Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Rhetorical Analysis: Harry Potter and the Death of Reading

Good Essays
940 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Rhetorical Analysis: Harry Potter and the Death of Reading
Mrs. Lander
FYC
September 17, 2007
Harry Potter and the Death of Reading
Ask anyone on the street if he or she has heard of Harry Potter and you will almost certainly get an affirmative answer. In some cases, you may even get a passionate, in-depth reply, followed by a myriad of questions concerning your own opinions. While this type of popularity and fascination in literature seems encouraging, some believe that the mania behind certain novels and series hides a less than stellar trend. Ron Charles, senior editor of Book World, argues that the United States is experiencing a steep decline in the integrity of reading in his article “Harry Potter and the Death of Reading”, published in the Washington Post in July 2007.
As a book critic for a well-known newspaper, Charles has reviewed numerous novels. Many of his previous articles allude to what this article boldly proclaims: his disappointment in the American literary standard. In December of 2006, in a review of a German novel, Charles wrote, “Measuring the World has sat on the German bestseller list for more than a year and sold more than 750,000 copies. In the American book market, that would require a teenage wizard…” His sarcastic attitude and allusion to Harry Potter convey his negative view of American taste in literature. Again in April 2007, in a review of Ludlow, Charles sadly reports, “the publicity director at a major New York publisher once told me there probably aren't more than 80,000 regular readers of literary fiction in America,” to emphasize how sharply interest in classic fiction has dropped.
Those remaining 80,000 readers of fiction are the main audience of Charles’ regular book reviews. The intended audience for “Harry Potter and the Death of Reading”, however, is decidedly larger because of the popularity of the novels discussed. Also, the timing of “Harry Potter and the Death of Reading” could not have been better; it was released days before the seventh edition of the Harry Potter series was up for sale, when the Potter mania was at its peak.
The main claim of Charles’ argument in “Harry Potter and the Death of Reading” is that American society is suffering from “a bad case of cultural infantilism” in which the integrity of our reading standards have gone into a steep decline. With references to the Harry Potter series trailing through the entire article as a continuous example, Charles works his way through appalling statistics about reading in American society and then analyzes the possible causes and solutions to such a decline. His reasons adequately support his claim: that the decline is caused by “the literary equivalent of loss of biodiversity,” for one. He quotes a 1994 Stanford study that discovered “over 70 percent of total fiction sales were accounted for by a mere five authors.” He also claims people are uneducated in how to choose which literary works to read. The average American merely looks to the bestsellers, which “[submerge] the world in an orgy of marketing hysteria” for the one book but leaves them in the dark concerning what other books might be worthwhile to read. Most of Charles’ statistics serve well to support both his suggested causes for the drop in reading integrity. But the article is not entirely statistical. The argument begins with a small narrative, capturing the reader’s attention and establishing a bit of pathos.
Charles’ ethos is established almost inherently; he is the senior editor of the Washington Post’s Book World, therefore it is assumed by his readers that he knows a thing or two about the definition of a good book. He also addresses a popular counter-argument in this article to establish a sense of fairness, since most people don’t entirely trust a fiercely biased piece of writing, and also because he knows how popular Harry Potter is. Lastly, Charles slips in the fact that he has had a “dozen years of teaching English,” giving him more credibility as a source of knowledge on literary works.
Logos is found through Charles’ connection between the dropping literary standard and his suggested causes. Charles does not merely make a claim, but gives plausible reasons for his claim to be true and cites many relevant sources to effectively solidify his causes. For example, Charles cites the National Endowment for the Arts, a U.S. federally funded program established in 1965 and “dedicated to supporting excellence in the arts…and providing leadership in arts education.” The source he uses is logical and relevant to his argument and even establishes a bit of ethos.
Finally, Charles effectively establishes pathos through his narration, his language, and his status as the average American adult. Charles begins the article with a small anecdote in which he is reading a Harry Potter novel to his daughter. This keeps him from sounding too anti-Harry Potter and shows that he himself has not been immune to the marketing scheme. Charles also maintains simple, direct language throughout, even when his writing changes from narrative to argument. His continuous references to Harry Potter keep his readers attention and his little sarcastic phrases, such as “Cap’n Crunch in a Gucci bag,” reveal Charles’ sharp wit. He seems amiable throughout his article, willing to put a dash of humor in an otherwise depressing assessment.
Charles’ argument that the American literary standard has dropped is quite clear in this particular article, and if read along with many of his other articles the argument is even stronger. Through Charles’ unique style of writing, his reliable status and sources and his use of rhetorical strategy he is able to maintain a reader’s attention throughout and make an effective statement about popular literature in America.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    It gets interesting when you examine the Harry Potter series through the aspect of commodity culture within the franchise. In her article, Harry Potter and the Technology of Magic, Elizabeth Teare aims to illustrate to her readers that while J.K. Rowling tends to poke fun at consumer culture in her novels, she takes equal measures in real life encouraging children to participate as consumers. Numerous examples from the books, contrast, and comparison to other works are techniques Teare skillfully uses to create a strong and convincing article.…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The well-known author JK Rowling has used her best selling novel Harry Potter not only to entertain but also to convey her points of view on current social issues such as technology. Technology has been something that everyone has come to rely throughout the time, and has helped us gain knowledge through the utilization of tools, techniques and systems that make it easier to use, create, manage and exchange information. Our society could not be imagined without new technologies and their role both in this society and in human life in general.…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The idea of reading has become very unpopular to many people across the world over the past few decades. According to Jordan Weissmann, the author of the article, “The Decline of the American Book Lover”, many people of our generation have stopped reading and have become unintelligent. She says, “The Pew Research Center reported last week that nearly a quarter of American adults had not read a single book in the past year. As in, they hadn't cracked a paperback, fired up a Kindle, or even hit play on an audiobook while in the car. The number of non-book-readers has nearly tripled since 1978”( Weissman). Books provide something that nothing else could ever provide, knowledge. Many could argue that if teachers provide and give us education, what's the point of reading a book? They have forgotten that the only way teachers could’ve gotten the knowledge to teach us is by reading books. Not having books in our society is almost like not having food. It is an essential quality that us humans must have. Similarly. Montag's society almost resembles our current world. Books have been ignored by many people of our generation and nobody has done anything about it. However unlike Montag's society, people of our generation haven’t outlawed reading. They still read books, and it creates a perfect chance to put an end to the extinction of…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Harry Potter Banned?

    • 1723 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Everyone loves to sit down and read a good book that really makes you get into it. What about a type of literature that really makes you wonder and is not realistic but fun to read about because it is different. Then maybe you should read the book called Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, which was written by a talented writer named J.K. Rowling. This is an amazing book that is very popular, but then at the same time very disliked by some also. Witchcraft and other mythical actions happen upon this novel and can capture your mind in the first chapter. It can capture children and adults alike; this is not just a book for children. Some adults think otherwise though because many of them have been trying to ban Harry Potter books from public schools. Many adults that think this have caused a great amount of arguments between the school districts and community. A vast amount of parents say it is evil and inappropriate to read to students accounting that they may believe in bad beliefs from now on. Harry Potter should not be banned from public schools because you have your own rights, it is your belief with different views, and you can’t control the whole public school.…

    • 1723 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Rhetoric and Reader

    • 1662 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Many writers use several diverse ways to persuade readers into believing them. Some writers may tell a story, provide facts and information, or other ideas to encourage his or her reader to agree with the argument. Aristotle's rhetorical triangle describes three diverse appeals: logos, pathos, and ethos. Logos is based on facts and reasons explaining logical arguments that rely on information and evidence. Logos is built with enough evidence, data, statistics, and reliable information. Another type of appeal is pathos, which attracts the reader's emotions and feelings into the work. Many writers who use pathos tend to write about their personal experience and by diction and tone. In addition to logos and pathos, ethos corresponds with character and value, which describes certain values with specific kinds of groups. Several writers tend to use the diverse appeals in a variety of ways. Two examples that rely on logos and pathos are, "One Picture is Worth a Thousand Diets," by W. Charisse Goodman, and "The Good Death," by .Marilyn Webb…

    • 1662 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Relationships can be started or ended on account of a first impression, but considering someone's personality isn't always shown through this snapshot judgment, first impressions are often deceiving. Sometimes authors use this powerful idea to develop their characters more thoroughly. In Great Expectations by Charles Dickens, Pip is first seen as a conceited and negative character and the Aged is seen as a simply dull one. Through Dickens' use of cheerful diction, Pip and the Aged evolve into more likeable and complex characters.…

    • 371 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Perkins, George B., and Barbara Perkins. Introduction. The American Tradition in Literature. Boston: McGraw-Hill, 2009. Print…

    • 922 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    English Essay Jane Austen

    • 2897 Words
    • 12 Pages

    * Through the guise of “Aunt Fay” Weldon stresses the importance of quality literature as written by Jane Austen. Quality literature, a thing forgotten by the modern day child consequently leaves a child of the modern day recoiling at the thought of reading Weldon.…

    • 2897 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Harry Potter Franchise has influenced young people from all over the world. Whether someone is watching the movies or reading the books the effect on society is unquestionable. Harry Potter’s popularity is massive, because his appeal cuts across demographic and religious lines. The vast majority of teens regardless of gender, ethnicity, faith, or other characteristics have been personally exposed to the story. For instance, even a large majority of teenagers from groups that have objected most stridently to the stories of wizards and witchcraft have indulged in this fantasy world. Even though the Harry Potter franchise is so well known and supported there are many adults and critics that say Harry Potter is a bad influence on our younger generation while others support the opposite saying that the Harry Potter franchise upkeep good morals and great ethics. Another argument that could be made is that both ideas could be good to the vulnerable mind. Having a mixture of both noble and corrupt deeds might be good for an innocent person. For being good one need to know what is evil that way one can prevent oneself from committing evil deeds.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Harry Potter series presents dangerous ideas that can be detrimental to young readers, and should be removed from school libraries.…

    • 519 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Besides, I am fond of reading fiction. Hence, no wonder why I am on the second novel of Harry Potter now. It is children’s fiction, I know, but since I like the first three movies made by the books about Harry Potter, which I have watched repeatedly, I decided that it wouldn’t be difficult for me to read it in the original language, all the more that I would be able to use it for my work. I refer to my hot wish to inspire my pupils to read in English just for pleasure, not only because of school tasks. So, here I am reading “Harry Potter and the Secret Chamber” in my forty-one years…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Literature is said to be any kind of written text that expresses whole expression and feeling. A simple sentence, a word or even a symbol like and apostrophe or a period can also be considered as a literature. Other forms of literature include: a sweet lullaby your mother used to sing when you as a baby, a rock song you are like or a novelty song that made a major trend in the entire planet, or a simple hum. See, there are a lot of examples of literature and we are living with it since we were born until our last breath.…

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arthur Schlesinger, author of many authoritative histories, writes “What Good Books Do For Children.” In the article, he explains how television has replaced the books in the life of the young, and how his generation may have been the last to grow up in a print culture. Schlesinger also believes that most people have read all they are going to read by the age of twenty-five. He believes with a passion that children should read books that face reality rather than fantasy.…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Conventional Books vs E-Book

    • 3186 Words
    • 13 Pages

    As past times go, there's little that is more old-fashioned, quiet and basic as reading a book. Or, at least, that used to be the case. But with the competitive flood of electronic readers, or e-readers, hitting the market as well as e-reader applications for smartphones, the reading experience has been getting a progressively modern makeover. The stats are in and the fight is on. Overall book sales have dropped in 2008 and 2009, according to the American Association of Publishers (AAP). While adult hardcover books actually increased by over 6% in 2009, eBook sales, which account for 4% of all book sales, have increased a whopping 176%.…

    • 3186 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The year 2008 had major changes, such as the election of Obama, the Taliban regime in Afghanistan, and a political change in Russia. During this time J.K. Rowling, author of the well known series Harry Potter, gave a speech that changed 20 thousand people’s view on the world and is still impacting people as of today. In The Fringe Benefits of Failure, and the Importance of Imagination, J. K. Rowling speaks to Harvard graduates about the ideas of failure and how critical individual imagination is from her first hand experiences that allows her to connect with her audience.…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays