Preview

Diana Goss Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
950 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Diana Goss Analysis
Focus Question:

Should Lyddie sign or not sign the petition Diana Goss is circulating?

In Katherine Paterson’s novel, her main character, Lyddie, is a factory girl in Lowell, Massachusetts. Lyddie is working to pay off the debts on her family cabin and be able to go home to her family. While working at the corporation, Lyddie made friends: Prudence, Amelia, and Betsy, who all later on leave the corporation. Only with one friend left, Diana-a known radical for the working condition petition-Lyddie debates whether she will sign or not. Although some may say she should not sign the petition because she could get blacklisted and can’t pay off the debts. Lyddie should sign the petition so the girls do not have to work long hours and getting injured …show more content…
The girls work extra hard to keep up with the speeded machines. Betsy protests for shorter hours because they are exhausted. “Now I’ve twice that many at a speed that would make the devil curse. I’m worn out, Amelia. We’re all worn out.” (91) This shows that the girls can’t manage working at this fast speed anymore and getting all tired. By signing the petition, they can manage the hours better and not get worn out as much. ^With the machines speeded, the workers are more tired than usual. When Lyddie gets back from work, she seems to be so worn out, she barely does anything. “She was too tired now at night to copy out a page of Oliver to paste to her loom. It hardly mattered. When would she have time to study it?” (98) This shows that working so many looms at a time, she never has time to focus on the things around her. The looms can be very dangerous if you mess something up, so you have to be extra careful and focused so anything doesn’t happen. ^The girls should always be at work, and if they weren’t, it would not be good to their overseers. A lot goes on in the factory, and if you miss work, lots of cloth is not being produced. “The overseers were offered premiums-prizes to the men whose girls produced the most goods in a pay period-which was why the machines were speeded and why the girls hardly dared to take time off even when they were …show more content…
The working conditions at the factory are very dangerous and could cause serious injuries. One mistake in the factory, and you could get badly hurt. “There were no deaths at the Concord Corporation, but one of the little Irish girls in the spinning room had caught her hair in the machinery and was badly hurt.” (101) This shows that when working, you have to be extremely careful around the machinery. The girl had made a simple mistake by not thinking how close her hair was to the machine. Mistakes get you injured in the factory. ^The machines at the corporation are very complicated and have a technique that you have to master. Even the best girls at the factory get hurt, also, by simple mistakes. Working conditions are terrible at the factory. Lyddie and the other workers are put at risk, they could get hurt at any time. They could easily misplace something in the machine and get blasted. “Before she could think she was on the floor, blood pouring through the hair near her right temple...the shuttle, the blasted shuttle.” (102) This means that Lyddie has gotten terribly hurt and has to take time off work until she is better. Because of the bad working conditions, this has caused Lyddie to get injured. ^When girls first start off working with the machines, they are supervised because they could mess up easily. New girls don’t exactly know
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Argumentative Essay: Lyddie Should Not Sign The Letter
    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Argumentative Essay: Lyddie Should Not Sign The Letter

    The other good reason for Lyddie should not sign the petition is because she will have no where to stay after she signs. While Lyddie can sign the petition , if she does she will have to leave the house and has nowhere to live. "You'd be blacklisted no other corporation would hire you" This shows that Lyddie would not have money to stay at a tavern or boarding house for long and would not be able to get a job. Lyddie should not sign because she will be payed much less, she could be blacklisted, and she has no place to go.…

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Should Lyddie Sign The Petition That Diana Goss Circulates?
    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Should Lyddie Sign The Petition That Diana Goss Circulates?

    In order not to get blacklisted Lyddie should not sign the petition & work hard because the more girls that leave the ore machines Lyddie gets do to “the pay reflecting her proficiency”(pg86). So the more girls that leave the factory the more machines Lyddie would get & the more money she will receive. In the story it says “you’d be blacklisted.No other corp. would hire you”(pg92). Signing the petition will get Lyddie blacklisted. So it’s better if she didn’t sign it, keeping her in her job. Also in the story it states “should you sign the petition, Betsy they’ll dismiss you. I know they will”(pg91). This is the final reason why Lyddie shouldn’t sign the petition. Lyddie cares a lot about the girls she works with & she wouldn't want one of them leaving the job & getting blacklisted. Getting blacklisted is not a good thing if Lyddie gets blacklisted she’ll have no job & then who would take care of her…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Analysis: Lyddie By Katherine Patterson
    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Analysis: Lyddie By Katherine Patterson

    In the novel Lyddie by Katherine Patterson, Lyddie is a young girl during the Industrial revolution who works as a factory girl in Lowell Massachusetts working conditions aren’t great in factories, so a petition to better these conditions is being passed around. Should Lyddie sign the petition? Lyddie should sign the petition because nothing will improve if these factory girls do not stand up for themselves.…

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    triangle fire
    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages

    triangle fire

    The women trade union league workers wanted shorter hours, better pay, safer shops, and unions. They decided to no longer keep quiet, so they went on strike. These women were the leaders of the largest women strike in American history. More than 50 factories gave in to their workers demand but the triangle factory owner’s Max Blanck and Isaac Harris refused to surrender. The owners tried so hard to stop these women from protesting that they even paid police and prostitutes to beat these women. Blanck and Harris were selfish people who only wanted to make money to defeat competition. They made sure these women were working hard in fear that those small companies will take over. Their terrible treatment brought the women an unexpected supporter, Anne Morgan. Later on she withdrew her support due to the fact that the workers wanted unions, which she did not support.…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Industrial Revolution Dbq Analysis
    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Industrial Revolution Dbq Analysis

    There were unhealthy conditions and air pollution from all the factories. Also, there were unfair and unsafe conditions in factories, which resulted in people having medical problems. For example, in document 1, someone is interviewing a worker from a factory. The worker exclaims that he began working at the age of 10; he worked from five in the morning to nine at night and had one period of 40 minutes in the 16 hours at noon for a meal. Also, he wasn’t educated and could only read, but not write. More examples of bad factory conditions are in document 2, where another factory worker was interviewed about their experience in the factories. The man has damaged lungs, improper leg muscles, and he would die in a year. His doctor says it was caused by dust in the factories, overworking, and an insufficient diet. His brother died from a bad cut from a machine and of infection. The worker also stated that he knows that nearly a dozen children died during the two and a half years that he worked there. These examples show that there were many negative effects of the Industrial…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Working Conditions Of Workers In Factories Dbq
    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Working Conditions Of Workers In Factories Dbq

    In factories the working conditions of workers were not good. Workers would have cut off limbs ad even worst they could be killed if they were not careful when working. Also the workers would have long hours with little to no breaks and if they were to lack on their job they would be punished. As stated in the excerpt, Okaya Japan (1900), workers would have thirteen to fourteen hour days with fifteen minute breaks for breakfast and lunch and then only two more ten minute breaks, (Doc 5). If a worker has an average working day of thirteen to fourteen days with little breaks it makes their life and working conditions stressful and harsh. It would be hard for the workers to do this as they would become tired and then would lack on work. As a result of lacking they would be punished. The female workers in England were treated almost the same way in the hours they worked and other conditions in the workplace. As reported by the primary source Hannah Goode’s to the Factory Inquiry Commission, (England, 1833) it tells how workers would work from five in the morning till seven at night with breaks only to eat their dinner meal, (Doc 10). The English female workers from the document shows how they would work about thirteen to fourteen hour days and with only one break the young female will most likely not be able to function properly and as a…

    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Second Great Awakening Dbq Analysis
    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Second Great Awakening Dbq Analysis

    In a letter from a Lowell mill girl in 1844, she describes her work schedule, which occasionally ranged to 13 hours in the factory per day. Although provided breaks, she states the girls’ annoyed beliefs saying that “laboring girls can say, who think nothing is more tedious than a factory life.” (Document B) An opportunity for women in the workplace was still extremely rare, but becoming more known. Still under the impression of becoming a ideal bride, women worked before marriage and then became housewives/mothers. In the family, women were also becoming in charge of a new trend, a child centered environment. This differed from in the past where childhood was short and tough. During the Age of Reform, middle class women played a big part in the reform crusades, finding it as a way to get out of the house and enter public affairs. Not only was the reform about evangelists and the market revolution, but criminal codes and laws were lightened, mocking the European practices. A problem that was brought to Dorothea Dix (the superintendent of women nurses, and an opinionated reformer) that those diagnosed of mental illnesses was being treated with superior cruelty. Carrying this awareness with her and trying to put a stop to it, she…

    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Florence Kelley Child Labor Speech Analysis
    • 1373 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Florence Kelley Child Labor Speech Analysis

    Working women and children fought for equal rights throughout most of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Ironically, women and children were the ones subject to heinous, unimaginable working conditions from an early age. Reformers, such as Florence Kelley, campaigned for equal conditions for all people in the workplace. While her crusade obtained the support of many, the opposition to equal conditions was immense and difficult to overcome. Speeches became a tool used to really support for the common cause, especially among women. Kelley’s speech at the national American Woman Suffrage Association’s convention appeals to the sentiments of the listeners and utilizes emotional examples in order to elicit a positive, as well as revolutionary , response from the listeners.…

    • 1373 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Florence Kelley Speech Rhetorical Analysis
    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Florence Kelley Speech Rhetorical Analysis

    In America, there used to be unfair laws and regulations regarding labor. Children are put to work in harsh conditions, conditions often deemed difficult even for adults, and are forced to work ridiculous hours. Florence Kelley gave a speech at the National American Woman Suffrage Association in Philadelphia on July 22, 1905. In her speech, Kelley uses repetition, pathos, imagery, logos, and carefully placed diction to express how child labor is morally wrong and inhumane.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Lyddie Essay
    • 1041 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Lyddie Essay

    How would you feel if you were working in a place with loud, clattering, uncovered machines with air that you can hardly breathe in? Imagine working in a place with these working conditions. In the novel “Lyddie” by Katherine Patterson, Lyddie Worthen, a young girl who works hard to support her family and the family’s debts. She was the mother figure of her family. She was then sent to work at a tavern to pay the debts. However, Lyddie is fired and she decides to work at the the textile mills in Lowell, Massachusetts. At the mills, her friends tell her about a petition that protests the horrible working conditions there Lyddie should not sign the petition because she is accustomed to the noise, speed and strength/ energy required/ needed to do the work. She is happy with the amount of pay she gets, and later on, she is responsible for taking care of Rachel. On the other hand, others believe that Lyddie is overworking herself, but actually, she is willing to take the risks and work that hard.…

    • 1041 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    How Did African American Women Start In The 1800s
    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages

    How Did African American Women Start In The 1800s

    As the industrial growth started in the 1800s many factory owners began to hire women. Majority of the women who worked in the factories were poor, young, unmarried or widows, women of the middle-class were privileged to stay at home to provide their domestic duties. Women were paid lower then men due to women were subordinate to them., it did not matter what kind of quality the women produced. Any income women received legally belonged to their husbands and with that status employers were able to keep women’s wages low. Eventually women created labor associations because they wanted to sort issues out such as the terrible working conditions, low pay, and longer hours. The Female Labor Reform met once a week to discuss conditions that needed to be improved. Even though they were doubted by many that they would not make any difference and would not be listened to, they never gave up.…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    The Family Medical Leave Act During The Early 1900s
    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The Family Medical Leave Act During The Early 1900s

    But, there were no laws enacted which specifically target protection of women in the workforce. In fact, labor was cheap and management exploitive. Laborers were being forced to work long hours without additional compensation. This time saw significant strides in women's rights. Women were striving for suffrage and equal recognition under the law. It was accomplished through petitions, going through the courts, rallies, public debates, and picketing. Although effective, working conditions for women were not equivalent to those of men. It was not until the creation of labor unions and the eventual inclusion of women into these unions that there is advancement in the working conditions for…

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Female Mill Workers in England and Japan
    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Female Mill Workers in England and Japan

    The Industrial Revolution was the greatest transformation period in human history. When people think about the Industrial revolution, they think about big steel, machines, and railroads. What’s missing are the exhausted, overworked laborers that operated the machinery that made things run. A prime example is the female textile mill workers from England and Japan. In the textile industry, women and young girls were the main employees. The main reason for this is that nimble fingers were needed to tend the spinning and weaving machines. Originally spinning and weaving were done at home or small spin shops but the Industrial revolution changed that by bringing house spinning and weaving to factories. With the mass production of textiles, women were given a chance to actually work for wage. This seemed like a grand opportunity but this work experience was difficult for these women. The experiences of the Japanese and English female workers were in fact similar. Both of which had to deal with long working hours with little pay, sexual and physical abuse from male supervisors, and hardship with their families over their occupation.…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Child Labor In The Progressive Era
    • 295 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Child Labor In The Progressive Era

    The next group that was severely impacted by the industrialization was the children. Prior to the Revolution, children would work in their family home. Once the revolution begun, child labor become common; children worked long hours with few breaks. Children would be punished if they fell asleep, but the necessity of their wages was obvious (“Childhood” 1). Machines were thought to be the perfect size for children with small hands and fingers. Unfortunately, hands and feet would get caught, and children were easily injured. The environment in the factory was unhealthy; sickness from fumes was a norm. Grace Abbot, a Progressive Era reformer, attempted to pass the first child labor law in 1917 (“Children” 1). Congress struck down this legislation,…

    • 295 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    History Of The Women's Suffrage Movement
    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages

    History Of The Women's Suffrage Movement

    Before the Women’s Suffrage movement began, women faced hardships that would later motivate them to take a stand for women’s rights. Women were, at that time, being abused and mistreated by men and society, in order to gain what was necessary to survive during this time in American history. The industrial revolution had just swept the nation by surprise. The industrial revolution changed the process of production from hand tools and man labor, to power driven machinery. (Dublin). This change from hand labor to power machinery affected the women greatly. The women continued to do the same jobs as before the industrial era, but now all work was done on machines to increase both output and production rates on products. This new way of manufacturing…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More

Related Topics