Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Holocaust vs Japanese Internment Camps

Good Essays
694 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Holocaust vs Japanese Internment Camps
Holocaust vs Japanese Internment Camps

In comparison between the two events of that of the Holocaust and of the Japanese Internment camps, I believe that the Holocaust was by far the worst of the two circumstances for the following three main reasons: the process and the steps taken, the deaths and how they occurred, and the mental trauma inflicted and forever engraved into the minds of that of the prisoners of the death camps. Throughout the entire tragic and horrendous ordeal of the Holocaust, every single category of the prisoners were belittled and had been inflicted upon by the public and the Nazi soldiers. They were first forced to pin on certain specified 'badges' that stated which category of the prisoners they were, for example, homosexuals, Jews, gypsies, Jehovah witnesses', etc. The main targets of all the prejudice and stereotypes were the Jews, as they were thought to be the reason they underwent a Great Depression of their own and the reason of which they did not succeed in winning in World War I. Soon after they had been placed the specified 'badges' that indicated to the Nazis of which of the main groups they belonged to, they were forced onto packed trains, where they would be transported to move into the crowded, packed houses in the Ghettos. The process of moving all the prisoners by force and separating them by physical means from their homes and families was even more terrible than just being taken off guard without being able to react. This process let the prisoners know that they had no choice but to be submissive, it made them realize that there was literally nothing left for them to do but to cooperate and wish for this ordeal to be over and done with. The number of deaths itself would be enough to explain how horrible the camps were, but the way they were handled was far more extreme and horrendous. There were many ways they could die: in the gas chambers, crematoriums, disease, starvation, hangings, dehydration, beatings, electrocution, gun shot,etc.- some of which were suicide attempts, a desperate need of escape and a way to end it all by their own doings. The entire time, you would be able to witness your family, friends, and neighbors being killed, knowing that soon you would be next. There were even some prisoners that were employed as the ones who were in charge of the killing process as a way to confuse prisoners and give them a false sense of security. Many of those employed were forced to kill their own family members and have that guilt with them for the remainder of their lives. The worst part of it all was the mental trauma the entire situation caused onto each and every of its prisoners and of that of the remaining survivors. Imagine witnessing hundreds of deaths each week, standing in line with the other prisoners during selection, receiving the smallest of crumbs and fighting over the scraps. Imagine witnessing your family being separated from you, knowing that you will never see them again, hoping your fate will not be as bad as theirs. Nothing you could ever imagine would ever even come close to how that prisoners felt. Only the survivors of the camps would be haunted by all these nightmares they have lived through and witnessed each and every day they've spent at the camp. Only they would be able to tell you of the true nature of the horrors that have occurred behind the barbed-wired fences. Each day, they would have to live, remembering and reliving the traumatic experiences they've had first hand forever for the remainder of their lives. Some of these survivors could no longer take the mindset of it all, and despite finally being free after all those years locked away, they have taken their own lives, just to keep away those thoughts that would sneak their way through. In conclusion, I find that, despite the two being both horrible and inhumane treatment, I find that the Holocaust is and always will be by far more worse than the Japanese internment camps ever will be.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    During World War 2, approximately 6 million Jews were killed in Nazi Concentration Camps, and Death Camps. Jews were usually transported to these unjust camps by freight cars, but sometimes they were forced to travel to them by foot. In Concentration Camps, Jews were given meager amounts of food, and if they got sick, or were too weak, they were killed. Concentration and death camps were liberated from 1944-1945 by Soviet forces.…

    • 72 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    To start off, the Holocaust was a killing that happened during World War I, while the Rape of Nanking happened in World War II. They were both considered the worst atrocities during their time besides the war that was going on. They were both considered genocides also, in my opinion, because they were both using most of the eight stages of genocide. The Holocaust targeted mainly Jewish people, and the Japanese targeted the Chinese, which is a form of classification. Then the German made the Jewish wear Stars of David, but the Japanese invaded China so there was no use of symbolism. Both genocides dehumanized them by the German chancellor, Adolf Hitler, taking away all rights for Jewish people, and the Japanese began to do hate crime by raping the women with sharpened wood, cutting off their breasts, then killing them and making Chinese men sleep with these dead bodies. Hitler had his own army, and a children’s army called the Hitler Youth. The Japanese leader, General Matsui, marched his troops in China to attack, which is stage four: organization. For stage five, polarization, the German made the Jewish give up the wedding rings they owned, and sometimes forced them to give out information upon other Jews. The Japanese killed anybody who didn’t listen to any order. The next stage, identification was used by the German making Jewish people who lived in Germany move into Ghettoes that usually held 3,000 to 75,000 people. The Japanese took some Chinese women into their base and separated them from friends and family, and were…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There were hundreds, if not thousands of death camps settled across Europe during World War II. But despite the word “death camps”, a term that is used to describe the horrible events of the Holocaust, the historic mass killing of around six million Jews or more. These were more of working camps, but still, out of all of those, only six of them were used specifically for actually working the Jews to death. Belzec, Chelmno, Majdanek, Sobibor, as well as Treblinka were quite large, but none of those five are as large or as infamous as the Auschwitz death camp. Through the beginning of the 1941 to around 1945, the camp has gone from 835 square feet of absolute horror to true historical suffering and terror that won’t, and shouldn’t, be forgotten.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Starting with 9 Million people in the Jewish population and nearly 3 Million left after the war… Japanese had it easier their camps were less brutal than the Jewish Concentration camps. Also, Jewish Concentration camps were more guarded and higher standardized than the Japanese Internment camps.. Jews were forced to do jobs or they had punishment, Japanese weren’t forced to work they could volunteer. Jewish concentration camps and Japanese Internment camps weren’t the same because Jewish camps were more Brutal than Japanese, Jews lives weren’t cared about in the camps and they were more secured with less freedom than the Japanese Camps, and Jews were forced to work unlike the Japanese.…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “When I came to power,I did not want the concentration camps to become old age prisoner homes,but instruments of torture.” Adolf Hitler Japanese bombed the pearl harbor so they relocated the american japanese away from the border. Nazi took jews and put them into concentration camps so they could be tortured and killed because hitler thought that they were a threat to the economy.Jewish and Japenese people were put into a camp because of the way they are or what they believed in. Japanese internment camps and Jewish concentration camps are not the same because Japanese were only relocated,Jews were killed, and Japanese were provided with food and homes for them and their family.…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Millions of Jewish civilians died in concentration camps due to the cruelty of the Nazi party (Rodriguez). “Jews were subject to beatings and harassment like the cutting of their beards” (Rodriguez). They were given meager rations of watery soup and bread, but it never put a stop to their starvation. According to Rodriguez, men often had no sleeping quarters, were not able to shower, and were almost never fed their tiny rations of food. Because of the lack of sanitation and food, diseases such as typhus spread throughout the camps. Furthermore, they were expected to work extremely physically demanding jobs despite their lack of nourishment and health. In fact, their mistreatment and work was specifically designed to weaken them until they died. Finally, the Jewish people were kept in a constant state of terror never knowing if they would live to see the next day…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both sides of WWII did something bad Just one was worse than the other.Concentration camps and internment camps were both built during WWII. Internment camp were built by the US Government to house Japanese-Americans after the bombing of pearl harbor. Concentration camps were built by the Nazi’s to house jewish citizens because the Nazis thought Jewish People caused all problems. Because of the fact that Jewish people were killed tortured, and experimented on in concentration camps, Jewish people weren't even considered people in Concentration camps and internment camps weren't designed for mass extinction American internment camps and German concentration camps are not the same.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Japanese internment camps, concentration camps, and extermination camps were part of World War II. They were all a negative aspect in history. Japanese internment camps intended to keep potential threats contained. They were motivated by propaganda and trust. People who lived in these camps were given real meals. Furnished rooms and cabins were constructed for them. They worked for small wages and could join the army and become members of society. Concentration camps were an alternative to mass executions. They were seen as torture facilities. Concentration camps were motivated by malice and hate. Prisoners of various nationalities were incarcerated. People contracted illnesses from the lack of insulation in rooms. Their food was disproportionate…

    • 214 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Between 1.1 and 1.5 million people died at Auschwitz; 90 percent of them were Jews” (“Auschwitz”). Concentration camps were large numbers of people; mostly Jews enduring forced labor and mass executions. One of the concentration camps during the Holocaust was Auschwitz. Auschwitz-Birkenau had a unique design, a horrible daily life for those in it, and is greatly remembered for what happened at these camps at the end of the war.…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In conclusion, the Nazi concentration camps and the Japanese internment camps were not essentially the same thing because they had different purposes and different aftermaths, and different locations. Many more Jews were killed than the Japanese-Americans. Jews dealt with much more grief and sadness. They were forever unequal and excluded from…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Everything I have heard, seen, and discussed about the Auschwitz Death Camp and the Holocaust in general has been bone chilling and made me sick to my stomach. One major issue was the conditions the Jews and the “un-American or imperfect” had to face; pictures depict men so bony and skinny that they could die from starvation at any second. Another sickening sight was the sign above the entrance to Auschwitz that read “Arbeit Macht Frei”, which translates to “Work makes you free”. Just think of all the people who got a sense of false hope and never were able to leave the concentration camps alive. While reading the excerpt from Knight, the thought entered my mind of being sent left or right during selection, possibly being split from your…

    • 237 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    On February 19, 1942, President Franklin D.Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9066, which called for the eviction and internment of all Japanese Americans. After Pearl Harbor, all Japanese were looked upon as being capable of sabotage. The interments began in April 1942. The Japanese-Americans were transported on buses and trains to camps in California, Utah, Arizona and other states. They were always under military guard. The Japanese-Americans were housed in livestock stalls in the beginning, or in windowless shacks that were crowded and lacked sufficient ventilation, electricity and sanitation facilities. There was also a shortage of food and medicines.<br><br>The internment camps were located in remote, uninhabitable areas. In the desert…

    • 250 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    5). The camps were also infested with disgusting creatures. “We had to make friends with the wild creatures in the camp, especially the spiders, mice, and rats, because we were outnumbered…” There were too many animals compared to humans at the camps and they made the conditions even worse than they already were. In addition, there was always a stench of horse manure which attracted horseflies every year (Doc. 6). The state of the internment camps provided a horrible lifestyle for the people living there. Apart from these terrible conditions, forcing the Japanese Americans to leave their homes in the first place was not right. Most of the Japanese interned were American citizens that were innocent. “...I’m an American citizen, not found guilty of anything and having to bear this type of treatment.” They had to go through gruesome conditions when they had shown no signs of evil purpose in the United States. “The Exclusion act uprooted innocent people…and interned us without giving us our rights” (Doc. 8). The Japanese were not given any choice or freedom; they had to move to the internment camps which was unjustifiable…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Japanese Internment Camps

    • 1778 Words
    • 8 Pages

    To be the enemy, or not to be the enemy, that is the question. After the surprise attack on Pearl Harbor, many Americans believed that the Japanese Americans, also called Nikkei, were disloyal and associated with the enemy. There were rumors that they exchanged military information and had hidden connections. None of these claims were ever proven. The U.S. government became increasingly paranoid about this new problem and demanded action. On Thursday, February 19, 1942, President Roosevelt issued the Executive Order 9066, which called for an evacuation of Japanese Americans on the west coast with the excuse of a “military necessity.” The government’s hasty enforcement of Executive Order 9066 in reaction to public hysteria, not only violated the rights of Japanese Americans, but also resulted in unnecessary effort and attention towards the internment camps.…

    • 1778 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust was traumatizing event in the 1900s. It was a life changing event for the Jews. This time period went down in history. Rudolf Hoss, estimated during Nuremberg Trial that nearly three million people died while being held hostage in death camps. Also, ninety percent of the ones killed were known as Jews. In death camps the people who were known as “different” suffered from cruel treatment, harsh environment and immoral medical experiments.…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays