Preview

In the Bedroom and "Killings"

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
642 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
In the Bedroom and "Killings"
In The Bedroom and "Killings" In The Bedroom and Killings are both based around the same story, they are however presented very differently. The short story "Killings" jumps around in the story revealing different events at different times, while the movie, In The Bedroom tells a more straightforward story. In The Bedroom shows the viewer exactly what is happening chronologically, "Killings" does not and provides a more effective and suspenseful story for the reader. Each story starts and reveals the conflict differently; In The Bedroom starts at one of the Strout children's birthday party. Frank Fowler is shown with Natalie Strout being affectionate, and then Richard Strout makes an uninvited appearance which sets off the conflict between the three of them. "Killings" opens on a darker note; it is a funeral setting with Matt Fowler burying his youngest son Frank. Frank had been killed by Strout for "making it with his wife." The opening of "Killings" is more effective because it launches the reader right into the plot. The fourth line of the story shows the reader what could happen, it says "Matt's older son Steve turned to him and said: ‘I should kill him." In The Bedroom also brings the reader into the plot but it does so slower as it does with most of the events from the story. The film takes longer to get into the plot, it gives insight into the relationship of Frank and Natalie and even after Strout appears the plot isn't clear. The way Dubus weaves the different killings into the story has more of an impact on the reader than the chronological movie because they aren't expecting it, it keeps the reader on the edge of their seat. In The Bedroom stretches the story more than "Killings" does because it is a two hour movie while "Killings" is only fifteen pages long. The Fowlers only have one child in the film therefore the scenes showing the Fowlers grief make the viewer sympathize with the parents more so than in "Killings." The plot

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    After reading the story “Killings” by Andre Dubus and watching the movie “In the Bedroom,” there are several noticeable differences and a few similarities. Since the movie was derived from the short story, the plot is practically the same throughout. “Killings" is portrayed as a revenge story, whereas “In the Bedroom” it appears to be a love story. As the plot progresses we find out this is not the case at all.…

    • 955 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ned finds the body of the senator’s son in the street and Paul asks him to stop the investigation because he wants to marry Janet. Ned goes to New York searching for Bernie. Meanwhile someone sends a series of letters to people close to the crime and each letter hints that Paul is the murderer. Suspicion for this falls on Paul's daughter Opal, the victim's girlfriend. Paul then refuses to get a person’s brother out of jail. The man goes to the rival mob boss Shad O'Rory, who eliminates a witness to the brother's crime. Paul declares war on Shad, leading the rival to offer a bribe to Ned so that he would expose Paul. Ned refuses and is taken hostage. Ned escapes Shad and ends up in the hospital. Ned tells Paul and Janet that he was laying a trap for Shad; he then heads off to stop the newspaper from getting out. Later, Ned confronts Shad, the publisher, and Opal. The publisher commits suicide after Ned seduces his wife. Next, Ned talks to Janet, and discovers that she wrote the letters and that the Senator knew about the murder before Ned found the body. Paul later confesses that he killed the senator’s son. This and Ned's growing interest in Janet causes a rift between the men. Ned and Janet pair up to solve the murder. Beaumont uncovers evidence proving the senator killed his own son and turns him over to the…

    • 1656 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    David discovers the complex world of adult morality and immorality after Marie was sexually assaulted, raped and found dead a few days after Frank goes in to see her. David reveals the fact that he saw Frank walking into David’s house a…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The main interest of the work is in a character, Matt, whose son has just been murdered, and his conflict with the concept of revenge. Throughout the story Matt makes frequent mentions to his family that he wants to and should kill his son’s murderer but is just as frequently disturbed and uncertain at this notion. Matt is never described to the reader as a violent or murderous person. The story even mentions that he was a caring and concerned father by stating that “He had always been a fearful father: when his children were young, at the start of the summer he thought of them drowning in a pond or the sea, and he was relieved when he would come home in the evenings and they were there” (92). Matt is angry with himself because he feels he should have been able to protect his son, but was not able to, and “he lost Frank in a way no father expected to lose his son, and he felt that all the fears he had borne while they were growing up, and all the grief he had been afraid of, had backed up like a huge wave and struck him on the beach and swept him out to sea.” (94). Frank, Matt’s son, was also previously beaten by Richard Strout, the man who would later murder him for “making it” with Richard’s wife. Frank’s battery was described as “Before ten o’ clock one night Frank came home; he had driven to the hospital first and he walked into the living room with stitches over his right eye and both lips bright and swollen” (91). Matt has such a burden put on him with the death of his son, and the magnitude of that event causes him not being able to think about “any of the small pleasures he had earned, as he had earned what was now…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sex and violence are possibly the two main themes in the story of ‘The Bloody Chamber’. They are closely linked throughout the story, through a variety of writing techniques.…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Gay gives an example of how language hides the ability of rape when she starts off her essay about a girl of age eleven who was gang raped by eighteen men in Cleveland, Texas. The news article about this event was more focused on the town and the eighteen men than the little girl. “The Times article was entitled, “Vicious Assault Shakes Texas Town,” as if the victim in question was the town itself. James Mckinley Jr., the article’s author, focused on how the men’s lives would be changed forever, how the town was being ripped apart, how those poor boys might never be able to return to school.” Gay, Roxane. The Careless Language of Sexual Violence. This is wrongful of authors to stray their focus away from the victim who was brutally raped by…

    • 164 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    "Killings" dubus

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Andre Dubus's "Killings" is a serrated look into the once placid life of Matt Fowler. Told in third person limited omniscient view, we learn that Matt "had always been a fearful father," standing by, looking calm and collected all the while anxiously waiting to catch them should they fall and always holding back his tongue. When his youngest is murdered by the estranged husband of his lover, he is brutally confronted with the reality of all the sufferings he had desperately long to prevent. "And he felt that all the fears he had borne while they were growing up, and all the grief he had been afraid of, had backed up like a huge wave and struck him on the beach and swept him out to sea"(112).…

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Matt Fowler is portrayed in the story as being a man of great moral fortitude; he is a sensitive, loving husband, a protective father and a respected friend. The brutal murder of his son catapults him into a position in which he feels compelled to avenge the death. The conflict that Fowler feels after his son is killed is overwhelming to him. Fowler feels that removing his son's murderer from the world he and his family live in will ease his wife's pain. His concern and compassion towards is wife is obvious when he says in the story, "She sees him all the time. It makes her cry" (Dubus 85). Killing Strout is…

    • 637 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Killings Andre Dubus

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Primarily, “Killings” concerns a crime and its consequences. The lead character, Matt Fowler goes one step too far and identifies with the evil that tragically marred his life-the murder of his son. Matt and his friend Willis Trottier executed Richard Strout, the man who killed his son. This murder was more of a private revenge than of protection but the character’s act was partially motivated by his wish to protect his wife who suffered every time she encounters their son’s murderer ( & , 2000, ). As Dubus wrote, “Ruth can’t even go out for cigarettes and aspirin....She sees him all the time. It makes her cry” ( ). While it is obviously too late to protect his son, Fowler experiences his son’s murder as an assault on his fatherhood and on his wish to protect his children. Matt could no longer tolerate watching his wife deteriorate before his eyes simply because she cannot cope with the loss of their son. Finally, he decided to bring grief resolution to both of them by killing Strout.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Murder is the most serious form of unlawful homicide. Murder is a common law offence, and has never been defined by statute. The most commonly accepted definition is the one given by the early 17th century judge, Sir Edward Coke. He defined murder as: ‘The unlawful killing of a reasonable person in being under the Queens peace with malice aforethought, express or implied.’’ The actus reus of murder is the ‘unlawful killing.’ Some killings are recognised by the law as being justified. For example a person who kills in self-defence or in the prevention of a crime, provided that the force used was reasonable in the circumstances, will not be guilty of an unlawful killing. However a criticism of this is that the ‘reasonable’ force used in self-defence or in the prevention of a crime is subjective to each individual and it depends on how scared each person would be in that circumstance for example a woman who is quite confident and fearless could be attacked on the street by a man and she just pushes him away and runs however a woman who is extremely terrified in the situation could react more irrationally and hit him with a weapon such as an iron bar to get him away from her because she is so terrified, therefore it is hard to dictate to some-one what reasonable force is as reasonable force to me could be completely unreasonable force to another. A reform I would suggest for this would be to clearly set out guidelines within this as what would be considered unreasonable force so that it is not as subjective to each individual. The next part of the actus reus of murder is ‘a reasonable person in being’. A reasonable person in being is considered to be any person in being, a baby is only considered to be such when it has been fully expelled from its mothers body. A criticism I think of this is that this should be allowed. I think after abortion is made…

    • 1331 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The first part, with I/The last to see them alive (from the first page to page 85): which is the beginning, the story itself, with the settings and the writer introduces the characters: we learn about 2 sets of characters: The Clutter Family and the 2 parolees. So we see the Clutter live their last day together on the farm and in the community, we get to know their solid Midwest values. And we get information about the two guys who have decided to rob and murder the Clutter, we begin to learn about their background, and this first part ends with the news of the murders.…

    • 1487 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A major difference between the short story and the film is the setting. In "The Birds", birds are attacking people all over the world. However, in The Birds the setting is only in one city. Having the birds in only one city attacking the people creates suspense because it makes the audience wonder why the birds are only in that one city and nowhere else. Also, in the short story,…

    • 611 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first difference between the movie and novel is directly at the beginning. While the novel tells us that there is a guest house where a few couples are staying, the movie shows a difference scene. In the movie, there are people sitting on the beach drinking. While drinking, the man notices a woman, named Chrissie, who he approaches. She then takes off running down the beach. The man follows after her, both yelling at each other and undressing as they run, and they arrive at the shore. The girl dives in and yells for the man to join her while she continues swimming. While he is still undressing, he passes out on the shore. This results in him being safe from what is about to occur. Still waiting on the man, Chrissie is attacked and killed by the shark. Now, in the novel, this scene appears to be much different. The man and Chrissie both walk out of a guest house and lay on the beach. Chrissie decides she wants to go for a swim, trying to tempt the man into going with her, but he refuses and falls asleep. She slowly wades out, calling one last time for the man to join her, who ignores due to the fact that he is asleep. While Chrissie is in the water, the shark attacks her and she is killed. This is where the next difference comes in.…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Number 1: The three main events of the story would have to be the 8th night; the night in which the murder occurs. 2 when the narrator kills the old man. 3rd when the police arrive at the scene. I think that the eighth night was an important event in the story because it was the only night out of the 7 before that the old man had his eye open. That’s important because without the eye the narrator did not have the courage to kill the old man. The narrator killing the old man is killed, is a huge development because it liberates the audiences suspense , because it lets them know that its finally over , and that he was able to complete the task and get rid of the old man’s evil eye. The police arriving at the scene is important for the development…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both Hunter and Dahl use point of view and setting to form the sinister tone in their baleful narratives. Written in third person, ‘Listen to the End’ starts with the girl hurriedly running to her familiar apartment at night while “swirls of mist danced beckoningly around her”. As though they are trapping and suffocating her, stopping her from getting back to her home, her safety. ‘The Landlady’ is also written in third person but alternatively, Billy Weaver is arriving to an unfamiliar place at night. He is compelled by the sign that was “staring at him through the glass”, and “forcing him to stay”, ultimately pulling him towards the wicked motel. Hunter’s omniscient narrator tells the story very intimately, as if he was there and is sensing what the girl is feeling. Unlike Dahl, who arranges his story to be told like an imagination, rather than telling it as though it was a memory. Therefore, these creative techniques of having darkness around the character from the beginning makes the stories sound threatening.…

    • 688 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays