Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Holocaust Experience

Better Essays
2147 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Holocaust Experience
Sogbeye Okoro
History 408
Dr. T Porter
The Holocaust Experience Simply put, the Holocaust was the annihilation of six million Jews by the Nazi regime. In 1933 approximately nine million Jews lived in the 21 countries of Europe that would be occupied by Germany during the war and by 1945 about two out of every three European Jews had been killed. The European Jews were the major victims of the Holocaust. But Jews were not the only group singled out for persecution by Hitler's Nazi regime. As many as one and a half million Gypsies, 250,000 mentally or physically disabled persons, and more than three million Soviet prisoners of war also fell victim to Nazi genocide. In this section of reading we talk about the categories in which those in the camps fell into. There are victims and perpetrators and we see how the Jewish people themselves played roles in the camps. This sections also talks about gender roles and we have a large divide between three of the historians and how gender played a role in this section.
In looking at the history of the Jewish survivors from the beginning of the Nazi occupation until the liquidation of the ghettos, you can see that there are common features and similar psycho physiological patterns in their responses to the persecutions. What was the duration of the trauma? During the Holocaust, was the victim alone or with family and friends? Was he or she in a camp or in hiding? Did he or she use false "Aryan" papers? Was he or she a witness to mass murder in the ghetto or in the camp? In looking at their will for survival we have to look at what was it that they were put through? Power is a strange phenomenon. In those camps the act of playing God seemed to be of fun to them.
Terrence Des Pres explains this best by stating: “As power grows, it grows more and more hostile to everything outside itself. Its logic is inherently negative, which is why it ends by destroying itself. . . The exercise of totalitarian power, in any case, does not stop with the demand of outward compliance. It seeks, further, to crush the spirit, to obliterate that active inward principle whose strength depends on its freedom from entire determination by external forces. And thus the compulsion, felt by men with great power, to seek out and destroy all resistance, all spiritual autonomy, all sign of dignity in those held captive. . .The death of the soul was aimed at.” Yet the Jewish people seemed to have mustered the will to fight to survive. Des Pres concludes that the "survivor is the figure who emerges from all those who fought for life in the concentration camps". Clearly, he believes that survival and resistance were possible. One could also argue that the acts of resistance used by the prisoners to help other prisoners were, in fact, acts of rescue. Certainly, without the help Des Pres describes, many other Jews would likely have died in the camps.
In his section Primo Levi describes the lagers as a terrible place for the newcomers. He states that people could not be simply divided into victims and persecutors. Now in looking at his exert we must first look at it openly. Before divulging into the gray zone we must know and understand that Levi though a “prisoner” in the camps he was not in a death camp and he was in the camps before they began killing the people. His account or opinion must be looked at a little differently. According to Levi, the gray zone of protekcja and collaboration springs from multiple roots. The motives of guilt, torture, terror and desire of power have come into play to create this gray zone. The camps, Levi writes, were an inverted moral universe, a ''gray zone'' where irrationality reigned. Precisely, the gray zone is a reflection on the nature of total domination in the accomplished form that it took on in the Lager. The topics of “complicity” and responsibility are tied in with those circumstances and this should help us never forget the extreme and uninterrupted pressure that was inflicted upon the prisoners. He says that prisoner-functionaries exist to maintain order in concentration camps based on a system of punishments and privileges, based on the consent or tolerance of the guards or other prisoners higher in the ranks of the deportees, or, in some cases, the consent of the commandant. Levi shows how all the “victims” were not truly victims in fact how they themselves played a role in the destruction of their people in order to survive. In my interpretation “the gray zone” is more of the survival of the fittest because it was either let them do to you what they want or fight to the best of your ability to survive. Those that you may step on in the course are just innocent obstacles that seemed to stand in the way.
Bruno Bettelheim writes that survival was possible, but only through lack of resistance. He argues that the longer prisoners remained in the concentration camps, the more childlike they became, and the more they imitated the behavior of the Nazi officers. He says that they were so imitated by the officers that they turned against other concentration camp survivors who were weaker or newer to camp than themselves and who, therefore, threatened the older camp survivors' lives. Terrence Des Pres contends that Bettelheim misses numerous instances of resistance that may have been masked by mimicking behavior. Des Press contends that prisoners often used the appearance of compliance to help other, weaker, prisoners He writes that Bettelheim's argument overlooks "'a whole system of mimicry toward the SS,' and 'ever-present camouflage' which concealed true feelings and intention”. As a child Psychologist he fails to understand humans adapt for survival strategy, Yes as a small child one automatically falls into line out of fear of punishment. When one becomes an adult in need to survive one will adjust and fit into the force environment they have been placed into in order to survive.
Documentation on survival of the Holocaust has primarily focused on the lives of men as written by men and perceived by men. This leads us to believe that men and women experienced the Holocaust the same way. Although one would be naïve in assigning purely gender-related reasons for survival (experiences such as thirst, hunger and deprivation were non-discriminate). According to Sybil Milton it is clear that gender-related behavior of men and women, and gender roles in the Jewish community led to different survival capabilities. Different experiences faced by men and women were a function of the fact that each sex was vulnerable to the Nazis in ways specific and exclusive to them.
We can say that woman carried a sort of card that queued them for instant death. Mothers were especially at risk for early execution. Being a mother with a child, pregnant, or just by holding the hand of a child meant instant death. Sybil Milton states that the social differences between men and women enabled women to better struggle against the sub-human conditions of degradation, deprivation, terror and even death. Milton offers an insight into the reactions of devoutly religious Jewish women, as she interprets their feelings of “both a physical and spiritual nakedness” upon being shorn of their hair. They formed mutual assistant groups to help and ensure their survival. Through friendship and comradeship came hope and a reason to live. These groups, sought strength in numbers. They formed deep bonds with each other which led to mutual co-operation and helped to increase their chances of survival. With emotional involvement, there was more of an interest invested in the group to see that everyone in the group survived. Members of these groups shared food, information and offered protection.
Milton then suggests that women flirtatiously played upon their feminine sexuality in their struggles against SS men. In a way, her suggestion that women used sex as a tool for survival is a feeble attempt to present sex in the camps as a positive aspect of women’s experiences and further obscures views of sex as a unique difficulty women faced. Milton goes on to say that, essentially on of the main reasons in way women survived was that women cleaned their surroundings and kept themselves cleaner longer than men did thus warding off diseases for longer periods. Milton states that this comradely and other such uses by the female population are what helped the women to survive. Yet in looking at Zoe Waxman she is the complete opposite of the so called feminist view of the holocaust well at least opposite of Milton. Zoe Waxman shows how the conditions and motivations changed those in the camps immeasurably. She reveals the multiplicity of Holocaust experiences, the historically contingent nature of victims' responses, and the extent to which their identities; secular or religious, male or female, East or West European affected not only what they observed but also how they dealt with the events occurring around them. She too like Levi showed that women themselves chose how they fought. They again yes are victims like Milton says they are but according to Waxman they as well are perpetrators because like with men they themselves did what had to be done to survive whether it be kill their children or it be deny that they had a child in order to survive. She also lets it be known that sex wasn’t a pawn like Milton attempts to make it, in fact it was rape and that the men in charge of those camps used it to hurt the woman and not that the women enjoyed it or used it as a way of survival like Milton tries to make it seem.
Lawrence Langer argues that gendered histories of the Holocaust will create “‘myths of comparative endurance’” that are likely founded on misleading “‘situational accidents”. What Langer is arguing or suggesting here is that examples like female solidarity that Milton points out as distinctive female coping Mechanisms, may have been a result of conditions imposed upon them by the Nazis or their collaborators. Langer argues for the “severely diminished role that gendered behavior played during the Holocaust. He says that it is ethically impossible to look at the holocaust through the glasses of gender. His argument is that we trivialize the holocaust by looking at it through such light especially when a feminist agenda is placed into the history of it. Langer suggests that women stayed together more often than men because of their work situations, not because of typical gender practices. Thus, to Langer, the Holocaust clearly exhibits universal suffering, and to view it in any other light would be an injustice to the victims. He also challenged the moral legitimacy of what he considered to represent the privileging of one group over another. He maintains that men and women suffered equally, but also rejects the very notion of gender-specific Holocaust studies.
In the End when looking at it from a general point of view, the survivors, for the most part have shown to be as strong as humanly possible. Not one person who hasn't seen what they saw can possibly imagine how they feel. Many people are greatly affected by things the survivors would consider menial. Yet I think in this section the line must be blurred. Truly all these people at one point in time had to play the role of perpetrator in order to stay alive. Yes they could have just allowed what happened to them happen but as human being we have the “flaw” to step on others in order to survive. These people were lucky to have survived but there is no doubt that there have been times when their memories have made them think otherwise. There is always a discussion into how and why those who made it through were able to make it. I agree that yes there was a psychological digression by those in the camp into a childlike state but there was also a fight and will to survive. Sybil Milton may have had some points that may have helped women survive but her argument was not historically sound. Many of her arguments are mere attempt at glorifying the feministic point of view and glorify simple things that women did or to use of sex in the camps as a way to over glorify women. Waxman and Lager are truthful in saying that all are victims but they point out the actions of the people. Levi though his opinion can be taken as a grain of salt make a point in the gray zone how people can jump between the role of victim to the role of perpetrator.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust was the country that sponsored mass murders for of over six million Jews by the Nazi government during World War II. It was the culmination of close to a decade of official discrimination, racial segregation, and brutal violence against the Jewish residential district in Germany. Under the shield of the war, the Nazis turned to systematic genocide after 1941, setting up industrial-style “extermination camps” planning to execute the detained Jewish population of Germany and Europe. While other groups targeted for extinction by the Nazi state, including gypsies, gays and communists, anti-Semitism was a fundamental tenet of Nazi ideology. In fact, Hitler believed until the end that the “war against the Jews” was a more important goal than victory in the conventional military battles of World War II. The Holocaust is today known as one of the worst mass crimes in human history.…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust was a tragic experience for the Jews. Hitler blamed the Jews for the lose of WWI. There was over six million Jews that got killed during the holocaust by Adolf Hitler and all the other Nazis. Holocaust is a word of Greek origin meaning “sacrifice by fire”[Introduction To The Holocaust.] Hitler also targeted the disabled, Jews, homosexuals, and other prisoners or undesirables.The holocaust absolutely destroyed the Jews, but luckily, some still survived. Today we are still hearing stories about the tragedies that they have went through. The Nazis would send Jews to either concentration camps, or even death camps, the death camps had to been the worse to go to. The Nazis would even make the Jews and other prisoners walk for miles on called death walks. The Nazis made the Jews and other prisoners walk for miles and miles to various death and concentration camps.…

    • 431 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust was traumatizing event in the 1900s. It was a life changing event for the Jews. This time period went down in history. Rudolf Hoss, estimated during Nuremberg Trial that nearly three million people died while being held hostage in death camps. Also, ninety percent of the ones killed were known as Jews. In death camps the people who were known as “different” suffered from cruel treatment, harsh environment and immoral medical experiments.…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Holocaust

    • 863 Words
    • 3 Pages

    What is courage? Yettie Mandels is the definition of courage. She had strength in times of pain and grief and hope for a better tomorrow. Yettie was willing to do the unthinkable in outrageous circumstances. Courage is a thing we all strive for, and Yettie achieved it. She was literally fearless and never afraid to face her fears. Lets face it , she was one of the many lucky survivors of the Holocaust.That is courage.…

    • 863 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages

    To many of us non Jews, whether it be Christian or Muslim or whatever, I…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    For the 12 years that Germany was ruled by the Nazi Party, a central belief was that there existed in society, certain people who were dangerous and needed to be eliminated for German society to flourish and survive. They included Gypsies, Poles, and Russians, but always and most certainly, the Jews. The Nazis condemned the Jews to death and there was no escape. No change in their behaviour or their beliefs would help them escape their fate. At every stage of the war, the Germans used their military power to dominate and terrorize the Jews. Thousands of Nazis and their accomplices searched the cities and countryside of Europe to eliminate Jews. This was a goal to which the Nazis devoted themselves completely. The Jews were in turn abandoned by their neighbours and by the world. They had no country of their own to which they could turn, and no means of self defense. The majority of the populations in which they lived remained indifferent to their fate. Many even helped the Nazis to imprison and deport Jews to the death camps.…

    • 1266 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust is considered the greatest act of hate and anti-Semitism in modern history. This relentless act of hate and genocide was made possible by the Nazi party under Adolf Hitler’s orders carried out by Heinrich Himmler to exterminate Jews and other minorities. The Holocaust is responsible for over 9 million people (an estimate of 6 million people murdered were Jews). Because the Holocaust was so insidious, this part of history cannot be forgotten to prevent these atrocities from ever happening. The book Night by Elie Weisel shows some infamous reasons why the Holocaust should never be forgotten.…

    • 584 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust was one of the most disturbing and petrifying eras of all time. The holocaust, one of the most famous genocides in the world, has showed the world what the evils of man can do to mankind. It was the genocide that killed approximately six million Jews and millions of others in a state-sponsored murder by Nazi Germany led by Adolf Hitler. In a book review of “The Holocaust” by Gilbert Martin, Martin says that, “The Holocaust is the definitive account of what is the most horrifying crime ever committed against humanity”. This brutal torture affected many Jews living in Europe, physically and mentally.…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Holocaust

    • 2668 Words
    • 11 Pages

    The Holocaust is one of the worst scenarios of genocide ever known to the world. The Jewish people of Europe were terrorized and slaughtered over a period that lasted nearly two and half years. During that time, nearly eleven million people were killed, including six million Jews. Even though the actual mass killings of the Jews lasted about two and a half years, the planning of this genocide started many years earlier. In order for the world to never experience this tragedy again, we need to look back at the events of the Holocaust and see how the world might be able to prevent this from happening again.…

    • 2668 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust was a horrific time, dating from 1933 to 1945, in our history as human beings. The descriptions and facts in this essay may make you question if we as people are even human to begin with. Such evilness is portrayed in the time of the Holocaust by the soldiers of what is called the Nazi army. The Nazi army was led by a very cruel and evil man named Adolf Hitler, a said spawn of the devil himself. The era of the Holocaust was a time span in which many people considered “a time of Hell.”…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Witness Holocaust

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Gary Weissman evokes the term "non-witness" in order to stress that subsequent generations only experience the Holocaust through representations of it. The term “non-witness stresses that those who did not witness the Holocaust, and that the experience of listening to, reading, or viewing witness testimony is not an experience of victimization. While there is the opportunity to read books or watch films on the Holocaust, listen to Holocaust survivors, visit Holocaust museums, take trips to Holocaust memorial sites in Europe, research and write about the Holocaust, look at photographs, but in none of these cases are we witnessing the actual events of the Holocaust. This is exactly to point where contemporary authors have nothing but their imagination and the possibilities engendered by fiction to represent and thus bear witness to the Holocaust. For them, the Holocaust is nothing but a vast void, the trauma it engendered an “impossible history". Narrative theorist Ernstvan Alphen explains that "[i]f we are to make sense of the Holocaust, the…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust was a very tragic and horrifying event in history that changed human minds forever. Millions of Jews died in this event, because of mass murders and death camps. Adolf Hitler was a very cruel, but persuasive leader of Germany. He turned many people against the Jewish by blaming the loss of World War I on them. Adolf started to send Jews to concentration and death camps, so Jews hid. Many Jews went into hiding, such as, Jeannine Burk. During her childhood she hid for two years from the Nazi. However, she hid by herself in a stranger’s house and didn’t receive attention and love. Jeannine had to stay away from her family, and the only friends she had were imaginary. She could only go to the backyard, and when the Nazi had marches…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust, (Holocaust derived from the Greek word “holos,” meaning completely, and “kaustos,” meaning burnt), refers to Germany’s NAZI (National Socialist political party) regimes deliberate extermination of 9 to 11 million Jews, Poles, Slavs, Soviet POW’s, Romans, physically disabled people, mentally ill people, gay men, Freemasons,…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Holocaust was one of the most horrible and dreaded events in history. Millions of Jews were killed, leaving many families devastated and hopeless. With the goal of racial purity, Adolf Hitler- along with many other Germans believed the Jews caused the defeat of their country, and led the Nazis to the elimination of Jews. For this reason, “Even in the early 21st century, the legacy of the Holocaust endures…as many as 12,000 Jews were killed every day” (The Holocaust). Later, Hitler organized concentration camps, where mass transports of Jews from ghettoes were brought and typically killed also. However, the fortunate Jews that were not killed still had many restrictions on their rights and freedom, compared to the followers of Hitler. Some of which were that “Jews are prohibited from all legal practices… Law requires Jewish passports to be stamped with a large red ‘J’…Law for compulsory Aryanization of all Jewish businesses,” etc. (The History Place: Holocaust Timeline). Many Jews suffered and never came out of concentration camps alive; the harsh conditions of the Holocaust harmed countless numbers of Jews and their families. “The Holocaust was the systematic annihilation of six million Jews by the Nazis during World War 2 … By 1945 two out of every three European Jews had been killed. 1.5 million children were murdered” (Bülow). Therefore, Jews were treated very unfairly and brutally by Germans during the Holocaust. They had their rights taken away, they were required to obey all words of Hitler- who threatened them with the loss of their lives, and Jews had no word against the propaganda Hitler set up all over the country.…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The holocaust is among the most notorious mass murders in the world, in which millions of Jews, gypsies, disabled people, and homosexuals were persecuted. In the graphic novel, Maus I: A Survivor’s Tale: My Father Bleeds History, by Art Spiegelman, Spiegelman interviews his father, Vladek, about his experiences during the holocaust and reveals the afflictions of the Jewish population. Through his delineation, Vladek exposes the heinous methods the Nazis used against the Jews in hopes of exterminating them entirely. Some methods the Nazis used to suppress the Jewish population include the spread of anti-semitic ideas, the relocation and division of families, and the use of concentration camps, all of which had immediate and long lasting repercussions.…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays