Preview

Descartes Dualism

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1488 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Descartes Dualism
Cartesian dualism is a system of beliefs used to explain the nature of our existence and reality. However, there are many problems with dualism, the most significant being the mind/body interaction issue which was raised by Elizabeth in her correspondence to Descartes. My essay will firstly expound the key principles of Cartesian dualism. Then, I will analyse the problems that Elizabeth raises for dualism and critically evaluate its counter arguments. Ultimately, I have concluded that Elizabeth presents a strong argument against Cartesian dualism.

The foundation of Cartesian dualism is that there are two different types of substances: physical and mental.1 Physical substances have the fundamental property of extension while mental substances have the fundamental property of thought. Furthermore, they are entirely distinct from each other; a physical substance cannot think and a mental substance cannot have extension.2

Another key principle of Cartesian dualism is that humans have a body, in the physical state, and a mind, in the mental state, which interact with each other.3 Descartes compared this union of mind and body to a sailor and his ship in Meditation 6; like how a sailor steers his ship, we too have a thinking thing, existing independently of the body, which controls our body.4 Thus our mind can affect our bodies. Furthermore, Descartes reasoned that our bodies can affect our mind because when our bodies are damaged, our mind perceives this as pain.

However, this raises the issue of mind/body interaction; it seems impossible for a mental substance, with no physical properties, and a material object to affect each other.5

1

Binder, MD, Hirokawa, N & Windhorst, U 2009, Encyclopedia of Neuroscience, Springer Berlin Heidelberg, Berlin.
2

Lloyd, M 2013, Week 3 Descartes I, PowerPoint slides, University of Queensland, Brisbane.

3

McLeod, S 2007, Mind Body Debate, viewed 13th April 2013, .
4

Temple, C 2002, Meditations on First



Bibliography: Binder, MD, Hirokawa, N & Windhorst, U 2009, Encyclopedia of Neuroscience, Springer Berlin Heidelberg, Berlin. Bloom, P 2007, Lecture 2 Foundations: This is Your Brain, Transcript, Yale University, Connecticut. Calef, S 2005, Dualism and Mind, Internet Encyclopaedia of Philosophy, viewed 12th April 2013, . Koksvik, O 2006, In Defense of Interactionism, Monash University, Melbourne, viewed 11th April 2013, . Lisa Shapiro (ed.) The Correspondence Between Princess Elizabeth of Bohemia and Rene Descartes, (Chicago: Chicago University Press, 2007) 61-67. Lloyd, M 2013, Week 3 Descartes I, PowerPoint slides, University of Queensland, Brisbane. Lloyd, M 2013, Week 4 Descartes II, PowerPoint slides, University of Queensland, Brisbane. McLeod, S 2007, Mind Body Debate, viewed 13th April 2013, . Rene Descartes, The Passions of the Soul, trans. John Conttingham, Robert Stoothoff & Dougald Murdoch (Cambridge: CUP, 1985), 340. Temple, C 2002, Meditations on First Philosophy, Philosophy Index, viewed 14th April 2013, .

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The mind and body problem can be divided into many different questions. We can consider or ask by ourselves that what is the mind? What is the body? And do both of them are co-existing, or does the mind only exist in the body? Or does the body only exist in the mind? Otherwise, we also will consider that if both the mind and body exist, and then there could be a number of types of relationships. Maybe the mind will affect our body. Or maybe the body will affect our mind, or maybe the mind and body will both affect each other.…

    • 1561 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Descartes argues the mind is seperate from the physical body. With advances in nueroscience and the contious brain injuries gives strong evidence in supporting materialism. Defining what Cartesian dualists mean by the brain, mind, body and soul, an argument by Cartesians dualists may be reached. Responding to evidence confronting brain injuries from claims that the brain is only ‘an instrument of the soul’. Concluding there is a simultaneous support for materialism resulting from neuroscience and the Cartesian dualism argument, may be wrong.…

    • 227 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Substance Dualism

    • 1770 Words
    • 8 Pages

    In order to truly understand Descartes’ argument of substance dualism, it is important to understand the methodological, reductionist approach that he employs to build his theory. In the First Meditation, Descartes sets the basis for his ontological search for truth by rejecting all of his previous beliefs, experiences, and memories in order to begin from a clean, uninfluenced position. He says, “I have no senses. Body, shape, extension,…

    • 1770 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Property Dualism

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This essay assesses property dualism, a theory of mind. It proclaims the existence of a single, physical substance (unlike Cartesian dualism), but argues that this single substance has two potential properties: physical and mental states that are not reducible.…

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Zombie Argument

    • 1641 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Cartesian Dualism is Descartes’ concept of dualism which states that physical and mental events belong to two different substance; the mind is immaterial and the body is material and all people possess this dual nature “I thought of the Queen and I saluted” there is the mental I and the physical I who does the act of saluting (Blackburn, 1999: 51). Cartesian Dualism states that minds are not in space, they are not subject to the laws of physics and most importantly minds…

    • 1641 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Mind-Body problem asks the question about the relationship between the mind and the body. We, as creatures have a brain, with several types of tissue and neurons and have we a mind because we have the ability to have emotions, sensations, beliefs and desires. The issue arises as we consider the brain as a physical object, but do we consider the mind as a physical entity too, and if the mind is a physical entity are our emotions, desires and sensations a product of our brain? Some argue that the mind is just like the brain and therefore it is a physical object. Some argue otherwise. Rene Descartes offered a solution for the Mind-Body problem, which he termed as Cartesian Dualism. According to Dualism, “brains and the bodies in which they are found are physical things; the mind, which is a non-physical…

    • 1184 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes suggests the viewpoint that the human body and the human mind are two completely different things with different functions. The viewpoint is called Dualism, and holds that both the physical world and the immaterial world exist. Dualism is based on two substances, which are mind and matter. Descartes explained that these two does not necessarily need one another to exist.…

    • 2101 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After Elisabeth presses Descartes to make a light on the mind-body participation, he inevitably responds. Descartes' response is reluctant and in addition opens up further issues, His responses are twofold. Firstly, he battles that a reaction to this issue presupposes a clarification of the union between the brain and the body (Atherton, 1994). Also, he guarantees that the question itself come from a false presupposition that two substances with finish diverse natures can't follow up on each other (Atherton, 1994); and imply there is an inconsistency in considering brain and body as both two particular substances and as joined together (Mattern 1978). As demonstrated by Descartes' points of view, the psyche and the body are two unmistakable sorts of substances. The body is spatially expanded and unequipped for feeling or thought. The brain, of course, is unextended and fit for thought and…

    • 418 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rene Descartes, a 17th century French philosopher, created the idea of Substance dualism. Descartes states that the mind and the body are two separate entities that possess different characteristics. The mind, a theoretical substance, cannot be viewed in space as a material substance using tradition measuments such as height or weight. Because of this, only the physical body can be extended, not the mind, separating the two into the theory of substance dualism.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes famously proposed the conception of the mind and body as two distinct substances. Substance dualism is one of his famously philosophical stances. According to this philosophical position, the mind and body can exist as two separate substances that can exist independently. Descartes commences by noting that the basis of his opinions have been his senses and we cannot be sure that our minds are not deceiving us. It is as such because we cannot be sure that our exciting thoughts of the world are not dreams. Descartes, therefore, argues that there is seemingly some sense in which people can be uncertain about the existence of items that they believe exist.…

    • 332 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Looking at the religious motivation towards Descartes’ theory of mind – body dualism, Descartes, just like numerous other religious believers, believed that the human soul was immortal and since at the point of death the human body became functionless, the soul, which he equated to the human mind was immortal and therefore this was proof that the human body and the human mind were two distinct substances. Looking at the scientific connotation, Descartes looked at the nature of physical things and established that they lacked mentality (Russell,…

    • 1621 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    She already knows that the body and the movement cannot happen without impulsion from another physical body. Therefore, Descartes’ answer is there are three concepts that she needs to understand it, the concept of the body, the concept of the mind and the connection between the mind and the body. He defines the association between the body and the mind by saying, “the force of the soul for moving the body, and of the body for acting upon the soul by causing its feeling and passion.”2 He means that the body’s effect on the soul by controls the emotions, and the soul controls the body movement. He tells Elisabeth that she needs to understand the concepts that the body is material, and the mind is immaterial. He tries to give Elisabeth example by using the physical concepts of the weight.3 He said that the weight is not separate from the body. However, Elisabeth did not satisfy with his answer and asked Descartes for more clarification of immaterial soul and its action with the body. He answers that he need to clarify more on the concepts he mentioned it in his first letter (the body, the soul, and the connection between them).…

    • 524 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Upon observation, Descartes formulated a thesis called mind-body dualism, which summarized the idea that even though they coexist with one another, the material human body is distinct from the immaterial human mind. He states that he can derive the “essence” of himself without needing to account for his body and that essence is thought. Therefore, even though his mind may not be material, it still exists. But he can also derive the essence of his body, which is extension. He reaches this conclusion through deductive reasoning regarding his existence, how he perceives the world, and God’s influence in his life. In Mediation I, he observes that he withdraws from the senses, but at the same time,…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The idea of Cartesian Dualism was conceived through the mind of Rene Descartes through a series of meditations. In its most basic definition, Cartesian Dualism is the belief in the separation between the immaterial mind and the physical body. Descartes began creating this concept as he began his first meditation where he came to doubt his own existence, however he also discovered that in order for him to doubt his existence then he indeed must already exist. Descartes uses this idea as his axiom, or base, of his conclusions on things such as the existence of himself, physical objects, and God. At this point Descartes has only…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dualism; Mind v Body

    • 1535 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Throughout the history of philosophy one of the strongest thesis’s in Descartes time as a philosopher was the idea of dualism. What is dualism? In short it is the theory that the mind and body are two separate substances. Although Descartes has his own arguments and support as to why dualism is true. The idea of dualism has been debated for centuries; it is basically on what one’s beliefs are if they think it is true or false. Descartes explanation of dualism was in his second and sixth meditation. He discusses how the mind is separate from the body. Descartes mediation two is split into four categories, the basis of certainty, what am I, the conceptual and perceptual and lastly distinction. The fourth category intertwines with meditation six. The idea of dualism is a true theory because the mind has its own process and how it works and the body is just there, basically. The theory of dualism has its pros and cons; it is the idea of what a person is and how they function. It is a great theory but all great theories have their problems and imperfections. Descartes uses his arguments to help support his theory and tries to counter argue what other philosophers believe. What is the basis of certainty is where his theory begins.…

    • 1535 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays