Preview

Gerard Jones's 'Violent Media Is Good For Kids'

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1095 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Gerard Jones's 'Violent Media Is Good For Kids'
“Violent Media is good for Kids” is an article which attempts to persuade the reader that violence (if used in the correct manner) can help children more than it hurts them. Famous comic-book author Gerard Jones claims that gory video games, comics, and cartoons may do a thing or two in helping to increase a child’s self-confidence. Jones says ‘creative violence’ can help by “giving kids a tool to master their rage.” In this time and age parents are more than ever protective of what their child watches, hears, or even comes into contact with. For all the right reasons including the ‘thug’ culture that was first displayed in hip-hop music but now throughout entertainment even including cartoons such as The Boondocks, Family Guy, and The Simpsons. …show more content…
I was especially fond of Jones’s creativity in not using the overused example of “standing up to a bully.” As a child Jones describes himself as “small and puny” unable to face any of his fears. Then one day his mother’s friend suggested that she bought The Hulk comics for Jones. Beginning that day Jones describes his delight to fulfill his inner rage and relate it to the Hulk. Jones claims that this is his inspiration to one day becoming both a famous action movie film writer and comic book writer. As he interviews and comes across children who have also been inspired by his works he says they all had one thing in common, they overcame personal fears as “people pulling themselves out of emotional traps by immersing themselves in violent stories.” In modern society where rage is absolutely opposed, so many kids are unable to release their rage. Where is all this bottled up anger supposed to …show more content…
In this research Jones and Moore look for how violent children stories help children develop confidence. How it can help them fulfill both their developmental and emotional needs. Moore and Jones created a Power play program which help kids realize their self-worth by having those reading books such as Tarzan, Hulk, and Superman. These books instill that the child can imitate whatever the hero does. The hero who is ruthless and brave does not let anything or anyone stop him/her from achieving their goal. From just reading these stories the child can feel that they can take over the world and nothing can stop them. Pretending to be a hero helps a child conquer fears which can come from being so little, small, and powerless due to such great dependency. Children are also able to fight back against bullies, fears, and great dependency which they can mold into

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Vivian Sobchack Analysis

    • 334 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Sociologists and cultural critics still argue about the effects of media violence. I don’t think anybody really knows the answer so why even bring it up in the first place? So kids, why even stock the flames? Still, violence and sensational gore is part and parcel of the beloved action-adventure film, science fiction, and suspense thrillers. It is an important component in the craft of screen writing. In this age of computer animation and special effects, it has become as mundane as ‘coffee and donuts’. Believe me, if they ever pull it all out, you’ll sit up on your sofa one day after your favorite show, or leave the movies after the world was saved and wonder what you…

    • 334 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Gerard Jones’ “Violent Media Is Good for Kids” found in our text, Practical Argument, Jones argues that children should not be sheltered from violence. Gerard Jones discusses his own experiences growing up in a home that banned any violent media. He was a scared, introverted child in desperate need of help understanding the feelings he was taught to bottle up. When a few Incredible Hulk comics somehow made it past his parents and right into his eager hands he was a child reformed. The stories of the violent brute known as The Hulk gave Jones an outlet for his internal rage. Consequently, he became braver and happier with his new so called “fantasy self”.…

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In reading “Violent Media is Good for Kids”; by Gerard Jones, he doesn’t argue against the fact that some harm has come from violence in the media. However the author does convey the fact that he has first handedly seen the positive effects of well managed use of violence in different mediums. Mr. Jones has reinforced my view and opinion on violence in the media by informing me to the efforts of him and his colleague to help children use their natural feelings in a positive manner and find an enlightening outlet.…

    • 414 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Violent Media Is Good For Kids,” Gerard Jones takes his position on how the comic books violence has led him to further develop as a person and inspire his career as a writer. In fact, he talked about how the Hulk led him out of passivity and loneliness as a young kid. But this is only about one person and not everybody else. Nobody is the same in this world.…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A story written in by Gerard Jones called Violent Media is Good for Kids that appeared in Mother Jones under the political section, written 28 June 2000. He is an author of several works to include fictional and non-fictional works. His written for Marvel Comics and other companies. The essay talks about his life, how he was sheltered from violence or what his family felt wasn’t appropriate because of his parents. However, it was his mom that got him hooked on comic books, she thought it would teach him about the bigger picture, he liked the violence. The comic books helped him evolve as a human. And as he evolved, so did his needs for greater substance or more complicated story lines. He argues that comics are healthy and that is teaches important lessons about life, emotions, and the interactions of life.…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Violent Media is Good for Kids,” the author Gerard Jones claims that violent media is good for children because it prepares them for violence in reality and teaches them how to control with rage. He argues against people’s view of violent media being negative influence on children. This view suggests that it is important to keep children away from violent media because it promotes imaginary gun battles, killing, blood, and violent fighting. In response, the author argues that such violence in media can give children a tool to master their rage.…

    • 259 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Gerald Jones’ article “Violent Media is Good for Kids” contained in the book Practical Argument he uses logos to present his argument that the censorship on the emotions of children. The censorship of children from their own emotional tendencies is preventing them from exploring and understating themselves. Jones provides example of this by describing a little girl that had been acting out her anger in her writings and drawings. Adults that interacted in her life attempted to control the violent acts that she wrote about causing her to act out more. With the help of the little girls’ she was encouraged to express herself in her writings. This led to the girl to become more self-confident about herself and to channel her anger better.…

    • 226 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Tap Water

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages

    3: The author has positive preconceptions of the subject. Growing up, Jones related Marvel comic ‘The Incredible Hulk” to his childhood in which he used to overcome fears and develop in boyhood. Violent media helped Jones become who he is today.…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his essay "Violent Media is Good for Kids" Gerard Jones states that parents try to shield their children from violence but in reality they keep them from self realization. In the analysis, Jones uses examples from his life experiences and quotes from a professional in child behavior. His argument, however, is incorrect and his support for his argument plays mostly on emotions and no statistical evidence to support his claims.…

    • 582 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even though Jones’ opening paragraphs have a strong appeal to emotion, the reader is aware that he is a proprietor of violent media, thus he has a financial incentive to propagate a theory that would benefit him. Jones introduces the idea of violent media as a method of therapy for kids, explaining that as they immerse themselves into it, children become more capable of handling stress in their own lives. He draws the reader in through his personal story from when he was young and had his first encounter with Marvel Comics, along with the stories of other young in people with whom he worked using Power Play, the program Jones developed in collaboration with Melanie Moore Ph.D. psychologist. The late example of Power Play is another aspect of self-promotion and implicit bias in Jones essay. The use of visual materials in his article is limited to his own violent cartoons, which emphasizes his bias for one type of media on one hand, and ignorance for other forms of violent media and their negative effects on children, on the other. All examples brought as evidence in this essay are in favor of violent media, thus, lack of data comparison for pros and cons is evidence of bias (or ignorance). While the information presented by Jones is interesting, it promotes his own work disguised as imperative…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In US, people believe violent media corrupts the minds of the youth and provokes violent actions and behaviors. Whenever there is a violent crime or act being committed by children, the first culprit the media turns to are violent video games or TV shows. In the case of one of the most infamous school shootings, Columbine, the news immediately blamed the shooting on played violent video games and music. There was no conclusive evidence for this statement, but the public still believed it. Gerard Jones, author of several works of fiction and nonfiction, writes the article, “Violent Media is Good for Kids”, to counter this popular belief that violent media is the cause of violent behavior. He brings up points on the topic that states that creative…

    • 213 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Disney Stereotypes

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages

    A small and gentle Belle tames a ferocious beast; a love-struck mermaid turns into a quiet, lovesick puppy; Snow White saves dwarves from their pigsty by dusting, sweeping, washing dishes, tidying and sprucing. Beneath the smiles, gardens and cheerful woodland creatures of the classic Disney we all remember from our youth lies a host of stereotypes and media violence that has shaped our generation. Since the early 1960s research evidence suggests that exposure to violence in television, movies, video games, cell phones, and on the internet increases the risk of violent behaviour on the viewer’s part increases the risk of them behaving violently. Most researchers define media violence as visual portrayals of acts of aggression by one human or…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Confliction

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In “Violent Media is Good for Kids,” Gerard Jones states and tries to prove that violent media is indeed good for children. He attempts this by saying that he believes, he grew up too passive because he was sheltered from the media. Hearing that the media has "lofty messages of pacifism and tolerance,” his mother borrowed some comics for him to read so he could learn about independence. After reading the comics he said that he followed Hulk for a while then switched to "more sophisticated heroes, “and "finally found my own lead along a twisting path to a career and an identity." Later on, his son was afraid to climb a tree, so Jones read the stories of Tarzan to his son. About a week or two later, his son was climbing trees. He also gives other examples of children who used violent media to overcome their stressful and hurtful lives. "When we try to protect our children from their own feelings and fantasies, we shelter them not against violence but against power and selfhood." Jones is right to say this; violent media can help kids if it is used in the right way rather than being abused. In recent years there's been dispute about whether or not children should view, or listen to violent media. In "Violent Media is Good for Kids" Gerard Jones says that we should. "When we try to protect our children from their own feelings and fantasies, we shelter them not against violence but against power and selfhood." Jones is right to say this; violent media can help kids if it is used in the right way rather than being abused. He doesn't include statistics to back-up his arguments and that is a downfall of Jones's essay. He does however include examples as to why he believes that violent media is good for children. His examples my not be credible, but when you think about it he has a good point: violent media is good for kids if used the right way. So instead of trying to keep the kids away from the media we should…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the past few years, more and more people have been discussing the topic of violent media to figure out if it triggers violent behavior to some people. Some media critics believe that young people play violent video games and read violent comic books as a safe place for kids to let out their aggression. Gerald Jones wrote a passage arguing that violent comic books and video games are useful for young people. He was taught as a little kid that violence was wrong and that anger was something you had to learn to overcome. While he was young, he was given violent comic books that also had good life lessons in them. Since those comic books Jones has been writing action movies and comic books, and made him into the man he is today. He believes…

    • 247 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Superheroes

    • 542 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Since the early 90's, there has been talk of how media violence and aggressive behaviour have affected the youth. Worried that violence was creeping into their children's lives, a group of child care centres in Melbourne have declared themselves "superhero-free zones", wherein children are prohibited from wearing any symbols or costuming of their favourite superheroes, as well as pretending to be or have any super powers. They claim that today's superheroes aren't suitable for today's children, and "cause their imaginations to be stretched in potentially harmful ways." Where will these day-care police draw the line? If a kid can't be Superman or Spiderman, can he be Buzz Light-year? Is SpongeBob Square pants a threatening archetype? Superheroes aren’t the villains they’re made out to be. As a role model, Spiderman spins an empowering web, both literally and figuratively. This is because he claims all his superhuman abilities are the results of "working out, getting plenty of rest, and you know, eating your green vegetables". Just what mom always told you, right? Spiderman also wakes up each day with a goal, a desire to give himself unconditionally to helping those in need. He realizes the fact that “With great power comes great responsibility”, a concept that is key in today’s society as the youth become more empowered.…

    • 542 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays