Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Jane Eyre and Much Ado About Nothing: Search for Family, Sense of Belonging, Love, and Need for Independence

Better Essays
1489 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Jane Eyre and Much Ado About Nothing: Search for Family, Sense of Belonging, Love, and Need for Independence
The main quest in Jane Eyre is Jane's search for family, for a sense of belonging and love. However, this search is constantly tempered by Jane’s need for independence. This does become an impediment in the love of jane and mr Rochester. She begins the novel as an unloved orphan who is almost obsessed with finding love as a way to establish her own identity and achieve happiness. Although she does not receive any parental love from Mrs. Reed, Jane finds surrogate maternal figures throughout the rest of the novel. Bessie, Miss Temple, and even Mrs. Fairfax look after Jane and give her the love she needs. She returns the favor by caring for Adèle a young French girl at thornfield hall and the students at her school. Still, Jane does not feel as though she has found her true family until she falls in love with Mr. Rochester at Thornfield. However, she is unable to accept Mr. Rochester’s first marriage proposal because she realizes that their marriage - one based on unequal social standing - would compromise her autonomy. Jane similarly denies St. John's marriage proposal, as it would be one of duty, not of passion. Only when she gains financial and emotional autonomy, after having received her inheritance and the familial love of her cousins, can Jane accept Rochester's offer. In fact, the blinded Rochester is more dependent on her (at least until he regains his sight). Within her marriage to Rochester, Jane finally feels completely liberated, bringing her dual quests for family and independence to a satisfying conclusion.
Religion
Jane receives three different models of Christianity throughout the novel, all of which she rejects either partly or completely before finding her own way. Mr. Brocklehurst's Evangelicalism is full of hypocrisy: he spouts off on the benefits of privation and humility while he indulges in a life of luxury and emotionally abuses the students at Lowood. Also at Lowood, Helen Burns's Christianity of absolute forgiveness and tolerance is too meek for Jane's tastes; Helen constantly suffers her punishments silently and eventually dies. St. John, on the other hand, practices a Christianity of utter piousness, righteousness, and principle to the exclusion of any passion. Jane rejects his marriage proposal as much for his detached brand of spirituality as for its certain intrusion on her independence.
However, Jane frequently looks to God in her own way throughout the book, particularly after she learns of Mr. Rochester's previous marriage and before St. John takes her in to Moor House. She also learns to adapt Helen’s doctrine of forgiveness without becoming complete passive and returns to Mr. Rochester when she feels that she is ready to accept him again. The culmination of the book is Jane’s mystical experience with Mr. Rochester that brings them together through a spirituality of profound love.
Social position
Brontë uses the novel to express her critique of Victorian class differences. Jane is consistently a poor individual within a wealthy environment, particularly with the Reeds and at Thornfield. Her poverty creates numerous obstacles for her and her pursuit of happiness, including personal insecurity and the denial of opportunities. The beautiful Miss Ingram's higher social standing, for instance, makes her Jane's main competitor for Mr. Rochester’s love, even though Jane is far superior in terms of intellect and character. Moreover, Jane’s refusal to marry Mr. Rochester because of their difference in social stations demonstrates her morality and belief in the importance of personal independence, especially in comparison to Miss Ingram’s gold-digging inclinations. Although Jane asserts that her poverty does not make her an inferior person, her eventual ascent out of poverty does help her overcome her personal obstacles. Not only does she generously divide her inheritance with her cousins, but her financial independence solves her difficulty with low self-esteem and allows her to fulfill her desire to be Mr. Rochester’s wife.

Gender inequality
Alongside Brontë's critique of Victorian class hierarchy is a subtler condemnation of the gender inequalities during the time period. The novel begins with Jane's imprisonment in the "red-room" at Gateshead, and later in the book Bertha's imprisonment in the attic at Thornfield is revealed. The connection implies that Jane's imprisonment is symbolic of her lower social class, while Bertha's containment is symbolic of Victorian marriage: all women, if they marry under unequal circumstances as Bertha did, will eventually be confined and oppressed by their husbands in some manner. Significantly, Jane is consciously aware of the problems associated with unequal marriages. Thus, even though she loves Mr. Rochester, she refuses to marry him until she has her own fortune and can enter into the marriage contract as his equal.
While it is difficult to separate Jane's economic and gender obstacles, it is clear that her position as a woman also prevents her from venturing out into the world as many of the male characters do – Mr. Rochester, her Uncle John, and St. John, for instance. Indeed, her desire for worldly experience makes her last name ironic, as "Eyre" derives from an Old French word meaning "to travel." If Jane were a man, Brontë suggests, she would not be forced to submit to so much economic hardship; she could actively attempt to make her fortune. As it is, however, Jane must work as a governess, the only legitimate position open for a woman of her station, and simply wait for her uncle to leave her his fortune.
Fire and Ice
The motifs of fire and ice permeate the novel from start to finish. Fire is presented as positive, creative, and loving, while ice is seen as destructive, negative, and hateful. Brontë highlights this dichotomy by associating these distinct elements with particular characters: the cruel or detached characters, such as Mrs. Reed and St. John, are associated with ice, while the warmer characters, such as Jane, Miss Temple, and Mr. Rochester, are linked with fire. Interestingly, fire serves as a positive force even when it is destructive, as when Jane burns Helen's humiliating "Slattern" crown, and when Bertha sets fire to Mr. Rochester’s bed curtains and then to Thornfield Manor. The first of Bertha’s fires brings Jane and Mr. Rochester into a more intimate relationship, while the second destroys Thornfield and leads to Bertha's death, thus liberating Rochester from his shackled past. Although the fire also blinds Rochester, this incident helps Jane see that he is now dependent on her and erases any misgivings she may have about inequality in their marriage. Although Brontë does not suggest that the characters associated with ice are wholly malignant or unsympathetic, she emphasizes the importance of fiery love as the key to personal happiness.
Gothic elements
Brontë uses many elements of the Gothic literary tradition to create a sense of suspense and drama in the novel. First of all, she employs Gothic techniques in order to set the stage for the narrative. The majority of the events in the novel take place within a gloomy mansion (Thornfield Manor) with secret chambers and a mysterious demonic laugh belonging to the Madwoman in the Attic. Brontë also evokes a sense of the supernatural, incorporating the terrifying ghost of Mr. Reed in the red-room and creating a sort of telepathic connection between Jane and Mr. Rochester. More importantly, however, Brontë uses the Gothic stereotype of the Byronic hero to formulate the primary conflict of the text. Brooding and tortured, while simultaneously passionate and charismatic, Mr. Rochester is the focal point of the passionate romance in the novel and ultimately directs Jane’s behavior beginning at her time at Thornfield. At the same time, his dark past and unhappy marriage to Bertha Mason set the stage for the dramatic conclusion of the novel.
External beauty versus internal beauty
Throughout the novel, Brontë plays with the dichotomy between external beauty and internal beauty. Both Bertha Mason and Blanche Ingram are described as stunningly beautiful, but, in each case, the external beauty obscures an internal ugliness. Bertha’s beauty and sensuality blinded Mr. Rochester to her hereditary madness, and it was only after their marriage that he gradually recognized her true nature. Blanche’s beauty hides her haughtiness and pride, as well as her desire to marry Mr. Rochester only for his money. Yet, in Blanche’s case, Mr. Rochester seems to have learned not to judge by appearances, and he eventually rejects her, despite her beauty. Only Jane, who lacks the external beauty of typical Victorian heroines, has the inner beauty that appeals to Mr. Rochester. Her intelligence, wit, and calm morality express a far greater personal beauty than that of any other character in the novel, and Brontë clearly intends to highlight the importance of personal development and growth rather than superficial appearances. Once Mr. Rochester loses his hand and eyesight, they are also on equal footing in terms of appearance: both must look beyond superficial qualities in order to love each other.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The plot of Jane Eyre follows the form of a Bildungsroman, In the novel, there are five distinct stages of development, each linked to a particular place: Jane’s childhood at Gateshead, her education at the Lowood School, her time as Adèle’s governess at Thornfield, her time with the Rivers family at Morton and at Marsh End (also called Moor House), and her reunion with and marriage to Rochester at Ferndean. From these experiences, Jane becomes the mature woman who narrates the novel retrospectively. The main relationship which affects the character of Jane is that of Mr.Rochester, and this relationship also changes throughout the novel, from Master/Governess, to companions, to lovers, to distrust and eventually to marriage.…

    • 3248 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the novel Jane Eyre, by Charlotte Bronte, the main protagonist, Jane experiences a lot of tribulations in life. When she thinks she can lead a happy life with her lover, Mr. Edward Rochester, she finds out that he is, in fact, hiding a dark secret. On the day of their wedding, she discovers that he is already married. Her beliefs and moral standing leads her to leave Mr. Rochester and Thornfield, her safe haven, because she does not want to partake in Mr. Rochester’s infidelity to Bertha Mason. In choosing to leave Mr. Rochester, she gains many more different types of happiness that she would have not had the chance to discover had she stayed with him. In the end, this decision leads to her ultimate happiness as she becomes aware that these…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Charlotte Bronte’s novel “Jane Eyre”, the eponymous protagonist suffers throughout the plot from loneliness and isolation, and these two themes interweave for the duration.…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    I believe that the theme of ‘a love story’ is a small section of a more prominent theme of the novel: Family. The main quest in Jane Eyre is Jane's search for family, for a sense of belonging. On the contrary, this search is constantly tempered by Jane’s need for independence. She begins the novel as an unloved orphan who is almost obsessed with finding love as a way to establish her own identity and achieve happiness. Although she does not receive any parental love from Mrs Reed, Jane finds surrogate maternal figures throughout the rest of the novel. Bessie, Miss Temple, and even Mrs Fairfax care for Jane, giving her the love and guidance that she needs. Jane returns the favour by caring for Adèle and the students at her school. Still, Jane does not feel as though she has found her true family until she falls in love with Mr. Rochester at Thornfield; he becomes more of a kindred spirit to her than any of her biological relatives could be. However, she is unable to accept Mr. Rochester’s first marriage proposal because…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Jane Eyre comes into a position to marry Edward Rochester when she receives her inheritance. Prior to the inheritance, Rochester saw her as a "dependent," who always did "her duty" (Bronte 282). Jane even refers to Rochester as "master" and makes note of the separation of "wealth, caste, custom" between them (Bronte 282). She refers to her love for him as unavoidable and beyond the bounds of class. Rochester proposes marriage to Jane and becomes intent on transforming her into his view of ideal beauty. She resists and tells him, "you…

    • 1299 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Charlotte Bronte was born 2 April 1861, third of the six children of Patrick Brontë and Maria Branwell Brontë. In all her childhood was a sad one. Her mother died in 1821, with her absence, she and two of her older sisters were sent to a school. Conditions there were bad, even for the standard of the time. It was not long before both her sisters became ill and were sent home, where they both dies in the spring of 1825. Proceeding this her father brought her and another sister who had recently joined back home, but through her description of Jane’s school it is obvious that she never forgot. Charlotte married for a very brief period at the end of her life. Her father had forbidden it but she married anyway. This proves that she knew love, unlike many people of her time she was not forced in to her marriage because of money or convenience. This is something that she was very much against, or so we can infer from her writing, refusing to marry St John because she was still in love with Rochester. But, throughout the book we find that there are very few times when she receives the love she gives. In what might be argued the most important relationship in the book, Jane’s love to Rochester goes unrequited.…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Conflicts in Jane Eyre

    • 907 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This novel presents a number of conflicts and struggles within Jane and between Jane and other characters, conflicts which must be resolved for her to achieve self-fulfillment and happiness.…

    • 907 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jane Eyre Research Paper

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre shows Jane going through all the steps of love and proving herself worthy. Her experiences at Gateshed show her how to see love even when it is not evident. Lowood is a similar experience except she learns about god through death. At Thornfield she learns the bad parts of love as well as how it can be a horrible mistress. Love is something most people will never come to understand. It is neccasary for people to read this book and for them to better understand love. Love is something we all need, it is something that we search and long for our whole life. Seniors in high school may not know the best road to achieve love and this book will help them make the right decisions so they don't make the same mistakes as Jane did. Love is an obstacle we must all overcome either through family, lovers, or pets we must all love a fellow creature or we are all doomed to an existence of sadness, depression, or a world full of…

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jane Eyre

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In Jane Eyre, by Charlotte Brontë, the main character, Jane Eyre, is a low-class feminist woman that stands up for herself and is not afraid to express her opinion in public. Throughout the novel, she receives two completely different proposals for marriage, one from Mr. Rochester and one from St. John Rivers. Mr. Rochester is a rich and intelligent man who is captures by Jane’s wit. St. John Rivers is a conservative and religious man led by the Church. John finds in Jane an incredible generosity and goodwill. Jane finally chooses Rochester over St. John Rivers because she finds a man who will love her truly and cherish her actions and opinions.…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jane Eyre Research Paper

    • 2119 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Rochester. The morning after his arrival, she asks Mrs. Fairfax for more information about him. She becomes even more interested in him, even though he is often mean and critical. Rochester 's attentions transform Jane, "So happy, so gratified did I become with this new interest added to life, that I ceased to pine after kindred; my thin crescent-destiny seemed to enlarge; the blanks of existence were filled up; my bodily health improved; I gathered flesh and strength" (Jane Eyre). Rochester brings a sort of life and excitement that Jane was craving for, but couldn’t reach because of her class and gender. Rochester also begins to develop a keen interest in Jane. In Jane’s life she has always been in an inferior position. As a child she just took it, the bullying from her cousins and her aunt. Jane kept quiet until she was about to leave the household for Lowood school. Jane had an out burst at her aunt about how she was a cruel and horrible person and from that point she never just took something again. When she meets Rochester it is the same way. He is her superior in age, in social status and power, to Jane that doesn’t matter she isn’t going to just back down. “I don 't think, sir, you have a right to command me, merely because you are older than I, or because you have seen more of the world than I have; your claim to superiority depends on the use you have made of your time and experience.” (Jane Eyre) Rochester is always challenging…

    • 2119 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jane Eyre Sacrifice

    • 373 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Rochester explains to Jane that he felt uncomfortable with his attachment to her partially due to her social inferiority, as marrying below one’s status was very uncommon and looked down upon in the Victorian…

    • 373 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jane Eyre Essay

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages

    With her relationship with Helen, Jane explores her need to be cared for by the world. One example of Jane’s struggle to balance her needs for companionship and independence is especially apparent in her relationship with Helen Burns. When Jane first meets Helen, Jane is in desperate need of companionship. Jane never felt companionship at Gateshead, and she searches for someone when she starts at Lowood.The first way that Helen helps her with her struggle with isolation is when Mr. Brocklehurst punishes Jane and makes her stay in isolation. Helen’s smile inspires Jane--on page…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jane is introduced to two characters that have a different views on religion. The first character is Mr. Brocklehurst. Mr. Brockelhurst is the headmaster of the school that Jane attends. He makes it his main duty to teach the children at Lowood school who don't know about God, about God (Shmoop Editorial Team). Unfortunately, Mr. Brockelhurst often misinterprets the Bible. For example, one day Mr. Brockelhurst read in the Bible to not be conformed to nature. One of the pupils at the school has naturally curly hair, and upon hearing this he says,”’Naturally! Yes, but we are not to conform to nature; I wish these girls to be the children of Grace: and why that abundance? I have again and again intimated that I desire the hair to be arranged closely, modestly, plainly. Miss Temple, that girl’s hair must be cut off entirely (Bronte 117).” Mr. Brocklehurst often uses what he reads in the Bible to back up what he wants out of his students, but since he misinterprets what God wants, he instills his own false wishes upon his students. The second religious influence is Helen Burns. Helen befriends Jane when Jane first attends Lowood. Helen is a positive influence that helps Jane get accustomed to the new school. Aside from that, Helen is devout to her Christian faith. Often telling Jane to, “"Read the New Testament, and observe what Christ says, and how He acts; make His word your rule, and His conduct your…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The protagonist of the novel, Jane Eyre herself, embarks on this quest for love from the very beginning of the book. As the novel opens, we see her long for the love and acceptance of her aunt, Mrs. Reed and her cousins, John, Eliza and Georgiana. However, all she gets is emotionally and physically hurt. She is constantly chastised and discriminated against by her aunt, while she finds herself more often than not becoming the target of her cousin, John Reed’s ire. Her aunt’s indifference to her pain and need to belong, takes a toll on the little girl who longs to get away from Gateshead.…

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She “desired liberty” (102) and decided to advertise for a new servitude. She received a response to work as a governess at Mr. Rochester’s house in Thornfield for his ward Adéle. This exile is alienating at first. Her feeling of alienation grew strong when Mr. Rochester invited his wealthy friends over for a few days. Jane felt as if she could not fit in with the extravagant people being that she lacks money and beauty, unlike the other women who were present. When Mrs. Fairfax first told Jane that she was invited to join the others by Mr. Rochester Jane resisted but Mrs. Fairfax insisted. Jane agreed to go “if no better may be but [she didn’t] like it” (197). Jane’s reluctance to go depicts how out of place she felt amongst Mr. Rochester’s esteemed colleagues. Mr. Rochester turned out to be Jane Eyre’s most valued companion. Not only did he marry her, he also taught her to express…

    • 1329 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics