Preview

Describe and Discuss a Specific Science and Technology Public Controversy in Light of One of the Following Explanatory Frameworks- Deficits in Public Understanding of Science, the Rise of Consumer Capitalism, or the Rise in Health Social Movements

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2193 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Describe and Discuss a Specific Science and Technology Public Controversy in Light of One of the Following Explanatory Frameworks- Deficits in Public Understanding of Science, the Rise of Consumer Capitalism, or the Rise in Health Social Movements
Genetic screening uses a variety of laboratory procedures to find out if a person has a genetic condition or disorder or is likely to develop a disease based on his or her genetic make-up. Many people choose to have these tests if there family history involves diseases such as breast cancer of Huntington’s disease. However one of the latest controversies within society is that of prenatal genetic testing. Some believe that prenatal genetic testing has great potential for our society. They believe that it has the capability of improving and lengthening human life. If it is used properly, genetic testing can eliminate unforeseen suffering and distress. On the other hand some fear that will lead to the abortion of pregnancies of fetuses with ASD, Down-Syndrome etc., with the end result being the elimination of children with special needs. This leads to the suggestion that people with mental or physical disabilities serve no use in our society which is not true. As such people opposed to genetic pre-natal screening are against the development of such tests and are campaigning to oppose their use (Parker, 2006).
An understanding of genetic irregularities is valuable in its own right, leading to a greater understanding, better and earlier diagnosis and interventions, and amelioration of the negative consequences of those genetic irregularities. The main argument used by those opposing prenatal diagnosis is that if a deficiency was discovered in a fetuse, that it could lead to mass abortions. This is a defeatist’s attitude towards humanity. Rather than attempting to deny parents of a test that is going to be introduced into society eventually, or deny them their legal right to choose because we might not like the way they exercise it, we should concentrate on promoting hope and likelihood of a better outcome, showing them that children born with autism, down-syndrome or other disabilities can live a happy and successful life (Parker, 2006). Throughout the course of this



References: • Parker, I. (2006). “Shades of Grey: Thoughts on Prenatal Genetic Testing”. Available at www.a-shade-of-grey.blogspot.com/2006/07/thoughts-on-prenatal-genetic-testing.html. Accessed on the 11-12-2011. • Murray, T. (1996). “The worth of a child”. University of California Press: California. • Medscape.com, (2011). “Prenatal Diagnosis for Congenital Malformations and Genetic Disorders”. Available at http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/1200683-overview. Accessed on the 12-12-2011. • Gregoire, S. (2009). “To Test or Not to Test” Available at http://sheilawraygregoire.com/totestornottotestprenataltestingp14.php. Accessed on the 12-12-2011. • Arc.org, (1997). “Genetic Discrimination”. Available at www.the.arc.org/depts/gbr03.html. Accessed on the 12-12-2011. • Botkin, J, (1995). “Federal Privacy and Confidentiality”. Hastings Centre Report: Hastings. • Morejon, D. (1996) “Commentary” Hastings Centre Report: Hastings. • Practical Ethics, (2011). “Preimplantation Genetic Screening: One Step Closer to the Perfect Baby”. Available athttp://blog.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk/2008/10/preimplantation-genetic-screening-one-step-closer-to-the-perfect-baby/. Accessed on the 13-12-2011. • Ornl.gov, (2007). “Tech Resources”. Available at www.ornl.gov/techresources/human_genome/public/hgn/v8n3/07/press.html. Accessed on the 14-12-2011.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Preimplantation diagnosis

    • 401 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the article “Where are we going with preimplantation genetic diagnosis?”, Timothy Krahn outlines the future implications of a ruling made by the United Kingdom’s Human Fertilization and Embryology Authority (HFEA), and the effect it may have on Canadian’s normative culture. Krahn begins by introducing the Assisted Human reproduction act, which received royal assent on 29th March 2009. Structured and influenced largely on the regulations of the HFEA, decisions made in the UK are naturally transferred and integrated into Canada’s policy.…

    • 401 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Though there are tests and testing facilities that do the genetic tests, prenatal genetic testing is not accessible to all at-risk or concerned families expecting a baby. Government funding should be put towards prenatal genetic testing to increase accessibility to testing facilities, discover more testing forms, and give more autonomy to physicians. With these improvements, low income-families and anyone with a family history of genetic diseases can find out and prepare for any irregularities before the baby is…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Survivor Siblings

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis or PGD tests a woman’s embryos outside of her body for genetic sequence that are linked to a variety of conditions. PGD was developed for couples at risk for passing on a serious genetic mutation. Since 1999 it has been most widely used to prevent the birth of children with conditions such as Down syndrome, Tay-Sachs disease, cystic fibrosis, sickle cell, Huntington’s chorea, and Cooley’s anemia. However, PGD is increasingly being used for other reasons. These include social sex selection, creating “savior siblings” who can provide bone marrow and other transplant tissues to sick older siblings, and selecting against embryos with genes correlated with late-onset and non-fatal conditions. Some clinics have even offered the technique for purely cosmetic traits including eye color, hair color, and skin complexion (geneticsandsociety.org). It also contributes to concerns over the creation of what are critically called designer babies, though the…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    American Eugenics Movement

    • 1915 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Allen, Garland E. "Flaws in Eugenics Research." Image Archive on the American Eugenics Movement. Dolan DNA Learning Center Cold Harbor Spring Laboratory. 5 May 2006…

    • 1915 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although not unanimously supported, the use of pre-embryonic diagnosis to screen for disease is generally accepted, this however leads to debate about how much freedom people should be allowed to make decisions about their future children. The issues arise as it is difficult to take an objective view on the topic, with many factors affecting peoples’ views. As there is in fact already a process of natural selection, perhaps it would be best to allow this to progress at its natural rate. On the other hand, if it is possible to allow people to decide elements of their child’s future, then who has the right to stop them from doing so? Can it be reasonable for a group of doctors and politicians to decide the fate of a generation? Especially where health matters are concerned.…

    • 305 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Others question the effectiveness and benefits of genetic screening and wonder if the process would prompt undue emotional distress, distress for the safety of the fetus and also the issue of…

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Procreative Beneficence

    • 2295 Words
    • 10 Pages

    The advances of Reproductive Assistance Technologies (ARTs), such as In vitro Fertilisation (IVF) and Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD) have established a broad platform for debate, which until recently has focused mostly on the moral permissibility of using these technologies for the detection of non-disease genes, those which cause a physical or psychological state not associated with disease, such as sex and tissue type (Stoller 2008, 364). However, in his article “Procreative Beneficence: Why we should select the best children” Savulescu widened the scope of this debate, arguing that the use of PGD in this manner is not only morally acceptable but a moral obligation for prospective parents. He contends that all genetic information, both disease and non-disease, should be utilised to ensure prospective parents have the best child that it is possible for them to have. This essay argues that Savulescu is incorrect in his assertion that prospective parents should have the best child it is possible for them to have and his Principle of Procreative Beneficence (PPB) should therefore be rejected for a number of reasons. Firstly, the principle indirectly, yet unavoidably, impacts on various aspects of the reproductive autonomy of prospective parents and is therefore immoral in what it advocates. Secondly, since PPB has its theoretical foundation in the notion of impersonal harm (Bennett 2009, 266), and requires parents to become complacent with oppression of minority groups, it unavoidably parallels the motives of the “old” eugenics of the 1930’s (Sparrow 2007, 51). Finally, Savulescu not only over exaggerates the moral obligation parents have toward their children in his account of PPB, but also fails to adequately prove that his believed moral obligation truly exists, and thus his argument loses its credibility with prospective parents.…

    • 2295 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    From a patient’s perspective, people tend to see genetic information as more definitive, in the sense that 'you cannot change your genes' and that 'genes tell all about your future.’ Such genetic determinism is an oversimplification and does not take into account the nature of biologic pathways. From a provider’s perspective, genomics presents challenges with respect to ethical and professional responsibilities, including the appropriate use of genomic information in the health care setting. I believe that there should be an identification of provider education programs that increase use of appropriate screening, counseling and evidence-based genetic tests. By increasing the effectiveness of genomic testing, it will help dissolve the negative association and further increase the proportion of people who are willing to receive genetic…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The topic I choose to cover for the Future of Eugenics is Pre-Implantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD). PGD is and will be used in the future of Eugenics to create almost the “fittest” or perfect baby before they are even born. The structure of DNA was discovered in the 1950s, and since then several of genes has been identified as well as genetic disorders, which lead us to PGD. “Pre-implantation genetic diagnosis is a technique used to identify genetic defects in embryos created through in vitro fertilization (IVF) before pregnancy” (Dayal 1).…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Prenatal Testing Ethics

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This paper explores the scientific and ethical considerations of DNA testing in prenatal testing (PT).Taking into consideration non-invasive and invasive sampling and the ethical issues DNA testing raises. Cell-free fetal DNA (CffDNA) in prenatal screening which considers being a recent non-invasive technique. This non-invasive diagnostic test believes to be much safer and can be performed in early pregnancy easily comparing to invasive diagnostic testing. However, CffDNA has flows such as confidentiality, informed consent, and counseling.…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For the benefit of having access to a full genetic screening, an ethical issue would arise as to whether the information about certain codes like predisposition to diseases would be helpful or harmful to a client. Similarly, screening for genetic abnormalities prenatally could lead to unsafe abortions if the child is abnormal or just a general anxiousness for their baby. While there are many benefits of genetic screening, the ethical dilemmas that accompany each one are…

    • 286 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Genetic tests are a viable method of detecting specific mutations or changes in the gene that codes for Hex-A; whereas, blood tests measures the level of Hex-A in a person's blood. Blood tests occur postnatally and have a 98 percent accuracy of detecting the disease in individuals; whereas genetic tests can be performed during the family planning stages and have a 50 to 60 percent accuracy of detecting mutations in carriers. Genetic tests are generally not too expensive and ensures couples are aware of possible conditions their children could develop. It allows them to decide if they should reproduce or seek out other options like adoption. However, there are some downfalls associated with these tests. The test accuracy is limited because it is impossible to screen for all the mutations that could cause the onset of this disease. For example, JScreen, a genetic assay company, claims a negative test result for Tay-Sachs disease “reduces one’s likelihood of being a carrier; however, it does not eliminate it.” This results in uncertainty in whether or not someone has a mutation for the disease because not all of the possible mutations were screened and this person could be given an inaccurate…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The topic is “designer babies.” Pre-natal screening for certain conditions like Down Syndrome is common practice, at least in places that offer that option. But now there’s a fertility clinic in Los Angeles that says it will soon help couples select for non-medical markers. It’s already possible to choose your unborn child’s gender. As genetics research advances, parents may soon have many more choices available to them: their child’s size, hair color, and intelligence. Because of gene technology, inherited diseases may someday be a thing of the past.…

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    BIG IDEA: In this speech I 'd like to show how issues of disease prevention meet ethical concerns of customized conception.…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 2015, Dr. Mauro Bertolotti wrote an article on genetic testing entitled “Opportunities, Risks, and Limitations of Genetic Testing: Looking to the Future From Patients' Point of View”. This issue of Mayo Clinic Proceedings presents the current and future problems and challenges of constantly innovating genetic testing. According to Dr. Bertolotti, “The novelty of genetic testing procedures and results interpretation, formal studies of patients' experiences with genetic testing, and their corresponding reactions to test results, are still limited.” He continues to highlight a few of the problem-areas or shortcomings that may accompany genetic testing. Emotional effects, ethical and regulatory concerns, and overall lack of knowledge are the main points of his argument. Bertolotti asserts that we need to take these perspectives into consideration when researching, designing, discussing, and administering these new types of genetic tests,…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics