Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Effects of Culture on Romantic Relationships

Good Essays
981 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Effects of Culture on Romantic Relationships
Grace Dare
Discuss the influence of culture on romantic relationships.
Within the world there is no relationship that is the same, there are many different experiences and these experiences are vastly different for each culture. The western culture (Europe or USA) is very different when compared with the non-western cultures (India or China). The main different between Relationships in Western and non-Western cultures is the in the degree to which they are voluntary or non-voluntary.
Western cultures place importance in the rights and freedom of an individual, Individual pleasure and happiness are important so individualistic cultures have a focus on the individual, meaning that relationships are based on freedom of choice. On the other hand non-western cultures have a clear focus on the wider group, group goals and interests are more important than their own individual views. In Western cultures people live in mainly urban settings and voluntarily interact with a number of people, they therefore have a big choice in who we date, there is a large “pool” of potential relationships however In non western cultures there are less urban areas
And less social mobility making interaction with strangers is rare. This means they have less choice in who they can interact and have a relationship with. In societies with reduced mobility arranged marriages are easy and make a lot of sense. In collectivist cultures, relationships are more likely to reflect the interests of the entire family. The idea of arranged marriage can give the family a say in the romantic relations.
There is a significant amount of research into this area which can show how culture does effect romantic relationship. Gupta and Singh(1982) compared 100 professional Indian couples. 50 had been married for love and 50 had taken part in arranged marriages, they used Rubin’s liking and loving scales. ‘Love’ was found to be high at the beginning of love marriages but then declined rapidly over the first 10 years.Arranged marriages started with low levels of like and love but these increased after 10 years. After 10 years arranged marriage couples liked and loved their partners more than those who had chosen each other. Suggesting that involuntary marriages are more likely to be successful.
Although it might be expected that more voluntary relationships based on love would produce more compatible partners and therefore be more successful, this is not necessarily the case. In cultures where families play a key part in arranging a marriage, parents may be in a better position to judge compatibility as they are not ‘blinded by love’. Another difference between
Western and non-western cultures is the importance of love in romantic relationships.Levine et al (1995) investigated love as a basis for marriage in 11 countries. Respondents were asked if they would be willing to marry someone that had all the qualities they desired in a marriage partner but whom they did not love.Western –US- respondents were reluctant to marry in the absence of love ( only 14% said they would.) Non-western respondents however indicated that a higher proportion of people in these cultures were prepared to marry in the absence of love
( India 24% and Thailand 34%.)This suggests that in Western, Individualistic cultures love is

important in a relationship compared to non-western, Collectivist cultures where the extended family for example is more important.

There is research support for this idea that non-voluntary relationships can work as well as, if not better than relationships based on love. Epstein found that in cultures with reduced social mobility, non-voluntary relationships appeared to work very well, with lower divorce rates than
Western marriages. However, this may be due to different cultural attitudes towards divorce.
Marital satisfaction was the same for voluntary and nonvoluntary relationships, suggesting that they work equally well.In contrast to this finding, a Chinese study by Xiaohe & Whyte found that women who had freedom of choice and who married for love were happier than women in arranged marriages. This study appears to support the claim that freedom of choice, which is more common in Western cultures this promotes marital stability.
There is larger support for the effect of culture on romantic relationships Ho (1986) found that
Marrying for love is seen as a vital component in the West, but for Chinese couples, romance and love are less important and are only considered in light of responsibility towards parent and the family. Spontaneous expression of love, especially in terms of sex outside of marriage, is not considered appropriate in Chinese society.
There disputes about whether culture does effect romantic relationships as questions such as, is love universal regardless of culture. Pinker (2008) found that views romantic love as a ‘human universal’ that has evolved to promote survival and reproduction among human beings. Being in a long term committed relationship offers lower mortality rates, increased happiness and decreased stress. There is a clear adaptive value to being in a long term relationship- across all cultures. Pinker suggests that romantic relationships are a form of an evolutionary process and I universal, and thus occurs in every type of culture. Pink therefore opposes the theorys idea of that romantic relationships differ between different cultures and thus decreases the theorys internal validity.
Psychologists also propose that the theory is ethnocentric.
The theory only bases itself upon

individualistic cultures and their values and thus neglect collectivist cultures and their values.
As the theory only considers individualistic cultures it lacks external reliability as the theory cannot explain the difference of all cultures specifically collectivist cultures.

There may also be a historical bias in much of this research. There has been a significant increase in the number of voluntary and temporary relationships in the West in the past several decades, perhaps due to the increased urbanisation. This would also explain the significant increase in voluntary relationships in non-Western cultures such as India and China.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Blood Diamon

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the article “I’m Happy with an Arranged Marriage” by Gitangeli Sapra it discusses her view of arranged marriages. Ms. Gitangeli is for arranged marriage, she stated that people who get married for “love” has a 40% rate of divorce. She also states that arranged marriages have a lower rate of divorce for the fact that the couples do not want to start a wrath between their families.…

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In societies with reduced mobility, (predominantly non-western cultures) arranged marriages are common as love is expected to grow due to the fact that it is not seen as necessary for marriage. Arranged marriages seem to work well and make good sense as divorce rates are low and Epstein (2002) found that perhaps about half of them report that they have fallen in love with each other.…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The topic I have chosen is the influence of culture and religion in human sexuality. Religion has been around for hundreds of years Society's views on sexuality, marriage and rituals are influenced by everything from religion to culture Religion has been the greatest influence on sexual behavior in the United States and other countries. Most world religions have moral codes that say what is right and wrong. Also it says in which sexuality can be expressed Religious doctrine often shy away from change, and some religions like Catholicism have changed very little despite the changes that are going on in our world today. On the other hand, Culture provides the sculpting of people’s social behaviors,…

    • 1648 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Psychologists have found differences between western and non-western cultures in relationships. There are voluntary and non-voluntary relationships. Voluntary relationships are most common in western culture as you’d expect; due to urban settings and east geographical & social mobility, so interaction with others occurs on a much greater scale. Leading to a higher degree of choice of partners. In non-western cultures however it is found that there are more non-voluntary relationships. This is due to less cities and less mobility, so less choice of people to interact with. In this setting relationships are usually ties to family or economic resources. In these cases culture seems to have an influence on the relationships formed where they live dictates how many people are available for them to form a relationship with. But tradition may play a bigger role in non-western cultures. Epstein found non-voluntary/arranged marriages seem to work and found low divorce rates, and partners state they have ‘fallen in love’. In addition, people living in non-western cultures still have arranged marriages, so perhaps culture doesn’t have that much of an influence of romantic relationships. Myers et al studied Indian arranged marriages, and no difference was reported in marriage satisfaction when compared to US non-arranged marriages. Gupta and Singh assessed 50 married couples, half arranged marriage and half love marriages. They were assessed on how much they liked or loved each other. They found love is higher in first stage of ‘love marriage’ but this decreases over time, and vice versa. This suggest that relationships based on romantic love aren’t always most fruitful.…

    • 1159 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A relationship can be defined as an encounter with another person or with people that endure through time. Two different theories have been proposed; the Reward/Need Satisfaction theory and the Similarity theory.…

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    An arranged marriage is a way of uniting and maintaining the difference between the rich upper class society and the poor lower class society.…

    • 1774 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Arranged marriages are common in Asian countries. Some people agree to arranged marriages that are set up by their parents, unlike…

    • 246 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Arranged Marriage vs. Free-choice Marriage"Happy marriages begin when we marry the ones we love, and they blossom when we love the ones we marry" (Tom Mullen, 2005, p.1). It is argued that free-choice marriages based on love or romance, offer more independence and freedom as compared to arranged marriages where the man and woman are chosen by the parents and so there is pressure and is not so suitable and independent. However, no marriage is necessarily an ideal sort of marriage. Therefore, it becomes difficult to predict the ideal sort of marriage. The decision is upon the individual, whether he or she wants to be part of an arrange or free-choice marriage. There are two main types of marriages that are practiced in various societies and cultures and they are: arranged marriages and free-choice marriages. Both type of marriages have benefits and particular expectations for the man and woman. Research shows that the type of marriage chosen often reflects a person's values, traditions, beliefs, and cultural customs. Both arranged and free-choice marriages have similarities and differences.…

    • 1630 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Arranged marriages should have a lower divorce rate because in the eastern countries where it is used they do not believe in divorce.…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arranged Marriages are very controversial. Many people argue that choosing your life partner is a fundamental right, and others seem to say that mommy and daddy know best. The truth is that arranged marriages are completely legal and practiced in many cultures.…

    • 914 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Author Serena Nanda begins the article by introducing the concept of arranged marriage in India. Nanda then begins to describe a filed trip to India and her direct experiences with arranged marriage. On this trip, Nanda met many young men and women whose parents were trying to match them…

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms…

    • 4557 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arranged marriages have been an integral part of Indian society for centuries, and even today people having their marriages planned by their parents and other respected family-members, with the consent of the bride and groom, does occur. Arranged matches were made after taking into account factors such as the compatibility of the couples' horoscopes, the backgrounds of their families (wealth, social standing) and their castes. The institution of marriage in India is considered a very important one. Thus, parents felt that since they were older and wiser than their progeny, they would be able to find a suitable match for their children with more prudence than the latter. Although the institution of arranged marriage has been witnessing a downward trend in metropolitan India, it is still prevalent in rural areas.…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pronged Marriages

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages

    They are better described as well aged traditions, rather than antiquated. Regardless of these erroneous beliefs, arranged marriages are changing to better suit the current time period. These changes involve adding prohibitions, on things like dowries, and minimizing the importance of caste (Marriage). Some might argue that arranged marriages leave people closed minded and, regardless of the benefits, belittle the children involved. Contrary to this belief, most children approve of their parents choosing their spouses, because they believe that their parents are more knowledgeable and truly do know what is best for them (Traditional Arranged Marriages). Since the children understand and believe this fact, they are able to work with their parents in the process and their feelings and emotions are taken into consideration. If anything, the children are maturing and being propelled into adulthood because of the arranged marriage…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Arranged Marriage

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages

    First, the difference is matchmaker. The traditional arranged marriage is determined by the parents without the consent of the future couple. The modern view is very different from traditional view. In most instances it is a service, provided by an agency, or a good friend. The purpose is to find a compatible mate, with the greatest number of similarities and the same primary objective: marriage.…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays