Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

“Doing Research on Animals: What Does Islam Say?”

Better Essays
1468 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
“Doing Research on Animals: What Does Islam Say?”
Doing research on animals exist long time ago. There are records were found in Egypt, dated in the 3rd Century B.C, where a scientist philosopher used animals to study body function. Since then, the use of animals in research has broadly multiply. Millions of animals are studied in research laboratories each year in order to test any new findings for human disease. Researchers have carried out experiments on monkeys, dogs, cats, chimpanzees and others, because these animals can serve as useful models of many human reactions. The western view on animal testing is somewhat agree because it benefits both human and also animals, there is great similarities between human and animals in the genetics and it makes more new and progressive findings for human diseases. On the other way around, there are also some western who do not agree about animal testing, it is because animals also have rights, using animals for experiments which is different from human and it is immoral and should not be allowed. The animals testing benefits both human and animals in similar ways. Tests of new surgical techniques often are first carried out on animals. Some animals are subjected to diseases so that researchers can observe the animals and investigate potential cures. In addition, animals studies resulting in many of new treatments and cures for human disease such as epilepsy, spinal cord injuries, stroke, treating anxiety and many more. At the same time, it also benefit animals; animal sexual behaviour, genetics and experimental aspects that control the timing and way of migration and animal necessity for habitat and territory. This is an effort to save endangered species from extinction. Human and animals share few biological and genetics similarities. Many medical treatment and procedures have been developed with experiments on animals. Since they share many of the features with human, researchers use animals to test the safety and effectiveness of newly developed drugs before they test on small group of patients and it is extremely unsafe to use without animals testing. Continuous doing research with animals make new and progressive findings for human diseases. Without animals testing there would not be the medical advances in today’s technology. Animals are closest things that resemble human life systems. Animals testing are also needed to ensure the medications, vaccines and surgical procedures are safe for human and it is very important for the survival of human race. In opposition, there are also those who against the use of animals testing because animals also have rights. They have right to be treated with respect and right not to be subjected to pain or discomfort. Animals should be treated as having value in themselves. Some also claimed that animals testing are not applicable to human. Human may share some of the similarities but they are totally different; the brain functions, habitats, psychological needs and so on. Researchers cannot simply do test on animals and further use it for treating human diseases. Animals testing are immoral and should not be allowed. Many people are concerned that doing research with animals only makes animals suffering unreasonably and brutality. Every year, millions of animals undergo painful suffering or death as a result of scientific research. According to Islamic principles, humanity is not allowed to do anything to the living things and must only take their lives if necessary. There are Islamic restrictions on manipulating animals because they represent Allah’s unique and wonderful creations and we must treat them nicely. Islam does not specifically agree or disagree about animals testing. Muslims believed that, all living creatures were made by Allah, animals exist for the benefits of human beings, but they also need to be treated with kindness and compassion. Muslims are also instructed to avoid treating animal cruelly and neglecting them. Generally, using animals is allowed in Islam. It is stated in Quran;
“It is Allah Who made cattle for you, that ye may use some for riding and some for food; And there are (other) advantages in them for you (besides); that ye may through them attain to any need (there may be) in your hearts; and on them and on ships ye are carried.”
(40:79-80)
As though Islam does not restrict animals testing, they must not suffer from any pain or mutilation and there must be a good reason for the experiment. Action shall be judged according to intention; killing with purpose which is for finding new treatment for human diseases. Even Prophet S.A.W also ordered His believers to use sharp knives and not to blunt ones while slaughtering animals as to minimise the pain and discomfort to them. The concept of ehsan is contained in the Islamic law, which is the basis of the rights of animals. The ehsan to animals mean providing enough food, enough space for them and being gentle. This is very important while conducting research with animals. As state in Quran;
“We sent thee not, but as a Mercy for all creatures.” (21:107)
Therefore, as Muslim, we shall promote compassion and gentleness to these tested animals as much as we can to reduce the sufferings of these animals.
Muslims researchers must respect animals as created beings and not simply as laboratory tools. They have an ethical obligation to ensure that their research aims cannot be achieved in other ways. As moral beings, man should not even tolerate pain on the part of animals except when it serves a clearly defined such as saving a precious life, as found in Abu Dawud Hadith, it forbids the disfiguration of the body of an animals, Prophet S.A.W said “do not clip the forelock of a horse, for decency is attached to its forelock; nor its mane, for it protects it, nor its tail, for it is, its fly-flap.” In general, animals experimentation should take place when and where there are no real alternatives. It is also true that researchers cannot use human in their research study because it takes more than a year to develop vaccines or cures than using animals.
Muslims researchers should follow the guidelines that have been provided in al-Quran and Sunnah. These are the most important things that prophets S.A.W left for humankind. Quran and Sunnah guides human in every aspect. Animals testing did not exist at the time of Prophet S.A.W, so it is not specifically cited in the Sha’riah. Guidance from such issues comes from analogy and inference (Ijtihad). Therefore, Muslims researchers must understand what comes in Quran and Sunnah, so that they will make use of Ijtihad.
The use of animals by doctors and researchers to understand the physiology of human beings is not unique to this century. Animals have been used in medical research for at least 2,000 years. The fact that animals testing has greatly contributed to medical field are undeniable. Animals make good subjects for research on human disease health conditions because they share certain biological and genetic similarities with human. We can use these advantages for studying and developing new medical treatment. Animal testing will continue to aid medical research in order to improve the health of human beings. Without animal testing, many procedures or new drugs would be extremely unsafe.
As we can see from doing research with animals, we find many advantages compared to disadvantages. Animals testing give us a broader view of finding new treatment for human diseases. Not only that, these animals testing also benefit animals; in efforts to save endangered species from extinction, researchers studies on few topics on genetic factors, animal sexual behaviour and so forth. Though it is true that animals should not be manipulated for unnecessary testing such as cosmetic testing, animals testing should not be eliminated from medical filed until a true successful alternative have been develop to substitute animals testing.
Quran provides broad guidelines concerning the spiritual and material aspects of life. It is also a scripture of guidelines and not a book of any physical or social sciences. Due to that, Muslims researchers should follow guidelines stated in al-Quran and Sunnah. While doing research with animals, it is necessary not to harm or hurt them, although animals are created for human benefit, they are also creations from Allah. A true Muslims in the unity of God will show deep respect for Allah’s entire creation. Muslims researchers also must understand the intention while conducting animals testing which is to find a new treatment for human betterment.

References:
Kimmel, Allan. J. (2007). Ethical issues in Behavioral Research. Australia: Blackwell Publishing.
James E. White. (2009). Contemporary Moral Problems. U.S.A: Thomson Wadsworth. http://www.themodernreligion.com/misc/an/an1.htm http://shaikhsohail.wordpress.com/2008/06/10/animal-rights-from-islamic-perspective/
http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/islam/islamethics/animals_1.shtml

References: Kimmel, Allan. J. (2007). Ethical issues in Behavioral Research. Australia: Blackwell Publishing. James E. White. (2009). Contemporary Moral Problems. U.S.A: Thomson Wadsworth. http://www.themodernreligion.com/misc/an/an1.htm http://shaikhsohail.wordpress.com/2008/06/10/animal-rights-from-islamic-perspective/ http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/islam/islamethics/animals_1.shtml

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Animal testing is rarely successful since animals have different physiologies than humans. There has been many studies that have shown inaccuracy and unsuccess in animal testing. Studies show, “90 percent of medications approved for human use after animal testing later proved ineffective or harmful to humans in clinical trials” (Stop Animal Testing) and also, “Animal-tested drugs have killed, disabled or harmed millions of people and lead to costly delays as well” (Stop Animal Testing). It is evident that animal testing lacks accuracy and has dangerous consequences, therefore it should no longer be…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Animals are used in scientific experiments in light of the fact that by utilizing more genuine models, scientists have the ability to learn more about the animal. The results of animal research can identify with different types of animals including people. Human wellbeing has benefited from the use of animals in scientific research. A few studies are hurtful for human wellbeing, so scientists study animals when there is no other alternative. Areas of human health that have benefitted or…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Inaccurate Animal Testing

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages

    As a result of this, nine out of every ten trial medicines that look safe and appear to be effective on animals, fail when they are given to humans. Because animals don’t react the same way as humans, not only do the failed tests delay medical progress, but also they are a waste of animal’s lives, and a waste of money that is spent into the research and tests. Animals have different anatomic, cellular, and metabolic structures than humans have. If a new product is passed just because it is safe on animals and isn’t on humans, that could be a very dangerous situation. One instance when this occurred was in 1950 when a sleeping pill worked on animals but when given to humans it caused 10,000 babies to be born with severe birth defects. Another time, a drug for arthritis was safe on mice but when administered to humans caused 27,000 heart attacks and sudden cardiac deaths. Animal testing can make researchers oversea potential cures and treatments. Some substances that are harmful to animals, are helpful to humans. For example, aspirin is dangerous to some animals. Arthur Allen says, “A source of human suffering may be the dozens of promising drugs that get shelved when they cause problems in animals that may not be relevant for humans.” (“Of Mice or Men: The Problems with Animal Testing”). Of all the medicines that pass animal trials and are ready for human…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Animal Testing Speech

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Comparing animals and humans, we do have lots alike. Both often contract the same illnesses and diseases, and they suffer from the same health conditions as humans, some examples being: cancer, diabetes, heart disease and high blood pressure. Although animals and humans are alike, that doesn’t mean we react to all illness the same. The Food and Drug Administration reports that 92 out of every 100 drugs that pass animal tests fail in…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Animals have been used in medical research for centuries. In a recent count, it was determined that 8815 animals were being used for research at MSU, 8503 of them were rats, mice, hamsters, and gerbils. The strugle against animal research has been one of the most debatable issues of the decade. Even though most researchers need to do experiments on animals in order to achieve medical advances, animal research should not be allowed because it is cruel and inhumane, it is not always accurate, and often unnecessary.…

    • 574 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Animals can be ferocious and wild, but they can also be gentle and tame. Some are our pets, and some are powerful forces that are to be respected and admired. It is as easy to appreciate a loyal dog as it is to be in awe of a lion in its' natural habitat. But the truth that many people either don’t know or don’t appreciate is that animals are essential to human existence and have played a vital role in improving the quality of our lives. They have been providing us with answers to our most complex medical questions for decades. Their role in finding cures for diseases, treatments for illness, and product safety is immense. First, we will examine how animal testing has benefited both man and beast. Second, I will dispel the belief that animals used in research are mistreated. Last, we will learn how the process of drug development is carried out.…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Leonard Thompson Biography

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Scientists are constantly looking for new medical advances that they hope will save people’s lives and often turn to animals as the optimal resource for testing new ideas and products. These animals range from rats and mice to dogs and monkeys. On top of varying animals, the tests they run fluctuate from simply checking the effectiveness of a medicine already in use to testing an entirely new form of treatment. However, there have beens years of controversy over the morality of using animals as the test subjects.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Testing on animals before trying with human reduces unwanted risks for human. It is necessary to use animals in medical testing. In order to decrease or avoid the harm to human, everytime researchers take antibiotics on animals to make sure whether this medicine is safe or not. For example,"Researchers would first learn to cure the mice with drugs, then cautiously try with…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Animal testing gains a lot of attention in the media for being unethical and unfair towards animals that do not have their own voice to be heard. One advantage of animal testing is that it is possible to carry out procedures on other species that simply would not be allowed on humans. Examples include Brady’s executive monkey, Morgan’s hamsters, Pavlov’s dogs etc. This is because humans are seen as having more ethical rights than animals due to the Marxist view that homo-sapiens “contribute towards society” whereas animals do not. Another point is that generations of animals can be studied in a relatively short period of time. This is beneficial when researching a drugs long term effects and want to know if it will affect offspring. Clearly, this kind of study would not be viable on humans since you could be waiting 30 years; whereas rats can reproduce and reach sexual peak very quickly. Thirdly, we can draw comparisons between the causes and function of animal and human behaviour due to the similarity of our brains; underlying structures of the midbrain for example are quite similar across all mammals and other biological…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    animal testing

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Animal testing also proves that some drugs and medication are either safe or unsafe. Animal research helps us find a cure to some deadly diseases. (Ian Murnaghan). They test new series of surgeries on animals and then it ends up…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Benefits Of Animal Testing

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In animal testing, countless animals are experimented on and then killed after their use is up. Some are injured and will still live the remainder of their life in captivity. The doctors will not do anything to help the animals that are in pain that happen to be the reason because of them. It is the aspect of animals testing that many view as a major negative against the practice, as it seems that the animal died in vain because no direct benefit to humans occurred. Even though animals and humans have many things in common like how we both have the same organ system, there are also many things that are different between animals and humans. Many animals cannot handle or take the same medication as humans, most the surgeries that are operated on animals are just too strong for an animal to take so they end up dying or sick for the rest of their lives. (Animal Testing…

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Animals testing has been applied throughout human history. The use of animals in scientific experiments in the United Kingdom can be traced back to at least the 17th century with the experiments on numerous animal species aiming to demonstrate blood circulation (“History of Animal Research”). Once animal testing became known, it expanded. During the late 19th and the 20th centuries, the expansion of medical science meant that the number of animals used in research expanded steadily (“History of Animal Research”). “The number of animals used rose to over 5.5 million in 1970 after this point the numbers began to decline rapidly (“History of Animal Research”).” Most of the medical advances that happened in the 20th century were from animal experimentation.…

    • 1448 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Many scientists and researchers are for animal testing. People throughout the world are living better lives because of the advancements made possible from the results of animal research. Researchers within many different medical and scientific organizations agree that animal testing is absolutely essential for progress. For example, over 70 percent of the Nobel Prize winners in medicine have used animals in their research. Advancements in science through animal research have brought us closer to finding cures for diseases such as cancer and AIDS. Nearly all of the scientists who do research on animals do it because they hope that, while it causes a few to experience pain now, it will help prevent many from feeling pain later.…

    • 1521 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Animal Research

    • 700 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There has been a disagreement between animal rights supporters and scientists about whether it is right to use animals in experimental research. Also, it is very debatable whether using animals for such research results in finding a cure for diseases. From my point of view, if there are no other alternatives, and if it is possible that this will contribute to science, animals may be used for experimental research.…

    • 700 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Convincing arguments can be said that animal experiments are commonly used in medical research. In studies on investigation and prevention, human diseases play a huge role. To start with the role of medicine, using animals to test new drugs could help in understanding the effects and side effects of new drugs. Therefore, people don’t have to be test subjects, and can avoid the dangers of being these test subjects. Moreover, animal experiments in cloning human organs also have a new break through. For instance, people found that goats implanted with human stem cells have blood and organs similar to DNA of humans. Specifically, the main use of it is nurturing human organs in animals’ bodies. One day when people are injured or sick, they will be able to directly replace organs.…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays