Preview

Examine the Extent to Which the Media Could Be Said to Present Us with Distorted Picture of Crime in Society

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
689 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Examine the Extent to Which the Media Could Be Said to Present Us with Distorted Picture of Crime in Society
Examine the extent to which the media could be said to present us with distorted picture of crime in society (15marks)
Crime is an illegal action or activity for which a person can be punished by law. Crime is a social construction as it can change over time, such as there being laws against doing something, and then the social norm changes over time, so it’s not considered a crime anymore. The media is considered a social construction as they are based on opinions. Legal crimes are said to reflect social norms and values, for example women did not used to be allowed in bars, but the social norm has changed and now they are. Deviance acts are acts that violate the accepted standards of the community whether it legal or illegal.
Crime and deviance is mostly what is the news coverage. Ericson, found that 45-71% of radio news concerns crime. Another sociologist , Williams et.al, found out that 30% of British newspapers is about crime. The news that is reported, mainly contain massive distortions about the acts. This is because newspapers and media can decide what they want to contain and what they think is most important. This is where social construction comes in because they are using their opinion to determine which stories are important.
Most stories in the newspapers are old people or young children. This would make the readers feel sympathy for them. This is called Age fallacy (Felson). This make the readers believe that the victims are older/younger/worse off than they actually are.
In the media, there tends to be an over-representation on violent and sexual crimes. This would make the readers/watchers/listeners to think that society is a lot more violent than it actually is. Ditton and Duffy found out that 46% of media reports are about violent/sexual crimes but in official statistics they only make 3% of all crime reported. This implies that the media exaggerate about crimes.
The media also exaggerate on the success of the police. However violent

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    There are many different ways that the media can affect the way crime is looked at. Many of the media companies will talk about increases in crime, but will only target the few specific crimes that have slightly increased but will not touch base on all the crime statistics that show decreases in other areas. The media has a very smooth way of focusing on violent crimes above all others. Homicides and violent crimes receive a much higher amount of attention than any other crimes. If there was a bunch of minor traffic violations and a few tickets given out for minor things and one assault charge the only thing that would be brought up in the media is the assault charge.…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    David Farabee starts off by looking at crime rates and the public’s perception of crime from the media. The media focuses on high profile cases for severe acts of crime which is not that common compared to other criminal acts. He states that the society’s reaction from the media produces an affect that the crime rate is increasing at an alarming rate. The public’s perception and voice has major influence on what happens with the criminal justice system. Society wants the policy makers to aim for rehabilitative and counselling efforts rather than locking up the criminals. They would rather see them be back on track and reintegrated into society to have a better life. What the…

    • 1870 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Social construction refers to the way in which crime and deviance in society might be created and shaped by society and social institutions. This can occur in a number of different ways. For example, they can influence public perception and definitions of what establishes crime and deviance, deviants or non-deviants. They can also influence the amount of crime in society by amplifying it therefore clamping down on it. They can add pressure for changes in legislation which can then alter definitions of crime and can criminalise activities previously regarded as legal. They can also influence the extent, trends and patterns of recorded crime in how they operate.…

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The public has always used the Mass Media as the primary source of information about most topics especially crime. The Mass Media has the power to convey messages and ideas to a large audience but how truthful or factual these messages are has long been a debate of sociologist, due to news broadcast being so criminogenic for example, Ericson et al (1987). “Study of news-making in Toronto found that a remarkably high proportion of news was about deviance and control. Ranging from 45.3% in newspaper to 71.5% on radio stations. ( Maguire,Morgan and Reiner 2012, p.248) Therefore this use of Media may create fear amongst the public which in turn causes “Moral panic” and “Folk Devils”. Therefore I will outline and Illustrate the term “Moral Panic” and the effect it has on the public, also aiming to show the role the Media plays in creating panic.…

    • 535 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The non-sociologist definition of crime and deviance would be that deviance is uncommon behaviour, something that offends the morals or the majority of society, without being harmful or serious enough to be criminal. Whereas a criminal act is an act which causes harm to someone else enough to warrant a decision-maker passing a law which forbids the act.…

    • 1431 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    The first argument supporting that the media distorts the crime problem is that the reporting of crime is selective and the types of crimes reported in the media are those deemed `newsworthy.' Media compete in a marketplace to attract as large an audience as possible as they are profit orientated organisations. Consequently, crimes are selectively reported and are generally reported in ways that conform to news values of the immediate, the novel, the dramatic, and so on, which reinforce already established images of threat from crime. The assumption that the volume of crime is high and rising is one of the main arguments advanced by society. In Australia, studies have shown that a substantial proportion of the population incorrectly believe that crime rates are increasing when, in fact, they are stable or declining (Indermaur D & Roberts L, 2005). The…

    • 1496 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Media focus primarily on violent crimes, even though such crimes forms only smart part of all criminal activity…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Violent crime in America has always been a problem, but as a result of the media citizens think it is a bigger issue than it actually is. The media would rather focus on violent crime, specifically murder, rather than the more common crimes such as: burglary assault, etc. This helped create what is known as the ‘CSI Effect,’ which is the idea that viewers think crime is exactly like crimes portrayed on television. As a Criminal Justice major I am able to see how the ‘CSI Effect’ affects members of society.…

    • 1425 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the 19th century, Benjamin Disraeli, a British politician made a statement that still has significant resonance today: “There are three kinds of lies – lies, damned lies, and statistics” (as cited in Ball, 2004). Disraeli’s statement is merely a simple explanation of how the media sensationalize data, especially crime data, when reporting or publishing news items to the public. In that regard, reporters and journalist on many occasions take liberties in spicing data and news items up just to garnish some increased attention from the readers or the listeners. In a broader sense, media reporting may not accurately reflect facts since reporters and journalists has the ability to manipulate figures to say whatever they want them to.…

    • 943 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Most individuals would agree that the media has an influence on us, although they themselves claim to not be influenced by its effects. The representation of crime and criminals has provoked consternation. It has been suggested that such representations inflate our fear of crime far beyond our actual risks of becoming victims. Those who are least at risk of being a victim of crime, old people and females, are those who live in most fear because it is young men that are more likely to be victims of crime (Hough and Mayhew, 1983; cited in Muncie 1996, p.56). Moral panics are also a topic worthy of discussion as some, such as Stan Cohen, suggest that their origins are within the media and are the root of our ‘fear’ of crime.…

    • 1270 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Best Essays

    Jewkes’ theory can also be dismissed on the basis that the political institutions and media institutions are not ‘intertwined’ but merely seem to be due to both dealing with crime on a daily basis. The argument does not however deny that the media intensify the fear of crime but rather expands on this in reference to the ‘labelling theory’. The labelling theory suggests that the media create stereotypes of particular groups with society. Stereotyping in the media normally has negative connotations that encourage people to treat others differently who are recognised as being part of these groups. (Hale, C et al, 2009). A particular group in society who have been labelled are black youths. The moral panic of ‘mugging’ in the early 1970’s identified the culprits to be young black males. It was from this assumption that the view of society was that all young black males were ‘muggers’. (Jones, S, 2009, p.64). The labelling theory would suggest that young black males were then treated differently in society due to the widespread acceptance that they were a danger on the streets. This treatment then directs the ‘perpetrators’, in this case young black males, to elicit the response that society expects. Okoronkwo, N (2008) explains that the media to negatively portray black youths but there is statistical evidence that crime among black youths is a serious issue. In this sense the situation can be looked at differently. The media create a moral panic about a particular group which then is made reality due to self-fulfilling prophecy that subsequently validates the creation of any criminal justice policy based on populism. This therefore challenges the statement that it is indeed based on a ‘crude…

    • 2328 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Social Constructionism

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Surrette 2007 breaks down the media’s role in the process of social construction into 4 categories, the first category describes how crimes occur in the physical world and are recognised by organisations and individuals. Surrette notes that the first stage usually dictates the boundaries and conditions which the other stages must work within.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The media do have a big influence on people’s opinions and attitudes as the media only choose stories that are newsworthy, crime stories are dramatic and tragic, therefore crime is the dominant theme of all media. Reiner agrees with this; “In the former the media are perceived as a source of criminality; in the latter a source if misrepresentation and exaggeration. Both positions rest on the assumption that the mass media have some impact on attitudes and/or conduct.” (Reiner, 2007 cited in Newburn, 2007: 85). The news is transmitted to the public by radio, television, newspapers and now the internet. There is approximately one quarter of all output on television is now dedicated to crime. This is due to a massive audience; “98% of British households have at least 1 TV” (Abercrombie et al. 2000 cited in Soothill et al. 2002) therefore reaching a large audience. Due to the increase in technology, the news can be seen on the internet as well as watching it on the television. The internet emphasizes crime stories to attract the reader as crime stories are more newsworthy and are recently updated. Newburn (2007: 84) argues that “what we think we know about crime, is hugely influenced by what we see on television and film and what we read in newspapers [and] in magazines” meaning that crime can be exaggerated and…

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Criminal Justice Opinion

    • 3286 Words
    • 14 Pages

    So that begs; are the media a real cause of added violence in crime or do they report simply what they see? Despite the few limitations to the press by governmental laws and regulations, the United States still can recognize the reality that it maintains a free press. With the freedoms allowed through the first amendment, the media is not limited to the accuracy of events but can have their own fiction or non-fictional version of events that generally can lead to additional crimes by a viewing public. These open gaps generally addressed by choice are the targets attacked by proponents of free speech, arguing a reduction in crime with added press control would improve crime statistics.…

    • 3286 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Measuring Crime

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages

    There are different ways that crime is reported in the United States. The media reports crime and influence society perception of crime (Schmalleger, 2011). This sometimes causes public opinion on crime unrealistic (Schmalleger, 2011). Statistic data provides a better view on the amount of crime occurring than what is reported by the news media. The statistic reports are not as accurate as society would want, but it still gives a better understanding of the amount of crimes, types of crimes and also the frequency of those crimes than the news media. People who are the victims of a crime are the ones who report the crime and allow the crimes to be placed in a crime database (Schmalleger, 2011).…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics