Frameworks for Measuring Innovation
Working Paper #06
Frameworks for Measuring Innovation:
Initial Approaches
Susan Rose Stephanie Shipp Bhavya Lal Alexandra Stone Science and Technology Policy Institute
March 2009
Athena Alliance 911 East Capitol St., SE Washington, DC 20003 www.athenaalliance.org | info@athenaalliance.org
Frameworks for Measuring Innovation: Initial Approaches
About Athena Alliance Athena Alliance is in the vanguard of identifying, understanding, analyzing, and educating on the information, intangibles, and innovation (I3 or I-Cubed) economy. Information, knowledge, and other intangibles now power economic prosperity and wealth creation. Intangible assets—worker skills and know-how, informal relationships that feed creativity and new ideas, high-performance work organizations, formal intellectual property, and brand names—are the new keys to competitive advantage. Intangibles and information drive innovation through a combination of formal research and informal creativity. These elements come together to power the productivity gains and process improvements that enhance prosperity in the 21st century. While the economic rules have changed, public policy has not caught up. Governments are struggling with ways to utilize information, foster development of intangibles, and promote innovation and competitiveness in this new economy. Policymakers are grappling with the urgent need to frame policy questions in light of the changing economic situation. Issues of developing and utilizing information, managing intangibles, and fostering innovation underlie discussions on a variety of subjects, such as intellectual property rights, education and training policy, economic development, technology policy, and trade policy. Crafting new policies in these areas requires infusing a better understanding of intangibles and the information economy into the public debate. As a nonprofit public policy research organization, Athena Alliance seeks to close the gap between the changed
Frameworks for Measuring Innovation:
Initial Approaches
Susan Rose Stephanie Shipp Bhavya Lal Alexandra Stone Science and Technology Policy Institute
March 2009
Athena Alliance 911 East Capitol St., SE Washington, DC 20003 www.athenaalliance.org | info@athenaalliance.org
Frameworks for Measuring Innovation: Initial Approaches
About Athena Alliance Athena Alliance is in the vanguard of identifying, understanding, analyzing, and educating on the information, intangibles, and innovation (I3 or I-Cubed) economy. Information, knowledge, and other intangibles now power economic prosperity and wealth creation. Intangible assets—worker skills and know-how, informal relationships that feed creativity and new ideas, high-performance work organizations, formal intellectual property, and brand names—are the new keys to competitive advantage. Intangibles and information drive innovation through a combination of formal research and informal creativity. These elements come together to power the productivity gains and process improvements that enhance prosperity in the 21st century. While the economic rules have changed, public policy has not caught up. Governments are struggling with ways to utilize information, foster development of intangibles, and promote innovation and competitiveness in this new economy. Policymakers are grappling with the urgent need to frame policy questions in light of the changing economic situation. Issues of developing and utilizing information, managing intangibles, and fostering innovation underlie discussions on a variety of subjects, such as intellectual property rights, education and training policy, economic development, technology policy, and trade policy. Crafting new policies in these areas requires infusing a better understanding of intangibles and the information economy into the public debate. As a nonprofit public policy research organization, Athena Alliance seeks to close the gap between the changed
References: Aizcorbe, A., C. Moylan, and C. Robbins. Toward a Better Measurement of Innovation and Intangibles. Survey of Current Business. Bureau of Economic Analysis, Washington, D.C., 2009. Arundel, A. Innovation Survey Indicators: What Impact On Innovation Policy? Science, Technology, and Innovation Indicators in a Changing World: Responding to Policy Needs. OECD Blue Sky II Forum, Ottawa, Canada, Sept. 25–27, 2006. Published September 2007 (ISBN 978–92–64–03966–7), part 3, chapter 4, 2007. Blair, M. and S. M. H.Wallman. Unseen Wealth: Report of the Brookings Task Force on Intangibles. Brookings Institution Press, Washington, D.C., 2001. Branscomb, L. Research Alone Is Not Enough. Science, Vol. 321, No. 5891, 2008. Corrado, C., C. Hulten, and D. Sichel. Intangible Capital and Economic Growth. Working Paper 11948. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 2006. Department of Commerce (DOC). Advisory Committee on Measuring Innovation in the 21st Century Economy. Innovation Measurement: Tracking the State of Innovation in the American Economy. Report to the Secretary of Commerce, 2008. Hill, P., and R. Youngman. The Measurement of Intellectual Capital Formation in the System of National Accounts. PRISM WP5, 2003. Jarboe, K. P. Measuring Intangibles: A Summary of Recent Activity. Alliance for Science and Technology Research in America, Washington, D.C., 2007. Jarboe, K. P., and R. Furrow. Intangible Asset Monetization: The Promise and the Reality. Working Paper #03, Athena Alliance, Washington, D.C., 2008. Lev, B. Intangibles: Management, Measurement, and Reporting. Brookings Institution Press, Washington, D.C., 2001. Mandel, M., with S. Hamm and C. J. Farrell. Why The Economy Is A Lot Stronger Than You Think. BusinessWeek, Feb. 13, 2006 Meyer, P. B., and Harper, M. J. Preliminary estimates of multifactor productivity growth. Monthly Labor Review, June 2005, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Washington, D.C. Milbergs, E., with B. Kalweit and R. Boege. Innovation Vital Signs. Report No. v.2.8. Alliance for Science & Technology Research in America, Washington, D.C., June 2007. Milbergs, E., and N. Vonortas. Innovation Metrics: Measurement To Insight. Center for Accelerating Innovation and George Washington University. National Innovation Initiative 21st Century Working Group, Sept. 22, 2004. Nakamura, L. What Is the U.S. Gross Investment in Intangibles? (At Least) One Trillion Dollars a Year! Working Paper No. 01–15. Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, October 2001. Athena Alliance March 2009 19 | Page Frameworks for Measuring Innovation: Initial Approaches OECD. National Efforts to Measure Intangible Investment. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris, France, 1998. OECD. Oslo Manual: Guidelines for Collecting and Interpreting Innovation Data (3rd edition). Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris, France, 2005. Stone, A., S. Rose, B. Lal, and S. Shipp. Measuring Innovation and Intangibles: A Business Perspective. Institute for Defense Analysis, Science and Technology Policy Institute, Washington, D.C., 2008. Athena Alliance March 2009 20 | Page