Preview

Cultural Pluralism

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
898 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Cultural Pluralism
In community interventions, ethical behavior relates to the treatment of humans, knowledge, and wealth and also the general activities of people when they are not dealing directly with the community. When it comes to social issues, ethical issues are most often the center of the controversy. Ethical controversies are created when groups quarrel that certain topics are moral or immoral. In the Model of American Ethnic Relations: A Historical Perspective, an essay by George M. Fredrickson, he explains the changes on how distinctive cultural groups define themselves or the way they have been defined previous through another group by delivering the four basic conceptions of how ethnic or racial groups should express to each other, including Ethnic …show more content…
"The model of cultural development during this period was evolutionary, progressive, and universalistic" (Fredrickson 571). Fredrickson believes that the best hope for a just a cohesive society is the offer of Cultural Pluralism. The difference between pluralists and assimilationists is that fact that pluralists celebrate the differences among groups rather than eliminate them. An example for this ethnic relation is the 18th and 19th centuries that ignored the essential conception of the aspect of cultures. Cultural Pluralism to immigrants is viewed to be a “melting pot,” they need to abandon their own culture, languages, and other traditions in order to assimilate the American culture. Different ethnic groups have enhanced the American life as immigrants and native-born citizens, broadening views on the basic aspects of life such as, art, cuisine, education, history, and …show more content…
Ethnic Hierarchy deals with the dominant group claiming to conceive themselves as society’s highest class and declare the rights and privileges that aren’t shared with the people who are considered to be “unfit” for equal rights. The One-Way Assimilation handles equality by allowing others to put aside cultural differences and adapt to the cultures and traditions of the society itself. Cultural Pluralism shows how the celebration of the differences instead of trying to eliminate differences between the diverse ethnic groups can keep a long lasting healthy society. And lastly, Fredrickson discusses the concept of Group Separatism in which the cultural or racial groups withdraw from their society and interactions from other groups in order to control themselves. Although we’ve grown closer together as a society, there is still a great mass of diversity throughout our nation. Once we all come together on a mutual decision of accepting all types of cultures and human beings, America will only then be ethically

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The melting pot, a concept evolved from Israel Zangwill’s play in 1908 whereby people from different ethnic origins are fused into one nation, presents the struggle for the American Government to assimilate the huge number of immigrants travelling to America, each coming from an array of different countries speaking various languages and owning a variety of different cultures. From 1865 to 1970, assimilation was forced upon the Native Americans yet was extremely hard for the American Government to achieve as the Native Americans demonstrated large efforts to resist any attempt at integration and continued to claim their right to be separate from other migrants in the ‘melting pot’.…

    • 1205 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Many individuals interpret diversity differently specifically in the United States because of its melting pot of distinct cultures and lifestyles. In his essay “People Like Us”, David Brooks’ argues that although the United States is a diverse nation as a whole, it is homogeneous in specific aspects like interactions between people. To some extent, his observation is true; people tend to stick to what or who they are comfortable with. There are also exceptions where the American people attempt to establish relationships with others because of their desire to expand out of their norm. For instance, Brooks excludes the explanation of diversity integration in the United States, where instead focuses on racial integration as the definition of diversity in America. He also makes assumptions that people purposefully intend to segregate themselves and underestimates their capability of living together because of their location, political values and personal appeal.…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to Ting - Toomey and Chung (2012), the "cultural assimilation" stance is an attitude towards the adaptation process in which individuals demand that strangers conform to the host environment. While the "cultural pluralist" stance is one that encourages a diversity of values, emphasizing the importance of providing strangers with larger sets of norms to choose from in regards to their transition into a new culture. When it comes to the stance I personally subscribe to in consideration of immigrant issues, I think that it…

    • 370 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    For a long time, assimilation was the dominant ideology, where immigrants and minorities socially integrated into American society. However, contemporarily America has become an multicultural society, where the minority group has outweigh the majority group in number. Therefore, assimilation is no longer seen as a completely inevitable and desirable process, and is even criticized for it's nature of culture eradication. In the reading written by Richard Alba and Victor Nee, Alba and Nee suggested that despite the deficiencies of traditional assimilation, it is still being the best way to understand and describe the integration into the mainstream experienced across generations by many individual and ethnic groups. Thus, they proposed a reformulation of assimilation which the definition is very different. In their version of assimilation, it is no longer a process which minorities loses their cultural traits and merges into the majority host society. It became a process where reduction of ethnic differences takes place between two…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Some Americans argue that immigrants refuse to assimilate into U.S. culture, but according to Cole, “our society exerts tremendous pressure to conform, and cultural separatism rarely survives a generation” (559). Little by little, immigrants newly living in the U.S. pick up on our language, behaviors, customs and so on, all through exposure alone. Over time, immigrants adapt to our culture and in return, they also enrich our culture by adding more diversity. It is this diversity that enhances environments within our country such workplaces, neighborhoods, and also schools. After all, being a diverse country shows that we are a country that openly accepts the differences of others and embraces their freedom to be different as well. Pressuring immigrants to completely leave behind their previous culture and conform to “American Culture” is not only seen as controlling and unjust, it also assumes America has one single culture when in fact, American culture is composed from various individual cultures. Although sometimes it can be rather difficult to work with different cultures and some cultures negatively interact with others, that should not be an excuse for anyone to fear immigrants nor immorally prohibit them from making a home where ever they please to do so. America is a melting pot of cultures, which helps portray itself as a beautifully diverse country where anyone is accepted with open arms. Immigrants choose this country for a reason; America is one of the most opportunity-filled countries that is rich in culture and diversity. Not only does immigration enrich our culture, but it also enriches the lives of…

    • 1455 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Nevertheless, Fredrickson’s opinion on Group Separatism is “a symptom of racial injustice” (459). Therefore, Cultural Pluralism is the best choice of Fredrickson…

    • 1212 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Boston Irish

    • 29910 Words
    • 120 Pages

    In some ways, assimilation and pluralism are contrary processes, but they are not mutually exclusive. They may occur together in a variety of combinations within a particular…

    • 29910 Words
    • 120 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The United States of America, since its commencement, has been a “melting pot” of different nationalities. While the term melting pot sounds forthcoming, this is not the case in reality. Many times cultures collide due their differences in ideology, culture, and geographical proximity. Such culture clashes have marked the history of the United States. Race is usually thought of in the physical sense with difference in skin color, hair, facial features, and language. Although race usually follows along physical lines, it is much more far reaching and extends into the social and cultural beliefs. In the past, the dominant trend was to keep these beliefs separate, consequently increasing the feeling of racial unity and racism in society. History has shown us that man has used segregation as a method of not only keeping the peace, but also of keeping the purity of a race in tact.…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ps 102

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In Huntington’s article, One Nation Out of Many, Huntington chronologically goes thru the immigration of the United States detailing how early immigrants had a desire to become American in both nationality and core culture. He illustrates how American business and government used their resources to assist in the teaching of immigrants both the language and culture. It was a time when an industrial powerhouse like Ford Motor Company was thinking in line with US Government, both creating schools that taught “American ways, the English language, and the right way to live.” Huntington goes further to explain how immigrants had a desire no only to assimilate, but how they internally believe in the United States as their Country. The decline of this belief in Core Culture is explained by way of Government trying to move to a multicultural position even as the American public remains strong to the Core Culture.…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hate crimes is a criminal offense committed because of the offender’s bias against a race, religion, ethnic group, national origin, sexual orientation. The third major point is sociological perspective on race ethnicity. Here it talks about different views. Functionalist point out the discrimination is both functional and dysfunctional for society. Conflict theorists explain racial subordinate ion through exploitation theory. Interactionists pose the hypothesis as means or reducing prejudice and discrimination. The fourth major point is that patterns of intergroup relations. There are a lot of major terms in this section. Amalgamation is when a majority group and minority group to form a new group. Assimilation is the process through which a person forsakes his or her cultural tradition to see themselves as part of a larger national family. Segregation is the action or state of setting someone or something apart from other people or things or being set apart. Pluralism is based on mutual respect for one another’s culture among the various groups in a society. The fifth major point of this chapter is race and ethnicity in the United States. In this section, it informs us that discrimination against African…

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to some historians, the USA in 1890 had become a ‘melting pot’ of different cultures, meaning that the people who had immigrated to America had left their old traditions behind to start a new country free from outdated laws; this idea was also linked to American Exceptionalism as America was ‘Exceptional’ for these reasons. Many historians argue against this idea as there is plenty evidence to suggest that the immigrants to America had not integrated with each other and stayed with people from their previous country with the same traditions. These different cultures lived alongside one another meaning the USA could be described…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The United Sates has always been a beacon for freedom and liberty to those across the globe looking to escape tyranny and oppression, or gain an opportunity to advance their personal interests that they would not otherwise have in the country of origin. National crisis like famine, war, poverty, unemployment and oppression have traditionally spurred people to emigrate from their home countries to find a better way of life within the United Sates welcoming borders.…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cultural pluralism is the “means valuing and maintaining cultural and linguistic differences within a society” (Tozer, 2013, p. 196). While assimilation is the “process by which diverse cultures—immigrants, racial, ethnic, and linguistic minorities—alter their customs, habits, and languages to allow absorption into a dominant culture, both positive and negative” (Tozer, 2013, p. 196). As the European American expansion to the West began to take root, it was in the best interest of the American Indian to be educated and civilized. As Tozer states “if the Indian couldn’t be eliminated, their Indianess could” (Tozer, 2013, p. 201). It was the American federal government's main focus to wipe out Native American culture and replace it with what…

    • 234 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Pluralism

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Pluralism in contemporary academic field implies multiple meanings. One interpretation of pluralism is "the idea, classically formulated by Isaiah Berlin, that there is a plurality of distinct or 'incommensurable' values or goods" (Crowder, 2010). The word 'incommensurable' here means, in short, incomparable. This is because pluralism believes in multiple values, and there is no single fundamental value acting as denominator to rank between different values. It is almost undoubtedly that people value much goodness such as friendship, health and freedom. These values, from a utilitarian's perspective, could be calculated to one fundamental value, say utility. Hence abovementioned good values along with others could be converted to utility. However, pluralists does not agree with this. Schaber (1999) argued 'some values are not reducible to one fundamental value and as a consequence not measurable in terms of a fundamental value'. According to Crowder (2002), the value pluralism can be argued from the possibility of rational regret. The argument starts with two options A and B, and we can only choose one. We often regret that we did not choose the other one after the decision is made. The regret is rational in many cases. Rationality will not be valid if there is only one value as people will not regret for choosing the option with higher fundamental value over the lesser one. There is no diminished value. Thus, the existence of rational regret proves value pluralism.…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Multiculturalism

    • 3324 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The text “Automatic Upgrade” from 2011 is a short story by Maggie Robb. In “Automatic Upgrade” we are introduced to Ramesh, a 26-year-old Indian boy, who is travelling by plane to Surrey with his grandmother. On the plane, Ramesh tells his grandmother that he is going to quit his career as a doctor to work in the mobile phone business. The grandmother doesn’t take this news very well and she is not satisfied buy his decision. She thinks he is crazy for doing such a thing. Later Ramesh falls asleep on the plane and then wakes up to find his grandmother cold without any pulse and completely lifeless in her seat. The aircrew on the plane shows professionalism and they handle the situation very well, and without a chaos. Ramesh and his grandmother are then automatically upgraded to first class, since this is the normal procedure in a situation like this.…

    • 3324 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays