Abstract:
The Indian constitution is quasi-federal and the country has a three-tier government – Central government, State Government and Local Governments. As the local public authorities are directly under the state government, no separate allocation of taxation rights has been done to them.
Rakesh Mohan at the NCAER conference held in January 2004, had argued that under-taxation in India is the root cause of its financial problem. In the conference, Indira Rajaraman supported the view point in her paper, ‘Fiscal Development and Outlook in India’. According to M. G. Govind Rao, “The available evidence shows that the tax-GDP ratio in India is lower than the level it should be for its per capita GDP growth by at least 2.5 percent per anum.
In under-developed country like India where mass of the population is poor, the ratio of revenue collection from direct taxes to that from indirect taxes can not be as high as developed countries of West.
Tax revenue is levied by both central as well as state governments. Some of the taxes are levied by each of those two governments. Come under direct tax front and implemented through Direct Tax Code (DTC) and some are Goods and Service Taxes (GST).
Indian tax structure is quite extensive. Now almost every conceivable direct an indirect tax is levied in this country. In terms of ratios of tax proceeds to GDP India is one of the modestly taxed countries. Since the resources are inadequate and governments (central as well state) have no choice bit to have to recourse to public debt and deficit financing which is mainly because of colossal unproductive expenditure and indifference to cannon of economy, identifying and evaluating of different elements of DTC and GST need to be done and accordingly to be restructured
This process of evaluation and restructuring of tax proposal both in front of DTC and GST also influence the economy of the country.
In this work an analysis has been made to study Indian tax structure and analyze the different areas under DTYC and GST and also study how it burdens as well as relieves Indian people and Indian economy.
Key words: Taxation, direct tax, GDP, revenue, public debt, deficit financing.
EVALUATION OF INDIAN TAX STRUCTURE IN PERSPECTIVES OF DTC AND GST AND IDENTIFYING ITS ROLE IN ECONOMY.
INTRODUCTION: India’s tax structure is quite extensive. Now almost every conceivable direct and indirect tax is levied in this country. In terms of the ratios of tax proceeds to GDP, India is one of the mostly taxed countries. And, if today the government feels that its resources are inadequate and it has no choice but to have resources to public debt and deficit financing, it is mainly due to its unplanned expenditure and to some extent indifference to its economy.
In India still there are existence of tax ambiguities and tax burden both in respect of DST and GST. In DST there need to analyze several areas and need rationalization with respect tax levied upon considering the demographics of economy, societal condition and developmental trend of people. As some area need tax exemption under DTC, in some areas tax need to be levied since the socio economic condition among Indian people are changing. Agricultural income are very rarely subjected to income tax being levied since in post independence era farmers, mostly throughout India, were existing as unprivileged wage earners 8in respect of lack of technology, information, knowledge, infrastructural resources, irrigation facilities, favorable environmental condition etc. But situation is changing with advancement of technology etc. and pattern of agricultural income are, in many cases, are being significantly under state of changes. This need reconsideration in respect of tax being levied upon agricultural income as an element DTC.
In GST also several discrepancies are still existing and need reviewing the situation. This work is an effort in this direction to identify progress, discrepancies and effect overn economy over of the different aspects and dimensions of Direct Tax Code (DTC) and General Service Code (GST).
2.EVALUATION OF INDIAN TAX STRUCTURE
As far as the Indian tax structure is concerned, the following features are notable for DTC and GST.
2.1 Built-in Flexibility and Buoyancy:
If elasticity of various taxes levied in a country is high, the taxation system is said to have built in flexibility. The concept of buoyancy of taxes is relatively wider. When changes in tax rates and expansion in tax bases are also taken into consideration for estimating the response of tax proceeds to rise in national income, we assess buoyancy of tax structure.
The National Institute of Public Finance and Policy (NIPFP) has estimated both elasticity and buoyancy of India’s tax structure for 1970 – 71 to 1983 – 84. The study revealed that while the elasticity of total tax revenue was less than unity 90.96), its buoyancy was greater than unity (1.21). Tax revenue of states was both more elastic and buoyant than the tax revenue of the center.
2.1.1 Built-in Flexibility and Buoyancy in DTC and GST:
In India presently among direct taxes, land revenue is the most inelastic and least buoyant tax. Its elasticity and
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Income tax levels in India were very high during 1950-1980, in 1970-71 there were 11 tax slabs with highest tax rate being 93.5% including surcharges. In 1973-74 highest rate was 97.5%. But to reduce tax evasion tax rates were reduced later on, by "1992-93" maximum tax rates were reduced to 40%. [2][3]…
- 4860 Words
- 20 Pages
Good Essays -
It is generally perceived that the introduction of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) can facilitate a significant improvement in the overall tax administration and enable revenue authorities to introduce modern procedures based on voluntary compliance. GST is a consumption tax charged on a wide range of domestic & international products, goods and services. GST covers all types of goods & services sold to Malaysian & non-Malaysian residents also known as consumers except for common commodities such as rice, flour & sugar. It is a broad-based tax imposed on every level of a product, from raw materials all the way to finished goods. Goods and services tax (GST) is one type of indirect taxes. GST is also known as value added tax (VAT) (Abood Mohammad Salmeen Alebel, n.d). On the other hand, indirect tax is a tax that can make people difficult such as export duties, import duties, excise duties, sales tax, service tax and others. (Juliana A. Kadir, Mustafa Idris, Zulkifli Mohamed, n.d). Although GST and VAT have different names, they represent the same system where the cost of tax is actually borne by the end user. It affects all layers of business and consumers and whether consumer realizes it or not, you’re being taxed for almost everything. It is a tax based on consumption.…
- 2080 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
|01 |Scheme of Taxation in India, Constitutional provisions, Direct vs. Indirect Tax, Excise Duty – Journey so far |…
- 3713 Words
- 15 Pages
Good Essays -
India is the largest democracy with federal form of government. The fiscal arrangements in India have evolved in a quasi-federal system to meet the requirements of centralized planning in a mixed economy structure and their sources of revenue for both Centre and State were clearly demarcated with regard to the financial relationship and the responsibilities between them. Our constitution provides residual powers to the Centre and makes clear division of fiscal powers between the Centre and the State Governments. Through various source of revenue to government, the Constitution of India provides for the establishment of a Finance Commission for the purpose of allocation of certain resources of revenue between the Union and the State Governments. The Finance Commission is established under Article 280 of the Constitution of India by the President. The Article 264 and 293 explain the financial relations between the Union and the State Government. Although the states have been assigned certain taxes which are levied and collected by them, they also share in the revenue of certain union taxes and there are certain other taxes which are levied and collected by the Central Government but whole proceeds are transferred to the states. In India, the Centre-State financial relationship relates to the distribution of power in resource mobilization between the Centre and States as also the sharing of expenditure responsibilities. During the last decade the disparities widened among the States which became economically and politically important. This situation resulted due to globalization and privatization by which certain States enjoy great advantages over the other. The most important and buoyant revenue sources are assigned to the Union Government, while major expenditure responsibilities rest with the State government, which take care of the social and economic sectors. Hence, in the federal structure, there is the possibility of conflicts in sharing the revenue…
- 8122 Words
- 33 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Competent Jurisdiction – Tax authority that has the legal power to assess and collect tax…
- 5092 Words
- 21 Pages
Good Essays -
The Constitution of India (COI) has given power to levy tax to central and state government under seventh schedule. The taxation in India is either charged by the state governments or by the central government. In the basic scheme of taxation in India, it is conceived that central government will levy and collect tax revenue from Income Tax (except on Agricultural Income), Excise (except on alcoholic drinks) and Customs while state government will get tax revenue from sales tax, excise on liquor and tax on Agricultural Income and the municipalities will get tax revenue from octroi…
- 320 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In modern tax system objects of taxation are mainly three - property, income and revs / goods and services /. As in the past, income taxes on a mass scale are implemented, direct taxes are represented by such property. Nowadays fiscal importance of property taxes is negligible so that it can be said that direct taxes today are mostly from income taxes.…
- 3117 Words
- 13 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Difficult to know the level of external cost and how much the tax should be.…
- 645 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In India the double taxation agreement is unique pattern of what the united nation (UN) has guided. In this agreement allocates jurisdiction between source and the residential country. This law also prescribed the maximum rate of taxation in the source country where the income arises and the maximum…
- 835 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In India, indirect tax has a multiple tax structure — taxes at central level such as excise, service tax and customs, and taxes at state level such as VAT and entry tax. Further, there are local levies like octroi.…
- 5204 Words
- 21 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Every country has their rules and specific law to maintain or increase country’s income. In Malaysia, government has projected the current SST to GST which means to regenerate tax collection. GST can define as multi-stage tax for goods and services on domestic consumption. It also can be known as value added tax which is a type of consumption based on the tax charged to all taxable supply of goods. Those goods and services tax are providing revenue to the government. The effectuation of GST will get rid of the weakness of current tax system in Malaysia.…
- 1235 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Tax Administrations in developing country contend with the same range of challenges with developed nations, although the significance of typical collection issues may be greater. As a result these countries suffer significant losses in revenue collection. Introducing tax initiatives such as self-assessment and GST does alleviate the revenue leakages to certain extent, however the agencies capacity and capability to administer an effective and efficient taxation system is the ultimate determinant to maximizing collections.…
- 848 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
tax regime as it is based on well accepted principles of taxation and best international practices. It will eventually pave the way for a single unified taxpayer reporting system. The Philosophy behind such replacement is to make the Direct Taxes Code very easy and simple so that tax payers themselves can, without help of experts compute and file Income Tax Returns. In planning and framing an ideal Income Tax Structure of a welfare state like ours the objectives are to give relief to the maximum possible extent to the lower and middle income group taxpayers and check creation of black money at one hand and to enable the Government to increase collection of tax revenue for development works on the other. The Direct Taxes Code (hereafter referred to as the ‘Code’) is not an attempt to amend the Income Tax Act, 1961; nor is it an attempt to “improve” upon the present Act. In drafting the Code, the Central Board of Direct Taxes (the Board) has, to the extent possible, started on a clean drafting slate. Some assumptions which have held the ground for many years have been discarded. Principles that have gained international acceptance have been adopted. Hence, while reading the Code, it would be advisable to do so without any preconceived notions and, as far as possible, without comparing the provisions with the corresponding provisions of the Income Tax Act, 1961. A. Highlights of DTC Earlier Income Tax Act and Wealth tax Act are abolished and single code of Tax, DTC in place. Some of the major highlights of New DTC are – 1. Concept of Assessment year and previous year is abolished. Only the “Financial Year” terminology exists. 2. Only status of “Non Resident” and “Resident of India” exits. The other status of “resident but not ordinarily resident” goes away.…
- 3310 Words
- 14 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Tax is defined as a compulsory payment made to the government by the individuals firms and companies without any expectation of a direct return. In general there are two types of tax system prevailing in our country. One is direct tax and other is indirect tax. Here we will restrict our discussion to direct tax only. Direct taxes are those the burden of which cannot be shifted, that is incidence and impact is on the same person. In India the tax law is governed by the finance act. The amendments are brought through budget every year which is issued on the last date of February. There have been various arguments in regard to the complexity of the tax laws. The new tax system which is proposed basically focuses on the principle of equality and simplicity. Instead of having different explanations of tax laws under different umbrellas all the laws will be brought under one head. The new tax system will be highly focused on the matter that the richer should pay heavier tax and vice-versa. For this regard the exemption limit and tax slabs will be expanded higher. Moreover under new taxation laws various taxes like securities transaction tax will also be abolished thus making the code an efficient one. With the new tax code being implemented in India one can expect to have free trade across the length and breadth of the country and peace in the bags of investors. Thus, the new tax system is an attempt to create a system with minimum loopholes of the existing system, thus contributing to the national…
- 281 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Hamilton in his federalist papers stated that Multileveled government permits various functions to be assumed by different levels, potentially improving efficiency since different activities have different optimal scales and hence in India with respect to Sales Tax Federalism, The Constitutional amendment in 1956, gave the States power to impose sales tax the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956,enacted by the Sixth Constitutional Amendment which introduced Entry 92A in List I of the Seventh Schedule authorizing Parliament to levy tax on the sale or purchase of goods (other than newspapers) in the course of inter-State trade.…
- 11096 Words
- 45 Pages
Powerful Essays