better Essays
1279 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Lord of the Flies: Can Someone Be Innately Evil or Innately Good?
The difference in the way humans perceive things is part of the complexity of mankind. What is thought of as evil to one person can be seen as good to another, and vice versa. The issue of good and evil is brought up in William Golding's Lord of the Flies, when innocent boys are set on an island to bear the weight of society on their backs. What happens to them? How do past influences effect them? Are their actions good or evil? The actions of the boys were not a matter of being good or evil, but were actions for survival. A man's environment does not influence him towards good or evil, nor is he born with it inside. Man has instincts and inner drives that are not matters of good and evil, but of survival.

Humans are always, by natural instinct, going to do what is best for them and their survival. Animals, much like men, kill when in need. For instance, when they feel they are backed into a corner, they will attack, and when they need food, they will kill to eat. In Lord of the Flies, Ralph was being hunted by Jack's tribe, and in a desperate attempt in his defense, he thrust his spear through a crack at the inspecting savages. Ralph attacked someone of his own kind for his own survival. It can be believed that man is the derivative of others animals, and as such, they have certain instincts that were instilled from birth. The boys on the island later began to resemble the behavior of animals. "At once the crowd surged after it, poured down the rock, leapt on to the beast, screamed, struck, bit, tore. There were no words, and no movements but the tearing of teeth and claws" (153). William Golding's description of this scene leads a reader to believe that these boys took on animal like qualities. What kind of human tears with teeth and claws? The boys mistake Simon for their beast and result in ruthlessly killing him. In their state of mind of savagery and hunting, they saw themselves in danger of this "beast" and their first instinct was to kill anything in sight that had the possibility of being it. Humans and animals have a natural instinct to protect themselves in the face of danger, like attacking when backed into a corner. Instincts are innate, but indefinite characteristics such as good or evil are not. The significance of moral values does not apply to actions in a situation for survival.

Instincts are not about being good or evil, because the issue of being good and evil is undefined. Whether an action or situation is good or evil depends on who it is and how it is being perceived. This makes this issue uncertain due to the way it is viewed from person to person. Since the way it is seen will differ, man cannot be exclusively evil or exclusively good. Consider the following example: A dog constantly jumps on the window of a door in an attempt to get the attention of the family inside. He is doing this in hopes to be let back inside the house. Someone inside the house could view this as being evil, which would be different from the view of an animal lover. They would not consider this evil and would claim that the dog had not caused physical harm and just didn't know any better. The dog doesn't believe that it is evil because he is only obeying environmental stimuli. He's been inside before and knows that it is much nicer than outside, and wants the attention that is inside. The dog has tried to jump on the door before, and had received the attention of someone who thus let him in. This leads the dog to believe that what he is doing is the "right" thing to do. After all, he just wants in, right? So the dog is evil because someone inside says he is, but then he is not evil because he doesn't think he is. The opinions on what is evil and what isn't disagree with each other because of how it was perceived by each side. In Lord of the Flies there is a situation that deals with Piggy's glasses, which is the key to fire on the island. The glasses are stolen in the middle of the night that leads to a brawl in the dark among the boys. Of course the fact that the glasses were stolen, and that they were Piggy's only seeing aid, can be seen as evil, but what about Jack's side? Jack acts upon his need for fire to cook the pig he slaughtered with his tribe to fully enjoy their prize. Ralph and Samneric engage in a fight with whoever they can touch first, not even attempting to reason. Which is evil in this situation? Humans are simply complex animals that respond to complex stimuli, and their behaviors are influenced or are a product of everything that they learn starting from the day of their birth do the day of their death.

Society sets a mold for the "good" and "bad" conditions that humans are learning from day to day. The role of society in being good or evil is that it acts as this guideline for that long lived dream of acceptance. It's where what's good gets you in, and what's evil is what will make you repulsive. The ideas of power and the abuse of that power are not learned from the environment. The environment is used as a resource to abuse that power. Jack manipulates the boys into joining his tribe and sets up his territory on the island. He threatens people to join his tribe, and hunts those that refuse to. Jack's tactics are an example of how he abuses power by using the environment and how he sets the society guidelines of acceptance. A society could not exist where people are brought up to know what they define as right or wrong, and could stick to that without problem. "We decide things. But they don't get done"(79). On the island, the civilized rules of having drinking water, shelters, and having a spot for a lavatory are not followed. The boys were brought up having rules like these, but they did not stick to them due to the problem that they didn't have a strong enough authority figure to instill them. Society acts as this needed component to life, and if it's not there then it needs to be made. The creation of society begins with people who have the power to set the rules of acceptance, and they are the ones who establish what is good and what is evil. Society may manipulate others into believing what is good and evil, but those that manipulate society create that belief.

It's not that man is innately good or innately evil, it's their natural instinct that drives them to do those evil or good deeds based upon what society leads them believe. Man can not be exclusively good or evil because the state of good and evil is undefined. People are born with an instinct that drives them to do what is necessary in extreme measures. This instinct over takes any other preceding thought and becomes the need for survival. In Lord of the Flies, it wasn't whether or not the inhabitants were evil or good, it was their human reaction and instinct in the case of survival.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Good and evil are polar opposites, yet one cannot exist without the other. To understand this intricate relationship, one must have a clear understanding on what exactly good and evil are. These two are not always so black and white, but good can be defined as acting agreeably with societical and personal values. Evil can be defined as going against those values. However, as societies and humans differ, so do their moral codes. What is seen as good in one society or time may be seen as evil in another. Two more factors to consider are intentions and actions. They are two separate entities. Actions are seen, and judged, by everyone else, but intentions are known only by the doer. This is why there is no clear-cut line between good and evil.…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lord of the Flies Essay

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages

    First of all, Golding demonstrates that adults place a nonexistent innocence on children through the controllability and power that fear has over humans. Fear is an impulse that all humans are born with. It lives inside of us and we can either choose to tame it or let it control us. However, if not tamed, fear can take over reason and take control. Golding demonstrates this in Lord of the Flies through Jack and Ralph’s characters. This is shown through Jack’s character because his fear of the beast takes control over him. During the feast on the beach, Jack begins chanting “Kill the beast! Cut his throat! Spill his blood” (Golding 168). The chanting grows louder and louder and later results in Simons death. When the littluns scream in fear because they see the beast coming from the jungle, the boys’ violent impulse is immediately revealed. “At once the crowd surged after it, poured down the rock, leapt on the beast, screamed, struck, bit, tore” (Golding 169). Their fear of the beast takes control over them and without thinking, their first instinct is to kill the beast. Golding also demonstrates this through Ralph’s character. This is because although Ralph has control over fear in the beginning, he slowly lets it consume him. This is proven when the boys are reenacting the mock hunt. Ralph starts off as playing and pretending that Robert is the boar, however gets too…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The beas plays a huge role and is a imaginary fear from the start. Simon is the only boy who understands that they are all beasts inside. Meaning that he understood the evil witrhin each of them. Golding directly tells us that they are evil when The Lord of the Flies says “There isn’t anyone to help you. Only me. And I’m the Beast. . . . Fancy thinking the Beast was something you could hunt and kill! . . . You knew, didn’t you? I’m part of you? Close, close, close! I’m the reason why it’s no go? Why things are the way they are?”(158). When this is said all the evidence and clues come together to form the conclusion that the beast is the evil within us that cannot be take out or removed because it is apart of each and everyone of us. The Lord of the flies is a physical symbol of the beats however the boys’ behavior mentally brings the beast into existence. The beast makes the boys make rash decisions, act violently, and turn against one another, the death of simon is an example of this. Simons death was horrific and gruesome. Simon was injured and was crawling down the mountain, when he reached the bottom the boys started vigorously attacking him while shouting “ Kill the beast!Cut his troat! Spill his blood!”(168). They were so caught up in the chant and the fear of being killed first that they did not notice they were killing one of there own. Ironically simon was coming down to spread the word that the beast is not real and there is no need to fear it because the only beast they should fear is themselves because there is a beast inside each and every one of them. The “existence” of the beast has brought out the evil within them and turned them against one another. Golding has clearly proven his point that mankind is…

    • 1392 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Humans are born neutral, no one is biases or evil from the beginning. Research has shown that young children do not tend to lean towards the bad of society. They do not know about racial indifferences, children know right from wrong. In some cases they to choice the bad side but in comparison to what people think of when they hear “evil” their actions are very much justified. Due to the fact that people are born neutral, with a build in moral compass, telling them what to do and what not to…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Good vs. Evil

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Good is an extremely broad concept that can concern love, happiness, life, charity, and even justice. Evil, also being a broad concept, is associated with deliberate wrong doing, discrimination, and even harm to others. We often catch ourselves getting into evil situations rather than good situations. For example, killing one person to save an entire tribe. In a way, it is an evil act as far as killing a person, but it also constitutes a good act for saving an entire tribe from one person trying to destroy it.…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Human nature is not exactly perfect to say the least, so it cannot be exclusively good or evil. A reason for this is because certain situations may bring out the good or bad in people. For example, you may be having a great day, spreading positivity and goodness out to the world and then all of a sudden someone does something such as cutting you off while you are driving. This specific situation may bring out the evil in you and you could possibly chase the driver down,…

    • 421 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Evil a Learned Behavior

    • 6329 Words
    • 26 Pages

    Humans are fundamentally good, and then are corrupted by their environment. It's because of evolutionary purposes. Every organism wants their species to continue (if they don't, they die off and aren't here any more). The same goes for us. If our species started off fundamentally evil, none of us would be here right now. People would've killed each other off instead of working together in communities to survive. It's the same as any other species that has made it this far. All characters, wherever they come from, may not be born evil, but they live up to this evil behavior eventually. According to Freudian theory, violence is a basic human instinct, described as a redirection of our self-destructive impulses…

    • 6329 Words
    • 26 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Simon was on his way back to the beach to tell the rest of the boys what the “beast” really was. Walking out of the forest the boys had noticed a dark figure that they had mistaken as the beast. They chanted “Kill the beast! Cut his throat! Spill his blood! Do him in!” With that, they took the weaponry that they had in their power to dismantle the beast for once and for all. Simon is crying out that he isn't the beast, but it never broke the war-cry scream that escaped the boys' mouths. The next morning, they had realized they had committed a murder. Even Ralph and Piggy, the wisest, most civilized out of the bunch, took part in the killing. They were in denial. They didn't want to believe that they had taken part in the killing of Simon. Ralph and Piggy, for as civilized as they are, still took part. They still had the nerve to kill a living thing, beast or no beast. The worst was brought out in them; the evil side of the boys.…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    James Oliver Curwood once said, “In every man’s heart there is a devil, but we do not know the man is bad until the devil is roused.” In Lord of the Flies, by William Golding, a group of schoolboys are stranded on an island after their plane crashes. Ralph becomes the leader of the boys and tries to maintain civilization on the island. In order to maintain a civilization there must be authority, hope, and intelligence. On the island, these aspects begin to break down and disintegrate quickly when human nature takes over causing civilization to fail. Consequently, many of the boys become savages and fight amongst themselves. The Lord of the Flies implies that all humans are born evil, but clearly not everyone acts in an evil manner. Golding suggests that the laws and norms of society restrain humans’ innate evil, and, if these laws are not reinforced, then man’s evil nature emerges.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    “What are we? Humans? Or Animals? Or Savages?”~ William Golding. Throughout the book Lord of the Flies that question will continue to run through your mind. It’s going to leave the reader wondering whether or not they would act the same as the boys in the story. There’s always a right and wrong way to handle whatever life throws at you. You can handle it as a Human, Animal, or a Savage. One of the boys from the story chose to handle it as a Human. Simon’s conversation with the “Beast” can tell us that he was vulnerable and that his theory of what the “Beast” might be was correct.…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the first incidents that shows the savagery within the boys is when they reenact the pig hunt using the littlun, Robert. After the disappointment of not killing a pig, Jack casts Robert into a ring of biggins, and began to chant, “’Kill the pig! Cut his throat! Kill the pig! Bash him in!’” (114). Robert cries as they prod him with spears, “’Ow! Stop it! You’re hurting!’” (114). Robert felt sincerely endangered. The hunters primary chant referred to the pig as “her”, whereas now they refer to the pig as “him”, which is ironically attributing the boys. A second incident that shows the savagery within in the boys is the slow, torturous, death they bestow on the Lord of the Flies. The air was thick with blood and sweat (135). “Roger ran around the heap, prodding of the sow, stabbing downward with his knife” (135). This scene uncovers the truth about the loss of civilization and furthermore, how brutal and bloodthirsty the boys have become. A third incident that shows the savagery within the boys is the death of Simon. Previously, Simon had found the dead parachute man and recognized it was not the “beastie.” Simon was going to the beach to inform the others about his discovery, when he fell over a steep rock causing the boys assume he was the “beastie.” The boys hastily ran to Simon. “At once the crowd surged after it, poured down the rock, lept on to the beast,…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Is man inherently evil? Many people have different answers to this question some do not believe that there is such a thing as good or evil. What is good and evil? Is evil a part of every human being from the moment he is on this planet? I think that man himself chooses in which direction to go to and the environment influences his or her decisions. Many think that you are not inherently evil or good it is you and the environment that makes you evil or good. William Golding in his book is trying to prove and say through his book that people are evil by nature. If a person does not see, what he has done is wrong or evil than you cannot consider this evil or wrongdoing. Evil is when a person knows that what he is doing is wrong but he wants and does it anyway.…

    • 1382 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Is Man inherently good or evil? This is a question that many philosophers, psychologists, and scientists have questioned for centuries. We have learned from Webster that good is morally excellent, virtuous, and pious. He also states that evil is the total opposite. Evil is morally wrong or bad and immorally wicked. I believe that man is inherently evil simply because when a baby is born the nature of evil is already in existence. This only indicates that humans don’t have to be taught to do wrong. (As human beings we have the most extraordinary capacity for evil, but we as a people also have an…

    • 349 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Lord of the Flies by William Golding is tale of a group of young boys who become stranded on a deserted island after their plane crashes. Intertwined in this classic novel are many themes, most that relate to the inherent evil that exists in all human beings and the malicious nature of mankind. In The Lord of the Flies, Golding shows the boys' gradual transformation from being civilized, well-mannered people to savage, ritualistic beasts.…

    • 1571 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Instincts…..What are instincts? Instincts are what we possess as an organism something that is passed on from generation to generation. Instincts consist of knowing not to touch hot items or to look both ways before crossing the road, these instincts are there to stop you from harm’s way or imminent threat but one that lurks in our mind is the “fight for survival”. Fighting for survival as a human being is to the point that anything will be done at any cost to live; whether that is to sever you’re arm to get dislodged from a rock or to kill and eat a human being to survive. In the “Lord of the Flies” the civilized group of British kids turn from what was a…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays