Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

How Do "Jasper Jones" and "Bora Ring" Explore Change?

Better Essays
1196 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How Do "Jasper Jones" and "Bora Ring" Explore Change?
What happens when a book known by heart is torn up and thrown in the air? What happened when a tribal story is lost in an alien tale? Craig Silvey and Judith Wright examine, explore and display such changes in their respective texts Jasper Jones and Bora Ring. The idea of change as a maturing yet calamitous and estranging force is conveyed onto the audience through demonstration of its dynamic effects. The skilful use of literary techniques—metaphors, similes and symbolism—allows the reader to fully comprehend the consequences of this perpetual force.

Metaphors and personification display the idea that change is cataclysmic when it is not required. Change emerges in the life of Jasper Jones’ protagonist Charlie Bucktin which results in chaos in his life. By being exposed to a horrific situation at the tender age of thirteen years old, “the world breaks and spins and shakes” for him. Charlie laments on this by saying “I can’t unfurl from my cocoon when I’m good and ready (p. 30).” These metaphors show the adverse effects that change has had on him and his lack of preparation for current circumstances. Meanwhile, in Bora Ring, the submersion of Aborigine culture is forced. On the site of a previous Bora Ring, “Only the grass stands up / to mark the dancing-ring; the apple gums / posture and mime a past corroboree (lines 5-7).” Wright uses personification to demonstrate the diminution of vitality in their culture. Wright’s use of this technique demonstrates the previous liveliness of the Bora Rings in contrast to the present state of dormancy. The metaphors in Jasper Jones assist the reader in realising the disastrous effects of the changes imposed on Charlie, since an animal cannot possibly survive without proper development inside its cocoon. Bora Ring likewise uses personification to portray the submission of an entire culture which was flourishing but changed from verve into inertia. The use of such techniques explores the idea of change being cataclysmic, since the societies it affects are functional without it.

The idea of forced change is explored by Silvey and Wright through Symbolism. Although change is shown as chaotic, the symbolism in Jasper Jones presents change as a prerequisite for maturity. When Charlie returns from Jasper’s hideout where “everything happened (p. 164),” he claims that he has been “pulled out early and left in the cold (p. 30).” The use of the passive voice in this metaphor indicates that this action has been imposed on Charlie, thus rendering it a forced change. Upon his return, he shucks off his “pansy sandals (p.52).” These sandals, typically a child’s footwear, are a symbol of immaturity. Judith Wright conversely portrays forced change as an agent of displacement. Her use of contrast shows native Australian culture gradually being forced out of the country. The description of current society as an “alien tale (line 4)” is in direct contrast with the ideas of land ownership espoused by modern Australia. The antithesis of “nomad feet” being “still (line 12)” presents the notion that lively nomad feet were forced to a stop resulting in the end of the “dance (line 1).” In Jasper Jones The metaphor of Charlie being left in the cold depicts the grand change which has occurred. This idea progresses to the symbolism of him throwing away his sandals of childhood, demonstrating his maturity due to the forced change. Wright portrays the conflicting idea that forced change leads to eradication of culture. She uses antithesis to show the contrast between the lively way Aboriginal culture ought to be and its actual state. The uses of symbolism and antithesis in Jasper Jones and Bora Ring convey convincing, though contrasting ideas about forced change, displaying the varied views on this matter.

The maturity that comes with change also brings scepticism. Silvey shows how negative change causes perspective to become more cynical, while Wright shows it to be a reason for cynicism. When Charlie sees the cricket coach laughing at Jasper he poses the questions “if he can watch this with a thin grin, what else could he watch? What other cruel things could he view without intervening? (p. 64)” These rhetorical questions demonstrate Charlie’s newfound scepticism by furtively implying that the coach could witness a murder. Bora Ring uses a metaphor to describe the manner in which Aboriginal culture was overlooked. It is described as “a dream the world breathed sleeping and forgot (line 11).” Wright describes the world as “sleeping,” as she sees the disregard the world has for the Aboriginal lifestyle a sign that they will remain latent and will not progress. The repeated use of words such as “useless,” “lost” and “sleeping” creates a negative tone of monotony and helplessness. This depicts the change in perspective of the Australian people as reason for being pessimistic. Jasper Jones comparably shows through rhetorical questions how change in Charlie’s perspective has led him to become more distrustful. The tone that Silvey and Wright create with their literary techniques shows that change creates an aura of scepticism that can affect people’s relationships.

Silvey and Wright continue to explore this theme, expanding on how change affects relationships. Through the use of simile and metaphor, Jasper Jones shows how change can strengthen relationships between individuals. When Jasper first leads Charlie to his hideout, Charlie stays “close behind like a loyal and leashless dog (p. 10).” Later on however, when the two are struggling against change together, Charlie believes they are “comrades in some private war (p. 50).” Charlie changes from instinctively being led to becoming an equal. The distrust of the rest of the community brings the two boys closer together. In Bora Ring, change is shown to ruin previously strong relationships. The poem finishes with a biblical allusion “the fear as old as Cain (line 16).” Cain, the first child of Adam and Eve killed his brother Abel. The simile of “the fear” being as old as Cain refers to the fear of being expelled from one’s own land. Wright implies that as fellow humans, Aborigines are naturally the Australians’ brothers. Yet similarly to Cain, Australians have shattered the relationship and effectively killed their brothers. As a natural result, indigenous Australians are now mistrustful of an Australia that excludes them. The metaphor in Jasper Jones contrastingly shows how Charlie and Jasper have been brought together like military compatriots. Their strong bonds of unity are due to the mutual change inflicted upon them. Wright and Silvey use different, but equally effective literary techniques to display contrasting views about change’s effects. It is portrayed as a catalyst for companionship, yet a reason for fear.

The diverse use of literary techniques explores various ideas of change in Jasper Jones and Bora Ring. Craig Silvey and Judith Wright reveal with the aid of these techniques that the effects of change range from causing chaos to forming friendships. The texts accordingly show that change results in calamity and scepticism. Jasper Jones further portrays change as a foundation of maturity and a basis for strong friendships, while Bora Ring contrastingly illustrates the unnecessary and destructive nature of change. They both demonstrate that change is an unavoidable and significant process of nature.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Similarly, in ‘Remittance Man’ an individual’s relationship to their physical environment is shown to impact both their sense of belonging and identity. “Blue blowing smoke... red blowing dust of roads”. By using vivid, colourful imagery and metaphorically describing the Australian breeze as breathing, Wright effectively evokes a sense of being physically and emotionally influenced by his relationship with the ‘living’ and vibrant Australian landscape. The ability for different…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Gary Crew’s Strange Objects and Peter Weir’s film ‘Picnic at Hanging Rock’, the effect of civilisation on the natural world is explored. Both texts display this by using the context of Australia, over time, to expose how nature will prevail over humanity. In the novel, the conflicting European culture and spiritual essence of the ancient land is portrayed in two life frames: 1623 and 1988. Dutch settlement, of Jan Pelgrom and Wouter Loos, on Aboriginal land exhibits the theme of the nature domination by portraying them as foreign influence to the Aboriginal people and their spiritual connections to the land. The action of Steven Messenger stealing an Aboriginal historical artefact, the ring, which, results in developing psychosis mirror the power of nature seen in the historical context of 1623. Based on the same context of Aboriginal Australian land, but in a different time period of 1975, ‘Picnic at Hanging Rock’, the disappearance of the girls who climb the rock are suggested to be closely linked to the spiritual powers of the land and nature. This is shown by Peter Weir using various film techniques to create a mystical and unknown aura relating to the indigenous land. These examples from the novel and film share the same idea of how nature seems to be challenged when humanity strikes.…

    • 1344 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The complexity of life might preoccupy one’s mind at any age when there is an underlying quest for personal growth and self discovery. Life on the Canadian prairie during the 1930s was filled with a sense of simplicity; truly appreciating the natural surroundings and resources available on the land. There was a recurrent theme to rely on oneself which made daily life difficult for many families on the prairie. Within W.O. Mitchell’s novel Who Has Seen the Wind, the protagonist, Brian O’Connal, tries to understand the meaning of life by thoroughly questioning the life cycle and relying on his inner sense for answers. Brian attempts to develop a clear definition for each stage by witnessing both the…

    • 1377 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tales of acceptance or the lack thereof, tales of forgotten traditions and the emergence of new traditions - all contained within the stories that are shared with the written word, yet still have an air of oral tradition. Recounting the struggles that the Native Americans have had to face while struggling to be a recognized voice in a land that they once owned, their literature holds an important place within the global lexicon, a place that should be examined by anyone that is not afraid to face their own feelings of…

    • 1233 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Having figurative language, motifs, and themes to help you through it. Two themes are taken place, one about politics and the other one is religion. Two motifs take charge, one about destiny and the other innocence. Figurative language takes the readers senses away leaving them breathless or even looking at something cute. In this book, the reader came across many things that can connect to now or later, or even based off of something or…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Symbolism In Rainbows End

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In my first text “Rainbows End” by Jane Harrison it supports and reveals connections made with people, places, groups, communities and the larger world. This will become evident throughout the language, and symbols used in the play. Rainbows End is fiction but Harrison tried to capture the indigenous experience that was set in the…

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The speaker begins by suggesting to “let the light of the late afternoon shine through chinks in the barn.” The “light” can symbolize a divine being’s presence shining through her life. Meanwhile, the sun moving down is prophetic of the afternoon’s end moving onto the inevitable “evening.” Next stanza describes a cricket taking up chafing as a “woman takes up her needles and her yarn.” This is yet another image that suggests change. The act of sewing or anything pertaining to weaving can be tied to the twists and turns of life. Letting the “dew collect on the hoe abandoned long grass,” the “fox go back to its sandy den,” “the wind die down,” “the shed go black inside,” are all images that touch on the theme of surrender. The speaker is merely encouraging letting the natural flow of things because change is not necessarily bad. Fighting change, the speaker suggests, is futile because the inevitable cannot be…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Exceeding Beringia Theme

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “Exceeding Beringia” however, is a special case because the two main themes of this poem clash, creating juxtaposition. Belonging and displacement become nearly polar opposites in the context of this poem. While belonging for the indigenous people is remaining in one place, being accepted, and settling, Kane has displacement which is being moved around by someone in a place where you don’t belong. For example the two symbols of the cooking pot belonging in an unexpected, but the bird not belonging in its expected nest. These symbols have a contrasting effect which conveys a meaning in itself. What Naviyuk Kane is expressing is that indigenous people belong to the land which they first encountered, yet the experience forced displacement which puts them in a different setting than they are used to. Joan adds the main message into the entire structure of the poem, but very subtly so because of nature. Nature’s role should not go unnoticed in this poem because essentially it helps to develop a complex piece of poetry, creating symbols which disguise the two contrasting themes that encompass the larger message.…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Many people say there is a book for everyone, the one book that will transcend what some might think of as the paper barrier and influence the person’s life because of its appeal. Critics eagerly manage to head dive into writing in order to analyze the details within the intricate messages authors intend to convey with their writings, which engulfs the beauty that absorbs readers as they grow through the journey that is reading a book. However, it tends to be complicated for less avid readers to be able to recognize that authors leave a part of themselves within the writings, and that these “horcruxes” reveal much about intimate concepts authors embrace or their beliefs. This concepts can be multiple from the broad spectrum of topics, including the reflection of cultural influences and concern for contemporary issues…

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    When referring to material objects, an individual automatically assumes a tangible item, however within the song lyrics Newsflash, Taylor (2004) an association is created between physical entities within the indigenous culture. Taylor (2004) refers to the colours of the “Aboriginal flag”, in which the sun, is yellow, the land is red and the people are black, which all signify importance, moreover there is an inference of the lyrics when Taylor (2004) refers to the land as “ mother”, or as something they “share and walk upon”. The importance of material/physical objects that help shape a culture is reconfirmed by Bond, R (1996), in which he states that physical objects or entities, such as art, landmarks and even links to spirituality have a strong link to culture. Therefore Ferraro (2010), first concept of material objects, gives me a better understanding of the indigenous culture, and how the three notions Ferraro points out interrelate.…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wild Cat Rising Essay

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages

    At times the novel is so derivative of the beat writers and existentialism, and effused with the swaggering and affected indifference and disdain of the youthful narrator towards everybody and everything, one could almost become bored with his predicament — if it were not for the fact that these devices are used as shields to protect his damaged, lonely, confused and troubled young black self. Notwithstanding the strong message of Aboriginal injustice, the popularity of the novel must also reside in historical, and perhaps even sentimental interest as the first Aboriginal novel.…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Impacted by Western cultures, Native American’s traditions gradually disappear. Similar to Native American, The Tao (達悟 Dawu) traditions are threatened by Han influences. To preserve indigenous customs, native writers either portray how dominant cultures impact aborigines or portray how native traditions do good for their lives. In Leslie Marmon Silko’s Ceremony and Syaman Rapongan’s Old Men of the Sea (老海人 Laohairen)1, both indigenous writers depict characters who confuse their identity when they are impacted by dominant cultures, that is, Western culture and Han Culture. However, when they reunite with nature, their traditions, and forsake main culture, their aboriginal identities reconstruct.…

    • 2732 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Native American Lierature

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Rodgers, John. “Return to White Earth.” Native American Literature: A Brief Introduction and Anthology. New York: HERPER COLONS COLLEGE, 1995. 46-57.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the Aboriginal world view, every event leaves a record in the land. The meaning and significance of particular places and creatures is linked to their origin in the Dreaming, and certain places have a particular strength. It refers to the time of creation, when ‘pre-existent but formless substance’ (Edwards, 2005 p17), emerged as spiritual beings and had taken on human and animal forms and moved across the land behaving as traditional Aboriginals and animals, providing a role-model for how life was to be lived; a moral system. Aboriginal people co-exist with the presence of spiritual beings in their everyday life (Edwards, 2005). Through an elliptical sense of time Aboriginal people continually connect with the origin of their spiritual being and wait for the right time to move from one stage of life to the next. This seems such a beautiful thing when read more deeply. To me, it reflects Aboriginal belonging, being and becoming.…

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    African Americans and Native Americans throughout history have suffered many unmentionable atrocities at the hands of the ‘whites’, whether from eviction of their ancestral lands to the evils of slavery. In Morrison’s Song of Solomon, the Dead family inherited their surname through the ignorance of a ‘white’ man and lost their patriarch at the hands of another ‘white’ man. In contrast to Morrison’s Song of Solomon, Silko’s The Ceremony, Tayo’s people have been forced to evolve due to the invasion of ‘whites’ on their ancestral lands and infiltration into their culture. Consequently, Morrison and Silko reveal through their protagonist that change occurs most conveniently when it has been beneficial to the ‘whites’.…

    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays