Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

discuss the importance of pavel in the boy and strip ed pyjamas

Good Essays
1200 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
discuss the importance of pavel in the boy and strip ed pyjamas
‘Discuss the importance of Pavel’
In the novel ‘The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas’ the author is giving his viewpoint on the “death camps” of the Second World War. John Boyne said “As a writer, one must approach the subject with respect and sensitivity but there’s also a responsibility to tell an emotionally honest story.” In my opinion, telling the story through the eyes of a nine year old German boy the author tackles the subject of the Holocaust sensitively, innocently and from a surprising angle. Therefore, he does not delve into the reasons why these events took place but allows the more mature reader to realise the inferences and implications that he makes about the horror and inhumanity of ‘The Final Solution.’
In addition, in order to show the reader his viewpoint the author uses the character of Pavel to enable the reader to recognise not only how cruel ‘The Final Solution’ was, but also the courage and bravery of the prisoners of war.
Firstly in the physical appearance of Pavel we are given an insight into how he was treated. The quote ‘he was quite a small man, and very skinny too, with long fingers and angular features,’ Implies to us that he is obviously malnourished. The words ‘very skinny’ imply that he is not just skinny he is gone beyond that. Further on in the story Pavel is described again, this time he is even worse than before. The quote ‘he seemed to grow smaller and smaller each week,’ suggests to the reader that he is very frail and over time; week by week his living conditions have got worse. Another physical aspect is the uniform the prisoners were made to wear; because even though Pavel is waiting in the house he is still made wear this uniform. In my opinion, they are made wear them almost to be shamed and as a constant reminder of who they were and that they were not free people.
As well as just physical appearance the author demonstrates the mental and psychological impact it seems to be having on Pavel. The quote ‘the colour that should have been in his cheeks had drained almost entirely away. His eyes appeared heavy with tears.’ implies to the reader that he is not healthy. The word ‘drained’ implies to the reader that almost the life is being sucked out of him, but this has been over time and that he has being getting gradually worse. Also the word ‘heavy’ implies to the reader that he is very tired and like he is really giving up on life and no longer trying. I feel the author uses the progression of time to show how being in places like death camps slowly ate away at the mind set of people and the cruelness they must have suffered. So from page 83 when you first see Pavel to his reappearance on page 142, there is a visible change in his mental and physical appearance.
We are also shown courage and bravery when Pavel helps Bruno when he is hurt. The quote ‘your mother hasn’t returned yet, I’m afraid, said Pavel, who was kneeling on the floor in front of him and examining the knee. I’m the only one here’ shows that although Pavel knows there is no one there at the moment he is still taking a risk because at any moment a solider or his mother could arrive at the scene. I feel this shows Pavel and his caring side.
Another aspect the author highlights in using the character of Pavel is the true disregard the Nazis had for the previous life skills of the prisoners. Pavel used to be a doctor and now is nothing but a waiter peeling vegetables; ‘before I came here I practised as a doctor’ displays to the reader that no matter what you did before it is useless unless seen a useful skill by the Nazis. One’s race, ethnic origin or religious persuasion if not of Aryan nature overrode any skill set you once had. In other words you were less than a comparable human. Through the eyes of Pavel the author truly reflects how someone so skilled and intelligent could be made into someone so low and unvalued.
During the novel Pavel’s relationship with some of the other people in the house is also shown by the author. For example on page 135 to 137, there is a passage with Bruno talking to Maria the maid. Firstly ‘only he told me then that he wasn’t really a waiter at all. Maria’s face froze a little’ the use of the word froze in this quote implies that this is quite a tense and awkward subject for Maria to talk about. The quote ‘Pavel is not a doctor anymore Bruno said Maria quietly’ suggests that Maria is quite uncomfortable and also the use of the word ‘quietly’ which infers that she is frightened of being overheard, and almost like she knows that it’s not something she should be discussing with Bruno. Also the quote ‘Bruno frowned and thought about it. I don’t understand he said. Few of us do, said Maria’ implies to the reader that even she is unsure about how the prisoner’s previous careers are of such disregard to the Nazi’s. In my opinion the use of the part of Maria with Pavel is to show that not all the members of the household are exactly like the Nazis and even some who should be have their doubts over the Nazis beliefs.
The incident with Kotler when Pavel accidently spills wine on him is used by the author to make the reader think for themselves and to emphasise the fact that the Nazis did not have any care at all for a person’s life. The quote ‘What happened then was both unexpected and extremely unpleasant. Lieutenant Kotler grew very angry with Pavel… even though none of them could watch it made Bruno cry and Gretel pale,’ shows that even for just one simple mistake the punishment could be fateful. Also as the author does not actually describe what happens to Pavel it keeps the writing sensitive but to a more mature reader it is clear as to what has happened.
Also the use of Pavel lets Bruno see a different side to his father. For instance the quote ‘…and not even Father-stepped in to stop him doing what he did next’ shows the ruthlessness of the father and that even though he had the authority to stop Kotler he didn’t. Another quote ‘and while generally Bruno realized that Father was generally a kind and thoughtful man, it hardly seemed fair of right that no one had stopped lieutenant Kotler getting so angry at Pavel’ shows that again Bruno is beginning to realise that his father may not be quite such the good solider he thought he was.
In conclusion, John Boyne successfully uses Pavel to emphasise the inhumanity of the Nazis and how the human body and mind can be so brutally tortured but ones spirit and inner strength can endure even the worse that life can offer.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    As Vladek develops as a character during both the graphic novels, he shows that he is not a compassionate and understanding character, before, during or after the Holocaust. He manages to make it through his war experience with a great deal of luck, and intelligence. His experiences have left him scarred emotionally, causing him to live a selfish, conservative life similar to how he lived during the Holocaust, because he became so accustomed to that lifestyle throughout the duration of the war. The text, at times, seems to go out of its way to emphasize Vladek's limitations as a human being . For example, his racist attitude when Francois picks up a black hitchhiker, "...you went crazy or what?!" "I had the whole time to watch out that this SHVARSTER doesn't steal us the groceries from the back seat!(p.99,Volume II)" His treatment of women is another prime example, "Your father! He treats me as if I were just a maid or his nurse... WORSE!- Mala (p.130,Volume I)" As well with his inability to deal with Artie. Vladek is portrayed as a victim, as someone very ordinary, without any privileged insight into what has happened to him or why. If we are seeking here some illumination of the events we witness, that does not come from anything Vladek has to offer.…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He was born in Dublin, Ireland in 1971 and has written a total of 14 novels. Boyne originally did not intend on this novel to be about the Holocaust; however, the idea came up and he just could not pass it up. When writing this novel, Boyne did not have a definite viewpoint expressed. He decided to keep the viewpoint neutral and give both sides of the story. The Boy in the Striped Pajamas is a fable according to John Boyne that is based on historical information. Boyne hoped that by writing this novel people would learn a lesson or understand a moral. As I have stated before, Boyne writes about two boys from different sides of a fence (literally and figuratively). They are each going through the Holocaust and the Nazi Party’s rule on…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    For several years, World War II had been raging in Europe. In 1945, German soldiers surrounded Russia and tried to choke off the train of supplies entering the country. Leningrad, Russia remained under constant bombing by German aircraft. Leningrad was a key location for Russia’s war efforts due to its manufacturing facilities and needed to stay functional. Lev Beniov was on the roof of his apartment building watching the anti-aircraft balloons above the city. It was on this night that a dead German paratrooper landed in front of Lev’s building. As the news reached all the boys and girls on the roof, they rushed down to examine and loot the dead soldier. Within minutes, Russian soldiers appeared. Lev’s friends deserted him and he was arrested and thrown into the Crosses. After spending the night, Colonel Grechko gave Lev a chance to redeem himself for his wrongs and save his life. Through…

    • 1292 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Effect of Temperature on the plot in One Day in the Life of Ivan and The Strangers…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    adaklfjda

    • 818 Words
    • 3 Pages

    ● Ivan was a lonely kid who was for the most part neglected by his family, who were busy…

    • 818 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Boyne represents the different perspectives of society in World War II through the representations of characters in the fictional novel The Boy in Striped Pyjamas. Bruno’s childlike perspective is represented through his malapropism of “the Fury” and “Out-With” and his reaction to unexpected events, “mouth making the shape of an O”. The irony of Bruno’s narrow view, “it’s so unfair...” confronts the audience with the ignorance of some German citizens to the horrific events of the Holocaust. The characters of “Mother” and “Grandmother” are utilised by Boyne to represent the differing perspectives of the society during the Holocaust. Grandmother exercises constructive disobedience in dissenting with the Nazi regime and perceiving Fathers role as “a puppet on a string”. This is juxtaposed to Bruno's Mother through the euphemism of "[Bruno] had never known anyone to need quite so many medicinal Sherries" showing her complacency to do nothing about the knowledge of the concentration camp. Boyne positions an older audience to see the dangers of naivety and the cost of inaction.…

    • 510 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As Rainsford sat down for breakfast, he asked Ivan to fetch the general. He felt almost sorry for Ivan, and he wondered how it must feel to be deaf-mute, to never have your own life and to always live it under someone else’s control. But Rainsford did not have long to pity Ivan, as the general walked in. Rainsford studied his long, wiry black beard and his unnerving dark black eyes which showed no emotion. A night of sleeping with the dogs had proved very damaging on his appearance, as he had big black bags under his eyes and seemed even more exhausted than what was humanly possible. “Thank you for coming up to breakfast” said Rainsford, trying to keep his voice blank. “Thank you for inviting me” replied the general, his Russian accent thick and emotionless, his black eyes studying Rainsford unnervingly, as though he was studying a rare animal he was about to pounce on. Rainsford refused to be un-nerved by the general, as he knew that he must stand his ground in order for the general to take his proposal seriously. “How was your night?” Rainsford asked, trying to build up conversation. “I have had better nights”,…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vladek In Maus

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The war changed Vladek from a well-mannered and grateful person, to someone who thinks he is entitled to do and say whatever he wants. Vladek grew to be judgmental because of the fact that he lived his life in fear of Nazis. For example, he was constantly hiding from the Nazis with their dogs. He hid under coal so that the dogs couldn't trace his smell. They had to live in bunkers with worms crawling all over; “Is it safe to go out yet? I can’t stand all these worms crawling over me.” He also survived extreme starvation and abuse in Auschwitz. In contrast, Mala thinks that Vladek is just the way he is, not because of the camps, “All our friends went through the camps. Nobody is like him!” Spiegleman portrays Vladek as someone who physically survived the war, but psychologically died. The fact that the author paints a complex picture from an individual perspective helps to relay the Holocaust’s unspeakable…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In paragraph seven, the text says, "By manipulating the historical realities of the Holocaust for the sake of a good story, Boyne runs the risk of giving readers a distorted view of the Holocaust." This was an example of what the writer was arguing about and what they think about the book, The Boy in the Striped Pajamas. The writer believes that the book manipulated some historic events in the Holocaust for the sake of a good story. To support their argument farther more, the writer quoted David Cesarani on the topic of how Bruno would pronounce some words, it says, "Young Bruno mishears “Auschwitz” as “Out-With” and “the Führer” as “the Fury.” As Cesarani points out, “any normal German nine-year-old would have been able to pronounce Führer and Auschwitz correctly.” This shows us that the author had changed the pronouncing of the words Auschwitz and the Fuhrer to out-with and the fury, this is impossible because Bruno is born in Germany and he should then also be able to speak German fluently. The writer also had some well supported points, one of them was a quote from Cesarani that says, "Guards patrolled the fences and prisoners did not have the freedom to move about at will. Boyne’s literary device hides the ugly truth of the concentration camps: constant roll calls, slave labor,…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Today I will be discussing two texts, the first text I will be talking about is a film called The boy in the Striped Pyjama’s directed by Mark Herman, the film is based on the novel written by John Boyne. The film evaluates different human spirits as a family from Berlin physically travels into the countryside regarding the father, Ralph, due to his promotion to commandment of a Nazi Concentration camp during the time of Nazi Germany. The wife Elsa is oblivious to the true reasoning of moving houses, I will discuss her emotional and inner journey as she gradually reveals her husband’s line of duty testing her strong human spirit.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For example in the text it says that, "for the older reader, of course, Bruno’s innocence comes to stand for the willful refusal of all adult Germans to see what was going on under their noses in the first half of the 1940s.” For younger readers, she argues, the story’s slow release of details “becomes an education in real time of the horrors of ‘Out-With,’ known to the grown-ups as Auschwitz" This shows us that the story could be taken as adults ignoring the events taking place around them or as a slow release of events in real time in Auschwitz. What Hughes says helps support the claim made in the Point essay by showing how historic fiction could benefit people in real life. All in all, Kathryn Hughes' view of The Boy in the Striped Pajamas is that it can mean different things for adults and for…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Another thing that I understood more was how miserable conditions were, by looking at the presentations about culture. I came to understand more about the harsh conditions of the gulags and economy. When reading the book, I was more focused on the weather of the book, such as when the prisoners were forced to work in the cold and stand still to be counted. People on their way to the gulags would die, because of the horrible conditions on the train. In the book, Shukhov explained about how horrible it was in the prison cells, because of how cold it was, especially because a person sent to the cells had nothing but his clothes to warm him. He also said that if the person in a cell survived being in the cells, they would not be the same ever again.…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas is a novel by John Boyne. This novel is set during World War 2 and explores themes such as prejudice, racism, war, innocence and friendship. What sets it apart from other novels is that it uses a third person limited point of view, and mostly depicts events as they are seen by a young and naïve boy. This was one of the main narrative conventions that engaged me in this novel.…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Told almost entirely from a young, naive German boy’s point of view, Mark Herman’s The Boy in the Striped Pajamas is a hard-hitting Holocaust tale that will render audiences speechless. After arriving home, Bruno (Asa Butterfield) learns that his family will have to move because his father (David Thewlis) achieved a promotion in the Nazi army. Bruno noticed what he believed to be farmers living just past a stretch of woods near their new home. One day, not long after being told not to go near the “farmers,” Bruno leaves his home and heads towards the camp. There he meets Shmuel (Jack Scanlon), a young Jewish boy. While trying to understand what is happening in the world around them, the boys become friends. While…

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The novel “One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich” follows the life of a prisoner in a Siberian labor camp during the communist period. Although the novel only describes one day in the life of this prisoner, the author succeeds at making the motifs that occur most likely every day clear to the reader. A major motif in the novel “One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich” written by Alexander Solzhenitsyn is dehumanization; Ivan Denisovich Shukhov is striped of his humanity because he is treated similarly to the way an animal would be treated. He is given instructions every second of the day, and has no say in how to live his life. Dehumanization occurs when people view others as less than human, therefore not giving them the moral respect they deserve as humans. In this particular Stalinist labor camp, in which the main character Ivan Denisovich Shukhov is imprisoned, the officers are instructed to attack the prisoner’s dignity, therefore they are taking away their humanity, treating them like they would treat a cattle, not people.…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays