Preview

Critically Assess The Claim That Conscience Is A Reliable Guide To Ethical Decision Making

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1426 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Critically Assess The Claim That Conscience Is A Reliable Guide To Ethical Decision Making
Critically assess the claim that conscience is a reliable guide to ethical decision making
In order for conscience to be consistently and absolutely reliable, infallible, it must stem from an infallible source - God. Alternatively, conscience might have a potential of ultimate reliability, if the faculty of conscience was dynamic and capable of solving problems i.e. if it was an innate part of human nature. St.Paul, Newman, Aquinas, Butler and Freud all argue on their ideas of what the conscience is and how reliable it can be towards ethical decision making.
St.Paul’s argument for the conscience can be found in the New Testament where the Greek word used for conscience is synderesis. This is the pain suffered by the one who goes against his or her moral principle. In Romans 2:15 Paul described the conscience as the witness to the requirements of the law being written on the hearts of those who are not under the law. In other words the conscience acts as a guide even where specific moral principles are not taken into consideration. It can be argued that St Paul’s conscience theory can be followed regardless of religious beliefs. However, some people may argue that St Paul’s idea of the conscience is undeveloped. There is no evidence to back up what he is saying as any reference to the conscience in the bible can only be referred to St Paul’s biblical writings. Therefore, we cannot say the conscience is a reliable guide to ethical decision making as there is no evidence to back up what St.Paul argues.
St Thomas Aquinas believed that the conscience was a device or faculty for distinguishing right from wrong through use of reason. He believed that it is a natural part of mental activity and provides an individual with moral guidance. He argued that there are two parts to making a moral decision; the Synderesis, this is the right reason, the awareness of being able to do good and prevent evil and the Conscienta, it distinguishes between right and wrong applies this

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    The Importance of Ethics

    • 3331 Words
    • 16 Pages

    Aristotle was one of the first and perhaps most influential of all people to shape the ethics of Western civilization from a secular orientation. He believed that every type of animal has a common essence or nature, and that human beings are essentially, or by nature, rational. He viewed rationality as the central and most significant trait distinguishing humankind from other creatures. Further, Aristotle taught that the good person is the one who lives most rationally and whose moral judgments and social conduct are born of contemplation and reason, in contrast to spontaneity and emotionality. Today, when we address a moral dilemma by saying, "Let us use reason; let us use logic; let us think rationally about this," we are being ethical in the Aristotelian, secular tradition.[i]…

    • 3331 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Taking a natural law approach to moral decision making can be seen as beneficial as it is a simplistic and universal guide to morality. As human reason forms the basis to this moral approach, it can be argued that natural moral law can be used by all people, even those who are not Christian. Thompson supports this idea when he comments; ‘Since natural law is based in reason, it is in principle discoverable by anyone…For the same reason, it is universal rather than limited to one religion or culture.’ This allows natural law to be applied to moral decisions that affect people all over the world including atheists such as contraception and abortion.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In support of this, cognitive effort (Kohlberg, 1984) and intellectual ability (Moore, Clark & Kane, 2008) have been found to be key components of moral judgement. Kohlberg stated that moral judgements are developed through an explicit learning process; for example, having turns at taking on different roles and attempting to understand dilemmas from different points of view. Of note, is that it is not clear whether the role of emotion was also considered in this…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Libertarians support the view that people have free will and so we are free to make moral decisions. For a Libertarian, the key evidence for this is the act of decision making in our daily lives. Hume states that “experience is what we see to be true”, each human being experiences the feeling of being free to make a decision. If experiencing any other action constitutes it to be true, then why not the same for free will? Libertarians argue that we have awareness of the choices we make; we can choose to do anything that we are capable of. Though we are influenced by our environment and experiences, ultimately we can make our own decisions, nothing is inevitable or determined. Libertarians hold the belief of a moral self; humans want to want to do things. For example, a smoker may think it would be a good idea to give up smoking, but their addiction is too strong for them to think it possible or in any way likely; they want to want to give up smoking. Humans are unique in this way and it is this which is called the moral self. Libertarians are dualists believing that the human mind is separate from the physical world. It is because of this that our reason and autonomy, our moral self, can transcend over other causal determinants. Kant argues that by applying reason to decisions we can escape any authority from cause and effect or desires and emotions, we are the agents of our own decisions. Libertarians believe in a forking path of choices rather than the straight road of determinism.…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    conscience and values to make a moral decision, it provides him or her with an equation. If I…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The company that I chose to compare to my Ethics Awareness Inventory Scoring Summary is Pfizer. Pfizer is a multination pharmaceutical company; they develop and produce medicines and vaccines for a wide range of conditions. Pfizer is a company had an annual income of 67 Billion dollars last year (P., 2012). Some of the popular products that Pfizer makes are Advil, Celebrex, Viagra and Lipitor. The reason I chose Pfizer is because I have always been interested in the company because it is their moral obligation to serve the people of the world community with pharmaceutical goods for the betterment of the life of the community.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There are many principles that set us up as a non-democratic nation. Which, are Freedom of Speech, Freedom of Assembly, Freedom of Conscience, and Freedom from Arbitrary Search and Seizure. John Locke and John Stuart Mill were two political theorists who lend a hand in shaping these evolving ideas about liberty and political rights. Having Freedom of Speech allows us the right to express any opinions without restriction. Having Freedom of Assembly allows the individual right of people to come together and collectively express, promote, pursue, and defend their ideas. Having Freedom of Conscience gives us the right to follow one’s own beliefs in matters of religion and morality. Having Freedom from Arbitrary Search and Seizure allows everyone…

    • 177 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Aquinas saw the conscience as the natural ability of a rational human being to understand the difference between right and wrong, and to apply the most basic moral principles to particular situations. Aquinas thought that there would be problems with people following their own moral sense, which lead him to natural moral law (NML). He thought that everyone should follow NML because they are moral laws found in nature (e.g. sex for procreation). He thought that the conscience was the intellectual part of you because you work out what to do using natural reasoning. Without following NML, people might have distorted judgments from their passions, ignorance and society and therefore different views on right and wrong. Therefore although he says that it is always right to follow one’s conscience, he does recognise that people may still get things wrong, through ignorance or making a mistake. Therefore Aquinas would not say that conscience should always be obeyed because a person may not be aware of the relevant moral principle. In order for conscience to work, a person needs to have some background information…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    For many of use our consciences have always been a part of us since the day we first started to recognise ourselves. It would be easy for everyone to follow this ‘voice of reason’ in our head as the outcome if often a positive one. However there are cases in which it could be deemed in the best interest of the person to disobey the conscience as it could led to a very immoral action. It is in these cases that not always obeying the conscience would be seemed as the right action.…

    • 1292 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some religious believers see the conscience as having a metaphysical origin such as a God, some argue that conscience has total authority and that we should in some respects not be blame for our actions because it’s a fault or difference in our conscience while others argue that we are totally responsible for our actions and conscience does not have ultimate moral authority.…

    • 1275 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ethical Decision Making

    • 1655 Words
    • 7 Pages

    A.5.b. Professional school counselors help educate about and prevent personal and social concerns for all students within the school counselor’s scope of education and competence and make necessary referrals when the counseling needs are beyond the individual school counselor’s education and training. Every attempt is…

    • 1655 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    "It may sound rather strange and needs to be pondered, lived with, and slept on for a long time. I regard bad conscience as the serious illness that man was bound to contract under the stress of the most fundamental change he ever experienced-that change which occurred when he found himself finally enclosed within the walls of society and peace".…

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The presence and absence of ethics in societal decision making contribute to the successes and shortfalls we experience every day. My personal ethical lens inventory reflected the many characteristics I as an individual contribute to society. This document will discuss certain characteristics such as my preferred ethical lens, my blind spot, my strengths and weaknesses, and my values and resultant behavior.…

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Crucible - Conscience

    • 1686 Words
    • 7 Pages

    "No critic seemed to sense what I was after [which was] the conflict between a man's raw deeds and his conception of himself; the question of whether conscience is in fact an organic part of the human being, and what happens when it is handed over not merely to the state or the mores of the time but to one's friend or wife."…

    • 1686 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Nietzsche: the Conscience

    • 1568 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The way in which we currently view guilt is as having an association with accountability and responsibility. To hold a promise; one is required to have a trained and able memory, and to have a confidence in one’s own predictability. Society and morality allow us to make ourselves predictable by providing a common set of laws and customs to guide behavior. When the concept of free will is introduced, a sovereign individual feels a responsibility to act according to these guidelines set by society. Being free to act in any manner, the burden of responsibility is placed on the individual rather than the society. “If something is to stay in the memory it must be burned in: only that which never ceases to hurt stays in the memory” (Nietzsche 1989b, p. 61). Therefore, the central stimuli in the formation of conscience are this sense of responsibility and a trained memory.…

    • 1568 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays