Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Discipline: Effective School Practices

Powerful Essays
1950 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Discipline: Effective School Practices
Discipline: Effective School
Practices
BY GEORGE BEAR, PHD, NCSP,
University of Delaware, Newark
Traditionally, with respect to school discipline, American educators ha ve had two distinct aims: (a) to help create and maintain a safe, orderly, and positive learning environment, w hich often requires the use of discipline to correct misbehavior; and (b) to teach or develop self-disci pline. Both aims are equally important and should always be included in the development and evaluation of school discipline practices.
Whereas the first is generally viewed as an immediate aim (to stop misbehav ior and bring about compliance), the second is viewed as long term (to develop autonomy and res ponsible citizenship). Both aims are reciprocally related in that each promotes the other. Both also se rve a preventive function. That is, by correcting misbehavior and developing self-discipline, schools help prevent the future occurrence of behavior problems.
CHALLENGES TO EFFECTIVE SCHOOL DISCIPLINE
Too often, schools fail to understand that maintaining safety, including the correction of misbehavior, is a prerequisite for developing self-discipline, but it is not sufficient. S chools and other institutions that are effective in establishing and maintaining order and safety are not necess arily effective in developing self- discipline or in preventing future behavior problems. This is most eviden t when adult supervision, systematic rewards, clear rules and expectations, and consequences for m isbehavior are the primary techniques used to manage behavior. When those external techniques are la ter removed, individuals are expected to function independently after having learned little other tha n ‘‘don’t get caught.’’ Prisons provide an excellent example of reliance on external control, as do many sc hools that adopt a similar zero- tolerance mindset.
Zero Tolerance: Punishment Focus
The zero-tolerance approach to noncompliance and misbehavior exclusive ly focuses school discipline on punishment—suspension, expulsion, alternative education, ‘‘sentenci ng manuals’’ (i.e., extensive codes of conduct for minor to major behavioral infractions), and the constant poli cing of student behavior. Although certainly more positive, programs that simply replace such punitive tech niques with the systematic school- wide use of tangible rewards for good behavior, regardless of grade level o r individual needs and without emphasizing other strategies that promote self-discipline, fail to teac h students the skills that will promote appropriate and independently guided behavior.
Comprehensive School-Wide Plan
Certainly, fair and reasonable policies governing serious and chronic be havior problems, as well as the strategic use of rewards, should be part of a school-wide discipline progr am. However, effective schools make this only one part of a much more comprehensive plan. A comprehensive s chool-wide plan consists of a full range of evidence-based strategies and techniques to achieve fou r important goals: (a) developing self-discipline, (b) preventing misbehavior, (c) correcting misbehavi or, and (d) remediating and responding to serious and chronic behavior problems. Strategies for each of these components of comprehensive school-wide discipline follow.
DEVELOPING SELF-DISCIPLINE
Self-discipline is seen in socially and morally responsible behavior tha t is motivated primarily by intrinsic factors, not solely by the anticipation of external rewards or fear of puni shment. Research shows that self- discipline promotes positive relations with others and a positive school climate, fosters academic achievement, and promotes self-worth and emotional well-being. Strateg ies for developing self-discipline
Helping Children at Home and School III
|
S4H18–1 are commonly part of evidence-based programs for character education and for social and emotional learning. Such programs include the following strategies:
N
Implement curriculum activities that teach social, emo- tional, and behavioral competencies
. Multiple evidence- based packaged programs exist for teaching social, emotional, and behavioral competencies (see
Recommended Resources below for a list of websites that review such programs). In addition to or as an alternative to adopting a packaged program, schools should consider infusing lessons and activities for developing self-discipline throughout the existing curriculum, such as in social studies, literacy, and health education.
N
Provide multiple models of social and moral problem- solving and responsible behavior
. Multiple models of targeted behaviors, social cognitions, and emotions should be included in the school’s curriculum (e.g., literature, videos) and, more important, in the real life of the classroom and school.
N
Provide multiple opportunities for students to apply skills of social and moral problem-solving and responsible behavior . Such opportunities would include class meetings in which classroom and school-wide pro- blems are addressed; meaningful student government activities (e.g., helping others in the community); programs and activities for conflict resolution, peer mediation, service learning, and cooperative learning; and sports and extracurricular activities.
N
Challenge self-centered thinking
. This recommenda- tion applies to each of the learning contexts above but especially to the context of disciplinary encoun- ters. Nearly all children tend to excuse or justify moral transgressions with various rationalizations
(e.g., ‘‘He started it,’’ ‘‘I didn’t mean to hurt him,’’
‘‘Others did it, too’’). Such excuses and self-centered thinking should be tactfully confronted, and models of desired thinking, feeling, and acting should be highlighted. PREVENTING DISCIPLINE PROBLEMS
In general, research supports the effectiveness of an authoritative approach to discipline (as opposed to an authoritarian or permissive approach) in the prevention of behavior problems. Authoritative teachers set high standards and hold high expectations; enforce rules and standards in a firm, fair, and consistent manner; and promote autonomy by encouraging students’ active participation in decisions regarding their behavior.
Although authoritative teachers use punitive and reactive strategies when needed, they focus more on the use of positive, proactive techniques for increasing the likelihood that students will exhibit appropriate behavior willingly rather than grudgingly.
The quality of the teacher–student relationship is of primary concern. Warmth, acceptance, and support are delivered noncontingently and thus are not conditional upon a student’s behavior. Effective teachers strive to develop a positive relationship with every student in their classrooms, and seek to promote positive relationships and a sense of community among the students themselves. In sum, authoritative teachers create a classroom climate, and school-wide climate, in which students follow norms for appropriate behavior out of respect for the teacher and one another.
Additional prevention strategies commonly used by authoritative teachers include the following:
N
Develop social problem-solving and decision-making skills among students.
N
Establish and maintain close communication with each student’s parents or caregivers, and work hard to garner the parent’s support.
N
Provide academic instruction and activities that motivate learning.
N
Create a physical environment that is conducive to teaching and learning.
N
Establish predictable procedures and routines.
N
Frequently monitor student behavior and respond immediately to signs of misbehavior.
N
Use praise and rewards strategically to maximize effectiveness in improving behavior while minimizing the risk of diminishing intrinsic motivation. One key to doing this is by using praise and rewards in an informational rather than controlling manner (see
Bear, 2005 for specific techniques).
CORRECTING MISBEHAVIOR
Research supports an authoritative style of discipline not only in the prevention of behavior problems but also in their correction.
Authoritative Approaches to Correcting Misbehavior
Authoritative educators guide rather than control students. They view disciplinary encounters not merely as situations that may require punishment as a means of correction, but as opportunities to teach appropriate behavior and help develop self-discipline and prevent future behavior problems. Similar to their approach to prevention, authoritative educators combine respon- siveness (e.g., demonstrating support and caring; striving to prevent lasting harm to the teacher–student relationship) with demandingness (e.g., remaining firm, communicating clear expectations of appropriative behavior, imposing fair consequences). When correct-
S4H18–2
|
Discipline
ing misbehavior, effective educators tend to use one of two general types of behavioral techniques: punitive and replacement.
Punitive techniques.
These various forms of punish- ment range from unpleasant verbal reprimands, ‘‘the evil eye,’’ proximity control (i.e., standing near the student), and taking away privileges (e.g., recess) to much harsher forms such as suspension, expulsion, removal to an alternative education program, and corporal punishment
(i.e., spanking, which is allowed in approximately half of the states, although most professional organizations oppose it).
Replacement techniques.
These strategies are intended to achieve the same goals as punitive methods, but focus on teaching or strengthening desired behaviors that might replace the undesired behavior.
Common replacement techniques include direct instruc- tion, positive reinforcement, modeling, social problem- solving, conflict resolution, and anger management training. Punishment: Limitations and Alternatives
Educators who are most effective in correcting misbe- havior use both punitive and replacement techniques.
Limitations of punishment.
Effective educators clearly recognize the limitations of punishment: (a) It teaches students what not to do and fails to teach desired or replacement behavior; (b) its effects often are short term; (c) it teaches students to aggress toward or punish others; (d) it fails to address the multiple factors that typically contribute to a student’s behavior; (e) it is likely to produce undesirable side effects (e.g., anger, retaliation, dislike toward the teacher or school, social withdrawal); (f) it creates a negative classroom and school climate; and (g) it can be reinforcing (i.e., negative reinforcement), such as in time-out and suspension, by allowing students to avoid or escape from situations they find aversive (e.g., academic work, peer rejection, a harsh and uncaring teacher).
Alternatives to punishment.
Due to these limita- tions, when correcting misbehavior, effective educators work hard to avoid using punishment. Instead, they focus on strategies for developing self-discipline and for preventing misbehavior. When correcting misbehavior, they are much more likely to use mild forms of punishment, such as physical proximity, taking away privileges, verbal reprimands, and ‘‘the evil eye’’ than harsh forms of punishment such as suspension. When punishment is used, it is used fairly, judiciously, in the context of a caring and supportive relationship, and typically in combination with replacement techniques that teach or strengthen desired behaviors. The latter would include techniques that emphasize social and emotional competencies and positive teacher–student relations, such as joint social problem-solving and induction, where the focus is on the impact of one’s behavior on others.
REMEDIATING AND RESPONDING TO CHRONIC AND
SERIOUS BEHAVIOR PROBLEMS
For the majority of students in most schools (i.e., the universal tier), the above strategies and techniques are generally sufficient for developing self-discipline and for preventing and correcting behavior problems. Students with chronic or serious behavior problems, and especially those shown to be resistant to interventions, require more comprehensive and intensive services, resources, and supports.
Similar but More Intensive Strategies
The strategies and techniques used for chronic and serious behavior problems differ more in intensity than design, relative to the strategies described above for more everyday discipline issues. That is, many of the same techniques are used, but delivered in a more frequent and systematic fashion (e.g., requiring a class- room aide or smaller class size).
More Targeted and Intensive Strategies
Other strategies, however, are more specific to this group of intervention-resistant students, and more congruent with an intensive (Tier 3) level of supports and interventions. Such services and supports should be:
N
Comprehensive, targeting multiple risk and protective factors N
Broad-based, adopting a system in which a network of mental health specialists, educators, and others in the community work together with students and their families N
Evidence-based
N
Intensive, sustained over time, and implemented with fidelity N
Individualized
N
Cognizant of the importance of early intervention, including interventions provided at an early age as well as those provided when indicators of behavior problems first appear
These interventions, services, and supports address not only the needs of students with chronic behavior problems, but also those who may have no history of behavior problems but nevertheless exhibit a serious behavior problem requiring immediate intervention, supports, and
Helping Children at Home and School III
|
S4H18–3

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    • Corrects the situation, which allows the students to come up better actions, which will result in acceptable behavior. • According to Morrish’s real discipline children can only learn SELF DISCIPLINE through experience.…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When it comes to special education, discipline is a major concern in this area because many students are incessantly being expelled for their behavior issues that are caused by their disabilities. With the previous law students were excluded from school and received long suspension time because of their behavioral problems but when the new law was passed in 2004 students that are disable, is entitle to a free appropriate education under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and can no longer be expel from school if their behavior is due to their disability. With the new law, students can no longer be suspended for more than 10 days during a school term for behavioral issues and 45 days for weapon and illegal drugs. A Functional Behavioral Assessment (FBA) should be included within the special need students Individualized Education Plan (IEP) at the beginning of each school year so that the general education teachers is aware of the students behavioral problems and is able to handle them before the student get out of hand and the other students learning is disruptive. If students know what is expected of them in the beginning, I believe that they will try to keep their behavior under control especially when they are in a more controlled and structure classroom.…

    • 1201 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With the most read news story this week being the video of a white sheriff deputy throwing a black high school girl to the floor earlier this week it is not wonder that the latest national discussion about race has to do with discipline and punishment. Several videos of the occurrence have spread like wildfire, a video that supposedly shows Deputy Ben Fields forcibly dragging a female African American student from her desk and slamming her into the floor after she supposedly ignored the teacher when he told her to leave and was being disruptive.…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Every child and young person has a right to an education. Along with those rights students, have the responsibilities to follow rules. If rules get broken schools can impose punishments to try to correct the behaviors from happening again. Schools must let the students be able to voice their opinions on whether the punishment is fair. The purpose of this paper is to examine three (3) current rulings about different types of discipline in public schools. Next summarize the cases and the court’s decision for each case. Finally give an opinion whether for or against the court’s decision and justify the position.…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Preventive Discipline

    • 287 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Preventive Discipline is important in the classroom because it is an effective way to prevent from having to give a consequence to a student or students. Most teacher do not want to give some form of consequence to their student or students, but it may be necessary. Support Discipline is useful because it helps the student refocus on what they are supposed to be doing. Some students just need a little reminder to stay on task, and Support Discipline techniques help keep the student on task. The Differential Reinforcement technique can be very useful because the teacher is drawing positive attention to a student that is doing something good instead of drawing attention to one student that is doing something…

    • 287 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Children misbehave everyday at home, school, day care, church, and other places for a reason. "If the behavior is accidental or if the child did not know it was unacceptable, then it is not really misbehavior. Bad behavior involves deliberate disobedience to a reasonable limit" (Smith 1). The truth is that every type of conduct has an intention. One of the most difficult – but most imperative – decisions a parent can make when trying to assist a child act in an improved way is to find out the purpose of the misconduct. Misbehavior cannot be effectively treated until the parent knows the reasons for it. The parent comprehends the child and what triggers him or her to have behavior tribulations better than anyone else ("Discipline Help: You Can Handle Them All" 1). Three main causes or "mistaken goals" of naughtiness are attention, power, and self-confidence. Rudolf Dreikurs, a trained physician and psychiatrist, believes "the true reason for children to misbehave is because they just ‘want to belong '" ("Causes of Misbehavior" 1).…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Discipline Children

    • 641 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Some parents often assume that disciplining a child means having control over him or her. They also believe it can only be accomplished through punishment which is often ineffective because there is little to no teaching involved. However, discipline is important training and crucial to the development of children. This is why parents should discipline their children; starting in the toddlers, then elementary aged children, and teens.…

    • 641 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    School Ethos and Policies

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The phrase above is the school’s ethos and was inspired following collaboration with the children, staff and governors of the school; with all believing and accepting they have an equal part to play in ensuring all children have a right to quality first teaching. It is felt that the ethos reflects the vision of the school community and yet it is easy to be remembered and understood by all. It is used regularly to praise the children of their positive actions and if necessary remind them of what is expected of them. The schools aim is ‘To develop a shared love of learning between our children, staff and parents and the wider community.…

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Teaching is not just earning a buck, it's a snap. At the beginning of a new school year with high school sophomores, Mr. Finn is working at his desk wondering what the first period is going to be like. While waiting for the bell to ring, most students stand in clusters talking quietly but a few the knock- upstairs are rather loud and boisterous around the room causing a commotion with every group they pass. Not wanting to be overly negative on the first day, Mr. Finn says nothing. By the time the bell rings most of the class has become loud and boisterous.…

    • 1004 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Approach to discipline

    • 408 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I’ve been on active duty for 22 years now and have had to obey and follow rules and regulations ever since knowing the consequence if I failed to do that. Every day we are changing these rules or better said, we are adjusting the way our society is changing too. In the military we carry what is called a Division Officer record for every Sailor E6 and below and it contains various forms from evaluations to counseling chits. When a young man/woman gets into trouble this record is reviewed to see about the past of a Sailor and how much trouble he/she has gotten into. When the charge is serious, I am all about them receiving the maximum punishment available. Like I mentioned this depends on the seriousness of the offense he/she has broken. We all have to obey and follow the same rules and regulations, so why let them get off easy, that’s not me.…

    • 408 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Proactive Lesson

    • 2513 Words
    • 11 Pages

    THE PURPOSE OF EDUCATION- How a teacher approaches classroom management—the priorities and techniques he or she uses—depends on his or her goals. If the purpose of classroom management is to elicit compliance, the methods chosen will reflect this choice. For example, the military requires behavior rooted in obedience. The methods used to foster compliant behavior include intimidation, drills, routine, and loyalty oaths. These methods are appropriate because the military needs to train soldiers and sailors who will follow commands unquestioningly. The purpose of education is to teach students to be responsible citizens (Langdon, 1996). However, the word responsible is an abstract term that has different meanings for different people. To some, responsible behavior means obedience to authority. To others, responsible behavior means exercising self-control, without the need for constant supervision. The definition of responsibility that guides the organization of this text is as follows: Responsible behavior is self directed and is characterized by the ability to make socially appropriate choices, care for others, and be accountable for personal action. Figure 1.1 illustrates the difference between compliance and responsibility. Marzano said the following about responsibility in the classroom: Ample evidence indicates that teaching responsibility is a high priority in U.S. education. Speaking of self-discipline, Bear (1998) explains that “the American public’s belief that schools should play a role in teaching self-discipline has never been greater than it is today” (p. 15). He cites the 1996 Gallup study (Elam, Rose, & Gallup, 1996) indicating that 98 percent of the public believes that the primary purpose of public schools should be to prepare students to be responsible citizens. (2003, p. 77) If educators want students to be responsible rather than compliant, they must think carefully about how they can achieve…

    • 2513 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    School Discipline

    • 1316 Words
    • 11 Pages

    According to Norman L. Webb, Wisconsin Center for Educational Research ("Depth-of-Knowledge Levels for Four Content Areas," March 28,…

    • 1316 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Disipline in Schools

    • 288 Words
    • 2 Pages

    behaviors are enacted, and, indeed, with whom they are directed towards. Discipline in schools is now passing through an extended eclipse. The problem…

    • 288 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    R.S Peters

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In ethics and education, R.S Peters speaks of education as ‘initiation into activities or modes of thought and conduct that are worthwhile’. According to Peter, the notion of discipline is tied to the learning situation and refers to the very general activity of submission to rules or system of order, whether externally brought about or self-imposed. The formal school education will be difficult to maintain without the existence of certain rules.…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    School Discipline

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Throughout the history of education the most common means of maintaining discipline in schools was corporal punishment. While a child was in school, a teacher was expected to act as a substitute parent, with many forms of parental discipline or rewards open to them. This often meant that students were commonly chastised with the birch, cane, paddle or strap if they did something wrong.…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays