Preview

How Barbaric were the Barbarians Really?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
812 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How Barbaric were the Barbarians Really?
The books have claimed the Mongols to be barbaric, but how barbaric were they? The barbarians have earned the title barbaric. The barbarians were people who didn’t belong to a certain culture or group of people, and pretty much did what they pleased. The Mongols were barbaric with their laws, punishments, and the amount of battles and deaths caused in their presence. The barbarians were barbaric in many different ways.
The Mongol Empire was bigger than the continental U.S., being 4,860,000 square miles of conquered land (Doc 1). The Mongol Empire was more that three times bigger that the amount of land Adolf Hitler conquered during his time (Doc 1). With the empire being this big, there would need to be laws. There were laws on hospitality, adultery, drinking, and marriage. With these laws came punishments. For example, if you committed adultery, you would be executed, even if there were no earlier convictions (Doc 10). There were also laws made by Genghis Khan that were enforced during battle situations. If you were a soldier and you got scared and ran away from battle, if you were found, the rest of your group of 10, including you, would be executed. If your whole group of 10 flees, the group of a hundred you were in would all be executed along with you. You were expected to stay with your group throughout battle, or your consequence would be death (Doc 2). In battle, if you were a prisoner or war, that was not desired to be a slave, or were an artisan, the law was to put you to death with the axe (Doc 3). The number of deaths caused by the barbarians, is not countable.
Many people were killed and or captured by the Mongols. Along with the people, their towns were also demolished. Through the years 1220-1258, there were 5,107,000 plus deaths alone (Doc 4). In 1221 in Nishapur, Persia, there were 1,747,000 deaths according to a Persian chronicler (Doc 4). The Mongols tore the city apart and in the process, “severed the heads of the slain from their bodies and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The way they treated their prisoners were very brutal and barbaric. Some of the things they did to the people would throw them into big pots of water and boil them to death with scorching hot water. Another killing tactic was they would berry prisoners upside down, making their blood rush straight to their head. Genghis Khan killed his blood brother went they went to war against each other, blood brother comes to Genghis Khan and whispers to him in his ear, give me a noble death. Within moments, Genghis Khan kills his blood brother by breaking his back. A last tactic they would do to treat prisoners would be just flat out shooting them with their armies Mongol archers.…

    • 538 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the twelfth century, Genghis Khan united the Mongol clans and created an empire. He conquered much of Asia but killed many people and destroyed many towns in the process. Many people consider the Mongols to be barbaric because of their ruthlessness and the amount of people they kill. However, this statement is incorrect. Barbaric means to be savage, primitive, and unsophisticated and no history of the Mongols could be adequate if it only dwells on its destructive side. The Mongols weren't barbaric due to the effective way they organize their empire, their tolerance towards the other people they conquer, and the advancements they made in their economy and empire.…

    • 785 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mongol’s army is different than the other army in war. It was so organized they were undefeatable. But they’re also brutal, if committed adultery you will be executed. It all began, in 1206 A.D with Genghis Khan who unites the Mongols, but the Mongol dynasty falls in 1368 A.D. The most important question is, but was the Mongol Empire brilliant or brutal? The documents that we read support that the Mongol empire was brutal. I will use documents 1 and 4 to support my arguments.…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Were the Mongols Barbaric?

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Mongol’s culture was very strict and well followed by their followers. If they’re culture or rules weren’t followed as they were supposed to, there would be severe consequences. The consequences given were cruel and inhuman. As in the picture in Document 5 “A scene from a Persian manuscript c.1300 showing the execution of a prisoner by a Mongol soldier. Others are being buried alive upside-down.” This shows the cruelty and barbarism of the Mongols toward the slaves in which they are being brutal and evil towards them. Mongols murdered so many people from different cities around the world. One of the cities that was reported the deathliest at the time was Baghdad in Persia with 800,000 – 200,000. Another city that was considered the deathliest in those days was Kozelsk, Russia which had no survivors.…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    They had no mercy for anyone who was in their way and would do anything to win a battle. In document 3, the Mongols brought children and women onto the battlefield to give the appearance that their army was larger than it really was. These harmless children often got caught in the crossfire and were killed. Doc 3 also states that “sometimes they even take the fat of the people they killed and, melting it, throw it onto the houses” (doc 3). To retrieve the fat, they would need to cut upon their already dead victims and savage through their insides. In addition to this, doc 5 shows a picture of Mongolian soldiers shooting an unarmed man with a crossbow and others being buried alive. For the Mongols, being buried alive wasn’t bad enough because these people were buried alive upside down. This is tremendously graphic and shows how the Mongols don’t have any boundaries when it comes to…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mongols as Villians

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Mongols were very intelligent in their warfare tactics which is what made them such notable villains of that time period. They were a very adaptable group of warriors as we can see that during their siege over Caffa. Even though they had never seen a castle with such a wall, they were quickly able to figure out a way to conquer. They also became very good at siege warfare by…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rise Of Genghis Khan Essay

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages

    To be a successful empire the Mongols couldn’t have been as brutal as they were stereotyped as because they had to treat their own people and civilians right to maintain society. They had values that were followed strictly with severe consequences…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When in Russia, they demanded 1/10 of everything and when turned down, were outraged and brutally murdered everyone, including nuns, priests, and children, in front of each other, (Document 2) An eyewitness of Chinggis’s leadership recounted a story about a time when, in a happy mood, Chinggis granted two of his prize soldiers the chance to take home some of the people they had conquered and use them as slaves in whatever way they saw fit. (Document 3) It is questionable whether or not these men had active consciouses. The large area of land conquered, itself speaks for how ruthless and powerful the Mongol army was. (Document 8) The Mongolian text, The Secret History of the Mongols, accurately accounts the different conquests that led to this large a dominated area of land by a single army. (The Secret History of the Mongols) A letter from Pope Innocent IV to Chinggis Khan speaks in utter amazement about how the Mongols seems to have no tolerance of anyone standing in their way. It doesn’t matter to them whether the country they are invading is Christian, Jewish, Buddhist, Hindu, black, white, or pock-a-dot. There are brutal with every man woman and child as well. (Document 9) By force, the Mongols achieved what they…

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The leaders of the Mongol Empire were definitely better at some aspects of ruling than others. One section they are known for is their violence and rapacity in their military. However, the Mongol’s violence brought more harm than good when compared to the economic practices of the empire.…

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Mongols

    • 569 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “Come out so that we may count on you according to our custom.” And when the people come out to them they seek out artisans among them and kept these. But the others with the exception of those they wish to have as slaves, they kill with the axe…This statement proves in many ways that the Mongols were uncivilized. Also soldiers would execute prisoners by shooting them with arrows or by burying them alive upside down in the dirt and tying there arms so they cant dig themselves out. Causing a slow excruciating bereavement of suffocation. Even the Mongol Yasa (laws) and Bilik (rules) were barbaric men were allowed to cheat on women having as many wives as they please but women could only have one husband and if a dad was to die then it was okay to marry all of his wife’s except for his own mother. Could you imagine our society if Mongols were in control? (Doc: 5, 10)…

    • 569 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Romans and Barbarians Dbq

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Although I do say that I don’t believe the nomadic people should be considered barbarians based on what historians and politicians have made of them; they did have a very strong military background, and also a thing for…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    the world has ever had. The Mongols were civilized because of their military structures, and their…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mongol Empire Dbq

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Document 1 shows that Genghis Khan, a Mongolian leader, conquered 4,860,000 square miles of land. Genghis Khan also made sure that every soldier had someone in charge of them, allowing no room for mistakes. He organized the army in a way that every ten people had a ¨captain of ten¨ and every 10 of these captains had a ¨captain of a hundred¨ and so on (Doc 2). If they did not obey one of their leaders or tried to run away, they would be killed (Doc 2). This shows how the leader did not allow any room for disorder and showed no mercy for even his own army. Document 5 shows the Mongolian leader, Genghis Khan, in action executing a prisoner. He and his soldiers were so Barbaric, they would execute on spot and burn people alive while hanging upside down. Genghis was very strict and forbidded theft and adultery of Mongols. They would not even steal two horses running astray with the owners already moved out of the country because of how strict the laws were on theft (Doc 7). Mongke Khan, also a Mongolian leader, made his profession to of faith to Rubruck and declared that all Mongols believe there is one God (Doc 9). In document 10 about Adultery, it shows again how Genghis Khan was strict on is policies of committing adultery, which says they will be executed if they have had previous convictions or…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The most important association of the Mongol state was the Mongolian army. Said in Doc 3, the Mongol armies were great at hunting, riding horses, fighting and definitely slaughtering people. The men were experts in many weapons and war tactics. Sometimes, if obligated to, the army would travel more than 100 KM per day to surprise an enemy. Thus giving the horsemen the name the most mobile forces of the prominent world. In the book, it said that the Mongol army officer were very obedient to…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When the Khubilai Khan and his Mongols came for China, they did so with great force. The two armies met on the North China plain, the armies of Jin numbering 10,000 compared to the Mongols cavalry of some 200,000 horsemen. Once the obvious outcome came about, the Mongols moved south and defeated the Sony army with gun-powder based weapons that they had borrowed from the Chinese, who did not expect them to be used against them. Once Khubilai Khan had finished the ruling emperor of that time, he began his full conquest, allowing his armies to plunder, destroy, and kill as they pleased. They brought violence and destruction to all aspects of China’s civilization, being very insensitive to their cultural values and government. From the bottom up, the Mongol invaders eliminated many Chinese institutions, their civil service and government to name a few. Since the Mongols only perceived China as just one section of their vast empire, they discriminated greatly against the Chinese, creating a caste system with the Mongols at the top, followed by the Islamic population, and ending with the conquered Chinese. Another political reformation brought by the Mongols to China was that no Confucian scholars or native Chinese were eligible for any positions in their government. The Mongols had changed the Han Chinese way of life greatly.…

    • 546 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays