Preview

Ecofeminism and John Milton's Paradise Lost

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1786 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ecofeminism and John Milton's Paradise Lost
Ecofeminism and John Milton’s Paradise Lost

In the King James Bible, God creates the world. He creates the sea, the field, the plants, and the animals. His most prized creation, however, is man, whom he creates in his own image. To man he gives dominion of his previous Earthly creations. The first man, Adam, chooses the name of each plant and animal. When Adam realizes that he is unfulfilled and lonely, God creates woman out of Adam’s rib. Eve, the first woman, is also subordinate to Adam (King James Bible, Genesis: 1-3). Thus, the creation story teaches us that women and the natural environmental are inherently inferior to men because God intended it to be so. The field of ecofeminism links the environmental and feminist movements, highlighting their dual paths of exploitation and oppression at the hands of man. While men are typically associated with culture, women are associated with nature. Men are the cultivators of knowledge and civil society, with the power to govern and rule. Women, on the other hand, are the source of birth and nourishment. It is no coincidence that “God” is male while “Mother Nature” is female. Though some women find the connection to nature limiting, there is no question that a parallel exists (Plumwood 22). Milton expands upon Genesis: 2-3 in his epic poem about Adam and Eve’s fall from the Garden of Eden. In Paradise Lost, ecofeminism is obviously demonstrated as Adam’s domination over Eve mirrors man’s domination over nature. The environmental destruction that the world faces today is undoubtedly due to man and an anthropocentric worldview that places human needs and wants above all others. We face climate change, rising seas, ocean acidification, deforestation, massive extinction, and other devastating environmental problems because man is valued over nature. This problem is especially pronounced in Western capitalist and consumerist culture. Christianity is often cited as inherently opposed to the environmental



Cited: Gray, Elizabeth D. "Man-Above: The Anthropocentric Illusion." Green Paradise Lost. American Buddha. Web. 12 Dec. 2012. King James Bible. Genesis 1-3 Milton, John. Paradise Lost. Ed. Gordon Teskey. New York: Norton, 2005. Print. Plumwood, Val. Feminism and the Mastery of Nature. London: Routledge, 1993. Print.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    There are so many bad things in this world and the environment is one of them bad things. Our environment will never just go away but it’s definitely needs to change. It’s causing damage to our friends and family, it’s taking away all of our animals, and it’s hurting the world we know around us. If we don’t do something about it, will the world’s population go down because of a great amount of people dying? Will the animals become extinct and no one ever talk about them again? Will the oceans be able to hold their ground and keep producing the oxygen it’s giving us? Throughout this essay, Sandra Steingraber does a great job using ethos, pathos, and logos while talking about the environment and the issues it is causing to the people and the…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gore vs. Suzuki

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages

    David Suzuki’s A Sacred Balance and Al Gore’s A Climate Emergency both outline the detrimental ways in which technology, population growth, and our way of living have begun to and will continue to destroy our diverse ecosystem. However, the outlooks that these two environmental giants have on man’s role in the world are perfectly opposite. “There is no environment ‘out there,’” urges Suzuki, “we are born of the earth and constructed from the four sacred elements of earth, air, fire, and water” (432). Gore, contrastingly, doesn’t look at humans as part of the interconnected “web,” but as rather just “[having an] impact on [the earth]” (456).…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the essay “Green Guilt” by Stephen Asma, the writer claims that environmentalism has become a substitute for religion. This claim holds a strong argument when paired with the Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary definition of the word religion which states that religion is “a pursuit or interest to which someone awards extreme importance.” With this definition of religion a strong argument could be made that anything we hold important can be our religion. However, a strong argument could also be made that our society and culture has not changed to make environmentalism similar to a religion, but to make religion similar to environmentalism. It is not a far cry to say that religion is not what it once was. Our society has changed and…

    • 177 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “The Letter to the Southern Baptist Minister” forced me to raise a number of questions. Rather often, we think of environmental issues as related to political ideology or connect them to personal religious identities, which confuses the matter. In his letter, E.O. Wilson asks this pastor to remove that confusion, and, while they hold different worldviews, to consider his position. Wilson further proposes that both Christian and non-religious individuals can hold a humanist belief of conservation. Whether an individual holds that creation is the offspring of a creator and should be preserved as a work of his genius, or that the world should be preserved because it is the only source of sustenance for the human race for the foreseeable future, they can mutually agree that conservation will have positive effects and that this masterpiece of biology should be preserved. As exemplified by the people of Easter Island, we should not allow ourselves to overuse natural resources, because of not only destruction caused to nature but also because of the negative effects which would be given to our ancestors.…

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many people are familiar with the well beloved Saint Francis. He is most well known for his care and love of animals and nature. However, people use this as a way to prove that he was an environmentalist in the modern sense of the term. They say he is one who tried to strike a movement against the brutalities and injustices of animals. The truth is, Saint Francis was a man who loved God’s creation and cared for it as well as he could. Saint Francis, however, is not a modern environmentalist, but exemplifies what it truly means to care and cultivate the creation which God has made.…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein novel is about man trying to conquer the knowledge of the world and nature. This endeavor ultimately leads to his failure. In this novel there are references to a work by John Milton called Paradise Lost. In Paradise Lost God creates a man Adam and a woman Eve; Satan later tempts them to eat the forbidden fruit of knowledge and they do (Dudczak). Once they eat the fruit they are cast from Paradise forever (Dudczak). Mary Shelley uses this allusion in her novel to show her opinion of Enlightenment as she herself was a Gothic Romantic. Shelley believed that trying to conquer nature would only lead to failure.…

    • 111 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Perhaps the most well known story of the Holy Bible is that of the creation story. In this story, God creates the earth in six days and rests on the seventh, after creating light, dark, oceans, and animals of all types. When he feels that there should be creatures other than animals, he creates man, in His image. He names this man Adam, and then creates a counterpart for his new creation, Eve. Adam and Eve lived together in harmony with God and all the other animals in the Garden of Eden, a paradise where evil did not exist, and their only rule was to not eat from the tree of Knowledge. However, Adam and Eve, under the temptation of the serpent, showed greed, and wanted to be more like God, so they ate the fruit, in order to become like God. When compared in depth, the protagonist of the creation story, Adam, and the street sweeper, Equality 7-2521, of Ayn Rand’s Anthem are condemned men, whose stories are very similar, save one key difference.…

    • 1337 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    For the past two-thousand years, the Book of Genesis has served as work of literature to the western civilization. Whether people believed in the Bible or not, the Book of Genesis tell stories they talk about having good morals, teaching live-learned lessons and overall it gives a glimpse of how the first human being acted when the world was developing and how they handle problems and situations. However, even though the book of Genesis shows a tone of life long morals, Genesis also shows the different sides of humans. Genesis shows how human can be deceitful, evil, and disobedient to authority figures. But these traits with humans were rarely displayed by man, but mostly by woman. In the book of Genesis, woman are displayed obstacles and road blocks to these undermining and broad goals through God‘s plan . From the beginning of the book with Garden of Eden to the ending of the story of Joseph, women, as mothers and wives are typically portrayed disloyal, undependable mischievous or, just simply for their womanhood, and they frequently threaten to undermine God's will than men. This portrayal is done because women were not considered equal to man and man was the only thing that God intended to create. Women in Genesis were set as these archetypes that God wanted them to be, but in the narrative its they are shown otherwise.…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Milton’s Paradise Lost is essentially the book of Genesis on steroids. Looking specifically at Book three and seven of Paradise Lost we will notice many descriptions and events that have been added to the book. The three most noticeable differences in Paradise Lost (book three and seven) compared to the book of Genesis in the Bible are: the devil’s use of Uriel to get to Earth, both the process of Jesus being asked to be the savior of the world and the dialogue between God and Jesus, and the use of the archangel Raphael to warn the oncoming temptation of Satan in book seven. All three of these are not mentioned in the Bible, and have been added by Milton to add excitement,…

    • 1842 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Best Essays

    Naples, Nancy A. "The New Poverty Studies (Book)." American Journal Of Sociology 108, no. 1…

    • 2648 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Milton starts off as presenting Adam as a protecting, reasonable and logical man with great authority. God created Adam with free will, so he has to make a choice to obey God’s orders of not eating from The Tree of Knowledge, or to follow Eve’s decision. Throughout the book, Milton drops hints about Adam’s flaws; For example, how Adam does not share the warnings that God and Raphael tell him about The Tree of Knowledge, or how Adam can only think about having sexual relations with Eve instead of working. Men are believed to have logical and reason, but Adam shows the trait passion, which women are believed to have. In Milton’s re-told story of The Fall, Adam is seen to have passion and Eve is seen to have reason and logical, which is complete opposite of belief (Lansbury 2). All of these actions characterized by Adam could be why he had the blame set on him for The Fall of man.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Women in Genesis

    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Interpretation is everything when it comes to identifying a text. Readings of one verse "may vary, when in fact they regularly do much more - at times they clearly oppose or contradict each other." 1 Within the book of Genesis we encounter opposition and contradiction in every verse depending on a variety of factors. "...Religious or theological persuasions, or one 's place in history, society and culture" 2 can sway or change an interpretation of text. This being said, the popular and widely accepted interpretations are the ones affecting women and our population in general. The Bible is widely distributed and acknowledged, Genesis is known throughout the world and its social order. Even more so, the creation story is famous, it is mentioned in films, books, school and much more. The interpretation of this story is still additionally accepted, everyone knows the story of the apple and Eve. The impact this one story has on the institution of patriarchy, Phyllis Bird has a good representation : "A hierarchy of order is introduced into the relationship of the primal pair. Mutuality is replaced by rule. Patriarchy is inaugurated. . . . The rule of man over the woman, as announced in Genesis 3:16, is the Bible 's first statement of hierarchy within the species." 3 The potential for this verse to be used for oppressive should not be underestimated. Eve and Lilith, the women of Genesis are sexualized, sin ridden and seen as antagonists within the creation story. Let us see how the interpretation of this take has created societal norms for gender roles.…

    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    While Milton’s retelling of the biblical tale of man’s origin within Paradise Lost is true to the bible, he manages to reinvent it in a slightly different manner – a manner that brings to light new questions about the roles Adam and Eve played in the fall of human kind. Speaking more specifically, his retelling of the fall of man seems to bring up questions about how gender operates within the biblical world and how it may relate to the time Milton comes from. At face value, the portrayal of Eve suggests that she is inferior and subordinate to Adam. There seems to be a stark contrast between Adam and Eve: where Adam is strong, rational, and intelligent, Eve is naïve and narcissistic. These differences between Adam…

    • 1755 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    As global warming intensifies, glaciers melt and forests reduced,more and more people begin to be concerned about environment problem. Environment is the fundamental of our existence,so we need protect environment. Paul H. Rubin in his article “Environmentalism as religion” says “But there is another sense in which environmentalism is becoming more and more like a religion: It provides its adherents with an identity”(399). He thinks environmentalism like a religion, and environmentalism and religion have many same characteristic. I agree Rubin’s opinion. Like religion, environmentalism has difference tribe, environmentalist like a missionary, environmentalism and religion both have food taboos and they also both no logical bases.…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The historical context of Milton’s is important to understand Milton’s work and his portrayal of Eve. In Milton’s time women were regarded with little respect. Women did not “hold official civil or ecclesiastical positions, attend universities, or engage in major professions” though it is apparent that that they wrote and “prophesy” (Danielson 177). Women were to keep their opinions to themselves, but in reality they would often give counsel to their husbands in the private of their home (“The Early Seventeenth Century"). Although, Paradise Lost is less focused on careerism in regards to women, there correlation between Eve and seventeenth century women still exists. Eve’s characterization is much more connected to her relationship with Adam…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays