Preview

Little Red Riding Hood: A Comparative Analysis of Two Cross-Cultural Retellings

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
824 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Little Red Riding Hood: A Comparative Analysis of Two Cross-Cultural Retellings
Different versions of Little Red Riding Hood have been retold throughout written history. Each retelling was written in a culture of its own, which holds its own philosophies on each of the continuing main ideas in each version. One integral philosophy is their principles of femininity. Because so much time had past from the original work to the time of the newer retelling, the newer version had to be rewritten to tell a different tale, distinguishing the principles of femininity that the two cultures contrasted. Two versions that contrast very well are Brother Grimms Little Red Cap and Tanith Lees Wolfland. They offer different positions of femininity, one representing the innocence of the earlier 19th century, the other representing the dominance of the late 20th century.

In Grimms traditional version, the femininity of Little Red Cap and her grandmother is a rather fragile one. Little Red Cap is an innocent character. She sees no danger in giving detailed information about the location of her grandmothers house, her destination, to a complete stranger: Her house is right under three large oaks. You must know the place from the hazel hedges near it (Grimm 620). She is also a naïve character, following the advice of the wolf to gaze upon the flowers and birds in the woods, without ever thinking about his intentions, as she should not have listened to anyone: Little Red Cap, have you seen the beautiful flowers all about? Why dont you look around for a while? I dont think youve even noticed how sweetly the birds are singing (Grimm 621). Little Red Cap and her grandmother are submissive to masculinity. In this particular version, the grandmother is eaten by the wolf, and later Little Red Cap. Furthermore, both women in this story are rescued by a man. A protective huntsman checking up on the grandmother cuts open the wolf and rescues both women from the wolfs belly (Grimm 620). A huntsman happened to be passing by the house just then and thought to himself: How the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Typically fairy tales are short stories that feature folkloric fantasies that contain explicit moral lessons and unusually happy happy, “fairy tale” endings. Anne Sexton’s poems in Transformations, however challenges the ideology that exist within the classic tales, and adds a pinch of cynicism to them. In doing so, she reinvent these tales, replacing their unvaried traditional message with a fresh more inclusive message. Sexton’s “Red Riding Hood” is one of the many poetic retelling that she makes. In the poem she conveys deceit and defines what a person who deceives is and what they do to innocent gullible people.…

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Carl-Heinz Mallet in "Little Red Riding Hood: Rated R" applies psychoanalytic criticism to evaluate the relationship between male and female characters. The wolf who is the only male character in the text presents with all the desires and characteristics a man has especially on sexual desire. Mallet mentions the moral of the story, "Little Red Riding Hood" means to give a message on how sexual behavior is considered to be wicked. From the detail, little red riding hood is a naive and innocent girl who doesn't afraid talking to a male stranger. Mallet reveals that the little girl is acting innocent because the mother tells her don't leave the path, but she apparently ignores her mother by talks to the wolf and walks into the forest. Little red…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Every so often, there comes a story so popular that it survives many decades and is common in many cultures. Growing up here in America, I was always told the story of Little Red Riding Hood. Because of the way American structure is set up, the story in this culture teaches the people told the story a lesson as well as has a happy ending. The American story of “Little Red Riding Hood” isn’t the only version of this story. As previously mentioned, there are stories that survive many decades and last through many cultures; this is one of them. However, they all have different names. There are also: Little Red Cap, Little Red Hood, The Grandmother, The True History of Little Golden Hood, Grandmother’s Nose, and Little Red Hat. These stories come from many different areas such as Germany, Poland, Italy, Austria, and France, and they have many different authors. There are two things that do stay the same throughout every retelling of this story, the characters and idea. There is always a little girl, her grandmother, her mother, and the wolf. Additionally, in every retelling, it involves the little girl having to go to her grandmother’s house to deliver something to her. However, the actions taken by the characters and their personalities change in every telling of the story. Although every version of Little Red Riding Hood has a similar idea, the characterization and moral of the story alters based upon what time period and location it was written in because of the influences of the country of origin’s stereotypes, ideals, and…

    • 280 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Fairy tales are part of every Western child 's upbringing, and have been for decades. The method of telling and the stories them selves may have changed from the purely oral tradition to that of the written word with the introduction of the printing press and more importantly the Chap Book in the eighteenth century (Montgomery, 2009 p. 13). But the basic core of the tales remain hundreds of years on to instruct and delight children to this day. These days children are surrounded by fairy tales in the form of the books read to them at home or nursery/school, television and film adaptations, cartoons and even advertisements, as well as Christmas pantomimes. Each version they see will have differences, some more subtle than others, but the basic story will be the same.…

    • 2178 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    One must first delve into the history of Little Red-Cap in order to understand the sense of wonderment the tale emanates. The fairy tale is written by Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, two German brothers renowned for their collection of folktales. This compilation of tales and creation of Little Red-Cap are a way to recall the “basic values of the Germanic people through storytelling” (Zipes). The story of a little girl going to visit her grandmother signifies the morals of people of German culture. By using the form of a fairy tale, the Grimms can convey to readers the moral principles that…

    • 1320 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eng 125, Week 2

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Many short stories have been written throughout time. Many are just for entertainment, but many of them are for teaching a lesson. Little Red Riding Hood was written partly to teach a lesson. In France, a girl that loses her virginity is said to have “seen a wolf.” That is what this story is based on. Little Red Riding Hood is about a little girl that runs in to a wolf in the forest as she is on her way to her grandmother’s house. Her grandmother was ill and her mother baked some food to make her feel better, in which Little Red Riding Hood was taking to her grandmother. When she met the wolf, the wolf was thinking he did not want to attack the girl because there were workers in the area and he did not want there to be any witnesses. Therefore, the wolf gained the trust of the little girl in just a short time so he can learn where the grandmother lived. The little girl, being naïve, gave the location of her grandmother’s house to the wolf. The end result was the death of the grandmother and the little girl because the wolf ate both of them.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Fairytales. When we hear or see that calming word, we automatically think of beautiful expensive ball gowns, charming handsome Princes, pumpkins turning into carriages, and the infamous ending of true loves first kiss. When growing up, many of us had these wonderful tales read to us before bed or at school with all of our friends. Fairytales, having been around for centuries, sends all kinds of important moral messages from being a child to facing the ‘beautiful’ world of adulthood. Growing up and being placed in the adult world, we come to terms that fairytales aren’t the classic stories of Little Red Riding Hood, Briar Rose, or Cinderella that we all know and love, its much more than that. We are surrounded by Fairytales, almost as if they…

    • 1583 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Little Red Riding Hood

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As the story of Little Red Riding Hood begins, Carter states that although there are wolves within the forest, the young girl believes that “the wild beasts cannot harm her.” This supports feminist ideas in two ways. It creates a sense that she is not fearful of the wolves. As Carter refers to the wolves as wild beasts, it also creates a negative image for men because they are symbolized as wolves. The girl, however, is portrayed as an innocent and positive figure. Together, these make the girl seem equal, if not dominant over men.…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In comparing The Grimm Brother’s “Little Red Cap” and Sharon Singer’s paintings of the infamous little red riding hood story, there are numerous similarities to be found. Singer’s painting “Fast Food”, depicts a dark and uncanny scene in which naked doll lies at the foot of bloody wolf paws. The naked doll in Singer’s bleak painting represents the vulnerability of Little Red Cap during her encounters with the wolf. Little Red Cap description as a “dear little girl” who was loved by anyone who “set eyes on her” works into Little Red Cap’s childish aurora connected by Singer’s naked doll (Tatar 13). The Grimm Brothers explain Little Red Cap “had no idea what a wicked beast [the wolf] was” during their first meeting, which characterizes Little Red Cap as a helpless and harmless young girl, with no knowledge of the dangers of society, such as a child (Tatar 14). Therefore, assessing Little Red Cap defenseless and innocent nature, there is a connection portrayed through the unclothed doll that lies at the foot of the wolf. In the painting from Singer, the wolf’s bloody paws are also seen under a red cloth, which can be concluded as two things from the story. One, the red cloth is Little Red Cap’s…

    • 430 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Literature allows us, as readers, to relate to stories in different ways while portraying a universal theme. As far as children’s stories go, the literal text will capture a child’s imaginations while an adult may push past that point and unravel a more critical message. By cunningly adapting hidden motives into the story, it allows the reader to open the door to more possibilities. When applied to Andrew Lang’s translation of Little Red Riding Hood, we are shown the sexual insinuations, and just how dangerous it is for children to be left alone.…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Little Red Riding Hood

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The stories "Little Red Riding Hood," by Charles Perrault, and "Little Red Cap," by the Brothers Grimm, are similar and different. Moreover, both stories differ from the American version. The stories have a similar moral at the end, each with a slight twist. This story, in each of its translations, is representative of a girl 's loss of innocence, her move from childhood or adolescence into adulthood. The way women are treated within each story is different. Little Red in the French version was eaten; whereas in the German version, she is rescued by the woodsman, and this further emphasizes the cultural differences.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Red riding hood and Goldilocks made decisions an both of their stories.Red riding hood was going to take cakes to her grandmother but a wicked wolf were trying to get her grandmothers cakes.The wicked wolf tried to get them but couldn't just yet after while Red Riding Hood had skipped bravely to her grandmothers house. Red Riding Hood got at her grandmothers house saw the wicked wolf and screamed.Goldie locks went into a house in the woods and went inside the house because, know one was there. Goldilocks saw three porridge, the first she saw was to hot and the second one she saw was to cold and the third now she saw was just right and goldilocks sat in all the bears chairs and only liked the third one but then she had broke so she had saw…

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rotkäppchen, Little Red-Cap, Little Red Riding Hood, there as so many different names for this story and this character. Just as the villain in Little Red’s tale has been called a wolf, a werewolf, and in NBC’s television show Grimm, it is even called a Blutbaden. This children’s fairy tale has been rewritten in screenplays, stage plays, books, songs, and poetry. But no matter what the characters are called, or how the story is presented, it all comes back to the original tales that was written by the brothers Grimm for the children of Germany. In this particular instance I will be focusing on the aforementioned version of Little Red Riding Hood written by the brothers Grimm, as well as the retelling that is titled, “The Company of Wolves,”…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Folklorists, cultural anthropologists, historians, sociologists, educators, literary critics, psychologists, even criminologists have different opinions about the same fairy tale (Tatar). For example, Little Red Riding Hood has probably suffered more interpretative tribulations than any other fairy tale. Charles Perrault, a French author in the 17th century said, “From this story one learns that children, especially young lasses, pretty, courteous, and well-bred, are wrong to listen to any sort of man (Tatar 39).” Many scholars have different opinions when interpreting this story. For one of them, the wolf displays pregnancy envy by attempting to put living beings into his belly. Another contends that the Red Riding Hood as a symbol of the German people terrorized and victimized, but finally liberated from the clutches of Jewish wolf. Also, some readers see the wolf as frightening male figures somewhere in the world and the Red Riding Hood as a female who are helpless before them. Each of these interpretations tells the readers as much about the ideological orientation and professional bias of its author as about the tale itself. These different views of fairy tales have been integrated as a whole abandoning the liberty to express opinions of readers. The modern fairy tales that are adapted for children lack not only originality but also liberty of…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    What does these two fairy tails have in common and have that is not in common? Goldilocks and LRRH are good fairy tails. Both of the little girls had a choice to go into the forest. LRRH went to their grandma house. Goldilocks was just being curios.…

    • 227 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics