Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Historiographical Essay: An Overview

Satisfactory Essays
874 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Historiographical Essay: An Overview
What is -- and How to Write -- a Historiographical Essay
(c) Muskingum College, Department of History, 2005

Defining Historiography:

Historians do not always agree about how to interpret the events and people that they study; this leads to multiple explanations, which at times, are diametrically opposed to each other. As students progress into upper-level courses in the Department of History, they must move from the mastery of facts and analysis of primary sources encouraged by lower-level courses to a richer and deeper understanding of how history is written and the fact that events and ideas are open to interpretation. Within History 420 (Readings in History), students then move into another level of explanation, where they read intensively on a topic and provide their own historiographical explanations for a series of events/ideas.

Therefore, historiography can be described as “the history of history.” What this means in practice is an exploration of a specific topic, and how historians have explained events or people over time, i.e. how their explanations have changed due to their own worldview and/or ideological bent, due to re-interpretation of previously-viewed sources, due to the availability of new sources, previously unexplored, and/or due to the application of different questions and/or methodologies to sources. Revision of prior interpretations of the past is an implicit and important element of historiography. It requires students to not only be able to explain the different schools of thought or interpretations but also potentially to develop their own explanations, based on their assigned readings. The focus of a historiographical essay is not on the event or person itself; rather, it is on the interpretations of the event or person.
Process:
1. Read and analyze multiple works independently on the same topic (assigned on weekly or bi-weekly basis), including an exploration of the sources that the authors utilize or do not utilize in shaping their arguments.
a. Make sure that you are not merely summarizing the author’s ideas; rather, you are providing analysis of the work’s argument, sources, and conclusions and of the author’s own interpretation of said topic.
b. In addition, each author is likely to provide an explanation of the fit of his/her work within the larger historiographical context; take careful note of this as well, particularly when he/she references other assigned works.
c. Another element of this process is to have a firm understanding of who the author is; be certain to conduct research into previous publications, ideological background and/or current research interests. Are there any parts of his/her background that are directly related to the subject matter and if so, what are the pros and cons of this?
2. Questions to consider as you write your historiographical essay: Individual Works

• What is the “main point” or argument made by each work regarding your specific topic? Think particularly about whether or not the author is trying to reinforce an earlier perception of history or argue for a re-interpretation of the past. • What kinds of sources are used, how and why? How does the author deal with counter-evidence, i.e. information that seems to weaken or contradict the thesis? • What are the strengths and weaknesses in terms of argument, analysis and conclusions of the work? • How does this work relate to earlier readings, i.e. do they present similar or dissimilar ideas and how/why? • How do these authors or works, as a group, contribute our understanding of this series of historical events and their outcome?
3. Bring these works together in an integrated analysis that incorporates and explains the different arguments, conclusions and evidence of various authors in order to build your own explanation of a central theme. An integrated analysis is one that not only draws on different books/articles but also explains how the works agree and disagree with each other. A particularly strong historiographical essay will do this by considering multiple points of view within discussion of a sub-topic, all in one well-crafted paragraph or series of paragraphs, which is then connected back to the overall argument. Then you would move on to the next connected sub-topic, again linking back to the overall argument. You want to avoid the temptation to simply discuss one work, then the next, and then another, with little explanation or analysis of how they fit together.
4. Questions to consider as you write your historiographical essay: The Big Picture • How has the historiography of your topic evolved over time? What has changed in terms of interpretation of events and ideas? What was the initial interpretation of this event, idea or person? How has it changed and why? • How have ideological shifts had an impact on your topic? Are the authors under study wedded to a particular “historical school” i.e. Marxist, Feminist, Neo-Conservative, Liberal, and/or how does the author’s main lens of analysis (cultural, political, military, social, etc.) have an impact on his/her interpretations? • Have the “discovery” or re-interpretation of sources caused historians to ask new questions or take their research in new directions? • Have historians used different methodological approaches (e.g. quantitative, linguistic) in their work and how was this had an impact on conclusions?

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Although events in history occurred over a long span of time and development, history first became an academic subject a little more than 100 years ago (McNeill 12). Since then, a plethora of controversies appeared regarding how historians, scholars, and intellectuals should examine and analyze history. Among the initial methods of studying history was the scientific research method, or scientific source criticism, which fundamentally extracts valid, legitimate facts from a diverse range of historical sources. Throughout time, however, the facts derived from this method of historical study gradually altered, leading to a new method of historical study: using facts and combining them with opinions and goals to constitute personal interpretations. As Oscar Handlin zealously asserts, historians and scholars should provide a strict examination of history based on a chronological study of known and verifiable facts as opposed to using verifiable facts as the basis for their own interpretation, influenced by their own group, experiences, beliefs, and personal motives. Through implementing a strict examination of history, historians can successfully detect and eradicate bias in their writings, allow the government as well as individuals to gain an insight into the past in order to secure and progress the future, and grasp the magnitude of truth.…

    • 645 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The role of the historian, in regards to the construction of history, is one of paramount importance. When constructing history it is imperative that historians do not reduce the integrity of historical sources and maintain credibility and accuracy within their accounts. An historian must strive towards objectivity, and eliminate bias, use relevant sources that are reliable and credible and also aim to represent the ‘truth of the past’ accurately which will ultimately allow an historian to construct a credible and accurate representation of the past.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    MacLeod, Anne Scott. “Rewriting History. (Cover Story).” Teacher Magazine 9.7 (1998): Academic Search Premier. Web. 10 January, 2013.…

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In their efforts to understand the past, historians rely upon a mixture of primary and secondary sources. Primary sources provide specific details about an event and offer insights into how people alive at the time of the event perceived its meaning and importance. Secondary sources provide historians context, or an intellectual framework, that helps them to interpret the primary sources. For example, the article that you will read for this assignment is a primary source. It will make a great deal more sense after you have studied a secondary source, the classroom lectures on the New…

    • 261 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hoa Essay

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Historians might disagree, too, as a result of the methods they use to explore their subjects. One scholar might choose to examine slavery by using psychological techniques; another might reach different conclusions by employing quantitative methods and making use of a computer. Because history is an unusually integrative discipline—that is, because it employs methods and ideas from many different fields of knowledge, ranging from science to the humanities, from economics to literary criticism—the historian has available an enormous range of techniques,…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The purpose of this essay is that history is a result of point of view.…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Conflicting perspectives require students to explore various representations of events, personalities or situations… Medium of production, textual form, perspective and choice of language influence meaning”…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    and Culture PUL will be the focus of the essays “The critical thinking PUL is addressed through…

    • 2352 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The legendary nature and reality of historic data complement each other when students study the past. They can learn principles like change over time, sound argumentation and debate, the nature of decisions and actions taken by influential people, assessment of the untold stories, positive or negative outcomes of both good and bad intentions, critical analysis of incredible amounts of data followed by precise explanations of the given information, bringing primary sources into context, etc. While each of these principles can be used directly in the field of history, their application transcends to other career paths as well. The subject of history is meant to go beyond classroom application, not only to be used by teachers for jobs and students for class…

    • 1445 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Long essay

    • 1386 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The basic skills to be tested are similar to those expected in a supervision essay: the ability to argue clearly and cogently; to expound the issues involved in a given topic or problem; to evaluate interpretations and their relevance to the evidence on which historical argument is based. Essays may vary in the extent of their treatment of historiography depending on the approaches of individual options, but because many Themes and Sources options focus particularly on primary source material, students are expected, where possible, to pay special attention to evaluating sources, e.g. by discussing and comparing their reliability and explaining their value for the historian. Sophisticated discussion of such matters raised by a question or topic may comprise the main contents of an essay. However, in other cases…

    • 1386 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    2. Juxtaposing the teacher’s version of historical events with the description of the children after they left the classroom is able to reflect what knowledge children can gain from their history class, and whether the history class can influence them. The effect of juxtaposing these two pieces of information together is to show that nothing has happened to the children after learning history because the teacher tries to teach the knowledge in a positive and simple way in order to keep the children’s innocence. The children still keep their nature to “torment the weak and smart” on the playground after their history class, and they are still innocent with the positive knowledge of history they have been taught.…

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why Study History?

    • 280 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The ability to assess evidence, conflicting situations, and past examples of change are all gained as a result of studying history. Students of history can use their training for broader professional purposes. They develop a broad outlook that gives them the range and flexibility required in many work situations. These advantages vary based on what kind of history is studied. Learning about different kinds of history offers many benefits. In the end, the advantages gained from studying history are many and differ in their way of providing assistance, whether in everyday society, the work force, or in gaining knowledge about why things have come to be as they exist…

    • 280 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    US history 1491-1800

    • 14545 Words
    • 67 Pages

    History is a complex process that combines historical facts and a historian’s interpretation to those facts…

    • 14545 Words
    • 67 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is useful to begin by considering why essay-writing has long been the method of choice for assessment in history. The chief reason is that no other method provides as effective a means of testing a student's comprehension of a topic. We want you to show us that not only have you acquired a knowledge of the topic but also that you fully understand the topic and the issues raised by it. Essays test understanding by asking you to select and re-organise relevant material in order to produce your own answer to the set question.…

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Why Study History?

    • 5161 Words
    • 21 Pages

    Historians do not perform heart transplants, improve highway design, or arrest criminals. In a society that quite correctly expects education to serve useful purposes, the functions of history can seem more difficult to define than those of engineering or medicine. History is in fact very useful, actually indispensable, but the products of historical study are less tangible, sometimes less immediate, than those that stem from some other disciplines.…

    • 5161 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Better Essays