Preview

Little Red Cap Comparative Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1404 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Little Red Cap Comparative Essay
Little Red Cap: Commentary Paper Little Red Cap is written by Carol Ann Duffy found in a collection of poems that she wrote about the voices of women and the voice they had compared to the voices of their husbands or partners. This poem works well to portray a rather eerie twist on an old fairytale as most of her stories tend to do. First, the title of the poem grabs your attention and reminds you of “Little Red Riding Hood”, a children’s fairy tale surrounding the life of one little girl. This is clever, as it sets the readers mind to thinking about the story, which means that the reader can connect all of the similarities in the poem to the children’s story, for example when the girl said, “What big eyes he had, what teeth!”, referring back to the wolf or antagonist in the story. The poem “Little red cap” is among others where Duffy has based this poem on a fairytale story, in this case little red riding hood. However, this poem has a few differences to the original version of the story. For example, this poem uses imagery to create a sexual feeling, where as the original fairytale was not in any way sexual, but had a more simplistic idea of a good little girl as little red riding hood and a very bad wolf who tricks her. The wolf in this poem is portrayed to the reader as a good character, and Little Red Cap as the sneaky one who appears to know what she is doing in order to get what she wants. In the first stanza of the poem, Duffy starts off with the line “At childhood’s end”. This portrays that childhood is so powerful it has been described as a physical place for the characters. The reader can picture this place clearly because of the way she has continued to describe the “houses petered out into playing fields…till you came at last to the edge of the woods”. This makes the reader think that she is no longer an innocent child, she is now an adult. However, we find out in the second stanza that she is still only 16 which makes us wonder if she is

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Mallet states that little red riding hood shares similar trait with her grandma and mother that they are women without men and show they haven’t conduct sexual relationship for a long time. The kinship between them reveals psychoanalytic criticism that one’s action is resulting from another one’s unconscious desire. The mother is the daughter of the grandma, and little red riding hood is the daughter of the mother where each of them carries expectations from their mothers. From the text, it mentions "Indirectly, Red Riding Hood's mother satisfies some of her sexual needs in the character of the grandmother. But, in addition, the mother seeks vicarious fulfillment through her daughter, with whom she identifies herself" (Mallet 9). The father of little red riding hood never appears in Perrault's version of the story which implies to the loneliness from the mother. The wolf eats the grandma who shows her satisfaction of sex from man and fulfillment of her daughter's sexual need from the absence of a husband. The grandma and the mother are each other’s second identities that they share feelings, and one of them accomplishes action can fill up another’s needs. Similarly, little red riding hood shares the bond with her mother, and she carries her mother's expectation of attracting the wolf. According to the text, it mentions "...the one expressed in words, to "walk decently" and stay out of trouble, and the underlying, unspoken message, to go out and seduce the wolf of her mother's vicarious pleasure" (Mallet 9-11). The author suggests little red riding hood's conflict with self and her mother is her another side of self that wants her to experience the sex. Little red riding hood's experience in sex is same as her mother having sex with the wolf in the little girl's body. The expression of the superego,…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Every so often, there comes a story so popular that it survives many decades and is common in many cultures. Growing up here in America, I was always told the story of Little Red Riding Hood. Because of the way American structure is set up, the story in this culture teaches the people told the story a lesson as well as has a happy ending. The American story of “Little Red Riding Hood” isn’t the only version of this story. As previously mentioned, there are stories that survive many decades and last through many cultures; this is one of them. However, they all have different names. There are also: Little Red Cap, Little Red Hood, The Grandmother, The True History of Little Golden Hood, Grandmother’s Nose, and Little Red Hat. These stories come from many different areas such as Germany, Poland, Italy, Austria, and France, and they have many different authors. There are two things that do stay the same throughout every retelling of this story, the characters and idea. There is always a little girl, her grandmother, her mother, and the wolf. Additionally, in every retelling, it involves the little girl having to go to her grandmother’s house to deliver something to her. However, the actions taken by the characters and their personalities change in every telling of the story. Although every version of Little Red Riding Hood has a similar idea, the characterization and moral of the story alters based upon what time period and location it was written in because of the influences of the country of origin’s stereotypes, ideals, and…

    • 280 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Secondly, Duffy implies that she perhaps feels some guilt towards her mother, an example being when she writes “I’m not here yet. The thought of me doesn’t occur”, before going on to describe the wild and carefree life that her mother had before she was born. This is suggesting that before Duffy arrived, her mother spent her blithe life simply living in the moment and enjoying the parties and movies that that came with her youth. Duffy seems to feel as though she, in some ways, ruined the life that her mother once had for the importance and responsibility of raising a child. This idea is also suggested in some of the language that appears later on in the poem, such as “ghost”and “relics”, both of which typically evoke connotations of death. Rather than referring to the physical…

    • 943 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    One must first delve into the history of Little Red-Cap in order to understand the sense of wonderment the tale emanates. The fairy tale is written by Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, two German brothers renowned for their collection of folktales. This compilation of tales and creation of Little Red-Cap are a way to recall the “basic values of the Germanic people through storytelling” (Zipes). The story of a little girl going to visit her grandmother signifies the morals of people of German culture. By using the form of a fairy tale, the Grimms can convey to readers the moral principles that…

    • 1320 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eng 125, Week 2

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Many short stories have been written throughout time. Many are just for entertainment, but many of them are for teaching a lesson. Little Red Riding Hood was written partly to teach a lesson. In France, a girl that loses her virginity is said to have “seen a wolf.” That is what this story is based on. Little Red Riding Hood is about a little girl that runs in to a wolf in the forest as she is on her way to her grandmother’s house. Her grandmother was ill and her mother baked some food to make her feel better, in which Little Red Riding Hood was taking to her grandmother. When she met the wolf, the wolf was thinking he did not want to attack the girl because there were workers in the area and he did not want there to be any witnesses. Therefore, the wolf gained the trust of the little girl in just a short time so he can learn where the grandmother lived. The little girl, being naïve, gave the location of her grandmother’s house to the wolf. The end result was the death of the grandmother and the little girl because the wolf ate both of them.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The poem completely diverts the social norm of the original little red riding hood as the little girl within the poem instead of being scared she portrays her fascination full of anticipation in the lines “what big ears he had!” “What big eyes he had!” “What teeth” which portrays her lack of nervousness which contrasts with her emotions from the original as originally she is scared. The young girl’s omniscience is portrayed in the line “away from home to a dark tangled thorny place” as this suggests that she is…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Comparative Essay

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In both of Bruce Dawe's poems, "Homo Suburbiensis" and "Up the Wall", he deals with contemporary Australian issues as it portrays the difficult domestic life of everyday working class Australians in Australian suburban settings. The poem "Homo Suburbiensis", embodies the idea of an ordinary man all alone in his garden with use of parody and metaphor. In the other poem, "Up the Wall", Dawe uses cliché and repetition in the housewife's dialogue to illustrate a stereotypical housewife suffering from seclusion. Essentially, both poems target the idea of isolation, ordinary, common residents living in a suburban setting.…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Duffy and Lochhead excellently implement a dramatic monologue form to convey their feelings towards their parents conventional roles within the home. In Duffys Litany, the poem is narrated by Duffys younger self who naively recounts women obsessed with social class and identity. The irregularity of the last two stanzas cleverly suggest that even at a young age Duffy felt as though the nature of these women who, dictated by the expectations of society at this time, and in particular Duffys strictly catholic community, seemed strange and distorted to her.…

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Fitting in is always an issue in the world of teenage girls and some girls have better outcomes than others. “Snow White” by Grace Hu is a story about a teenage girl named Mary who is an albino. Mary struggles to be accepted because of her scary white exterior. Also she has low self confidence from being teased by her peers. Mary also only has one true friend that begins to drift apart from her. Another story that deals with the issue of acceptance is the story “Red Dress”. “Red Dress” by Alice Munro is a story about a teenage girl entering her first year of high school. She fights to be accepted and decides to go to the school dance with her one friend Lonnie, despite her terrible clothes put together by her crazy mother. Acceptance in “Snow White” and “Red Dress” is affected by appearance, family influence, and being left out by their one true friend.…

    • 1810 Words
    • 52 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Duffy’s overall tone throughout the poem has a very nostalgic feel as she looks back on her mother’s previous life. In stanza three the poet looks back at one of her childhood memories, “I remember my hands in those high-healed red shoes.” Here Duffy looks back fondly on her past to when her mother was alive. It shows how much the poet admires her mother as the memory is such a small one, but must have meant a lot to her. In stanza two her tone is quite light-hearted as she refers back to her mothers teenage years. “Your ma stands at the close with a hidden for a late one.” This shows her mothers relationship with her mum and how her life wasn’t as perfect as it seemed to be as she also had a rebellious side to her. At the beginning of stanza four Duffy shows an admiring tone towards the things her mother once taught her. “Cha cha cha! You’d teach me the steps on the way home from mass.”…

    • 414 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Different versions of Little Red Riding Hood have been retold throughout written history. Each retelling was written in a culture of its own, which holds its own philosophies on each of the continuing main ideas in each version. One integral philosophy is their principles of femininity. Because so much time had past from the original work to the time of the newer retelling, the newer version had to be rewritten to tell a different tale, distinguishing the principles of femininity that the two cultures contrasted. Two versions that contrast very well are Brother Grimms Little Red Cap and Tanith Lees Wolfland. They offer different positions of femininity, one representing the innocence of the earlier 19th century, the other representing the dominance of the late 20th century.…

    • 824 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the poem “Lizzie, Six” by Carol Ann Duffy, a young girl is being questioned by an abusive adult. Every time the child answers, the adult gives a negative or threatening response, in an almost cruelly sarcastic manner. Similarly, the poem “Quetzals only come once” by Sheenagh Pugh describes a young child speaking to an adult. The adult, whom we are told is the child’s mother, is creating shapes through a kaleidoscope for her child. Both poems explore the theme of innocence.…

    • 1321 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Literature allows us, as readers, to relate to stories in different ways while portraying a universal theme. As far as children’s stories go, the literal text will capture a child’s imaginations while an adult may push past that point and unravel a more critical message. By cunningly adapting hidden motives into the story, it allows the reader to open the door to more possibilities. When applied to Andrew Lang’s translation of Little Red Riding Hood, we are shown the sexual insinuations, and just how dangerous it is for children to be left alone.…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Little Red Riding Hood

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The stories "Little Red Riding Hood," by Charles Perrault, and "Little Red Cap," by the Brothers Grimm, are similar and different. Moreover, both stories differ from the American version. The stories have a similar moral at the end, each with a slight twist. This story, in each of its translations, is representative of a girl 's loss of innocence, her move from childhood or adolescence into adulthood. The way women are treated within each story is different. Little Red in the French version was eaten; whereas in the German version, she is rescued by the woodsman, and this further emphasizes the cultural differences.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    What does symbolism add to a book? It adds morals and depth to the novel. It makes the reader learn something interesting or lets them gain knowledge of something that can change their outlook on how they perceive things. In the novel Catcher in the Rye, by J.D. Salinger, it is about a perplexed boy, Holden Caulfield. He has trouble dealing the issue of growing up. One of the major symbols in the book is Holden’s red hunting hat. Salinger uses the hat to signify Holden’s need for comfort and his adolescent problems and pressures.…

    • 754 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays