Preview

Ethical Dilemma

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1251 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ethical Dilemma
Stephen Shoup
Professor Maloney
Policy, Professionalism & Ethics
October 1, 2012
Ethical Dilemmas Chapter 8
Situation 4 In this situation if the I was the prosecutor I would waive the juvenile back to juvenile court. Also, I would charge the individual in the juvenile court with assault, not murder. The 12 year old committed the crime with his older brother and should not be fully liable for the actions that took place. I feel like maybe I am acting on my own conscious, but a 12 year old boy who did not even commit murder should not be tried as an adult and have his whole life taken away from him for not really understanding the consequences beforehand. Some facts in this situation would be that I am the prosecutor and there is a 12 year old boy who committed some type of violent offense with his brother. The media, the juvenile judge and the victim’s family all want the boy charged as an adult. Also, I must determine whether the boy should be charged for attempted murder, assault or some lesser crime. It is my duty to do what is just for the victim’s family and so that society feels justice has been served, but I can’t help, but feel for the boy and what he is going through. I have friendships with the juvenile judge, but I do not agree with his decision to move the juvenile to adult court when he probably was just doing what his older brother was telling him to do. I am loyal to the court system and it is my job to be honest in making a rational decision. A moral dilemma is created by this notion of whether I should try the individual as an adult or juvenile and also I must determine which crime is suitable for the boy’s actions. Moral dilemmas are usually created by someone else’s actions. The most immediate ethical issue facing the individual is whether to prosecute the 12 year old boy in a juvenile or adult court. The utilitarian approach says that the boy should be tried as an adult in this situation because all other members involved agree that the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Juvenile Justice Center

    • 382 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Both juveniles and adults have the right to counsel in court proceedings. Nevertheless, juveniles may be represented by court appointed advocates who look out for the juvenile’s “best interest,” as a parent would for his or her child; with right ways to help the child rehabilitate. In the case of adult trials, court appointed advocates may be representing the accused, but the “best interest” lies in reducing or foregoing the sentence, not rehabilitate (Goldstein, 2007). In the cases of both groups, a “traditional” counsel may be hired to…

    • 382 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many juveniles in the United States are being tried as adults. “Age can shape every aspect of a capital case,”(54) stated Adam Liptak in” Supreme Court to Rule on Executing Youth Killers”. Teenagers as well as kids have the ability to commit an adult crime. In the Article “A Portrait of a Child Who Murdered” by Gitta Sereny ten year old Mary Bell murdered her friend’s eight year old brother and skinned his genital area with a pair of scissors. She then abandoned his body by a brick wall and covered him with leaves and branches. Youth and kids commit crimes, do to the way they think, what they watch on TV, read in books and the internet.…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Persuasive Paper Part 1

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages

    A common theory among many people is that if a crime is committed, punishment is deserved and that the punishment should fit the crime. What are the influencing factors when punishment is determined? Today, minors who commit violent crimes can be tried as adults or as a juvenile. The juvenile justice system provides a rehabilitation program for offenders of crimes. Often minors take advantage of the system because they understand once of legal age their records are expunged and they are no longer held accountable for the crimes committed as a minor. In order to protect victims and families, serve justice and prevent future violent crimes, the American justice system must impose tougher punishment on offenders of violent crimes which means sometimes children should be tried as adults.…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Several authors address the issues surrounding juveniles who are tried as adults (Hudson, 2009; Mason, Chapman, Chang & Simons, 2003; Nunez, Tang, 2003). Hudson (2009) emphasizes…

    • 1525 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A worldwide situation in criminal justice is the youth, who are being tried as adults for their wrongdoings. Although juveniles commit heinous crimes such as robbery, murder, or even rape, they are not mature enough to understand what they are doing. In the article “Kids Are Kids-Until They Commit Crimes” a 12-year-old boy got sentenced life in prison after he beat a 6- year-old girl to her death (Lundstrom). The boy did not know the girl was going to die because he is not mature enough to know what his actions will do. These consequences should not apply to the youth because their minds are not fully developed like the adults. Because kids like to play around with each other “Now fourteen and convicted as an adult of first-degree murder, Tate…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Dr. Allison Burke stated, “Adolescence is a tumultuous time, full or change and transformation... The adultification of youth (or waiver to adult court) is unduly harsh for youth whose brains have not fully formed” (Should Adolescents). Many facts point to the conclusion that juveniles should not be tried as adults. Although some believe children should be punished for what they have done, it should not be done in such a harsh and permanent method. Juveniles make bad decisions, but they are somewhat not responsible for doing so. Excluding the case of violent crimes, such as murder and rape, children should never be tried as adults.…

    • 1400 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    For the people who said that they should be tried as adults, they believe that juveniles should be held responsible for their actions, that juveniles are not kids that they are young adults, and that by forgiving the juvenile for the crime they did, would just make them think their actions are okay. For the people who think that juveniles should not be tried as adults, they believe that juveniles are physically incapable of thinking like an adult, therefore should not be treated like one. Both sides have valid points in backing up their reasoning’s. I think it is important to look at both sides of the arguments before deciding if you think juveniles should be tried as adults or…

    • 2034 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Juveniles Tried as Adults

    • 455 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “For over one hundred years, laws in the United States have distinguished juveniles who were charged with crimes from adult’s juvenile courts are structures to be less formal than their adult counter parts” (Huma Khan). No matter what the crime the juvenile is still a juvenile and should only be a tried as a juvenile. A juvenile court system allows for teens to be rehabilitated, one example is a boy named Tyheem J. Henery accused of beating another student to death and prosecutors want to try him as an adult. Officers from his detention center say he is model in mate and cab be rehabilitated. This proves that even the nastiest of young criminals are still too young to understand the…

    • 455 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Juvenile Justice System

    • 2095 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In today’s society, there are not that many distinctions between juveniles and adults when it comes to the criminal justice system. The main distinction between an adult and a juvenile is of course the age and the types of sentencing a juvenile may receive compared to an adult. The juvenile justice system has a tiered affect when it comes to sentencing but it relies heavily on the maturity and intellect of the juvenile. Due to that reason, there will always be a separate juvenile justice system to ensure the juvenile truly understands the nature of the crime and the consequences.…

    • 2095 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ten year old boy murders his family. Does he get out when he turns eighteen, because he knows not what he did? Or does he spend the rest of his life in prison? Sometimes teenagers are tried for crimes as adults and face equal penalties that are subject to adults. This is a controversial issue among americans. There are two groups of people. Those who believe that teenagers under the age of eighteen who commit serious crimes should be held responsible as adults for their actions. Courts are said to be too lenient and the young juveniles are evolving into violent youth criminals; And there are those who suggest that teenagers are less likely to understand the consequences of their actions and more likely to become productive citizens if the criminal justice system continues to treat eighteen year olds as juveniles. Juvenile death penalties and life sentences without parole have increased at an estimated rate of three times higher today than fifteen years ago. The youth are still growing to become fully developed, like an adult. There are many cases where tough decisions have to be made and choices must be made by officials. In my opinion all youths at the age of eighteen or younger should be tried as juveniles and all our juvenile courts need to focus more on rehabilitation for the lost of youth to criminal acts. Age should be a factor, not a determinant on how these youths should be tried.…

    • 2098 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    PSY328 final proposal

    • 1936 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Semple, J. & Woody, W. (2011). Juveniles tried as adults: the age of the juvenile matters.…

    • 1936 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Juvenile Court Process

    • 348 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I feel that the juvenile process should and shouldn’t differ from the process. I feel that juveniles shouldn’t be trialed as an adult because juveniles are still young when they commit the crimes and didn’t mature yet. I do feel depending on the type of crime a juvenile should be trialed as an adult if they commit murder or other extreme crimes. In conclusion I think the type of crime committed should determine how a juvenile is trialed.…

    • 348 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I will view both sides to whether children should be tried as adults. The rate of murders by juveniles and children has skyrocketed across the country. There are many people who feel that children should be tried as adults due to the popular saying “If you do the crime, you must do the time”. According to many sources it is believed that it will make them understand the consequences of their actions and deter them from committing any further crimes.…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Juvenile Justice System is a separate world from the criminal justice system. There are laws that protect the youth of today on a level where it is exclusive to only a certain age group. There are considerations that are often brought in to sentencing for the youth that would never be considered for an adult. There are decisions that have to be made on different levels including age, culture, laws based on the juvenile system, policy and most important different situations and how to handle them. There are four ethical realms that involve the criminal justice system. The ethics that will be discussed in this team project concerning the decision made with Brian the Juvenile youth are as follows: the situation based on ethical relativism, ethical egoism, deontological ethics and teleological ethics. There is a very fine line when taking action in today’s juvenile youth system. The laws are different concerning youth; therefore, every ethical situation is different and can be detrimental to the staff and the youth involved. This situation with Brian and Daren can be considered and compared to the ethics that best fit.…

    • 1753 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    On September 28, a 14-year-old boy murdered his father. He also injured a 6-year-old little boy in a shooting at an elementary school. Prosecutors have taken action to have the case moved to the Court of General Sessions where the 14-year- old can be tried as an adult. His charges include murder and others. The teenage boy murdered his father while he was watching television within their home. The teenager then took the car and went to the elementary school. He was carrying a handgun at the time and began shooting, ultimately wounding two boys and a teacher. One of the boys died due to the fatal wounds he sustained. One of the bullets hit an artery and caused him to suffer a significant loss in blood which led to cardiac arrest.…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays