Preview

How Did The Sodaderas Of The Mexican Revolution

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1980 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How Did The Sodaderas Of The Mexican Revolution
IDENTIFICATION AND EVALUATION OF SOURCES

The question I chose for my internal assessment is, “To what extent did the Soldaderas of the Mexican Revolution change the role of women in Mexico, in terms of societal importance?” The question essentially needs use of sources that assess the role of Soldaderas, as well as the impact after the war, in terms of views on the deserved role of women after the war. I decided to use two sources that correctly evaluated the impact of the Soldaderas post-revolution. The first source I chose is titled, “Las Soldaderas De Elena Poniatowska: Estampas femeninas de la revolución” found on Ebscohost. The academic journal was published in 2011 by Romance Notes, Vol 51 issue 3. The subjects that the article covers
…show more content…
Women in Mexico before the revolution would hide behind the shadows of their husbands, they were simply seen as the homemakers, the women who tended to her husband's needs. A typical woman in Mexico focused on church, children, and husband. “Consumed by family life, marriage, and the Catholic Church.” Mexican women were seemingly regulated to a simple traditional existence. Politically and socially women essentially had no role as they were not seen as being capable of possessing certain knowledge and characteristics to allow for them to hold any power. Women essentially carried no power in the political or social world, they had no rights and word in any of the decisions taken. There was a gap that existed amongst women and men, as men were the only ones to hold power and make decisions, overtime the gap seemed to grow stirring awareness in women. Slowly the revolution began to evolve and form, pulling men from all over, from their kids, and wives. They left behind much of the jobs causing for women to take over the workforce. During the first stages of the war, majority of the men were being pulled into the revolution for combat, there was a greater need for more soldiers as most of the laborers and working class was being taken away to fight. Some of the women took the place of their deceased husbands as the number of soldiers was steadily going

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The role of a women in the American Revolution was originally a supportive spouse. They would tend to household needs and take care of their husbands businesses while they were away at war. Like in the picture “Banner of Washingtion’s Life Guard” she watches the man leave her behind as he goes to war. She is in a dress and is holding on to American symbols behind her which shows that she will be waiting for him to come back. Another painting that shows how women were expected to be is “Liberty in the Form of a Goddess of Youth Giving Support to the Bald Eagle”. She is giving life to the bald eagle by feeding him and crushing the British symbols with her foot. She is holding firm to her beliefs and feeding the bald eagle at the same time. Women…

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The main point I find after reading the article “Women and the American Revolution” is that women during Revolutionary War times had the same issues as women today with many more piled on top. Many women today are stay at home mothers like the women were then but they have more freedoms now. If a woman wants to serve their county by joining the military it is accepted now but it was not then. Women then were not even expected to give their opinion on many matters. The few women known to have served in the military during the Revolutionary War were said to be disguised as men when they did so.…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Throughout the Cristero rebellion, women played a major role in supporting the movement. As Meyer mentions, women encouraged men to fight in this war in order to defend their right to worship and profess their faith. In fact, women organized different pro-religion groups to support Cristeros. For example, Barbara Miller talks about “The Union de Damas Catolicas de Mexico” who were a religious group who was organized way before the Cristeros Rebllion began, but played a key role during the rebellion. This group was successful that in “1922 they held the first national congress”. There were two types of women that contributed to the war, Las señoras and Las religiosas,. Las señoras, were upper and middle class women, which supported the Cristeros…

    • 152 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    When people talk about the revolutionary war, they think of a bunch of men fighting. Not many people know that women actually did take part in the war and had a great influence in it. In “Revolutionary Mothers” by Carol Berkin, she writes about all of the different ways that women were affected by the war and how they influenced the war. Berkin explains with detail about the enormous workloads that women had before the war and the way it doubled during the war. The wives and sisters had to step up and take on the role of their men who left to fight in the war. Women were not only emotionally disturbed but physically as well due to the raids and…

    • 2164 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In June of 1914, Victoriano Huerta, self proclaimed President of Mexico, sent a large force to the city Zacatecas. He did this because he knew that Poncho Villa, a rebel leader from the North, wanted the city because it was an import rail junction. This city was the railway to all other railways, if Villa had obtained this city he would have access to all of Mexico. Huerta couldn’t let that happen and neither could Carranza, who was another rebel leader from the West and despised Villa as much as he despised Huerta.…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The indigenous populace of Mexico was abused and seen as a nuisance, where Diaz sought to erase them from Mexican history and took away their land which greatly affected their livelihood and left them in poverty which affected the soldaderas because the majority of them came from mestiza origin. During that time period, the Mexican constitution restricted women’s rights where they were not given the right to vote, women could not own property or allowed to oversee the education of their children – women’s life were virtually limited by gendered laws and constrained by men their entire lives beginning in their childhood by their fathers and during adulthood by her husband. Women were expected to be devoted to their families and be the reproducers of the next Mexican generations serving as their primary caregivers. Joining the revolutionary movement allowed them to escape the oppression that Marianismo represented and seek their independence in a male-orientated…

    • 514 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women back then were treated like subordinates. Traditionally, their only role was to marry, bare children, stay home and take care of the family. They had no say to political views. Women raise their sons to be a future leader. However, since the Second Great Awakening and after the American Civil War, women became more outspoken, opinionated and even took some of the men’s role at their home since most men never returned home from the war. Women started to see other possibilities. They worked outside their homes; they became great workers and teachers. Most of these women created a movement for women’s rights and they spurred a great wave of social reform. The potential for religious, political and social influence in women was…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Men were the workers, bread winners, property owners, decision makers, and kings in their families and in society. Everyone worked beneath them. They went out to work each day and expected that when they returned, the women within their families would provide the proper necessities of life: food, a clean house, and take care of the children. A woman on the other hand was expected to provide these necessities and often she also provided work outside the home, she may have even work alongside her husband too. When she finished that job, it was expected that she would attend to her home duties, these included, providing care for her husband and family and never to complain.…

    • 1730 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, strict gender role segregation placed men in the turbulent public and political world, where it was necessary to be competitive, aggressive, and merciless, while the more delicate women were placed in the private sphere of the home, with the responsibility of guarding morality and spiritual integrity. For many women, this seemed an impossible contradiction. In the 1760s, women were exposed to Revolutionary ideas based in morality - justice, freedom, equality - yet they expressed feelings of guilt at becoming interested in such political subjects. The contradictory messages only increased as the Revolution progressed, as women were asked to contribute to the Revolutionary cause by boycotting British goods and producing homespun cloth, but were criticized when taking overtly political action like signing petitions. Women's contribution was welcome as long as it was hidden from public view. This conflict was partially resolved with the ideology of Republican motherhood. A generation of women that had been unavoidably exposed to…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Carol Berkin clearly states her thesis in the introduction of Revolutionary Mothers. “Despite the absence of radical changes in gender ideology and gender roles for most women, the Revolution did lend legitimacy to new ideas about women’s capacities and their proper roles”. (Berkin 2005) In two thousand and fourteen it is questionable about how clearly women’s roles have changed especially in the areas of economics and politics at least it is obvious that the revolution did not bring equality. Legal status has changed. Of course, educational opportunities have expanded greatly; however, it often appears the more things change the more they stay the same. Even our popular vernacular demonstrates an entrenched gender inequality. “You throw like a girl” reveals poor physical performance. To concretely state subordination a person need only to make another their “bitch”. Female autonomy is usually used to denote weakness. While women now have the right to vote it is interesting that in the US Senate only 20 of the 100 senators are female. Look to Fortune 500 CEO’s and you will find only 24 female CEO’s. (Fairchild 2014) It is standard knowledge that while women are legally entitled to their wages they make 82 cents to the dollar of a male’s wages and even lower percentages for women of color. (US Department of Labor 2014)…

    • 1716 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The lives of women had changed in a good way. The way it was before the revolution they had no rights and their husband or father was the one in charge, as it says in document 1 “…the mothers and the daughters had to tolerate the male authority as longed they lived the father or husband.” No matter what starting from birth if you were a girl you were always gonna be under male authority whether it was their own father or their husband no women could be free. But things started to change in 1960 when young women were able to go to school to learn basic job skills like it says in document 2 “…14,000 young women from the countryside, including the most remote areas, came to Havana to learn basic job skills.” “The program included sewing, reading, and writing, and basic health and hygiene such as eliminating body parasites and fixing teeth.” So women were going to be able to start taking on jobs and make money for themselves. But the majority of the men don’t like the idea that women are starting to have freedom. In document 3 it says “the revolution gave women a lot more freedom by giving them jobs…” “I expect my wife so stay home and look after the house.” “She owes herself to me and the children.” Most men are used to the fact that women would be the ones to stay home, do all the cooking the cleaning and looking after the children, while they go out and do the work and make the money, now they have to be worrying about who’s gonna look after the kids when is dinner gonna be ready etc. Most men like the fact that they have complete control over women but it’s all changing and that’s why most of them are getting upset about women having more rights. Also it’s not only the majority of the men that think it’s a bad idea or that it’s wrong. A lot of the older women thought it was bad too in document 4 it says “Lots of older women who think women’s liberation is…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    What did the Revolution mean for the women of America? Some scholars say the Revolution did little to change life for her at all, while others argue that the Revolution was the catalyst of change that paved the way for a more independent American woman. The argument of a woman’s property rights became a hot topic in the court systems of post-Revolution America. Women we key in raising productive members of society and the idea of Republican motherhood was born. In order to raise educated children, women had to be educated as well and post-Revolution America saw a boom in school specifically for women. The Revolution did more to improve the lives of unmarried women than those who were married. These now educated and financially independent women soon realized that they could use their education to better the world beyond they doorstep as women entered the political arena of post-Revolution America. “American men had not fought a revolution for the equality of American women,” but the unintended consequences of the Revolution not only raised the expectations of American women, it helped them to see those expectations met.…

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women’s roles changed after the Revolution War, but such change was subtle and did not make a large difference in society. Previously, they were “household wives” who should stay at home, taking care of children and doing housework. They were considered inferior to men and were not allowed to do jobs that required high techniques. After Revolution War, women recognized the unequal treatment and pursued equality, freedom and independence. Mentioned by Abigail Adams on March 31, 1776, “if particular care and attention is not paid to the Ladies, we are determined to foment a rebellion, and will not hold ourselves bound by any laws in which we have no voice, or Representation.” However, women were still encouraged to be “good mothers” instead of capable workers who could replace men’s role in different fields in society. On an education level, most colleges still only accepted male students; as a result, women had limited opportunities to enhance their skills and take good positions.…

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the 1700’s, women performed all the domestic tasks as they were not seen equal to men. During the Revolutionary War women stepped up and proved that they were not beneath men. Showcasing that they could be as strong as the men and that they weren't just made to cook and be tasteful companions for their husbands. Without women's support in the Revolutionary War, the war wouldn't have been as successful. They managed businesses, became secret soldiers, and opposed British Policies, proving that they could perform tasks just as well as men.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    With the American revolution came an entirely new perspective of female ability. A entire political world was opened up to the female population education became more common for the group of white middle class women. Changing dramatically form being souly educated for religious purposes, the demand for education for women increased it was a battle very quickly won and women slowly became more well-rounded and knowledgeable. Although women’s legal rights were still little it was becoming more evident that they were capable of more than what was previously believed. Many new arguments arose questioning how a women trusted with the duty of shaping the future generation was ‘small minded’. Women themselves were realizing their own abilities. During the revolution they helped as much as they could using their needlework to pay off war debts, this boosted the women’s confidence many were expecting better occupations as well as voting rights. These events all led to the women’s awakening and prompted them to fight for their rights.…

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays