Preview

Critical Analysis of Giorgio Agamben

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
901 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Critical Analysis of Giorgio Agamben
In, Life That Does Not Deserve to Live, Giorgio Agamben aims to expand on Michel Foucault’s concepts of ‘biopower’ and ‘biopolitics’, to express the way in which the state has power over society in the way that ‘bare life’ is produced. He uses the Latin term homo sacer – literally translated to ‘sacred man’ – to describe a life which can be “eliminated without punishment” , one that possesses no value to the state and therefore can be terminated without the act being considered a crime. Examples of this can be seen in people who experience ‘brain death’ and subsequently have their life support machine switched off, and in people in prison camps such as Guantanamo Bay. However, the biggest example we are given of bare life, is in the Jewish Ghettos and concentration camps during the Holocaust.
For Agamben, the camp acts as a paradigm for the boundaries between bare life and political existence, the fence that intersects the homines sacri from the people of juridical worth represents the line between ‘bare life’ and state recognition, between bios and zoe. He states that, “every society sets this limit; every society – even the most modern – decide who its ‘sacred men will be” . Therefore, the camp as an allegory represents the boundary that all societies set in which a person becomes bare life; it symbolizes the line of distinction. This, for Thomas Lemke, is a downfall of Agamben’s argument in the sense that it does not “analyse how inside ‘bare life’ hierarchisations and evaluations become possible, how life can be classified as higher or lower” . In other words, Agamben sees only the distinction between bare life and legal existence; he does not see the variations within them both, rather they are two homogenous groups of people with no internal structure – the ‘zone of indistinction’ . In focusing on the line that separates the two groups of people, Agamben fails to see the difference within the groups themselves. For instance, Rabinow and Rose note that, “it

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Dehumanization happens all around the world and is overlooked by millions. When hearing the word “ genocide” many think about the Holocaust. To summarize, Dehumanizing was evident throughout World War Two but especially during the Holocaust. To begin, In the book Night, written by Elie Wiesel, Elie describes his experiences in Auschwitz during the Holocaust. In fact, The United nations crafted the Universal Declaration of Human rights after the second world war. Inhuman acts desecrated the conscience of mankind during the time, as a result, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights was forged.…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Throughout Borowski’s collection of short stories, “This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen” various characters have been deceived into their own executions. The thought of being led to one’s own death without even knowing is what went through the minds of many Jews during the Holocaust. These victims had no control or say in their fates and faced the judgment without any sympathy or remorse from their executers. Although the victim’s futures were for the most part condemned, as they got closer and closer to death, few never lost hope that some miraculous intercession could drastically change their fate for the better. Their mindset is exemplified in “Auschwitz, Our Home (A Letter): “ We were never taught how to give up hope, and this is why today we perish in gas chambers” (Borowski 122). Through this, Borowski demonstrates the victim’s desperation to live even in the early stages of death through the gas chambers. Their individual stories and situations are expressed and explained through the eyes of narrator Tadek. The author uses narrative voice to set the tone of every individual life story and experience during the days of the Holocaust.…

    • 1247 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Everyone deserves the right to live in freedom and safety. History provides many chief examples of the violation of these human rights, such as the Holocaust. The murdering of over 6 million people of the Jewish religion and the extreme mistreatment of them in concentration camps clearly shows these violations. Many of the Jews that survived the dreadful concentration camps, retell their stories through books and interviews. Elie Wiesel, a Buna concentration camp survivor, reveals the violation of his human rights through the literary devices of imagery, conflict, symbolism along with understatement. Wiesel uses these literary devices to emphasize the theme that a prisoner must remain optimistic to overcome oppression in his book, “Night”.…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Between Dignity and Despair, a book written by Marion A. Kaplan, published in 1998, gives us a portrait of Jewish life in Nazi Germany by the astounding memoirs, diaries, interviews with survivors, and letters of Jewish women and men. The book is written in chronological order of events, from the daily life of German Jewish families prior to when the Holocaust began to the days when rights were completely taken away; from the beginning of forced labor and exile to the repercussion of the war. Kaplan tries to include details from each significant event during the time of the Holocaust. Kaplan tells us the story of Jews in Germany not from the perception of the Holocaust, but by focusing on the persecutors from the confused and vague viewpoint of Jews trying to direct their lives on a day to day basis in a world that was becoming more and more insane. Kaplan shows us that the Holocaust was impossible to predict exactly because Nazi oppression occurred in random and impulsive steps until the massive violence of November 1938. Between Dignity and Despair focuses on the destiny of families and mostly women’s experience, taking the reader into neighborhoods, kitchens, shops, schools and it gives us form and consistency. It is giving us the exact impression of what life was like to be a Jew in Nazi Germany, except we are sitting behind the book taking it all in.…

    • 2244 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Capital punishment is something that has been debated over by the public for ages whether if it is impartial to take away another human’s life. For politicians it’s a way to extract dangerous criminals, but is it appropriate to take another human life due to a crime? “A Hanging” by George Orwell presents the perspective of a guard ordered to take a prisoner to the gallows for hanging as a result of an unknown crime. Throughout the essay Orwell uses symbolism of life and death to convey his animosity towards the capital punishment through the perspective of a guard in Burma during British Imperialism. “A Hanging” a hanging by George Orwell uses examples of life and death to assert Orwell’s distain towards capital punishment before the hanging of the prisoner, at the gallows, and after the hanging.…

    • 1737 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The thousands of people who died daily in Auschwitz and Birkenau, in the crematoria, no longer troubled me”. The death and dying did not affect the Jews, because that was all around them. The many children and mothers were sent to the crematoria to be killed they were sent in alive. “I watched other hangings. I never saw a single victim weep. These withered bodies had long forgotten the bitter taste of tears”. The people that did not obey we hanged or flogged in front of the camp for everyone to see. The hanging was torture to watch, but they desensitized to the death of one another.…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eyewitness Auschwitz

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The memoir greatly details the resilience of the human spirit, the choices individuals were faced with and decided to act upon and, the treatment of those who had succumbed. The personal choices that some made were extremely unmoral. “"Every day we saw thousands and thousands of innocent people disappear up the chimney. With our own eyes, we could truly fathom what it means to be a human being. There they came, men, women, children, all innocent. They suddenly vanished, and the world said nothing ..” An example of an unmoral prisoner was the Kapo Mietek, who was trusted to discipline the working prisoners. According to Muller, it was not necessary for Mietek to treat his fellow prisoners as human beings but rather beat them mercilessly to gain appreciation from the Nazi leaders. Another theme that Muller presents in his testimony is dehumanization of the camp’s victims. Approximately seventy percent of the prisoners that arrived at Auschwitz were immediately gassed. Their hair was shaven and their bodies were exploited in order to find valuables for the Nazi’s economic gain.…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Masci, David. "Torture." CQ Researcher. 13: 15 (18 April 2003): 345-368.(pg 3, 4,5) CQ Researcher.…

    • 1765 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust was certainly one of humanity’s darkest hours. The Nazi leaders of Germany rounded up millions of Jews from across Europe and place them in camps to be exterminated or for hard labor. These actions were caused by the Nazis’ belief that all of the Jews were responsible for corruption and injustice in the continent. They labeled all of them in this fashion and sought to get rid of them as a group. Part of this mentality was characterized by depriving the Jews of their individuality. This is reflected in “This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen.” The workers of the death…

    • 661 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Selzer, R. (1987). A mask on the face of death. Intersections: Readings in the sciences and humanities (2nd ed., pp.91-93). Toronto: Pearson Education Canada. Retrieved from: http/search.ebscohost.com.auth01.norquest.ca…

    • 1715 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Germany and Communist regimes that used similar procedures of “torture” and “persecution” to those who opposed Nazism and Communism ideologies. Therefore, Pérez’s interpretation and explanation not only make sense, but they are well…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Holocaust was one of the most disturbing and petrifying eras of all time. The holocaust, one of the most famous genocides in the world, has showed the world what the evils of man can do to mankind. It was the genocide that killed approximately six million Jews and millions of others in a state-sponsored murder by Nazi Germany led by Adolf Hitler. In a book review of “The Holocaust” by Gilbert Martin, Martin says that, “The Holocaust is the definitive account of what is the most horrifying crime ever committed against humanity”. This brutal torture affected many Jews living in Europe, physically and mentally.…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the novel Night, author Elie Wiesel describes his time being exposed to the extremely brutal conditions of the Nazi concentration camps. Most, if not all European Jews were forced into these labor camps where the prisoners had to work in order to stay alive. Upon arrival, people were split into two categories, one of which was given the opportunity to live, while the other was not as lucky. This chance was “granted” to those who showed an ability to work with ease, but for those who showed signs of weakness; they were sent to the gas chambers and crematories. Although somewhat blessed with the opportunity of life, they were treated so horrifically that death would have been the blessing; even while death enticed more suffering than need…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Nobel Peace Prize winner, renowned scholar, and author of over fifty books, Elie Wiesel is a name with worldwide recognition. In addition to his literary and scholarly accomplishments, Wiesel is also recognized as an eminent champion and defender of human rights for both the work he has done in the field, as well as his own status as a Holocaust survivor (“Elie Wiesel”). Wiesel believes indifference, or the lack of sympathy towards others, as being the devastating culprit in dividing humanity. In this rhetorical analysis of Wiesel’s speech “The Perils of Indifference” I will explain how Wiesel uses the concepts of ethos, logos, pathos, and other rhetorical devices to make this a powerful and timeless speech in hopes to eliminate…

    • 1486 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Holocaust Lost Hope

    • 1486 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Holocaust was a horrific genocide in which the Nazi party systematically exterminated millions of Jews, homosexuals, mentally retarded persons, and others, on the pretense of ‘purifying’ the German race. The Nazis put a great deal of thought and consideration into the creation of concentration camps to create demeaning and lethal places of extreme desperation. No other genocide has been nearly as creative in the methods it used to torture and exterminate…

    • 1486 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics