Ethical Dilemma of Hiv Disclosure in Intimate Relationships
HIV Prevention with Positives in Thailand: Ethical Dilemma of HIV Status Disclosure in intimate relationship.
Abstract
Every year, there are about ten thousand new HIV infection cases in Thailand. The majority of new HIV transmissions in Thailand have changed from commercial sex to intimate relationships while HIV prevention generally focuses on self protection and universal precaution. In 2003, Center for Disease Control and Prevention recommend to integrate HIV preventive measure into routine HIV care. According to a survey of People Living with HIV and AIDS (PLWHA) in Thailand, 45% of HIV infections came from transmission between spouses and 10% believed that their partners knew their HIV status before having a relationship. Unprotected sex increased in those who did not disclose HIV status to partners. Health professionals reported the limitation of time for counseling and recognized the risk of HIV transmission between sexual partners. Health care providers face ethical dilemmas regarding disclosure of HIV status in intimate relationships. In this ethical dilemma, most exempt notifying patients’ sexual partner with the reason that it is the right and confidentiality of HIV patients. This paper argues that disclosure of HIV must be promoted in intimate relationships, because the right to healthy life of the sexual partner outweighs the right to privacy of the HIV positive individual and condom use is low and difficult to put in practice in intimate relationships. Given the largest proportion of spousal transmissions, the principle of responsibility should be complementary with the principles of self-protection and universal precaution. HIV prevention campaigns focusing on universal vulnerability are not effective in intimate partnerships where trust, fidelity and monogamy are mostly expected and are barriers of condom use. The legal requirements are unclear in Thailand and the policies are not explicitly determined. This paper proposes that PLWHA should
Abstract
Every year, there are about ten thousand new HIV infection cases in Thailand. The majority of new HIV transmissions in Thailand have changed from commercial sex to intimate relationships while HIV prevention generally focuses on self protection and universal precaution. In 2003, Center for Disease Control and Prevention recommend to integrate HIV preventive measure into routine HIV care. According to a survey of People Living with HIV and AIDS (PLWHA) in Thailand, 45% of HIV infections came from transmission between spouses and 10% believed that their partners knew their HIV status before having a relationship. Unprotected sex increased in those who did not disclose HIV status to partners. Health professionals reported the limitation of time for counseling and recognized the risk of HIV transmission between sexual partners. Health care providers face ethical dilemmas regarding disclosure of HIV status in intimate relationships. In this ethical dilemma, most exempt notifying patients’ sexual partner with the reason that it is the right and confidentiality of HIV patients. This paper argues that disclosure of HIV must be promoted in intimate relationships, because the right to healthy life of the sexual partner outweighs the right to privacy of the HIV positive individual and condom use is low and difficult to put in practice in intimate relationships. Given the largest proportion of spousal transmissions, the principle of responsibility should be complementary with the principles of self-protection and universal precaution. HIV prevention campaigns focusing on universal vulnerability are not effective in intimate partnerships where trust, fidelity and monogamy are mostly expected and are barriers of condom use. The legal requirements are unclear in Thailand and the policies are not explicitly determined. This paper proposes that PLWHA should
References: Ahmad K (2000). "Concerns raised about Botswana 's proposed HIV-disclosure law." Lancet 356(9230): 662. Allen C F, Simon Y, Edwards J and Bernards P S (2008). Factors associated with condom use in the Caribbean regional network of people living with HIV/ AIDS (CRN+). XVII International AIDS conference. Mexico city, Pharma service. Arcus K and Kessel A (2005). "Are ethical principles relative to time and place? A Star Wars perspective on the Alder Hey affair." BMJ 325: 1493-5. Bayer R (1996). "AIDS prevention--sexual ethics and responsibility." N Engl J Med. 334(23): 1540-2. Beauchamp T and Childress J (2001). . Principles of biomedical ethics. , . New York: , Oxford University Press. Bunnell R, J. M and K D C (2006). "HIV prevention for a threatened continent: implementing positive prevention in Africa." JAMA 296(7): 855-8. Castro A and Farmer P (2005). "Understanding and addressing AIDS-related stigma: from anthropological theory to clinical practice in Haiti." Am J Public Health. 95(1): 53-9. Chaiyamahapurk S (2010). Sexual practice of PWHA attending HIV clinic in lower northern part of Thailand. National Disease Prevention and Control Seminar, Bangkok, Department of Disease Control. Chamratrithirong A, Kittsuksathit S, Podhisita C, Isarabhhakdi P and Sabaiying M (2007). National sexual behaviour survey of Thailand 2006, Institute for Population and Social Research, Mahidol University: 104. Chasombat S, Lertpiriyasuwat C, Thanprasertsuk S, Suebsaeng L and Lo Y R (2006). "The National Access to Antiretroviral Program for PHA (NAPHA) in Thailand." Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 37(4): 704-15. Eisele T P, Mathews C, Chopra M, Brown L, Silvestre E, et al. (2008). "High levels of risk behavior among people living with HIV Initiating and waiting to start antiretroviral therapy in Cape Town South Africa." AIDS Behav 12(4): 570-7. Emson H (1993). "The duty to warn in the Canadian context." CAN MED ASSOC J 149 (12): 1781-2. Gable L, Gamharter K, Gostin L, Hodge J and Puymbroeck R (2007). Legal Aspects of HIV/AIDS: A guide for Policy and Law Reform. Washington D.C.: 82. Hathirat S. "Case Study in HIV Status Disclosure: Seminar in Medical Law Series " Retrieved April, 2010, 2010, from http://www.doctor.or.th/node/8234. Hewson B (2000). "Why the human rights act matters to doctors. HIV/AIDS(GNP+) T G N o P L w (2009). Positive Health, Dignity and prevention: Technical Consultation Report, 17-28 April 2009, Hammamet, Tunisia. Amsterdam: 15. Janssen R S, Holtgrave D R, Valdiserri R O, Shepherd M, Gayle H D, et al. (2001). "The Serostatus Approach to Fighting the HIV Epidemic: prevention strategies for infected individuals." Am J Public Health 91(7): 1019-1024. Kadando R, Lyavala J and Mulongo M (2008). Sero status disclosure in HIV prevention: encouraging results from TASO Tororo. XVII International AIDS conference. Mexico city, Pharma service. Levy N C, Miksad R A and Fein O T (2005). "From treatment to prevention: the interplay between HIV/AIDS treatment availability and HIV/AIDS prevention programming in Khayelitsha, South Africa." J Urban Health. 82(3): 498-509. Epub 2005 Jul 27. Marks G, Richardson J L, Crepaz N, Stoyanoff S, Milam J, et al. (2002). "Are HIV care providers talking with patients about safer sex and disclosure?: A multi-clinic assessment." AIDS 16(14): 1953-7. Mears A (2007). "The criminalization of HIV transmission in England and Wales: a brief review of the issues arising." Curr Opin Infect Dis 20(1): 47-53. National AIDS Prevention and Alleviation Committee (2008). UNGASS Country Progress Report, Thailand. Reporting period: January 2006‐December 2007. S. Petchsri, K. Porntip, D. Vipaet al. Bangkok, Department of Disease Control: 30. National AIDS Prevention and Alleviation Committee (2008). UNGASS Country Progress Report, Thailand. Reporting period: January 2006‐December 2007. S. Petchsri, K. Porntip, D. Vipaet al. Bangkok, Department of Disease Control: 144. National AIDS Prevention and Alleviation Committee (2008). UNGASS Country Progress Report, Thailand. Reporting period: January 2006‐December 2007. S. Petchsri, K. Porntip, D. Vipaet al. Bangkok, Department of Disease Control: 97. Rojanapithayakorn W (2006). "The 100% Condom Use Program in Asia " Reproductive Health Matter 14(28): 41-52. Ruth D-M (2007). "The Sexual Ethics of HIV Testing and the Rights and Responsibilities of Partners." Studies in Family Planning 38(4): 284-296. UNAIDS (2000). Evaluation of the 100% Condom Promotion Program in Thailand. Geneva: 42. UNAIDS (2000). Opening up the HIV/AIDS epidemic:Guidance on encouraging beneficial disclosure, ethical partner counselling & appropriate use of HIV case-reporting. Geneva. UNAIDS (2006). International Guidelines on HIV/AIDS and Human Rights. Geneva, UNAIDS. UNAIDS. (2009). "Eminent African Jurists discuss HIV and the law." Retrieved January 1, 2010 from http://www.unaids.org/en/KnowledgeCentre/Resources/FeatureStories/archive/2009/20091211_Safrica_jurists.asp. Vernazzaa P, Hirschelb B, Bernasconic E and Fleppd M (2008) "Swiss Statement: HIV-positive individuals not suffering from any other STD and adhering to an effective antiretroviral treatment do not transmit HIV sexually." Volume, DOI: