Preview

The Good Earth, the book vs. the movie.

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
871 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Good Earth, the book vs. the movie.
The Good Earth, made in 1937, was an interesting portrayal of life in China during these times. Although I think it is a great movie for this era, I had a hard time relating to the film. The advancements in film have made it hard to go back to older movies; things like digital effects and color have really made older movies seem like ancient history. The characters seemed over dramatized and unrealistic. The plot did not stick to the book and seemed to change some of the symbolism the Buck used. The book was much better then the movie and the movie did not do the book justice.

The book is a good representation of Chinese society and shows the independence of each community and the lack of support that the government gives them. The movie did not feature any Chinese actors in the lead roles, but appeared to speak for the Chinese people. Still, the book and movie made Chinese people real for millions of Americans. The Earth is seen through out both the movie and book as a metaphor for the growth of life and culture in China. Loosing touch with the land also meant loosing touch with traditions, morals, and their identities. By the end of the book the sons no longer realize where they come from and take the land for granted. They have forgotten that the land was their source of wealth and that they are dependent on the land for their future. The land also was very cruel to Wang Lung at times. Everyday he struggled and O-lan struggled besides him. All his life he spent his time in the fields, not until his the end of his life did he get to relax.

The Characters O-Lan and Wang Lung changed throughout the story. Wang Lungs character portrays a man's unselfishness, determination, and loyalty towards his family and friends. The character in the end desires rich things and spends money frivolously, and turns away from his family and towards pleasures. Although during his younger years the family was his main focus. Wang Lung is not "free" as a male to do what he wants; he

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    As a Chinese child who was born in Canada, Sek-Lung is living in an immigrant family, and he gets attracted by the local culture so that…

    • 1540 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ah Q Sparknotes

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages

    As the story continues, some Chinese traditions have come alone. Confucianism, filial piety, and women status are expressed more or less. The story is taking place in this newly republic china, when China is still struggling on the road to be republic. Lu Xun doesn’t blame foreigners but rather Chinese people, the ignorant masses, corrupt officials, the self-indulgent, and the lack of compassion at every level. China doesn’t even know it is breaking apart. In this era, people’s life was worthless. Lu Xun is one of the revolutionaries, he used writings as his armour, hoping to wake people’s consciousness. There were no human rights under the rule of Manchus. Farm laborers as Ah Q have the lowest social status. He had no land, no house, the place he lived is in a temple. Being at the bottom of the social structure, Ah Q could not write nor read. He does not even know he was assigned death penalty until on the way to the execution…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Death Of Woman Wang Essay

    • 1581 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Death of Woman Wang, by Jonathan D. Spence, paints a vivid picture of provincial China in the seventeenth century. Manly the life in the northeastern country of T’an-ch’eng. T’an-ch’eng has been through a lot including: an endless cycle of floods, plagues, crop failures, banditry, and heavy taxation. Chinese society in Confucian terms was a patriarchal society with strict rules of conduct. The role at this time of women, however, has historically been one of repression. The traditional ideal woman was a dependent being whose behavior was governed by the "three obedience’s and four virtues". The three obedience’s were obedience to father before marriage, the husband after marriage, and the son in case of widows. The four virtues were propriety in behavior, speech, demeanor and employment. The laws of the land and fear of shame in society dictated that men were allowed to rule over their household leaving women in a powerless state as almost a slave of the home. In P’u’s stories women are portrayed as complex characters who hold important roles in the family, but are treated with little to no respect by authority figures, and other men of higher class. In The Death of Woman Wang, Spence portrays…

    • 1581 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    As established by Wang Lung’s rags-to-riches journey, an unfortunate situation or condition is never permanent. There is a cycle of life that is slightly implied throughout the chapters of the book. When it seems that that world has ended when something terrible occurs, it really hasn’t. For Wang Lung, the combined losses of his wife, Olan, father, and friend, Ching, were especially devastating. But, his spirits are lifted with the marriage of his sons and the birth of his first grandson. As cliché as it sounds, the promise of a better tomorrow is what motivates individuals across the globe to get through…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    A strong, intelligent, independent boy is what every traditional Chinese family wants. Unfortunately, Sek-Lung is not such an ideal child. In the novel, The Jade Peony, Sek-Lung is a marginal character. He is rejected by the dominant group, first being made to feel insignificant and second to feel uncomfortably visible.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Good Earth

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages

    5. As the family works and begs in the city, they think the foreigners are impatient and ill-tempered. When they first arrived, Wang Lung and his family could not understand them under their accent, and the men make fun of him for being a country man. The author includes these descriptions to convey the difference in lifestyles and societies throughout China in this era.…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There are some movies that are adapted from the novel such as Harry Potter, Da Vinci Code, Twilight Saga, The Hunger Games and Lagenda Budak Setan. What are the differences between watching a movie and reading a novel? There are some contrasts between the two actions. One of the differences is by watching a movie, you just need to sit and relax. It is very easy since you only need to watch it and understands it. Furthermore, you can watch the movie while doing something else such as eating or exercising. You do not really have to focus like to imagine how the atmosphere is in the movie at that time or how a person is walking down the streets. Lastly, you can avoid disbelief since it is a multi-sensory experience. On the other hand, by reading…

    • 292 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this story, Wang Lung’s life gives detailed examples of the hardships and struggles of living in a lower social class. Then, as the story progresses, the novel tells of the luxuries and customs of being wealthy. Many people can relate to this novel because it shows what life was a wealthy man and as a poor man. Nowadays, people in third world countries or are just common laborers…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Through her actions and dialogue, it was able to display how she was keeping the family grounded. Her rash yet beneficial decisions allowed her to be the rock of the family and keep them together. When the family was in need of money and they were in the south they as well as many other families raided the homes of the rich. Wang Lung was able to get enough gold for them to move back to the land. Then, Wang Lung felt a lump inbetween O-lan’s breasts. It turned out to rag that was tied and when he opened it and saw of pile of jewels. O-lan explained how she saw “... a brick loosened in the wall and I slipped there carelessly so no other soul could see and demand a share.” (Buck 145) Nothing was mentioned of O-lan even debating on going to the rich man’s house. Her discrete actions show how she’s always putting family first. Plus her not telling Wang right away shows how she doesn't feel the need to brag nor spend it again showing how she keeps the family in…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Good Earth

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages

    First, personification is useful in that it shows Wang Lung’s dependency on the land to find food. Wang Lung has many good harvests and he sells them at the market until the drought. Not only do people steal during the drought, but his aunt and uncle eat their children to survive. To make matters worse, Wang Lung’s family is suffering from starvation without the land producing any food. As time goes on, Wang Lung’s uncle comes to his house attempting to make Wang Lung sell his land. The money he would receive if he sold the land would make him able to get food to feed his family, but it wouldn’t be worth it because it wouldn’t last them much longer. Therefore, O-lan says, “The land we will not sell surely” (Buck 92). Instead, they go south where there is food and when they come back to the farm Wang Lung’s harvests are even richer than before.…

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Red Scarf Girl

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Jiang Ji-li's weak character also contributes to the kind of mood the author feels during the time he/she reads the book. Ji-li, by the way she acts, she seems very fragile and she is not one that can easily accept what negative things that are said about her. Ji-li thinks that there is only good things and good people in the world. If it's not said or pointed out to her, she would never have noticed it. She is too carefree, allowing herself to think that there are only harmless people, that they would never hurt her until there was a da-zi-bao written about her, "Ke Cheng-li doesn't like working-class kids. He only likes rich kids... We have to ask the question, What is the relationship between them after all?" If she had been a very strong girl, knew where she stood and didn't care what others said about her or her family, the reader would have felt a different mood. Though there are other factors that contribute to the story, for instance "setting." In this novel, it talks about the Cultural Revolution of Chairman Mao whose intention was to do good things to China starting by ridding the…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Symbolism In O-Lan

    • 246 Words
    • 1 Page

    One way O-lan symbolizes the earth is they are both incredibly productive. She bears five children for Wang Lung, and cares for each one greatly. She binds the young daughter’s feet, which is a daunting task for both the daughter and O-lan because of the pain it causes, while continuing to work in the field. On page 30, the text stated, “They worked on, moving together-together-producing the fruit of this earth -speechless in their movement together.” Furthermore, after O-lan had given birth to a child, she immediately went back in the fields to work. On page 40, it said, “And then, almost before one could realize anything, the woman was back in the fields beside him.” This exemplifies how O-lan and the earth have similar roles in the story.…

    • 246 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Good Earth, by Pearl Buck is set in the early twentieth century in China. During this time period, many rely on the earth to provide them with food, extra produce to sell in order to buy items the land cannot produce, and even for material to build their earthen homes. The Good Earth begins in the humble home of the Wang family on the wedding day of Wang Lung, when Lung is introduced to his wife, O-lan. Throughout O-lan’s lifetime she has been both a street-beggar and a slave. Having experienced such roles, O-lan is equipped with a plethora of skills which benefit the Wang family. O-lan assists Lung in the fields, makes the family’s clothes, ministers to Lung’s elderly father, prepares all of the family’s meals, and cares for her own children. Lung relies upon O-lan as he relies upon the land. In this novel by Pearl Buck, O-lan symbolizes the earth.…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Good Earth Analysis

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The land went through many hardships, but was still able to provide for the family after the misfortunes had passed. For example, the land went through a long drought, but was able to come back and be farmed, after a while of waiting. Also, the land got hit by a flood, and could not be farmed for a long period of time, but was still able to produce them food afterwards. The earth they reside on provides food rapidly and abundantly for the family. Similarly, O-lan is able to work in the land just as much as Wang Lung. Along with helping toil on the land, she still takes care of his father, prepares food for the entire family, and takes care of their children. And, even though O-lan does not have bound feet, which displeases Wang Lung, she is able to do so much to help the land and Wang Lung than she would if she had her feet bound. In addition to doing so much, O-lan works on the land just days before and after having children, and all throughout her pregnancy. She also cooks even after a long day of work, and gets things done quickly and efficiently. The land is a foundation for their house, just like O-lan is the foundation for their family. Without these two things, the family would fall…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The 17th century illustrated beauty standards that evolved with women’s physical characteristics, submissiveness, and timidity. In the early (21st century), Chinese women are feminine and proficient in skin care. There were four women in ancient China who were praised for their beauty. These beautiful women lived in four different dynasties. According to "China: Under the Hood: Bewitching-The Four Beauties of Ancient China" (2012), there were four women in ancient China who were praised for their beauty as stated, “Xi Shi (c. 7th to 6th century BC/Spring and Autumn Period), Wang Zhao Jun (c. 1st century BC, Western Han Dynasty), Diaochan (c. 3rd century, Late Eastern Han/Three Kingdoms period) and Yang Guifei (719–756, Tang Dynasty)” (2012, 1). Chinese women utilized traditional massage lotions during their skin care routines.…

    • 220 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays