Differences Between A Rose For Emily Book And Movie
In 1930, William Faulkner’s short narrative ‘A Rose for Emily’ was printed. William Faulkner’s narrative may be one of the greatest anthologized works of literature. In 1981, Lyndon Chubbuck directed a movie based on the short story. This film has, however, received criticism from critics suggesting that the feature movie failed to bring about the same emotions as reading the short story. The film failed to bring out the Southern Gothic culture and traditions, the change in the chronological order of the events, and failed to explain certain issues with details, as in the original work. The two texts that is Faulkner’s short story and Chubbuck’s film adaptation from the short story, will be looked at more closely. The differences and few similarities
…show more content…
The original story, A Rose for Emily, is a thrilling story of Emily. Emily symbolized how the town lived. Faulkner described Emily as a fallen monument. She was a young girl brought up by her father under strict southern gothic traditions. The fictional story unfolded in a fictional city named Jefferson located in Mississippi. The muddled narrative opened with Emily’s funeral and proceeded with explaining Emily’s life. During the 1930s, the industrial revolution was at its peak. People were steadily accepting industrialization as their new source of income. They lost interest with agriculture and slavery, which were their traditional economic activities. However, the Griersons thought of themselves as belonging to a higher class than the rest of the society members. The rest of the society members did not undergo the transition. In fact, they decided to uphold their …show more content…
Emily later developed a relationship with Homer Barron and she had decided to settle down with him. However, Barron had claimed to be a bachelor and expressed no interest in marrying her. Barron wanted to leave but unfortunately, Emily could not let another man get out of her life. The town didn’t take too well with him because he was a Yankee and a construction worker. They did show happiness with the fact she had found someone. They didn’t feel sorry for
The original story, A Rose for Emily, is a thrilling story of Emily. Emily symbolized how the town lived. Faulkner described Emily as a fallen monument. She was a young girl brought up by her father under strict southern gothic traditions. The fictional story unfolded in a fictional city named Jefferson located in Mississippi. The muddled narrative opened with Emily’s funeral and proceeded with explaining Emily’s life. During the 1930s, the industrial revolution was at its peak. People were steadily accepting industrialization as their new source of income. They lost interest with agriculture and slavery, which were their traditional economic activities. However, the Griersons thought of themselves as belonging to a higher class than the rest of the society members. The rest of the society members did not undergo the transition. In fact, they decided to uphold their …show more content…
Emily later developed a relationship with Homer Barron and she had decided to settle down with him. However, Barron had claimed to be a bachelor and expressed no interest in marrying her. Barron wanted to leave but unfortunately, Emily could not let another man get out of her life. The town didn’t take too well with him because he was a Yankee and a construction worker. They did show happiness with the fact she had found someone. They didn’t feel sorry for